Correction
25 Nov 2008: van der Pluijm I, Garinis GA, Brandt RMC, Gorgels TGMF, Wijnhoven SW, et al. (2008) Correction: Impaired Genome Maintenance Suppresses the Growth Hormone–Insulin-Like Growth Factor 1 Axis in Mice with Cockayne Syndrome. PLOS Biology 6(11): e304. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.0060304 View correction
Figures
Abstract
Cockayne syndrome (CS) is a photosensitive, DNA repair disorder associated with progeria that is caused by a defect in the transcription-coupled repair subpathway of nucleotide excision repair (NER). Here, complete inactivation of NER in Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mutants causes a phenotype that reliably mimics the human progeroid CS syndrome. Newborn Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice display attenuated growth, progressive neurological dysfunction, retinal degeneration, cachexia, kyphosis, and die before weaning. Mouse liver transcriptome analysis and several physiological endpoints revealed systemic suppression of the growth hormone/insulin-like growth factor 1 (GH/IGF1) somatotroph axis and oxidative metabolism, increased antioxidant responses, and hypoglycemia together with hepatic glycogen and fat accumulation. Broad genome-wide parallels between Csbm/m/Xpa−/− and naturally aged mouse liver transcriptomes suggested that these changes are intrinsic to natural ageing and the DNA repair–deficient mice. Importantly, wild-type mice exposed to a low dose of chronic genotoxic stress recapitulated this response, thereby pointing to a novel link between genome instability and the age-related decline of the somatotroph axis.
Author Summary
Normal metabolism routinely produces reactive oxygen species that damage DNA and other cellular components and is thought to contribute to the ageing process. Although DNA damage is typically kept in check by a variety of enzymes, several premature ageing disorders result from failure to remove damage from active genes. Patients with Cockayne syndrome (CS), a genetic mutation affecting one class of DNA repair enzymes, display severe growth retardation, neurological symptoms, and signs of premature ageing followed by an early death. Whereas mouse models for CS exhibit relatively mild deficits, we show that concomitant inactivation of a second DNA repair gene elicits severe CS pathology and ageing. Moreover, a few days after birth, these mice undergo systemic suppression of genes controlling growth, an unexpected decrease in oxidative metabolism, and an increased antioxidant response. Similar physiological changes are also triggered in normal mice by chronic exposure to DNA-damaging oxidative stress. From these findings, we conclude that DNA damage triggers a response aimed at limiting oxidative DNA damage levels (and associated tissue degeneration) to extend lifespan and promote healthy ageing. Better understanding of the ageing process will help to delineate intervention strategies to combat age-associated pathology.
Citation: van der Pluijm I, Garinis GA, Brandt RMC, Gorgels TGMF, Wijnhoven SW, Diderich KEM, et al. (2007) Impaired Genome Maintenance Suppresses the Growth Hormone–Insulin-Like Growth Factor 1 Axis in Mice with Cockayne Syndrome. PLoS Biol 5(1): e2. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.0050002
Academic Editor: Priscilla Cooper, Lawrence Berkeley National Lab, United States of America
Received: May 19, 2006; Accepted: October 16, 2006; Published: December 12, 2006
Copyright: © 2007 van der Pluijm et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This research was supported by the Netherlands Organization for Scientific Research (NWO) through the foundation of the Research Institute Diseases of the Elderly, as well as by grants from SenterNovem IOP-Genomics (IGE03009), NIH (1PO1 AG17242–02), NIEHS (1UO1 ES011044), EC (QRTL-1999–02002; LSHC-CT-2005–512113), and the Dutch Cancer Society (EUR 99–2004). LJN was supported by Postdoctoral Fellowship #PF-99–142 from the American Cancer Society. JHJH is CSO of DNage.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Abbreviations: ANOVA, analysis of variance; BrdU, bromodeoxyuridine; CS, Cockayne syndrome; DEHP, di(2-ethylhexyl)phthalate; GG-NER, global genome–nucleotide excision repair; GH, growth hormone; IGF1, insulin-like growth factor 1; INL, inner nuclear layer; IR, ionizing radiation; MEF, mouse embryonic fibroblast; NER, nucleotide excision repair; ONL, outer nuclear layer; PAS, periodic acid-Schiff; ROS, reactive oxygen species; SEM, standard error of the mean; TC-NER, transcription-coupled nucleotide excision repair; TCR, transcription-coupled repair; TTD, trichothiodystrophy; TUNEL, terminal deoxynucleotidyltransferase-mediated dUTP nick end labeling; XP, xeroderma pigmentosum; wt, wild-type
Introduction
A prevailing hypothesis to explain the molecular basis of ageing is Harman's “free-radical theory of ageing”, which states that endogenous reactive oxygen species (ROS), which result from cellular metabolism, continually damage biomolecules [1]. In line with this hypothesis, it has been shown that increased resistance to oxidative stress (e.g., by improved antioxidant defense) extends the lifespan of Caenorhabditis elegans, Drosophila, and rodents [2–4], whereas hypersensitivity to oxygen considerably reduces the lifespan of nematodes [5]. A key macromolecule at risk for ROS-mediated damage is nuclear DNA [1], which is evident from the wide range of oxidative DNA lesions that accumulate gradually in rodents and humans with advancing age [6,7].
In humans, the causative role of DNA damage in ageing is supported by a variety of progeroid disorders with defects in DNA repair pathways [8,9]. One such condition is Cockayne syndrome (CS) (affected genes: CSA or CSB), a photosensitive disorder that originates from a defect in transcription-coupled repair (TCR), which specifically removes DNA lesions that obstruct RNA polymerases, allowing resumption of transcription and promoting cellular survival from DNA damage. TCR of helix-distorting DNA damage is a dedicated subpathway of the multi-step “cut-and-patch” nucleotide excision repair (NER) system, and is designated TC-NER [10] to distinguish it from the so-called global genome NER (GG-NER) subpathway that operates genome-wide to eliminate distorting damage. Available evidence suggests that CS cells are also defective in TCR of non–helix distorting DNA lesions that block transcription such as transcription-blocking oxidative DNA lesions [11,12], which are normally genome-wide removed by base excision repair. We will use the term TCR when referring to transcription-coupled repair in general.
CS patients present with growth failure (cachectic dwarfism), progressive neurological abnormalities (including delayed psychomotor development, mental retardation, microcephaly, gait ataxia, sensorineural hearing loss, retinal degeneration), along with impaired sexual development, kyphosis, osteoporosis, and severely reduced lifespan (mean age of death: 12.5 y) [13,14]. A related yet distinct disorder is trichothiodystrophy (TTD) (affected genes: XPB, XPD, or TTDA). TTD patients are partially defective in TCR as well as in the GG-NER, and share the symptoms associated with CS. In addition, these patients have a partial defect in transcription itself, causing additional symptoms such as ichthyosis and brittle hair and nails [15]. Many of the CS and TTD features are progressive and resemble premature ageing. Because patients develop some but not all aspects of normal ageing in an accelerated manner, CS and TTD are considered “segmental progeroid syndromes” [8].
Mouse mutants for CS-A and CS-B reliably mimic the UV sensitivity of CS patients and show accelerated photoreceptor loss, reduced body weight, and mild neurologic abnormalities [16,17]. Similarly, mice homozygous for a causative TTD point mutation in the Xpd gene faithfully mirror the symptoms in TTD patients [9], whereas complete inactivation of NER (by concurrent inactivation of the Xpa gene) dramatically aggravates the CS features of partially NER-defective TTD mice [9]. These observations, together with the notion that DNA lesions can provoke a permanent cell cycle arrest or apoptosis, led us to propose that ageing can result from (oxidative) DNA lesions that interfere with transcription and/or replication causing cell death or cellular senescence, ultimately leading to the loss of tissue homeostasis and the onset of age-related diseases [18–20].
Here we report that mice with engineered mutations in both Csb and Xpa genes display many CS features in a dramatic form, including postnatal growth attenuation, progressive kyphosis, ataxia, retinal degeneration, motor dysfunction, and premature death. Importantly, full genome transcriptome analysis of the Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mouse liver at the age of 15 d uncovered a systemic response seen also in wild-type (wt) mice exposed to chronic oxidative stress. These findings disclose a novel link between DNA damage, compromised genome maintenance, and the somatotrophic axis that determines lifespan and shed new light on the etiology of Cockayne syndrome and natural ageing.
Results
Attenuated Growth and Perinatal Death in Csbm/m/Xpa−/− and Csbm/m/Xpc−/− Mice
TCR-defective Csbm/m mutant mice [16] were intercrossed with GG-NER-defective Xpc−/− [21] and GG/TC-NER-defective Xpa−/− [22] animals to investigate whether an increase in the endogenous burden of unrepaired DNA damage, as provoked by the inactivation of GG-NER, enhances the phenotype, including progeroid features. Analysis of UV-induced repair synthesis and RNA synthesis recovery (indicative for GG-NER and TC-NER capacity, respectively) confirmed complete inactivation of NER in Csbm/m/Xpa−/− and Csbm/m/Xpc−/− animals (Figure 1A). As expected on the basis of previous work, Xpa−/− cells display the highest UV sensitivity, whereas Xpc−/− and Csbm/m cells show intermediate sensitivities (Xpa−/− > Csbm/m > Xpc−/− > wt; see Figure 1B). Interestingly, inactivation of GG-NER in Csbm/m mouse embryonic fibroblasts (MEFs) (as in Csbm/m/Xpa−/− and Csbm/m/Xpc−/− cells) renders cells more UV-sensitive than already completely NER-deficient Xpa−/− MEFs. We attribute this enhanced sensitivity to the absence of CSB-mediated TCR of UV-induced lesions that do not form a substrate for NER. Thus, the repair defect in the double mutant appears to be more severe than that of the single mutants. We could not detect a similar increased sensitivity to ionizing radiation in double-mutant cells above that of Csbm/m cells [12] (unpublished data), supporting the notion that MEFs in culture are already under high oxygen stress [23,24].
(A) UV repair characteristics of wt, single-mutant, and double-mutant primary MEFs. UV-induced UDS (left panel) and recovery of RNA Synthesis (RRS, right panel) are indicative for GG-NER and TC-NER capacity, respectively. For a detailed explanation of the procedure, see Methods. Error bars indicate standard error of the mean (SEM).
(B) Survival of primary MEFs exposed to increasing doses of UV-C light (254 nm), as determined using the with [3H]-thymidine incorporation assay. Error bars (in most cases smaller than symbols used) indicate SEM.
(C) Photograph of a 14-d-old Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mouse with an Xpa−/− littermate (hybrid 129Ola/C57BL/6J background).
(D) Photograph of an 8-d-old Csbm/m/Xpc−/− mouse with a Csbm/m littermate (hybrid 129Ola/C57BL/6J background).
(E) Body weight curve of Csbm/m/Xpa−/− and Csbm/m/Xpc−/− mice (n = 7) compared to those defective in a single NER gene (n = 7) all in a hybrid 129Ola/C57BL/6J background. The arrow indicates birth. Error bars (in most cases smaller than symbols used) indicate SEM.
(F) Photographs of day 18.5 Csbm/m/Xpa−/− and Xpa−/− embryos (C57BL/6J).
As evident from their overall appearance and weight (Figure 1C–1E), Csbm/m/Xpa−/− and Csbm/m/Xpc−/− pups (hybrid C57BL/6Jx129ola genetic background) displayed a strikingly attenuated growth, resulting in pronounced dwarfism. Whereas the number of double mutant pups was ∼3-fold below that expected for Mendelian inheritance (Table S1), embryonic day 18/5 (E18.5) Csbm/m/Xpa−/− and Csbm/m/Xpc−/− embryos were present at Mendelian frequency, pointing to considerable lethality during or shortly after birth. Importantly, double-mutant embryos were morphologically and histologically indistinguishable from wt and single-mutant embryos (Figure 1F and unpublished data), indicating that the growth defect was postnatal and did not reflect impaired embryonic development per se. In the third week of life, however, Csbm/m/Xpa−/− and Csbm/m/Xpc−/− pups developed progressive cachexia (evident from the weight loss after day 15; see Figure 1E), ultimately resulting in death before postnatal day 22. Neither moistening of food pellets (to facilitate intake of solids) nor removal of wt or single-mutant pups from the litter (to reduce competition for breast milk) improved the physical condition or the lifespan of Csbm/m/Xpa−/− and Csbm/m/Xpc−/− pups. Necropsy revealed milk or solid food in the stomach, indicating that insufficient access to supplied nutrition was not the underlying cause of growth retardation, weight loss, and early death. Importantly, progressive growth retardation, cachexia, and short life expectation (∼12.5 y) are also observed in human patients with CS [13]. Combined inactivation of Xpa and Xpc rendered mice without any overt phenotype (unpublished data), leading us to conclude that the dramatic phenotype of Csbm/m/Xpa−/− and Csbm/m/Xpc−/− pups results from a combined GG-NER/TC-NER/TCR defect.
Growth and Neurological Abnormalities in Csbm/m/Xpa−/− Mice
Further analysis of the Csbm/m/Xpa−/− phenotype, performed in an isogenic C57BL/6J background, revealed a near-normal size of the skull at day 11 and 21 (autoradiographs shown in Figure 2A), implying that the (postnatal) growth defect is restricted to the trunk, and to a lesser extent, the extremities. All 21-d-old double-mutant animals showed kyphosis (abnormal curvature of the spinal column, Figure 2A, middle left and bottom right), which was also observed in younger Csbm/m/Xpa−/− pups, indicating that it is not determined by terminal illness. The normal appearance of the spine in 11-d-old double-mutant pups excluded a prenatal developmental defect and further pointed to an extremely accelerated onset of kyphosis, a feature observed in naturally aged (2-y old) C57BL/6J mice (see Figure 2A, bottom left panel). Two-dimensional images of proximal end-to-mid-diaphysis micro–computed tomography (micro-CT) scans of fixed tibiae from 10-, 15-, and 20-d-old wt and Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice revealed retarded, yet steady, longitudinal as well as radial (perimeter) growth, along with a thinner bone cortex and a less developed growth plate (Figure 2B). In line with this observation, we observed a reduction in tibia length (Figure 2C). Notably, whereas Csbm/m/Xpa−/− pups lose weight in the third week of life, bone growth proceeds, resulting in relatively large extremities, a representative feature of CS and TTD [13].
(A) Radiographs of wt and Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice (age as indicated) and photograph of a 15-d-old Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mouse (C57BL/6J).
(B) 2-D images of micro-CT scans of tibiae taken from Csbm/m/Xpa−/− animals and wt littermate controls (age indicated in the figure). Horizontal sections are shown of the upper and lower part of the tibiae. e, epiphysis; g, growth plate; and d, diaphysis. I indicates the section through the smaller part of the diaphysis, II indicates section through the broader part of the diaphysis.
(C) Growth of tibiae, taken from Csbm/m/Xpa−/− animals (light squares) and wt littermate controls (dark squares).
(D) Representative footprint patterns of 19-d-old wt and Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice. Arrows indicate the trajectory of each mouse. Stride length and front base width measurements on 15-d-old wt, Xpa−/−, Csbm/m, and Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice. The significantly (asterisk; p < 0.001) greater base width in the double mutant mouse indicates ataxia.
(E) Representative pictures of a TUNEL staining in the retina of wt and Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice and quantification of the number of TUNEL positive cells. Arrows indicate TUNEL positive cells in the ONL and INL. Note the significantly higher number of TUNEL-positive cells in both the ONL and the INL in the retina of Csbm/m/Xpa−/− compared to wt mice (asterisk; p < 0.05).
Motor coordination problems, manifesting as tremors and abnormal posture of the hind limbs (flexion rather than extension in tail suspension test), became evident around day 10 in Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice (unpublished data). Foot print analysis revealed a disturbed gait from day 15 onwards. Whereas wt and single-mutant animals maintained a straight path with regular alternating strides, Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice demonstrated a nonuniform alternating left-right step pattern and unevenly spaced shorter strides (Figure 2D). Despite their runted size, the front base width of Csbm/m/Xpa−/− animals was significantly greater than that of wt and single-mutant littermates, which likely illustrates an attempt to maintain balance (Figure 2D). These data are consistent with the profound early postnatal ataxia and abnormal cerebellar development in Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice [25] and the progressive neurodegeneration observed in human CS patients [26].
We next examined the retinas of 15-d-old Csbm/m/Xpa−/− pups for the presence of apoptotic cells, because retinal degeneration is a prominent neurological feature of CS patients [27] and adult CS mice (T. Gorgels, I. van der Pluijm, R. Brandt, G. Garinis, H. van Steeg, et al., unpublished data). At this age, cell loss occurs as part of the normal development of the retina. Yet, as shown by terminal deoxynucleotidyltransferase-mediated dUTP nick end labeling (TUNEL) (Figure 2E) and caspase-3 staining (unpublished data), the number of apoptotic cells in the outer nuclear layer (ONL) and inner nuclear layer (INL) of the retinas of Csbm/m/Xpa−/− pups was significantly increased (analysis of variance [ANOVA], S-N-K posthoc test, p < 0.05), as compared to wt and single-mutant littermates (Figure 2E). Thus, the Xpa defect enhanced the apoptotic sensitivity of photoreceptor cells in Csbm/m mice, thereby pointing to DNA damage as a trigger for age-related retinal degeneration. Because 15-d-old Csbm/m mice still have wt levels of apoptotic cells, spontaneous photoreceptor loss in the Csbm/m mouse initiates in the second/third month of life.
Visual inspection and histological analysis of most internal organs of 15-d-old Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice did not reveal any obvious pathological abnormalities (unpublished data), with the exception of substantial loss of abdominal fat. Because we did not find any sign of infections, necrosis, or abnormal cellular proliferation (as determined by bromodeoxyuridine [BrdU] staining) in the gastrointestinal tract of 15- and 21-d-old Csbm/m/Xpa−/− animals, intestinal malfunction is an unlikely cause of the growth defect (Figure 3A). In addition, the liver had a normal histological appearance (Figure 3B), whereas neither BrdU (Figure 3C), proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) (Figure 3D), and Ki67 staining (unpublished data), nor TUNEL (Figure 3E) and caspase-3 staining (unpublished data) revealed any significant difference between Csbm/m/Xpa−/− and wt livers. This finding indicates that aberrant cell proliferation or apoptosis in the liver does not likely contribute to the Csbm/m/Xpa−/− phenotype. Moreover, inactivation of the p53 tumor-suppressor gene failed to rescue the mutant phenotype, because Csbm/m/Xpa−/−/p53−/− triple-mutant pups appeared indistinguishable from Csbm/m/Xpa−/− pups (unpublished data). Thus, the precise etiology of the overall physical deterioration and the cause of death of Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice remain unknown.
(A) BrdU staining of the jejunum of Csbm/m/Xpa−/− and littermate control mice, showing normal proliferative capacity of the intestine in the double mutant mouse. (B–E) Histological examination of liver sections of 15-d-old Csbm/m/Xpa−/− and littermate control mice, stained with HE (B), immunostained for the proliferation markers (incorporated) BrdU (C) and PCNA protein (D), or TUNEL-stained for the presence of apoptotic cells (E). Quantification of the number of proliferative or apoptotic cells did not reveal significant differences between Csbm/m/Xpa−/− and wt littermate mice. (F) HE staining of the pituitary of Csbm/m/Xpa−/− and littermate control mice.
Enhanced Ionizing Radiation Sensitivity of the Csbm/m/Xpa−/− Mouse Retina
The spontaneous, age-related and ionizing radiation (IR)–induced loss of post-mitotic photoreceptor cells in Csbm/m mice underscores the relevance of DNA repair in the removal of (oxidative) DNA damage for the long-term survival of terminally differentiated cells in the retina (T. Gorgels, I. van der Pluijm, R. Brandt, G. Garinis, H. van Steeg, et al., unpublished data). To test whether Csbm/m/Xpa−/− animals are more sensitive to genotoxic insults than are single-mutant Csbm/m and Xpa−/− animals, we next examined if the additional Xpa defect further enhances the IR sensitivity of the Csbm/m retina. To this end, we exposed 18-d-old Csbm/m/Xpa−/− pups and wt and single-mutant littermates to γ rays (10 Gy) and quantified the number of apoptotic cells in the retina by TUNEL staining 20 h after exposure. As shown in Figure 4, the number of apoptotic cells in the ONL of untreated (19-d-old) Csbm/m/Xpa−/− pups further increased, as compared to 15-d-old double-mutant animals (see Figure 2E). Whereas IR exposure did not increase the frequency of apoptotic photoreceptors in the ONL of wt and Xpa−/− animals, Csbm/m mice already show a tendency to increased photoreceptor loss, as characteristic for mature Csbm/m animals (T. Gorgels, I. van der Pluijm, R. Brandt, G. Garinis, H. van Steeg, et al., unpublished data). In contrast, the retinas of IR-exposed Csbm/m/Xpa−/− animals showed an almost 2-fold increase in the level of TUNEL-positive photoreceptor cells (Student's t-test; p = 0.021). Taken together, these findings not only further point to unrepaired DNA damage (likely originating from oxidative stress) as the underlying trigger for photoreceptor loss, but importantly, also show that inactivation of Xpa further enhances the sensitivity of Csbm/m mice to genotoxic stress.
Representative pictures of TUNEL stained retinas of 19-d-old wt, Csbm/m, Xpa−/−, and Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice (right panel), 20 h after exposure of animals to 10 Gy of ionizing radiation, and quantification of the number of TUNEL positive cells in the ONL (left panel). Note the significantly higher number of TUNEL-positive cells in the retina of Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice, as compared to wt and single-mutant littermate controls (p < 0.05). Single asterisks indicate statistically significant differences between unirradiated Csbm/m/Xpa−/− and littermate control mice (p < 0.05), double asterisks indicate statistically significant differences between unirradiated and irradiated Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice (p < 0.05).
Analysis of the Csbm/m/Xpa−/− Mouse Liver Transcriptome
To investigate whether a disturbance in growth and metabolism could explain the pronounced accelerated organismal deterioration seen in Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice, we evaluated the liver transcriptome of 15-d-old wt, single-mutant, and double-mutant mice (n = 4 mice). At this age, the Csbm/m/Xpa−/− pups have not yet become cachectic. Two-tailed t test analysis Affymetrix full mouse genome arrays revealed 1,865 genes with significantly changed expression patterns between wt and Csbm/m/Xpa−/− livers (p ≤ 0.01, 1.2-fold change up- or down-regulated, Table S2), a number that significantly exceeds the ∼80 genes that are expected to occur by chance under these selection criteria. Among the set of 1,865 genes, we identified those gene ontology (GO)–classified biological processes with a significantly disproportionate number of responsive genes relative to those printed on microarrays (false detection rate ≤ 0.10). This unbiased approach revealed processes implicated in the derivation of energy from oxidation of organic compounds, homeostasis of energy reserves, cell growth and maintenance, and the redox status of the cell.
Subsequent analysis of these processes led us to identify the following four results.
(1) A profound attenuation of the somatotroph axis, as evidenced by the consistent down-regulation of genes encoding main components of the GH/IGF1 axis (e.g., IGF1, Igfbp3, Igfbp4, Igfals, Ghr), as well as lactotroph (e.g., Prlr) and thyrotroph functions (e.g., Dio1) in Csbm/m/Xpa−/− livers, in addition to a decrease in the expression of several genes associated with a variety of mitogenic signals (e.g., Esr1, Fgf1, Fgfr3, Fgfr4) (Table 1 and Table S2).
Significant Gene Expression Changes in the Livers of Csbm/mXpa−/−, Csbm/m, and Xpa−/− Mice Compared to Livers from Littermate Controls
(2) An extensive suppression of catabolic metabolism in the Csbm/m/Xpa−/− liver, as evident from the significant down-regulation of key genes involved in glycolysis, the tricarboxylic acid cycle, and oxidative phosphorylation pathways (Table 1 and Table S2), coupled with a significant up-regulation of genes associated with glycogen synthesis (e.g., Gyg1 and Gys2) and down-regulation of glycogen phosphorylase (Pygl), suggesting that the Csbm/m/Xpa−/− liver stores glucose into glycogen, rather than burn it for energy derivation. These changes were further accompanied by the broad down-regulation of genes associated with electron transport and oxidative phosphorylation (e.g., several cytochrome P450 monooxygenases, the NADH dehydrogenase complex, and the NADPH-dependent oxidative metabolism) (Table 1 and Table S2) and the significant down-regulation of several genes associated with peroxisomal biosynthesis (Table 1). Apparently, the complete catabolic metabolism is restrained in the Csbm/m/Xpa−/− liver.
(3) A broad up-regulation of genes associated with fatty acid synthesis and transport (several genes listed in Table 1 and Table S2), the up-regulation of the receptor for the adipocyte hormone leptin (Lepr), and the central fat regulator peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor-gamma (Pparγ). Thus, similar to their reserved glucose utilization and enhanced glycogen synthesis, Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice attempt to store rather than burn fat.
(4) An up-regulation of genes encoding key enzymatic and nonenzymatic low–molecular mass scavengers and antioxidant defense enzymes (e.g., Sod1, Prdx2 and 3, Txnip, Ephx1, Hmox1 and five components of the glutathione system) (Table 1), suggesting that Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice try to minimize the induction of (DNA) damage by counteracting ROS.
None of these genes were identified as significantly differentially expressed in the livers of Csbm/m or Xpa−/− littermate controls (Table 1). Quantitative real-time PCR (Q-PCR) evaluation of the expression levels of key genes involved in the somatotroph axis, energy metabolism, and antioxidant defense in the livers of Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice, and wt, Csbm/m, and Xpa−/− littermates, as well as further biochemical analysis (see below), confirmed the validity of the microarray data (Figure 5A, upper left panel).
(A) Q-PCR evaluation of mRNA levels of genes associated with antioxidant defense (dark gray bars), oxidative metabolism (light gray bars), and the GH/IGF1 axis (black bars) in the liver, kidney, heart, and spleen of 15-d-old Csbm/m/Xpa−/−, Csbm/m, and Xpa−/− pups. For each gene, expression levels in the mutant tissue are plotted relative to that of age-matched wt control tissues (dotted line). Error bars indicate SEM between replicates (n ≥ 3).
(B) Relative mRNA expression levels (fold changes, relative to embryonic day 18) of genes involved in the GH/IGF1 growth axis, antioxidant defense, and oxidative metabolism in the liver of wt and Csbm/m/Xpa−/− pups, plotted as a function of time. Error bars indicate SEM between replicates (n ≥ 3).
Postnatal Systemic Changes in Somatotroph Axis, Energy Metabolism, and Antioxidant Defense in Csbm/m/Xpa−/− Mice
Next we analyzed whether the onset of the aforementioned transcriptional changes paralleled the progressive postnatal growth attenuation as well as the weight loss observed later. Consistent with the normal embryonic development, the expression levels of genes involved in the somatotroph axis (Ghr, Igf1, Prlr), antioxidant defense (Gstt2, Hmox1, Ephx1), and oxidative metabolism (Gck, Gyg1, Cs, Ndufs8) did not differ significantly between wt and Csbm/m/Xpa−/− livers at postnatal day 1 (Figure 5B). In contrast, during the first 2 wk of life, wt mice exhibited, as expected, a robust up-regulation in Igf1, Ghr, and Prlr gene expression, a response that was virtually absent in Csbm/m/Xpa−/− animals (Figure 5B, left panels); this explains well the severe growth retardation of double-mutant pups after birth. Analysis of Gstt2, Hmox1, and Ephx1 mRNA levels revealed that the up-regulation of the antioxidant defense system in the Csbm/m/Xpa−/− liver already initiated before postnatal day 10, and thus occurs well ahead of the initiation of the physiological decline (i.e., weight loss) (Figure 5B, middle panels). When comparing mRNA levels of key genes in glycolysis (Gck), tricarboxylic acid cycle (Cs), and mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation (Ndufs8), we noticed that beginning postnatal day 10, Csbm/m/Xpa−/− livers do not show the prominent up-regulation of these catabolic genes seen in the wt liver (instead, expression levels continued to decline), whereas they up-regulate glycogen synthesis (Gyg1) (Figure 2B, right panels). In agreement, the enzymatic activity of citrate synthase was significantly lower (p ≤ 0.01) in the livers of 15-d-old Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice (119 ± 15 mU/mg protein), as compared to wt littermate controls (70 ± 13 mU/mg protein).
We next determined the expression levels of aforementioned genes in the kidney, heart, and spleen of the same set of animals used in the microarray experiment. Expression levels markedly mirrored the deviant expression patterns observed in the liver, whereas mRNA levels in Csbm/m and Xpa−/− tissues were not significantly different from wt animals (Figure 5A). Thus, attenuation of the GH/IGF1 axis and down-regulation of metabolism, along with the enhanced antioxidant/detoxification response, represents a systemic rather than liver-specific response of the Csbm/m/Xpa−/− pups to the DNA repair defect. Interestingly, when 96-wk-old wt livers were tested for expression levels of this same set of Csbm/m/Xpa−/− responsive genes, we noticed a remarkable resemblance (Figure S1).
Comparison of the Csbm/m/Xpa−/− and Naturally Aged Mouse Liver Transcriptomes
The previous result prompted us to investigate whether and to which extent the gene expression changes in the Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mouse liver overlap with those observed in a natural aged liver. To this end, we first compared the full mouse liver transcriptome of adult 16-, 96- and 130-wk-old wt C57Bl/6J mice (n = 4) with that of adult 8-wk-old wt C57Bl/6J mice (n = 4) (Tables S3–S5). Using the same analytical method as applied to the Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mouse livers, we identified homeostasis of energy reserves, oxidative metabolism, along with cell growth and maintenance to be significantly overrepresented in 96- and 130-wk-old wt mice, but not in 16-wk-old animals (Table S6). These findings fit well with previous studies, suggesting the repression of oxidative metabolism to represent a conserved response shared by highly diverged species [28].
Next we implemented a previously described method [29] to evaluate the extent of genome-wide similarity between the liver transcriptomes of 2-wk-old Csbm/m/Xpa−/−mice and wt animals of various ages. We first classified all significantly differentially expressed genes in the Csbm/m/Xpa−/− liver transcriptome as having increased or decreased expression (as compared to wt), and we asked how many of these genes respond in a similar direction in the 16/8 wk, 96/8 wk, and 130/8 wk datasets. If the Csbm/m/Xpa−/− liver resembles an aged liver, one expects the Spearman's rank correlation coefficient (r, +1.0 or −1.0 in case of perfect similarity or dissimilarity, respectively, and 0.0 in case of no correlation) to increase with age. Notably, whereas the liver transcriptome of Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mutant mice was dissimilar to that of 16-wk-old wt mice (Spearman's r = −0.28), as it was with 15-d-old littermates, this turned into a positive correlation when the comparison was made between the Csbm/m/Xpa−/− and 96-wk-old mouse liver transcriptomes (r = +0.15) and even more with the 130-wk-old wt mouse group (r = + 0.44, p ≤ 0.0001) (Figure 6A). Comparable results were obtained when the same approach was applied over the whole mouse transcriptome (including all Affymetrix probe sets with signals above the detection cutoff value; see Materials and Methods), thus avoiding any initial preselection or introduction of bias. Using the same approach, we did not find a significant correlation between the liver transcriptomes of 15-d-old Csbm/m or Xpa−/−mice and aged wt mice.
(A) Spearman's r correlation of 16-, 96- and 130-wk-old mice with 15-d-old Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice, where −1.0 is a perfect negative (inverse) correlation, 0.0 is no correlation, and +1.0 is a perfect positive correlation.
(B) Similarities between significantly overrepresented biological processes. Note that in both Csbm/m/Xpa−/− and naturally aged mice, transcriptional changes were mostly associated with metabolic processes.
(C) Correlation in significant expression changes of genes associated with the GH/IGF1 axis and oxidative metabolism in the livers of Csbm/m/Xpa−/− and naturally aged (96- and 130-wk-old) mice. An extensive overview is listed in Tables S3 and S4.
The genome-wide resemblance between the short-lived Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice and the 130-wk-old mice was substantially higher (>90%) when the comparison was restricted to those functional categories that were significantly overrepresented in the double-mutant and 130-wk-old mice, such as the GH/IGF1 axis, oxidative metabolism (i.e., glycolysis, Krebs and oxidative phosphorylation), cytochrome P450 electron transport, and peroxisomal biogenesis (Figure 6B and 6C and Table S7). Despite the occurrence of dissimilarities between the liver transcriptome of Csbm/m/Xpa−/− pups and aged wt mice (the latter animals showing over-representation of genes involved in the immune and inflammatory responses, ATP biosynthesis, and protein glycosylation, along with a lack of the anti-oxidant response), these findings strongly underline the genome-wide parallels between the Csbm/m/Xpa−/− repair mutants and natural ageing, thereby validating the progeria in the double mutant pups.
Reduced IGF1 Serum Levels, Glucose, and Fat Use in Csbm/m/Xpa−/− Mice
In agreement with the down-regulation of Igf1 gene expression in the liver (the main source of circulating IGF1 [30]), we observed a significant reduction (p < 0.004) in serum IGF1 levels in Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice (Figure 7A) together with significantly lower blood glucose levels (p < 0.04) (Figure 7B). Following an initial reduction of ∼30% (p < 0.04) in 7- and 10-d-old Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice, blood glucose levels started to drop at day 15, gradually reaching low levels in 17-d-old Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice (∼3 mM), contrasting the steady blood glucose levels (∼ 9 mM) in littermate controls (Figure 7B). The presence of milk and food in the stomach of the double-mutant pups along with the normal appearance of the intestinal epithelium (Figure 3A) indicates that the hypoglycemia is not due to food intake. Even more, the suppression of the somatotroph axis and subsequent decreased IGF1 production in 15-d-old Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice appeared not to originate from a pituitary dysfunction as histological examination (Figure 3F) and TUNEL staining of sections from the pituitary pars distalis, intermedia, and nervosa did not reveal any abnormalities (unpublished data). Moreover, serum GH levels in 15-d-old Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice (15.2 ± 4.2 ng/ml, n = 8) did not differ significantly from wt littermates (12.8 ± 2.8 ng/ml, n = 6). Interestingly, the normal serum GH levels together with the significant systemic down regulation of GH receptor gene expression likely point to growth hormone resistance in 15-d-old Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice.
IGF1 (A) and glucose (B) in the serum of 7-, 10-, 15-, and 17-d-old wt, Xpa−/−, Csbm/m, and Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice (n = 6). The levels of IGF1 (ng/ml) and glucose (mmol/l) in the serum of Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice are significantly lower than that of control littermates (p < 0.0004 and p < 0.04, respectively). (C) PAS staining for glycogen and Oil Red O staining for triglycerides in livers of 15-d-old wt and Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice and 96-wk-old wt mice. Pictures were taken at 100× magnification. Note the large polyploid nuclei in the 96-wk-old wt mouse liver and the reduced glycogen levels in the Csbm/m/Xpa−/− liver after overnight fasting.
Periodic acid-Schiff (PAS) staining of liver sections from 10- to 20-d-old pups and naturally aged mice revealed enhanced accumulation of glycogen in unusually large vesicles in Csbm/m/Xpa−/− pups and 96-wk-old mice when compared to wt littermates and 8-wk-old wt mice (Figure 7C) . This observation fits our microarray data, suggesting that both the Csbm/m/Xpa−/− and naturally aged mice store rather than use glucose. Overnight fasting of Csbm/m/Xpa−/− pups and littermate controls resulted in a near-to-complete depletion of liver glycogen (Figure 7D), indicating that the glycogen accumulation is not due to inability to split glycogen into its constitutive glucose monomers.
Consistent with the broad up-regulation of genes associated with fatty acid synthesis (Table 1), Oil Red O staining of liver sections from 15-d-old pups and naturally aged mice revealed enhanced accumulation of triacylglycerides in both compared to control littermates and 8-wk-old mice (Figure 7C), indicating hepatic steatosis. This and the absence of adipose tissue suggest that Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice display generalized lipodystrophy (loss and abnormal redistribution of body fat) [31].
Systemic Changes in Somatotroph Axis and Antioxidant Defense in DEHP-Treated wt Mice
To test whether the presence of endogenous (oxidative) DNA damage can provoke the somatotrophic drop and enhanced antioxidant potential, wt C57BL/6J mice (n = 6; 4-wk-old) were fed ad libitum for 9 wk with standard food containing subtoxic levels of an oxidative DNA damage-inducing agent [di(2-ethylhexyl)phthalate (DEHP), 1500 ppm] [32]. Neither body weight nor appetite and food intake of DEHP-exposed animals deviated from that of untreated control animals. As shown in Figure 8, subsequent analysis revealed suppression of the expression of genes associated with the somatotroph axis (Igf1, Igfbp3, Ghr, and Dio1) and oxidative metabolism (Gck, Cs, and Ndufs8), along with the up-regulation of glycogenin 1 (Gyg1, Figure 5A) in DEHP-exposed animals. Consistent with the ability of DEHP to generate ROS-induced DNA damage in the liver, we also noticed a significant up-regulation of genes associated with the antioxidant and detoxification responses (Hmox1, Ephx1, Gsr, Sod1, Gstt2). These findings suggest that the accumulation of unrepaired (oxidative) DNA damage is likely one of the causes underlying the observed suppression of the GH/IGF1 and oxidative metabolism in Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice (Text S1).
Relative mRNA levels of genes involved in the GH/IGF1 growth axis, oxidative metabolism, and antioxidant defense in 13-wk-old wt mice treated with a low dose of the pro-oxidant DEHP. For each gene, expression levels in the treated wt mouse livers are plotted relative to that of age-matched untreated wt littermate controls (dotted line). Error bars indicate SEM. Asterisks indicate statistically significant differences (one-tailed p ≤ 0.05, see also Text S1).
Discussion
Csbm/m mice exhibit several CS features (e.g., attenuated growth, blindness, neurological dysfunction), but their phenotype is overall milder than the human syndrome [16] despite the fact that the truncation in the N-terminal part (mimicking a mutant allele of CS-B patient CS1AN) completely inactivates the protein and TC-NER [16]. Although the severity of clinical features in humans does not seem to correlate with the severity of the molecular defect [33], the absence of the complete spectrum of CS features in the Csbm/m mouse model is likely to originate from human-mouse differences (i.e., adaptation to stress, tolerance to DNA damage/genome instability), rather than from the nature of the Csbm/m mutation. This idea is supported by our observations that XpdTTD and XpdXPCS mice (all carrying causative point mutations) also fail to show the severe CS features associated with XPCS and TTD [9,34].
Yet, the present study reveals that inactivation of GG-NER or complete abrogation of NER (through inactivation of Xpc or Xpa, respectively) in TCR-deficient Csbm/m mice dramatically aggravates the Csbm/m mouse phenotype. Because animals were not exposed to exogenous genotoxic agents, we attribute this effect to enhanced levels of unrepaired endogenous (oxidative) DNA damage. In further support of this, we have shown that Csbm/m/Xpc−/− and Csbm/m/Xpa−/− MEFs, as well as Csbm/m/Xpa−/− retinal photoreceptor cells, are more sensitive to environmental genotoxic insults (i.e., UV light and ionizing radiation) than their single mutant counterparts. A comparable phenotypic deterioration has been noticed when Xpa was inactivated in XpdTTD [9], XpdXPCS [34], compound heterozygous XpdTTD/XPCS animals (carrying causative mutations for TTD and combined XP/CS) [35] or XpgdeltaEx15 mice [36].
Importantly, Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice appeared normal at birth, indicating a normal intra-uterine development and ruling out that this condition is in fact an embryonic developmental disorder. Instead, after birth, the Csbm/m/Xpa−/− pups displayed progressive kyphosis, cachexia, photoreceptor loss, and motor dysfunction, all common postnatal manifestations of CS [13], as well as of natural mammalian ageing [37–39]. Also similar to human CS patients (average age 12.5 y), Csbm/m/Xpa−/− pups fail to grow into adulthood and die before weaning. The relation between (residual) repair capacity, time, and severity of a particular phenotype is well illustrated by the retinal photoreceptor loss in the Csbm/m mouse models. Whereas ageing C57Bl/6J mice lose about 5%–10% of their rods and cones in 30 months, TCR-deficient Csbm/m mice have already lost about 50% of their photoreceptor cells by the age of 16 months. This spontaneous retinal degeneration in Csbm/m mice originates from enhanced apoptotic sensitivity of photoreceptor cells (T. Gorgels, I. van der Pluijm, R. Brandt, G. Garinis, H. van Steeg, et al, unpublished data), evolving in the first 1 or 2 months after weaning. Interestingly, further crippling of NER in Csbm/m animals by inactivation of Xpa accelerates the onset of photoreceptor loss, which becomes visible as early as postnatal day 15, and progressively increases thereafter. The strong correlation between the severity of the repair deficiency and the onset of photoreceptor loss, as well as the enhanced ionizing radiation hypersensitivity of photoreceptor cells of Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice (as compared to age-matched Csbm/m animals), well support the hypothesis that (oxidative) DNA damage likely underlies the retinal degeneration.
Full genome transcriptome analysis of the Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mouse liver, aiming at unraveling the etiology of the severe double-mutant phenotype, led us to identify significant genome-wide parallels between the 2-wk-old Csbm/m/Xpa−/− and 130-wk, but not 16-wk-old, wt animals at the fundamental level of gene expression. This resemblance was largely attributable to the substantial down-regulation of genes associated with processes implicated in oxidative energy and growth metabolism that were previously revealed by others to represent a conserved transcriptional response in ageing [28].
The down-regulation of genes associated with the GH/IGF1 growth axis in the liver, the systemic reduction in GH receptor mRNA levels, and the impaired Igf1 gene expression in liver and other tissues (resulting in low serum IGF1 levels) likely underlie the postnatal growth defect in Csbm/m/Xpa−/− pups. These changes were not due to reduced GH serum levels or pituitary abnormalities. A steady decline in the GH/IGF1 somatotroph axis was also observed in rodents and humans during natural ageing [40]. Furthermore, Csbm/m/Xpa−/− pups failed to up-regulate metabolism; instead, they displayed a sharp systemic reduction in the expression levels of genes involved in glycolysis, tricarboxylic acid cycle (including decreased citrate synthase activity), and oxidative respiration, which coincided with the onset of weight loss (cachexia). In addition, Csbm/m/Xpa−/− pups up-regulated genes associated with glycogen and fatty acid synthesis, leading to increased hepatic glycogen storage and fat accumulation (steatosis) and pronounced hypoglycemia. Simultaneously, subcutaneous fat tissue was virtually absent. Given that in mammals, the GH/IGF1 signaling pathway is one of the major regulators of energy homeostasis to integrate metabolism with growth [30,41,42], it is tempting to speculate that reduced IGF1 signaling is responsible for the postnatal metabolic shift and growth defect seen in Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice. Interestingly, several CS patients have been previously reported with hypoglycemia and low IGF1 serum levels [43,44], low metabolic rate [45], and abnormal fat deposition [46].
Paradoxically, however, the systemic suppression of the somatotrophic axis and energy metabolism, along with the up-regulation of antioxidant defenses, low IGF1 serum levels, and low blood glucose levels observed in the Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mouse, are all associated with increased longevity rather than with the short lifespan of this mouse model. In lower paradigms for lifespan extension (C. elegans, D. melanogaster), genetic interference in the insulin-signaling pathway can prolong life multi-fold [47,48]. In mammals, IGF1-deficient, Ames and Snell dwarf mice (characterized by defects in the development of the anterior pituitary due to mutations in the Prop-1 and Pit1 loci and diminished levels of GH, thyroid stimulating hormone, and prolactin hormone) combine hypoglycemia, low body temperature, and increased storage of carbohydrates and lipids [40,42] with up-regulation of antioxidant defense capacity and extended lifespan [49,50]. Conversely, GH-overexpressing transgenic mice display reduced lifespan and antioxidant responses [51]. These findings have also been recently confirmed by our identification of genome-wide parallels between the extremely short-lived DNA repair mutants (Csbm/m/Xpa−/− and Ercc1−/−) and the extremely long-lived Ames and Snell dwarfs and growth hormone receptor knockout (Ghr−/−) mice (Garinis et al. manuscript in preparation). Last but not least, IGF1 plasma levels decline with age in humans and rodents [52–54]. Along with this hormonal shift, ageing cells surmount an intricate antioxidant defense response [55,56] that is thought to prevent the detrimental consequences of oxidative stress. Interestingly, the progressive, age-related decrease in the somatotroph axis has been suggested to confer a selective advantage by postponing the onset of age-related disease and prolonging lifespan through the reduction of toxic free radicals [40].
How would repair-deficient mice benefit from such a response? During development, the mitogenic action of GH and IGF1 fuels cellular metabolism, thereby promoting tissue growth and function [40,57,58]. A high metabolic activity, however, leads to higher oxygen consumption [40] and may also increase the ROS burden through the parallel increase of mitochondrial electron transport, peroxisomal fatty acid metabolism, and/or microsomal cytochrome P-450 enzymes [59]. Despite antioxidant defense and DNA repair, oxidative DNA damage will still accumulate, leading to transcriptional stress, impaired replication, cellular senescence, malfunction or death and eventually to progressive loss of tissue homeostasis and organismal decline (Figure 9, model). We hypothesize that complete abrogation of NER (by inactivation of Xpa) renders TCR-deficient Csbm/m mice unable to adequately cope with the increased burden of DNA damage in the transcribed strand of active genes. This triggers an adaptive response; i.e., reduction of metabolic activity through down-regulation of the GH/IGF1 axis to relieve the pressure on their genome. We interpret this as an attempt to limit the deleterious effects of arrested transcription, such as cellular senescence and death causing accelerated ageing. As a consequence, the initially normal growth becomes arrested soon after birth, leading to severe growth retardation. This scenario provides a plausible explanation for the growth defect in CS patients. However, this response is unable to fully compensate for the repair defect, and thus damage still accumulates to critical levels and triggers apoptosis and/or senescence, thereby leading to ageing-associated pathology such as neurodegeneration (as illustrated by the photoreceptor cells in Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice).
ROS are natural byproducts of metabolism and can injure several macromolecules including DNA, thus contributing to a slow but steady accumulation of damage, transcriptional stress, impaired replication, and eventually the progressive loss of tissue homeostasis and gradual organismal deterioration. Cells and tissues will respond by (1) up-regulating their antioxidant defense responses that would moderate the harmful effects of ROS, (2) using a battery of genome maintenance pathways that would repair or remove damaged macromolecules and help to resist the oxidative stress, and (3) suppressing their GH/IGF1 somatotroph axis along with the oxidative metabolism, thus substantially moderating their metabolic activity that would otherwise lead to high oxygen consumption and increased generation of oxidants. To this end, the physiologic reduction of the somatotroph axis and oxidative metabolism is envisaged to be beneficial in terms of net lifespan.
The conceptual link between DNA damage and the systemic adaptive response is supported by our observation that chronic exposure of wt mice to a sub-toxic dose of DEHP (a pro-oxidant that enhances the DNA damage load; [60]) triggers a response similar to that observed in (untreated) Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice. Although DEHP at much higher concentrations has been previously documented to affect the endocrine function of the pituitary, proteome analysis revealed that synthesis of prolactin and growth hormone appears unaffected in DEHP-treated rats [61]. This suggests that the observed suppression of genes associated with the somatotroph axis and oxidative metabolism in the liver of DEHP-exposed mice is triggered by DNA damage in the liver, rather than by a pituitary defect or hypothalamic defect.
As one would predict, other short-lived NER mouse models (e.g., Xpg and Xpf mice [62,63]) or NER mutant mice with a milder progeroid phenotype could also show accelerated attenuation of the somatotrophic axis in response to their DNA repair defect. Indeed, Ercc1−/− animals, carrying a combined NER/crosslink DNA repair defect and a lifespan of only a few weeks, demonstrate a remarkable genome-wide similarity in liver gene expression profiles with Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice (L. Niedernhofer, G. Garinis, A. Raams, A. Lalai, A. Rasile Robinson, et al., unpublished data), whereas XpdXPCS/Xpa−/− and compound heterozygous XpdTTD/XPCS/Xpa−/− mice contain lower serum IGF1 levels [35]. Furthermore, XpdTTD mice, which manifest accelerated ageing in many (but not all) organs and tissues, have recently been shown to display features related to a caloric restricted–like phenotype and suppression of the GH/IGF1 axis in a limited set of organs and tissues, stressing the segmental nature that is characteristic of all progeroid syndromes and the systemic nature of the response [64]. Finally, proper glucose homeostasis and normal IGF1 levels were recently shown to require activity of Sirt6, a chromatin deacetylase that may promote DNA repair [65]. Because ROS-mediated DNA damage appears to be the underlying cause of the Csbm/m/Xpa−/− progeria, it is tempting to speculate that one can attenuate the premature onset of age-related features by directly counteracting the harmful byproducts of metabolism (ROS) and, consequently, DNA damage. An antioxidant-based nutraceutical intervention pilot study with Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice, aiming at extending lifespan and delaying onset of pathology, yielded promising results (I. van der Pluijm, R. Brandt, J. Hoeijmakers, G. van der Horst, unpublished data).
Materials and Methods
Animals.
The generation and characterization of NER-deficient Xpa−/−, Xpc−/−, and Csbm/m mice has been previously described [16,22,66,67]. p53 −/− mice [68] were kindly provided by T. Jacks (Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts, United States). Unless stated otherwise, all mice were kept in a C57BL/6J genetic background. In the DEHP exposure study, 4-wk-old male wt mice (C57BL/6J; n = 6) were put on a DEHP (1500 ppm; Sigma, St. Louis, Missouri, United States) containing diet or on a regular diet for 9 wk. Animals were screened daily for discomfort and weighed once a week. Food consumption was registered by weighing the food. In the ionizing irradiation exposure study, 18-d-old Csbm/m/Xpa−/− and littermate control animals (n = 4–6/genotype) were exposed to 10 Gy, killed 20 h after exposure, and their eyes were further processed. Additional information on the isolation and processing of the eyes is provided in the Text S1. As required by Dutch law, all animal studies were approved by an independent Animal Ethical Committee (Dutch equivalent of the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee). Further information on mouse crossing, genotyping, housing, and macroscopic examination is described in the Text S1.
Cellular sensitivity studies.
UV sensitivity was determined as described [69]. Sparsely seeded Petri dish cultures were exposed to different doses of UV (254 nm, Phillips TUV lamp). After 4 d, the number of proliferating cells was estimated from the amount of radioactivity incorporated during a 2-hr pulse with [3H] thymidine. Cell survival was expressed as the percentage of radioactivity in exposed cells in relation to the radioactivity in untreated cells. UV-induced GG repair was assayed using the unscheduled DNA synthesis (UDS) method described in [70]. In brief, coverslip-grown cells were exposed to 16 J/m2 of 254-nm UV light and labeled with [3H] thymidine. Repair capacity was quantified by grain counting after autoradiography. RNA synthesis recovery was measured according to [71]. In short, coverslip-grown cells were exposed to 10 J/m2 of 254-nm UV light, allowed to recover for 16 hr, labeled with [3H] uridine, and processed for autoradiography. The relative rate of RNA synthesis was expressed as GUV/GC (percentage), where GUV and GC represent the number of grains over UV-exposed and nonexposed nuclei, respectively.
Ionizing radiation sensitivity of immortalized MEFs was determined using a colony assay. Cells were plated in 6-cm-diameter dishes at various densities. After 16 h, cells were exposed to a single dose of ionizing radiation (137Cs source; dose range of 0 to 8 Gy. Cells were grown for another 5 to 14 d, and after fixation and staining, colonies were counted. All experiments were performed in triplicate.
Immunohistological examination and blood parameters.
Detailed histopathological examination was performed on all organs and tissues. Paraffin-embedded tissues were sectioned at 5 μm and stained with haematoxylin/eosin (HE) solution. Liver sections were stained with PAS or Oil Red O (cryosections) to detect glycogen and triglycerides, respectively. Detailed information on the immunohistochemical procedures is described in Text S1. Apoptotic cells were detected using a TUNEL assay as described by the manufacturer (Apoptag Plus Peroxidase In Situ Apoptosis Detection Kit, Chemicon, Temecula, California, United States). For retinal evaluation, eyes were marked nasally with Alcian blue (5% Alcian blue in 96% ethanol), enucleated, fixed in 4 % paraformaldehyde in 0.1 M phosphate buffer, washed in PBS, and embedded in paraffin. Horizontal sections (5 μm thick) of the retina were cut, and sections in the middle of the retina were selected by Alcian blue marking and proximity of the optic nerve. Sections were stained for degenerating cells by TUNEL according to the manufacturer's instructions (Apoptag Plus Peroxidase In Situ Apoptosis Detection Kit, Chemicon). For quantification, the number of TUNEL-positive cells in the INL and ONL were counted in six whole sections per mouse. Differences between the genotypes were tested for statistical significance using multivariate ANOVA, followed by a posthoc test of Student-Newman-Keuls (S-N-K). Significance was set at p < 0.05. Serum IGF1 and GH levels were determined with the active mouse/rat IGF1 enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and active mouse/rat GH ELISA kits respectively, as described by the manufacturer (Diagnostic Systems Laboratories Inc., Texas, United States). Blood glucose was measured using a Freestyle mini blood glucose measurement device (Abbott Diabetes Care, Amersfoort, The Netherlands).
Radiography and microcomputed tomography.
Mice were anaesthetized by intraperitoneal injection of ketalin and rompun (120 and 7.5 μg/g body weight, respectively). Lateral films were taken at 2× magnification using a CGR Senograph 500T x-ray system operated at 30 kV and 32 mAS [9]. Formalin fixed tibiae from wt and mutant mice were scanned from proximal end to mid-diaphysis, using a SkyScan 1072 microtomograph (SkyScan, Antwerp, Belgium) with a voxel size of 8.82 μm. Scans were processed, and 2-D images of the bones were obtained.
Footprint studies.
Footprint analysis was performed by painting the hind and fore paws of the mice with different colors of water-soluble nontoxic paints. Animals were allowed to walk along a 30 × 7 cm walled runway, lined with paper, into a darkened, enclosed space. Tests were performed in duplicate at day 15 and 19. Footprint patterns were analyzed for (1) stride length, measured as the average distance between each stride; (2) front base width; and (3) hind base width, measured as the average distance between contralateral footprints [72].
Microarray analysis and Q-PCR evaluation.
Standard procedures were used to obtain total RNA (Qiagen, Valencia, California, United States) from the liver of wt, Xpa−/−, Csbm/m, and Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice (n = 4) at postnatal day 15 and from the liver of 8-, 16-, 96-, and 130-wk-old mice (n = 4). Synthesis of double stranded cDNA and biotin-labeled cRNA was performed according to the instructions of the manufacturer (Affymetrix, Santa Clara, California, United States). Fragmented cRNA preparations were hybridized to full mouse genome oligonucleotide arrays (430 V2.0; Affymetrix). Q-PCR was performed with a DNA Engine Opticon device (Bio-Rad Laboratories B.V., Veenendaal, The Netherlands). Detailed information on microarray hybridization, microarray data analysis, gene ontology classification, and analysis of overrepresented biological themes, as well as on Q-PCR data analysis and used primer pair sequences is described in Text S1. Microarrays were complied with the Minimum Information for Microarray Experiments (MIAME, E-MEXP-835 and E-MEXP-839).
Supporting Information
Figure S1. Q-PCR Evaluation of mRNA Levels of Genes Associated with the GH/IGF1 Axis, Antioxidant Defense, and Oxidative Metabolism in 2-wk-Old Csbm/m/Xpa−/− and 96-wk-Old wt Mice
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.0050002.sg001
(114 KB TIF)
Table S1. Frequency of Viable Csbm/m/Xpa−/− and Csbm/m/Xpc−/− Mice and Parallels of Human and Mouse CS Symptoms
(A) Frequency of viable Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mice; (B) frequency of viable Csbm/m/Xpc−/− mice; (C) parallels of human CS symptoms with the mild Csbm/m and severe Csbm/m/Xpa−/− mouse models.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.0050002.st001
(13 KB PDF)
Table S2. Extensive Overview of Significant Expression Changes in Csbm/m/Xpa−/−, Csbm/m, and Xpa−/− Mice Compared to wt Littermate Controls
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.0050002.st002
(129 KB PDF)
Table S3. Extensive Overview of Significant Expression Changes in 130-wk-Old wt Mice Compared to 8-wk-Old Mice
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.0050002.st003
(92 KB PDF)
Table S4. Extensive Overview of Significant Expression Changes in 96-wk-Old wt Mice Compared to 8-wk-Old Mice
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.0050002.st004
(121 KB PDF)
Table S5. Extensive Overview of Significant Expression Changes in 16-wk-Old wt Mice Compared to 8-wk-Old Mice
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.0050002.st005
(106 KB PDF)
Table S6. Extensive Overview of Gene Expression Profiles Associated with Significantly Over-represented Biological Processes in 96- and 130-wk-Old Naturally Aged Mice
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.0050002.st006
(13 KB PDF)
Table S7. Comparison of Gene Expression Profiles Associated with Significantly Over-represented Biological Processes between Csbm/m/Xpa−/−, Csbm/m, and Xpa−/− Mice and 96- and 130-wk-Old Naturally Aged Mice
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.0050002.st007
(11 KB PDF)
Acknowledgments
We thank Wiebeke van Leeuwen and Willem Sluiter for assistance with x-ray analysis and citrate synthase activity measurements, respectively.
Author Contributions
IvdP, GAG, JHJH, and GTJvdH conceived and designed the experiments. IvdP, GAG, RMCB, TGMFG, SWW, KEMD, JdW, JRM, CvO, RB, SV, HvS, and GTJvdH performed the experiments. IvdP, GAG, and GTJvdH analyzed the data. LJN, ECF, KT, and HvS, contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools. IvdP, GAG, JHJH, and GTJvdH wrote the paper. JHJH is head of the department.
References
- 1. Harman D (1956) Aging: A theory based on free radical and radiation chemistry. J Gerontol 11: 298–300.
- 2. Schriner SE, Linford NJ, Martin GM, Treuting P, Ogburn CE, et al. (2005) Extension of murine life span by overexpression of catalase targeted to mitochondria. Science 308: 1909–1911.
- 3. Melov S, Ravenscroft J, Malik S, Gill MS, Walker DW, et al. (2000) Extension of life-span with superoxide dismutase/catalase mimetics. Science 289: 1567–1569.
- 4. Orr WC, Sohal RS (1994) Extension of life-span by overexpression of superoxide dismutase and catalase in Drosophila melanogaster. Science 263: 1128–1130.
- 5. Ishii N, Fujii M, Hartman PS, Tsuda M, Yasuda K, et al. (1998) A mutation in succinate dehydrogenase cytochrome b causes oxidative stress and ageing in nematodes. Nature 394: 694–697.
- 6. Hamilton ML, Van Remmen H, Drake JA, Yang H, Guo ZM, et al. (2001) Does oxidative damage to DNA increase with age? Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 98: 10469–10474.
- 7. Lu T, Pan Y, Kao SY, Li C, Kohane I, et al. (2004) Gene regulation and DNA damage in the ageing human brain. Nature 429: 883–891.
- 8. Martin GM (2005) Genetic modulation of senescent phenotypes in Homo sapiens. Cell 120: 523–532.
- 9. de Boer J, Andressoo JO, de Wit J, Huijmans J, Beems RB, et al. (2002) Premature aging in mice deficient in DNA repair and transcription. Science 296: 1276–1279.
- 10. Hanawalt PC (2002) Subpathways of nucleotide excision repair and their regulation. Oncogene 21: 8949–8956.
- 11. Spivak G, Hanawalt PC (2006) Host cell reactivation of plasmids containing oxidative DNA lesions is defective in Cockayne syndrome but normal in UV-sensitive syndrome fibroblasts. DNA Repair (Amst) 5: 13–22.
- 12. de Waard H, de Wit J, Gorgels TG, van den Aardweg G, Andressoo JO, et al. (2003) Cell type-specific hypersensitivity to oxidative damage in CSB and XPA mice. DNA Repair (Amst) 2: 13–25.
- 13. Nance MA, Berry SA (1992) Cockayne syndrome: Review of 140 cases. Am J Med Genet 42: 68–84.
- 14.
Bootsma D, Kraemer KH, J.E C, Hoeijmakers J (2002) Nucleotide excision repair syndromes: Xeroderma Pigmentosum, Cockayne Syndrome and
trichthiodystrophy. New York: McGraw-Hill Medical Publishing Division. pp. 211–237.
- 15. Vermeulen W, Rademakers S, Jaspers NG, Appeldoorn E, Raams A, et al. (2001) A temperature-sensitive disorder in basal transcription and DNA repair in humans. Nat Genet 27: 299–303.
- 16. van der Horst GT, van Steeg H, Berg RJ, van Gool AJ, de Wit J, et al. (1997) Defective transcription-coupled repair in Cockayne syndrome B mice is associated with skin cancer predisposition. Cell 89: 425–435.
- 17. van der Horst GT, Meira L, Gorgels TG, de Wit J, Velasco-Miguel S, et al. (2002) UVB radiation-induced cancer predisposition in Cockayne syndrome group A (Csa) mutant mice. DNA Repair (Amst) 1: 143–157.
- 18. Hasty P, Campisi J, Hoeijmakers J, van Steeg H, Vijg J (2003) Aging and genome maintenance: Lessons from the mouse? Science 299: 1355–1359.
- 19. de Boer J, Hoeijmakers JH (2000) Nucleotide excision repair and human syndromes. Carcinogenesis 21: 453–460.
- 20. Mitchell JR, Hoeijmakers JH, Niedernhofer LJ (2003) Divide and conquer: Nucleotide excision repair battles cancer and ageing. Curr Opin Cell Biol 15: 232–240.
- 21. Cheo DL, Ruven HJ, Meira LB, Hammer RE, Burns DK, et al. (1997) Characterization of defective nucleotide excision repair in XPC mutant mice. Mutat Res 374: 1–9.
- 22. de Vries A, van Oostrom CT, Hofhuis FM, Dortant PM, Berg RJ, et al. (1995) Increased susceptibility to ultraviolet-B and carcinogens of mice lacking the DNA excision repair gene XPA. Nature 377: 169–173.
- 23. Parrinello S, Samper E, Krtolica A, Goldstein J, Melov S, et al. (2003) Oxygen sensitivity severely limits the replicative lifespan of murine fibroblasts. Nat Cell Biol 5: 741–747.
- 24. Busuttil RA, Rubio M, Dolle ME, Campisi J, Vijg J (2003) Oxygen accelerates the accumulation of mutations during the senescence and immortalization of murine cells in culture. Aging Cell 2: 287–294.
- 25. Murai M, Enokido Y, Inamura N, Yoshino M, Nakatsu Y, et al. (2001) Early postnatal ataxia and abnormal cerebellar development in mice lacking Xeroderma pigmentosum Group A and Cockayne syndrome Group B DNA repair genes. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 98: 13379–13384.
- 26. Itoh M, Hayashi M, Shioda K, Minagawa M, Isa F, et al. (1999) Neurodegeneration in hereditary nucleotide repair disorders. Brain Dev 21: 326–333.
- 27. Traboulsi EI, De Becker I, Maumenee IH (1992) Ocular findings in Cockayne syndrome. Am J Ophthalmol 114: 579–583.
- 28. McCarroll SA, Murphy CT, Zou S, Pletcher SD, Chin CS, et al. (2004) Comparing genomic expression patterns across species identifies shared transcriptional profile in aging. Nat Genet 36: 197–204.
- 29. Fraser HB, Khaitovich P, Plotkin JB, Paabo S, Eisen MB (2005) Aging and gene expression in the primate brain. PLoS Biol 3(9): e274..
- 30. Frystyk J (2004) Free insulin-like growth factors—measurements and relationships to growth hormone secretion and glucose homeostasis. Growth Horm IGF Res 14: 337–375.
- 31. Ahima R, Osei SY (2004) Leptin and appetite control in lipodystrophy. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 89: 4254–4257.
- 32. Seth PK (1982) Hepatic effects of phthalate esters. Environ Health Perspect 45: 27–34.
- 33. Horibata K, Iwamoto Y, Kuraoka I, Jaspers NG, Kurimasa A, et al. (2004) Complete absence of Cockayne syndrome group B gene product gives rise to UV-sensitive syndrome but not Cockayne syndrome. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 101: 15410–15415.
- 34. Andressoo JO, Mitchell JR, de Wit J, Hoogstraten D, Volker M, et al. (2006) An Xpd mouse model for the combined xeroderma pigmentosum/Cockayne syndrome exhibiting both cancer predisposition and segmental progeria. Cancer Cell 10: 121–132.
- 35. van de Ven M, Andressoo JO, Holcomb VB, von Lindern M, Jong W, et al. (2006) Adaptive stress response in segmental progeria resembles long-lived dwarfism and calorie restriction in mice. PLoS Genet. E-pub 2 October 2006.
- 36. Shiomi N, Mori M, Kito S, Harada YN, Tanaka K, et al. (2005) Severe growth retardation and short life span of double-mutant mice lacking Xpa and exon 15 of Xpg. DNA Repair (Amst) 4: 351–357.
- 37.
Arking R (1998) Biology of aging; Observations and principles. Sunderland (Massachusetts): Sinauer Associates. 528 p.
- 38.
Kalu DN (1995) Bone. In: Masoro , editor. Handbook of physiology of aging. New York: Oxford University Press. pp. 395–411.
- 39. Weiss A, Arbell I, Steinhagen-Thiessen E, Silbermann M (1991) Structural changes in aging bone: Osteopenia in the proximal femurs of female mice. Bone 12: 165–172.
- 40. Carter CS, Ramsey MM, Sonntag WE (2002) A critical analysis of the role of growth hormone and IGF-1 in aging and lifespan. Trends Genet 18: 295–301.
- 41. Puigserver P, Rhee J, Donovan J, Walkey CJ, Yoon JC, et al. (2003) Insulin-regulated hepatic gluconeogenesis through FOXO1-PGC-1alpha interaction. Nature 423: 550–555.
- 42. Longo VD, Finch CE (2003) Evolutionary medicine: From dwarf model systems to healthy centenarians? Science 299: 1342–1346.
- 43. Park SK, Chang SH, Cho SB, Baek HS, Lee DY (1994) Cockayne syndrome: A case with hyperinsulinemia and growth hormone deficiency. J Korean Med Sci 9: 74–77.
- 44. Fujimoto WY, Green ML, Seegmiller JE (1969) Cockayne's syndrome: Report of a case with hyperlipoproteinemia, hyperinsulinemia, renal disease, and normal growth hormone. J Pediatr 75: 881–884.
- 45. Ellaway CJ, Duggins A, Fung VS, Earl JW, Kamath R, et al. (2000) Cockayne syndrome associated with low CSF 5-hydroxyindole acetic acid levels. J Med Genet 37: 553–557.
- 46. Laszlo A, Simon M (1986) Serum lipid and lipoprotein levels in premature ageing syndromes: Total lipodystrophy and Cockayne syndrome. Arch Gerontol Geriatr 5: 189–196.
- 47. Kenyon C (2005) The plasticity of aging: Insights from long-lived mutants. Cell 120: 449–460.
- 48. Partridge L, Gems D, Withers DJ (2005) Sex and death: What is the connection? Cell 120: 461–472.
- 49. Brown-Borg HM, Bode AM, Bartke A (1999) Antioxidative mechanisms and plasma growth hormone levels: Potential relationship in the aging process. Endocrine 11: 41–48.
- 50. Brown-Borg HM, Rakoczy SG (2000) Catalase expression in delayed and premature aging mouse models. Exp Gerontol 35: 199–212.
- 51. Bartke A, Chandrashekar V, Bailey B, Zaczek D, Turyn D (2002) Consequences of growth hormone (GH) overexpression and GH resistance. Neuropeptides 36: 201–208.
- 52. Florini JR, Harned JA, Richman RA, Weiss JP (1981) Effect of rat age on serum levels of growth hormone and somatomedins. Mech Ageing Dev 15: 165–176.
- 53. Johanson AJ, Blizzard RM (1981) Low somatomedin-C levels in older men rise in response to growth hormone administration. Johns Hopkins Med J 149: 115–117.
- 54. Rudman D, Kutner MH, Rogers CM, Lubin MF, Fleming GA, et al. (1981) Impaired growth hormone secretion in the adult population: relation to age and adiposity. J Clin Invest 67: 1361–1369.
- 55. Camougrand N, Rigoulet M (2001) Aging and oxidative stress: Studies of some genes involved both in aging and in response to oxidative stress. Respir Physiol 128: 393–401.
- 56. Ji LL, Leeuwenburgh C, Leichtweis S, Gore M, Fiebig R, et al. (1998) Oxidative stress and aging. Role of exercise and its influences on antioxidant systems. Ann N Y Acad Sci 854: 102–117.
- 57. Bartke A (2003) Is growth hormone deficiency a beneficial adaptation to aging? Evidence from experimental animals. Trends Endocrinol Metab 14: 340–344.
- 58. Chandrashekar V, Zaczek D, Bartke A (2004) The consequences of altered somatotropic system on reproduction. Biol Reprod 71: 17–27.
- 59. Beckman KB, Ames BN (1998) The free radical theory of aging matures. Physiol Rev 78: 547–581.
- 60. de Waard H, de Wit J, Andressoo JO, van Oostrom CTM, Riis B, et al. (2003) Different effects of CSA and CSB deficiency on sensitivity to oxidative DNA damage. Mol Cell Biol 24: 7941–7948.
- 61. Hirosawa N, Yano K, Suzuki Y, Sakamoto Y (2006) Endocrine disrupting effect of di-(2-ethylhexyl)phthalate on female rats and proteome analyses of their pituitaries. Proteomics 6: 958–971.
- 62. Harada YN, Shiomi N, Koike M, Ikawa M, Okabe M, et al. (1999) Postnatal growth failure, short life span, and early onset of cellular senescence and subsequent immortalization in mice lacking the xeroderma pigmentosum group G gene. Mol Cell Biol 19: 2366–2372.
- 63. Tian M, Shinkura R, Shinkura N, Alt FW (2004) Growth retardation, early death, and DNA repair defects in mice deficient for the nucleotide excision repair enzyme XPF. Mol Cell Biol 24: 1200–1205.
- 64. Wijnhoven SW, Beems RB, Roodbergen M, van den Berg J, Lohman PH, et al. (2005) Accelerated aging pathology in ad libitum fed Xpd(TTD) mice is accompanied by features suggestive of caloric restriction. DNA Repair (Amst) 4: 1314–1324.
- 65. Mostoslavsky R, Chua KF, Lombard DB, Pang WW, Fischer MR, et al. (2006) Genomic instability and aging-like phenotype in the absence of mammalian SIRT6. Cell 124: 315–329.
- 66. Cheo DL, Meira LB, Hammer RE, Burns DK, Doughty AT, et al. (1996) Synergistic interactions between XPC and p53 mutations in double-mutant mice: Neural tube abnormalities and accelerated UV radiation-induced skin cancer. Curr Biol 6: 1691–1694.
- 67. Nakane H, Takeuchi S, Yuba S, Saijo M, Nakatsu Y, et al. (1995) High incidence of ultraviolet-B-or chemical-carcinogen-induced skin tumours in mice lacking the xeroderma pigmentosum group A gene. Nature 377: 165–168.
- 68. Lowe SW, Schmitt EM, Smith SW, Osborne BA, Jacks T (1993) p53 is required for radiation-induced apoptosis in mouse thymocytes. Nature 362: 847–849.
- 69. Sijbers AM, de Laat WL, Ariza RR, Biggerstaff M, Wei YF, et al. (1996) Xeroderma pigmentosum group F caused by a defect in a structure-specific DNA repair endonuclease. Cell 86: 811–822.
- 70. Vermeulen W, Scott RJ, Rodgers S, Muller HJ, Cole J, et al. (1994) Clinical heterogeneity within xeroderma pigmentosum associated with mutations in the DNA repair and transcription gene ERCC3. Am J Hum Genet 54: 191–200.
- 71. Ma GT, Roth ME, Groskopf JC, Tsai FY, Orkin SH, et al. (1997) GATA-2 and GATA-3 regulate trophoblast-specific gene expression in vivo. Development 124: 907–914.
- 72. Carter RJ, Lione LA, Humby T, Mangiarini L, Mahal A, et al. (1999) Characterization of progressive motor deficits in mice transgenic for the human Huntington's disease mutation. J Neurosci 19: 3248–3257.