Figures
Abstract
We combine information about the evolutionary history and distributional patterns of the genus Saintpaulia H. Wendl. (Gesneriaceae; ‘African violets’) to elucidate the factors and processes behind the accumulation of species in tropical montane areas of high biodiversity concentration. We find that high levels of biodiversity in the Eastern Arc Mountains are the result of pre-Quaternary speciation processes and environmental stability. Our results support the hypothesis that climatically stable mountaintops may have acted as climatic refugia for lowland lineages during the Pleistocene by preventing extinctions. In addition, we found evidence for the existence of lowland micro-refugia during the Pleistocene, which may explain the high species diversity of East African coastal forests. We discuss the conservation implications of the results in the context of future climate change.
Citation: Dimitrov D, Nogués-Bravo D, Scharff N (2012) Why Do Tropical Mountains Support Exceptionally High Biodiversity? The Eastern Arc Mountains and the Drivers of Saintpaulia Diversity. PLoS ONE 7(11): e48908. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0048908
Editor: Giovanni G. Vendramin, CNR, Italy
Received: January 13, 2012; Accepted: October 3, 2012; Published: November 19, 2012
Copyright: © 2012 Dimitrov et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: Funding for this research was provided by the Danish National Research Foundation (www.dg.dk). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: Co-author Dr. David Nogues-Bravo is a PLOS ONE Editorial Board member. This does not alter the authors’ adherence to all the PLOS ONE policies on sharing data and materials.
Introduction
The processes that have led to the accumulation of species in hotspots of biological diversity continue to be elusive [1], [2]. For tropical mountains, two different scenarios have been proposed: Pleistocene glacial refugia [3]–[6] and the long-term stability [7]. The refugia model suggests that differences in species diversity between refugia are the result of allopatric speciation and a reduced level of extinctions due to reduced climatic fluctuations within refugia. New species resulting from this process should also have allopatric distributions, which in the context of tropical mountains implies that different species should be present on different mountain blocks. Stability, in contrast, reduces extinction rates within an area and permits survival of relictual lineages; thus species richness is not a result of extinctions outside of stable areas. Meanwhile, stability does not preclude sympatric speciation of radiating groups within these areas. Under the stability scenario young species are expected to be distributed around the periphery of stable areas where contractions, extensions and/or temporary fragmentation of these areas has increased heterogeneity. We explore these hypotheses using the biodiversity hotspot in the Eastern Arc Mountains of Tanzania and Kenya and focus on the genus Saintpaulia H. Wendl. (Gesneriaceae; ‘African violets’) as a study system.
The discovery of extensive numbers of endemics with regional distribution seems to support the long-term stability model. Furthermore, data from sediment cores from the Uluguru Mountains provides evidence that highland forest composition has remained stable for at least the last 48000 years [8], which might suggest similarly stable conditions across the earlier glacial-interglacial cycles during the Pleistocene. These results are in concordance with previous findings from sedimentary cores from the larger East African region (see also [4], [9]). Emerging evidence that local climatic conditions in the eastern Arc have been stable during periods of past global climatic changes provides a possible explanation for the extremely rich biota and numerous endemic species found in the region (e.g., [7], [10]). Much of the tree species diversity in East African forests has been linked to vicariance due to the pan-African tropical forest fragmentation initiated during the Oligocene-Early Miocene [10]. A similar pattern has been reported for amphibians [11] and in both cases lack of diversification during Pleistocene climate oscillations has been attributed to the stable conditions on mountain tops. Likewise, much of the bird diversity in the Eastern Arc stems from speciation events predating the Pleistocene and is consistent with repeated vicariance and dispersal events in expanding and contracting forests, which supports a model of long-term stability in the face of climatic fluctuations [12]. Recently Measey and Tolley [13] have shown that effects of forest fragmentation and local expansions and contractions can be detected in the Taita Hills leaf chameleon’s biogeographical history. In some cases differentiation among populations was attributed to fluctuations in forest extent during the Pleistocene, and – in concordance with the stability hypothesis – new lineages formed on the periphery of stable areas.
A better understanding of the biogeographic histories of Eastern Arc lineages is essential to explain how present diversity has been formed and maintained in this biodiversity hotspot over the recent geological time frame, and in the context of past climatic fluctuations. The Eastern Arc endemic plant genus Saintpaulia provides an ideal model to study the effects of ecosystem dynamics at high and low altitude on the diversity and distribution of tropical forest species in the Eastern Arc. A highland ancestry has been proposed for this genus [14]; however, due to the lack of a calibrated phylogeny, the timing of divergences among lineages could not be assessed. Burtt [15]–[17] recognized a total of 20 species of Saintpaulia as well as four varieties, but species delimitations have been questioned in two molecular studies [18], [19]. A recent revision of the genus reduced the number of species to six [20], all endemic to the Eastern Arc Mountains and coastal forests of Tanzania and Kenya. Two new species from the Uluguru Mountains, Tanzania, were recently described [21] elevating the number of species to eight. Most species of Saintpaulia are restricted to montane forests on a single mountain block, although S. shumensis B.L. Burtt occurs on two and S. pusilla Engl. on four mountain blocks. Only Saintpaulia ionantha H. Wendl. has a wider distribution over the altitudinal gradient, from coastal lowlands to montane forests. Saintpaulia has already attracted attention due to its high degree of endemism and commercial importance (several thousand cultivars originating from a few specimens of wild S. ionantha are sold under the common name of African Violet or Usambara Violet) [14], [18], [19], [22]–[25].
Here we use historical biogeographical data for Saintpaulia in conjunction with distributional and environmental data to further our understanding about the role of past environmental variations on current diversity patterns in the region and the possible impacts of future changes of climate and habitats. We aim to reconcile species’ phylogenetic and biogeographic histories with information on current environmental conditions to gain insights into the processes that have shaped present day distributional patterns and diversity.
Materials and Methods
Taxa and Gene Sampling
Our study is based on the genus Saintpaulia H. Wendl. (Gesneriaceae; ‘African violets’), an endemic plant of the Eastern Arc Mountains in Kenya and Tanzania. Here we adhere to the Saintpaulia classification proposed by Darbyshire [20] including the species from Haston et al. [21]. In particular cases where species determinations are uncertain we also refer to the original label information. We attempted to maximize the representation of Saintpaulia lineages using sequences from specimens of this genus present in public data repositories (e.g., GenBank). Data were available for five of the currently recognized species with the exceptions of S. inconspicua B.L. Burtt, a very rare species with a very limited distribution in the highlands of the Uluguru Mountains, and the two species described by Haston et al. [21]. As outgroup we used Streptocarpus caulescens Vatke. The genus Streptocarpus Lindl. (Gesneriaceae) has been hypothesized as the closest relative to Saintpaulia [22] and has been used to root the Saintpaulia phylogeny in previous studies (e.g., [14]).
There are few published molecular datasets of Saintpaulia and they rely on different genetic markers. Möller and Cronk [19] used ITS sequences to study the relationships and biogeography of 17 Saintpaulia species (of the 20 species recognized at that time) cultivated in the research collection at the Royal Botanic Garden, Edinburg. Lindqvist and Albert [14], [18] used 5S non-transcribed spacer (5S-NTS) of all but one of the species then included in the genus. More recently Caro et al. [25] sequenced chalcone synthase (CHS) for five out of the approximately 22 species recognized species at the time. In addition a couple of atpB-rbcL spacer, trnL-F and ITS1/ITS2 sequences were generated by Möller et al. [26] as part of a large study of didymocarpoid Gesneriaceae. Few additional data are available (e.g., [27], [28]). Among these datasets, the study of Lindqvist and Albert [14], [18] includes the largest number of Saintpaulia lineages. In addition, the recent taxonomic changes and the use of different voucher specimens in the various studies make it impossible to combine these datasets. For these reasons we have selected the Lindqvist and Albert [14], [18] data for our analyses, with the addition of sequences of 5S-NTS from the Möller et al. [26] that were generated using the same set of primers. Additional ITS data from Möller et al. [26] for S. tongwensis and S. velutina ware also included in the molecular clock analyses to augment overlap with the [29] dataset, used to estimate the divergence between Saintpaulia and Streptocarpus as explained below. This second matrix had larger representation of Gesneriaceae and is referred as RCZ_dataset. The [29] sequences are available in TreeBase under study number TB2: S1820 or via this link http://purl.org/phylo/treebase/phylows/study/TB2:S1820. Accession numbers for all sequences used in the present analyses that are not available through the aforementioned link are presented in Table 1.
Phylogenetic Analysis and Molecular Dating
Calibration of a molecular clock for Saintpaulia is problematic due to the absence of fossils or sister lineages with disjunct distributions along well defined geological features of known age. The genus is also missing from recent analyses of Gesneriaceae that use molecular clock techniques [29]. To overcome these limitations, we have adopted an indirect calibration approach that relies entirely on already published data [29]. Due to the lack of overlap between the most taxon-rich dataset for Saintpaulia [14] and the datasets of [26], [29] we built two separate matrices and ran two different molecular clock analyses. The existing calibrated phylogeny containing Saintpaulia sister group Streptocarpus [29] was used to estimate the time of divergence of these two lineages. To do so, we added two taxa of Saintpaulia, S. ionantha H. Wendl. subsp. ionantha (as S. tongwensis B.L. Burtt) and S. ionantha subsp. velutina (B.L. Burtt) I. Darbysh. (as S. velutina B.L. Burtt), sequenced for the same gene fragments [26], to the original dataset of [29].
Two different calibration schemes (56/52 and 56/52/8) from Roalson, Skog and Zimmer [29] adding the estimated age of the clade Beslerieae+Napeantheae (ranging from 71.62 Ma to 33.65 Ma with a mean of 52 Ma in the majority of their analytical treatments) from the same study were used with the RCZ_dataset. Both calibration schemes rely on geological events (e.g., GAARLANDIA land bridge formation; see [29]) and estimates for the maximum age of the stem age of the Gesneriaceae by Bremer et al. [30]. Under the 56/52 scheme Gesneriaceae stem maximum age was constrained to 71 Ma [30] and the Gesnerieae+Gloxinieae stem lineage age was constrained between 35 Ma and 25 Ma [29]. The 56/52/8 strategy adds an additional maximum age constrain for the migration of the Gloxinieae back to South America [29]. Further details on the 56/52 and 56/52/8 calibrations are given in [29]. The data was analyzed with BEAST v1.5.4 [31] using a relaxed uncorrelated lognormal clock [32]. All calibrations based on geological events or set as maximum constraints were implemented using uniform density distributions for the tmrca priors; normal distribution was used for the Beslerieae+Napeantheae constraint. The resulting estimate for the age of the mrca of Saintpaulia and Streptocarpus was used as the calibration point in the analysis of the second dataset, which included all available Saintpaulia 5S-NTS sequences from [14], [18] – the LA_dataset. This calibration was applied using a normal distribution for the trmca prior.
Given the lack of known fossils or suitable geological calibration points for the LA_dataset, an alternative to the described dating protocol could be the use of a fixed rate of DNA evolution for the 5S-NTS with the corresponding standard deviation. However, such rate has not been established for Saintpaulia and close relatives. Potential use of rates estimated for other angiosperms would likely result in very incorrect age estimates as rates of molecular evolution in plants are know to be extremely variable (e.g., [33]–[36]).
Since the publication of the aforementioned datasets, taxonomy of Saintpaulia has been revised, so that names associated with GenBank sequences often do not match the current classification. Here we have adopted the most recent classification as proposed by Darbyshire [20]. However, we did not re-examine the voucher specimens used to generate the DNA data in the original studies; thus the old names and the specimens voucher numbers are also kept as a reference. Revising the systematics of Saintpaulia is beyond the scope of this study and original vouchers should be examined before formalizing any nomenclatural changes. GenBank accession numbers and relevant specimen information are shown in Table 1.
All BEAST analyses were run assuming a birth-death tree prior using the maximum likelihood starting trees built with RaxML v7.2.6 [37] on the CIPRES cluster [38]. When datasets included more than one gene, they were partitioned by gene. The GTR+Γ model of sequence evolution was used in all RaxML analyses (as recommended by the program manual); for consistency reasons the same model was used in all BEAST analyses. In the case of the LA_dataset (which included just one gene as specified above), the best fit model selected by jModeltest v0.1.1 [39] was the TVMef+Γ, hence an additional round of BEAST analyses was run using this model to make sure that use of the more general GTR+Γ did not affect the results. Analyses in BEAST were run for 10 million generations; trees were sampled every 1000 generations. Results were examined for convergence with Tracer v1.5 [40] paying special attention to ensure that effective sample size of all parameters was above 200. All datasets were realigned using the L-INS-i method in MAFFT v6 [41].
Alternative molecular clock methods available in the package r8s [42] could not be used with the LA_dataset as they require at least one fixed calibration point, and therefore r8s was not considered for our analysis. The median values of the 95% confidence intervals for the age of the mrca of Saintpaulia and Streptocarpus as estimated by BEAST were compared and their mean was used in the calibration of the LA_dataset assuming normal distribution.
Haplotype networks were built with TCS v1.21 [43] using the LA_dataset. The networks were assembled based on the number of mutations separating each haplotype with a parsimony probability of 95% (the default settings in TCS).
Species Distributions Models
Distributional data for Saintpaulia consisted of 147 presence records covering most of the described species. Although this is the largest distributional dataset available, only two species are represented by over ten records: S. ionantha and S. pusilla. Georeferenced records were not available for the species described by Haston et al. [21]. Because all lowland populations fall within a monophyletic clade (S. ionantha) with no indication of hybridization with the strictly highland species (see results), we decided to merge all records of the strictly highland species of Saintpaulia to supply the modeling algorithm with sufficient presence records. Therefore, instead of modeling current and future climatic suitability of single species, we estimate suitability of climatic conditions for two sets of species: high elevation (strictly high elevation lineages) and low elevation (the remaining lineages).
Current and future 30Arc seconds downscaled climatic data including minimum, maximum and mean temperature and monthly precipitation were obtained from the WORLDCLIM database (http://www. worldclim.org/). Spatial downscaling is widely used to obtain data with higher spatial resolution. However, this approach assumes that the relationship between large- and small-scale climate variables is stationary over time, which is unlikely to always hold true, implying that downscaling might produce errors that could propagate across scales [44]. We are well aware of the problems with downscaled data (e.g., [45]); however, due to the lack of regional forecasting models these are the only data concerning the Eastern Arc region currently available. As there is a high level of uncertainty on how CO2 and other greenhouse gas emissions will evolve in the future, we used four different predictions for the potential climate changes in 2080 based on two different Atmospheric Ocean coupled General Circulation models, CGM2 and 3.1 and HadCM3, and two different emission scenarios, A1b and B2 [46]. The A1 emission scenarios family describes a future world with maximum energy requirements and specifically the A1b describes a future world with a balanced use of fossil and non-fossil sources of energy. The B2 family of emission scenarios describes a future world with lower energy requirements than A1.
In addition to the climatic data, land cover, lithology and soil data were available and included in analyses for the Tanzanian part of the Saintpaulia distribution. Due to the lack of future projections of these variables, we have assumed no change in 2080 when calculating future habitat suitability. However, this assumption is violated in some cases (e.g., land cover [47]) and ignoring changes may lead to positive bias in the projections. It is, nonetheless, important to include these variables as they are critical for the distribution of Saintpaulia and help better understand the potential effects of changes in the environment such as land use that are not strictly related to climate.
Species potential distributions were modeled using the maximum entropy method implemented in the software package MAXENT [48], [49]. This method uses presence only data and performs well when few distributional records are available [50], and it has ranked very high in a recent comparison of species distribution modeling methods [51]. To study the potential effects of future climate changes modeled distributions were inferred based on projections for 2080. Models performance was assessed by the means of ten-fold cross-validation as implemented in MAXENT. To reduce the risk of over fitting, preliminary runs were conducted with all variables. Based on these analyses, only the variables with higher contribution were selected for subsequent analyses. Final analyses were limited to the six most important variables.
In order to make sure that discussed trends in habitat availability are not biased due to algorithm choice, in addition to MAXENT we have used also BIOCLIM [52] and GAPR with best subsets [53] algorithms as implemented in the package openModeller v1.1.0 [54]. BIOCLIM and GARP analyses were applied only to the reduced set of climatic variables across the whole Eastern Arc region.
Information on all distribution modeling analyses, including model performance and relevant statistics are reported in Table 2.
Results
Saintpaulia Phylogeny and Biogeography
Maximum likelihood results for the LA_dataset agree with previously published phylogenies, based on maximum parsimony, of what is essentially the same dataset [14]. Saintpaulia monophyly was well supported and results suggested well structured lowland populations. Several specimens from the Nguru Mountains sequenced by [14], [18] originally determined as S. indet (voucher 1998-1687, Edinburgh), S. brevipilosa (voucher 1970-0909, Edinburgh), S. brevipilosa (voucher 1995-505, Kew), S. nitida (voucher 1997-0104, Edinburgh) and S. cf. velutina (voucher Dibohelo.1, East African Herbarium) formed a well supported monophyletic clade (Fig. 1). According to the current taxonomy [20], and given that original determinations are correct, these specimens belong to S. ionantha (subsp. nitida and subsp. velutina); thus as currently delimited, it is paraphyletic with respect to S. shumensis. The two Saintpaulia species included in the RCZ_dataset analyses also formed a well supported clade sister to Streptocarpus.
Values above branches are bootstraps from the maximum likelihood analyses; black stars show clades that receive posterior probability>95% in the BEAST analysis. Node bars show dating 95% confidence intervals (error for the Saintpaulia – Streptocarpus divergence given in brackets). Colors in map B and color bars in the chronogram represent geographical distributions (see legend under map B). Map A – Africa with a square showing the position of the study area. Map B – detailed map of the Eastern Arc region. Graph A – min/max altitude for each linage. Graph B – reconstructed ancestral altitude (altitude treated as continuous character) vs. lineage age. Numbers following taxa names are unique identifiers that link the specimen to the voucher and original determination listed in Table 1.
The basalmost Saintpaulia lineages are restricted to the high elevation montane forests as in [14]. Reanalysis in BEAST of the RCZ_dataset under the two different calibration schemes specified above resulted in very similar estimates for the age of the mrca of Streptocarpus and Saintpaulia: 21.92 Ma (11.17–33.67 Ma, 95% confidence interval) and 22.31 Ma (11.07–34.83 Ma, 95% confidence interval) respectively. The mean of these two estimates was used to calibrate the split of Streptocarpus and Saintpaulia in the LA_dataset assuming a normal error distribution of the age prior. The LA_dataset molecular clock analyses showed an old divergence between lowland and highland lineages. The younger lowland lineages formed several distinct populations. Most of the lowland populations diverged long before the quaternary glaciation and have persisted in the area (Fig. 1). The divergence of the Nguru S. ionantha specimens is significantly older than that of the major S. ionantha group. Analyses of the LA_dataset under the TVMef+Γ and the GTR+Γ converged to the same results (overlapping age estimates and same topology). Because the TVMef+Γ is just a specific case of the more general GTR+Γ, and the latter was used to build the starting tree for the dating analyses, only the results based on the GTR+Γ model are shown here (Fig. 1).
TCS analyses also supported the separation of the Nguru S. ionantha populations as they did not form a network with the main S. ionantha clade. The Kenya coastal forest populations, S. ionantha subsp. rupicola (B.L. Burtt) I. Darbysh., are probably the result of a single dispersal into the area and there is no evidence for secondary contact with their likely source populations in the Usambara area. The populations of S. ionantha subsp. ionantha in lowland forests of Tanzania and the Usambara and Udzungwa mountains populations of S. ionantha from all the subspecies (subsp. velutina, subsp. grotei, subsp. orbicularis and subsp. grandifolia) found in these areas share haplotypes (Fig. 2).
Size of bubbles is proportional to the number of specimens (small –1; intermediate –2; large –3). Colors represent geographical distributions.
Species Distribution Models and Projected Distributions under Climatic Change Scenarios
Results from tenfold cross validation in MAXENT and model performance statistics in BIOCLIM and GAPR show that models predictions are significantly different from random based on the area under the curve (AUC) of the receiver operation characteristic (ROC) (Table 2). Cross validation in MAXENT and using a subset of the distribution records as a test dataset in BIOCLIM and GARP allows us to test the internal consistency of the models; however, to evaluate their predictive power an independent evaluation dataset would be necessary. Therefore, predictions have to be treated with caution. The climatic variables with highest contribution to each model are given in Table 3. Suitable habitats under current climatic conditions differ between the high and low elevation datasets with greater spatial overlap in the Usambara Mountains (Figs. 3–5). Using different algorithms result in differences in the extent of the areas with suitable climatic conditions (Figs. 6–7), but except for differences in their size suitable areas are otherwise consistent between different methods. When the minimum and maximum altitudes of each lineage are plotted, the difference in range breadth between the high and low elevation lineages is particularly apparent (Fig. 1). Our models also identify areas with suitable climatic conditions in the southernmost parts of the Eastern Arc chain and on the younger volcanic mountains along the border of Tanzania and Kenya, Mount Kilimanjaro and Mount Meru, where Saintpaulia has not been found.
Darker color denotes higher suitability; color scale ranges from 0 (white) to 1 (red).
Darker color denotes higher suitability; color scale ranges from 0 (white) to 1 (red).
Darker color denotes higher suitability; color scale ranges from 0 (white) to 1 (red).
Darker color denotes higher suitability; color scale ranges from 0 (white) to 1 (red).
Darker color denotes higher suitability; color scale ranges from 0 (white) to 1 (red).
Suitable habitats for both groups of species under all climatic scenarios are expected to be significantly reduced by 2080 (Figs. 3–5). Practically all suitable habitats at lower elevation are expected to disappear while areas with suitable climatic conditions on the younger volcanic mountains along the border of Tanzania and Kenya where the plant is not present (Mount Kilimanjaro and Mount Meru) will increase. These results are congruent with recent findings suggesting that impacts of climate change in mountain biodiversity can be more significant in lowlands than in highlands [55], [56]. Using alternative algorithms to model species distributions and habitat suitability resulted in predictions showing the same general trends under the different climate change scenarios that we considered (Figs. 3–7).
The predicted distribution of Saintpaulia under both current and future conditions changed when additional information on soils, land cover and lithology was added (Fig. 5). The size of the available habitats and the associated probabilities of species occurrence diminished. Although non-climatic information was available only for the Eastern Arc region of Tanzania, we expect to see the same pattern for the Kenyan populations.
Discussion
Our results support the hypothesis of montane origins of Saintpaulia [14] and place its origin in the Oligocene (Fig. 1). This coincides with the initial processes of fragmentation of the tropical forests [57] that covered most of the African continent up to about 32 Ma ago [10]. The Eastern Arc mountains were already present at this time (the basal structures of the mountains are at least 30, and perhaps more than 100 million years old, but final tilting resulting in the highest elevations may be as young as 7 Ma [58]) and many of their forest species descend from lineages inhabiting ancient tropical forests [10]. The early divergence of Saintpaulia and Streptocarpus is probably a signature of these early fragmentation processes. Wetter conditions during the Miocene and the corresponding increase in forest extent have allowed the spread of plant species through Eastern Africa and have fostered potential species exchange between East and West African tropical forests (e.g., [10], [59], [60]).
The Eastern Arc origins of Saintpaulia, its limited dispersal abilities, together with its tight association with stony stream banks in montane forests (naturally a very patchy habitat with limited extent), have posed additional limitations on species ranges. The majority of Saintpaulia species are restricted to a narrow altitudinal band (Fig. 1) of the montane forest throughout the Eastern Arc. This distributional pattern combined with phylogenetic results that reveal a highland ancestry suggest that niche conservatism (the tendency of closely related species to retain ecological traits of their common ancestor, resulting in similarity of their niches [61]) may be the mechanism that has maintained most of the Saintpaulia species’ distributions over time. Phylogenetic niche conservatism and its effects on species distributions and other important aspects related to species biology have been widely discussed in recent literature (e.g., [62]–[65]). Therefore, the warmer and wetter conditions during the Miocene climatic optimum 17–15 Ma ago [57] may have not resulted in expansion of Saintpaulia distribution beyond the Eastern Arc region. Alternatively, if such expansion took place and Saintpaulia species/populations were present outside the Eastern Arc they were driven to extinction toward the end of the Miocene/beginning of the Pliocene when the climate in Africa became drier with the formation of the Antarctic ice sheet [66]. At the same time grasslands began increasing in prevalence around the region [59], [67], thus preventing later recolonization by Saintpaulia species. These climatic oscillations coincided with divergences of the older lineages of Saintpaulia and the appearance of species endemic to the northern mountains of the Arc (Fig. 1). Further forest fragmentation starting 8–5.4 Ma ago [10] may be the reason for the split of Nguru populations of S. ionantha subsp. nitida (voucher 1997-0104, Edinburgh) and S. ionantha subsp. velutina (voucher 1970-0909, Edinburgh and 1995-505, Kew).
The aim of the present phylogenetic analyses is to provide a time frame for the diversification of Saintpaulia lineages. The limited data availability does not allow studying relationships in great detail and we do not intend to address taxonomic questions; therefore possible implications for systematics are not central for the discussion. It is, however, important to mention that a systematic revision in a phylogenetic context may be necessary as our results suggest that the Nguru populations of S. ionantha subsp. nitida and S. ionantha subsp. velutina (as S. brevipilosa in [14], [18]) may be a different species than S. ionantha. In the case of S. ionantha subsp. nitida, distributional patterns are consistent with this hypothesis. Phylogenetic data suggests that S. ionantha subsp. nitida is endemic to the Nguru mountains, whereas the S. ionantha cf. subsp. nitida specimen from the Tanga area (voucher Kwamtili.4, East African Herbarium) is likely a misidentification [18] and most probably belongs to S. ionantha subsp. ionantha (R. Gereau in litt. 2012). Darbyshire acknowledged inconsistencies between the classification that he was proposing and molecular phylogenies [20], but he argued that morphological similarities were large enough to establish the changes. At the very least, to address these inconsistencies a re-examination of the voucher specimens from Nguru and sequencing of additional populations will be required in the future.
Towards the end of the Pliocene S. ionantha increased its range and successfully expanded into lowland areas covered with tropical forests. The wider distribution of S. ionantha and particularly its wide altitudinal range indicate greater ecological plasticity. This is likely a result of adaptation to different climatic conditions leading to niche evolution in this species. Results from species distribution modeling, although suffering from many limitations, also support this conclusion. There is a tendency of overlap for the distribution of potential habitats of S. ionantha and the strictly highland species, but, the younger S. ionantha also encompasses the adjacent geographical and climatic space unsuitable to its highland congeners (Fig. 1, 3–5).
By the middle of the mid-Miocene lineages endemic to different mountain massifs were already established, and in the Pliocene lowland areas were colonized. Deep divergences among the lowland S. ionantha populations provide evidence for long term presence in the lowland, contradicting the traditional Pleistocene refugia model as these lineages have persisted in the area throughout the Pleistocene glaciation cycles. Thus, the montane refugia model may be relevant only to pre-Pleistocene events, as suggested by Fjeldså and Bowie [12].
Saintpaulia taxa are tropical forest understory plants and are never found outside forest in nature, with the exception of S. ionantha subsp. rupicola, which frequently grows in rather exposed habitats in coastal Kenya. Therefore, its presence throughout the Pleistocene in coastal and other lowland areas of Kenya and Tanzania provides strong evidence for the continuous presence of forests in the region. These forests were probably highly fragmented and separated by savannahs during glacial maxima but large enough to allow the survival of many forest species in an area that was otherwise unstable. During wetter periods when forests expanded, some of these fragmented populations likely underwent expansions and this has presented opportunities for secondary contact and hybridization. This may explain the observed pattern of shared haplotypes between lowland populations from different subspecies of S. ionantha, which otherwise show old divergences (Fig. 2). Periods of populations’ expansion and contraction (with extinction of some populations and their haplotypes) also fit the observed reticulatations in the haplotype network and the large number of reconstructed missing haplotypes (Fig. 2). This process of lineage differentiation is similar to the one described from leaf chameleons [13] and also takes place on the periphery of the stable areas as hypothesized by the stability theory.
The origin, maintenance and distribution of African violets in Eastern Arc Mountains and Coastal Forests seems therefore connected to past climatic stability in the highlands and changes in the lowlands. Thus, how will climate change affect African violets during this century? All Saintpaulia species are at high risk due to habitat degradation and environmental changes [23], [24]. Although our future projections address only the climatic component of environmental change, habitat degradation due to human activities is very severe in this region [47], [68], and as both Kenya and Tanzania face population growth and associated development it is unlikely that this tendency will change soon. The importance of non-climatic variables was reflected in the niche modeling results for Tanzania where some data were available (Fig. 5); as a result of landuse changes some of the climatically suitable areas are no longer habitable for Saintpaulia. Most of the conservation effort in the region has been traditionally focused on the mountain areas, although there is a recent surge in establishment of protected areas in the coastal and other lowland forest [69]. Evidence for lowland micro-refugia indicates that lowland populations may have higher chance to survive future climate changes if putative micro-refugia are considered when designing protected areas. However, most of the lowland areas with suitable climatic conditions for Saintpaulia are already much altered (transformed for agricultural use). Even worse, projections of climatic suitability show rapid collapse of the suitable habitats in a dramatic loss of genetic diversity and virtual extinction of some populations within the next 70 years (e.g., all Kenya haplotypes may go extinct). This is likely due to the fact that the expected climate change for 2080 may bring levels of green house gases and global temperatures that do not have analogs during the Pleistocene interglacial periods [70]. Significant warming is expected for the East African region and predictions also show increased net rainfall and stronger seasonality in this region [71]. As a result some of the lowland micro-refugia may experience environmental changes which would make these areas unsuitable for Saintpaulia. Under this scenario additional measures may be needed to ensure survival of lowland lineages; establishment of protected areas alone will not be able to solve the problem.
In contrast to the coastal forests, the montane areas seem to be in a much better position. Several of the high elevation areas with suitable climates are already protected and, more importantly, according to our results, expected changes in climate will not cause shifts of suitable conditions beyond existing reserves. However, the surface area of mountain regions with suitable conditions will decrease significantly, resulting in increased vulnerability of Saintpaulia species and likely other plants and animals adapted to the same environmental conditions.
Our results on future impacts of climate change in African violets should be interpreted with caution. As in other tropical mountains, where local climates are decoupled from the global weather trends due to regional phenomena, climatic data available for reconstructing current and future climatic trends is scarce [72]. Moreover, predicting biodiversity responses to climate change in the tropics, where data on species occurrence are scarce, is challenging enough [73] and the accumulation of climatic data is only one of many challenges affecting the accuracy of niche modeling predictions in these regions. However, our results provide a useful first approximation to a better understanding of the processes that have shaped diversity in the Eastern Arc and also show general tendencies for the future changes that may be a helpful guide for better conservation planning.
In summary, we present evidence that pre-Quaternary speciation processes and stable environmental conditions have been key factors for the high levels of biodiversity in the Eastern Arc Mountains, as proposed by the long-term stability scenario. However, the role of the upper parts of these mountains as climatic refugia for lowland lineages, by preventing extinctions during the Pleistocene, may have also contributed to augment and maintain the extraordinary species diversity of this area. We also find evidence for the existence of lowland micro-refugia during the Pleistocene, but further investigation is necessary to characterize them better. Such micro-refugia have likely been a paramount for the survival of the lowland Saintpaulia populations during the Pleistocene climatic fluctuations, and should be given priority for conservation. Our analyses suggest that there is not any single factor, but a combination of biogeographical factors, that explain why tropical mountains are currently areas of high biodiversity concentration.
Acknowledgments
We thank R. E. Gereau, N. Burgess, K. Marske, K. Puliafico and three anonymous reviewers for comments on earlier draft of the manuscript. All distributional records of Saintpaulia species were kindly provided by R. E. Gereau from the Missouri Botanical Garden. Neil Burgess and the Valuing the Arc project contributed the land cover, lithology and soil data for the Eastern Arc region of Tanzania.
Author Contributions
Conceived and designed the experiments: DD DNB NS. Analyzed the data: DD DNB. Wrote the paper: DD DNB NS.
References
- 1.
Mittermeier RA, Gil PR, Hoffman M, Pilgrim J, Brooks T, et al.. (2005) Hotspots revisited: earth’s biologically richest and most endangered terrestrial ecoregions. Washington, DC: Conservation International.
- 2. Burgess ND, Butynski TM, Cordeiro NJ, Doggart NH, Fjeldså J, et al. (2007) The biological importance of the Eastern Arc Mountains of Tanzania and Kenya. Biol. Cons. 134: 209–231 .
- 3. Crowe TM, Crowe AA (1982) Patterns of distribution, diversity and endemism in Afrotropical birds. J. Zool. 198: 417–442.
- 4.
Hamilton AC (1982) Environmental history of East Africa: a study of the Quaternary. Academic press London.
- 5.
Moreau RE (1966) The bird faunas of Africa and its islands. Academic Press New York, London.
- 6. Diamond AW, Hamilton AC (1980) The distribution of forest passerine birds and Quaternary climatic change in tropical Africa. J. Zool. 191: 379–402.
- 7. Fjeldså J, Lovett JC (1997) Geographical patterns of old and young species in African forest biota: the significance of specific montane areas as evolutionary centers. Biodivers. Conserv. 6: 325–346.
- 8. Finch J, Leng MJ, Marchant R (2009) Late Quaternary vegetation dynamics in a biodiversity hotspot, the Uluguru Mountains of Tanzania. Quatern. Res. 72: 111–122 .
- 9. Mumbi CT, Marchant R, Hooghiemstra H, Wooller MJ (2008) Late Quaternary vegetation reconstruction from the Eastern Arc Mountains, Tanzania. Quatern. Res. 69: 326–341.
- 10. Couvreur TLP, Chatrou LW, Sosef MSM, Richardson JE (2008) Molecular phylogenetics reveal multiple tertiary vicariance origins of the African rain forest trees. BMC Biol. 6: 54 .
- 11. Evans BJ, Kelley DB, Tinsley RC, Melnick DJ, Cannatella DC (2004) A mitochondrial DNA phylogeny of African clawed frogs: phylogeography and implications for polyploid evolution. Mol. Phylogenet. Evol. 33: 197–213 .
- 12. Fjeldså J, Bowie RCK (2008) New perspectives on the origin and diversification of Africa’s forest avifauna. Afr. J. Ecol. 46: 235–247.
- 13. Measey GJ, Tolley KA (2011) Sequential Fragmentation of Pleistocene Forests in an East Africa Biodiversity Hotspot: Chameleons as a Model to Track Forest History. PLoS ONE 6: e26606 .
- 14. Lindqvist C, Albert VA (2001) A high elevation ancestry for the Usambara Mountains and lowland populations of African violets (Saintpaulia, Gesneriaceae). Syst. Geogr. Plants 71: 37–44.
- 15. Burtt BL (1947) Species of Saintpaulia. Gard. Chron 3: 22–23.
- 16. Burtt BL (1958) Studies in the Gesneriaceae of the Old World XV: The genus Saintpaulia. Notes Roy. Bot. Gard. Edinburgh 22: 547–568.
- 17. Burtt BL (1964) Studies in the Gesneriaceae of the Old World XXV: Additional notes on Saintpaulia. Notes Roy. Bot. Gard. Edinburgh 25: 191–195.
- 18. Lindqvist C, Albert VA (1999) Phylogeny and conservation of African violets (Saintpaulia: Gesneriaceae): new findings based on nuclear ribosomal 5S non-transcribed spacer sequences. Kew Bull. 54: 363–377.
- 19. Möller M, Cronk QCB (1997) Phylogeny and disjunct distribution: evolution of Saintpaulia (Gesneriaceae). Proc. R. Soc. B 264: 1827–1836.
- 20.
Darbyshire I (2006) Gesneriaceae. In: Beentje HJ, Ghazanfar SA, editors. Flora of Tropical East Africa. Kew, UK: Royal Botanic Garden. 1–74.
- 21. Haston EM, Mejissa J, Watkins C (2009) Two new species of Saintpaulia from the Uluguru mountains, Tanzania. Curtis’s Bot. Mag. 26: 270–272 .
- 22. Möller M, Cronk QCB (1997) Origin and relationships of Saintpaulia (Gesneriaceae) based on ribosomal DNA internal transcribed spacer (ITS) sequences. Am. J. Bot. 84: 956–965.
- 23. Kolehmainen J, Mutikainen P (2007) Population stage structure, survival and recruitment in the endangered East African forest herb Saintpaulia. Plant Ecol. 192: 85–95.
- 24. Eastwood A, Bytebier B, Tye H, Tye A, Robertson A, et al. (1998) The conservation status of Saintpaulia. Curtis’s Bot. Mag. 15: 49–62.
- 25. Caro SE, Stampfle JM, Greene MJ, Kotarski MA (2006) Using a chalcone synthase Gene to Infer Phylogenies in the Genus Saintpaulia. Bios 77: 72–76.
- 26. Möller M, Pfosser M, Jang CG, Mayer V, Clark A, et al. (2009) A preliminary phylogeny of the “didymocarpoid Gesneriaceae” based on three molecular data sets: Incongruence with available tribal classifications. Am. J. Bot. 96: 989–1010 .
- 27. Qiu YL, Li L, Wang B, Xue JY, Hendry TA, et al. (2010) Angiosperm phylogeny inferred from sequences of four mitochondrial genes. J. Syst. Evol. 48: 391–425.
- 28. Citerne HL, Möller M, Cronk QCB (2000) Diversity of cycloidea-like genes in Gesneriaceae in relation to floral symmetry. Ann. Bot. 86: 167–176 .
- 29. Roalson EH, Skog LE, Zimmer EA (2008) Untangling Gloxinieae (Gesneriaceae). II. Reconstructing biogeographic patterns and estimating divergence times among New World continental and island lineages. Syst. Bot. 33: 159–175.
- 30. Bremer K, Friis E, Bremer B (2004) Molecular Phylogenetic Dating of Asterid Flowering Plants Shows Early Cretaceous Diversification. Syst. Biol. 53: 496–505 .
- 31. Drummond AJ, Rambaut A (2007) BEAST: Bayesian evolutionary analysis by sampling trees. BMC Evol. Biol. 7: 214 .
- 32. Drummond AJ, Ho SYW, Phillips MJ, Rambaut A (2006) Relaxed Phylogenetics and Dating with Confidence. PLoS Biol. 4: e88 .
- 33. Soltis PS, Soltis DE, Savolainen V, Crane PR, Barraclough TG (2002) Rate heterogeneity among lineages of tracheophytes: Integration of molecular and fossil data and evidence for molecular living fossils. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 99: 4430–4435 .
- 34. Gaut BS, Muse SV, Clark WD, Clegg MT (1992) Relative rates of nucleotide substitution at the rbcl locus of monocotyledonous plants. J. Mol. Evol. 35: 292–303 .
- 35. Kay KM, Whittall JB, Hodges SA (2006) A survey of nuclear ribosomal internal transcribed spacer substitution rates across angiosperms: an approximate molecular clock with life history effects. BMC Evol. Biol. 6: 36 .
- 36. Smith SA, Donoghue MJ (2008) Rates of Molecular Evolution Are Linked to Life History in Flowering Plants. Science 322: 86–89 .
- 37. Stamatakis A (2006) RAxML-VI-HPC: maximum likelihood-based phylogenetic analyses with thousands of taxa and mixed models. Bioinformatics 22: 2688.
- 38.
Miller MA, Pfeiffer W, Schwartz T (2010) Creating the CIPRES Science Gateway for inference of large phylogenetic trees. Proceedings of the Gateway Computing Environments Workshop (GCE). New Orleans, LA. 1–8.
- 39. Posada D (2008) jModelTest: Phylogenetic Model Averaging. Mol. Biol. Evol. 25: 1253–1256 .
- 40.
Rambaut A, Drummond AJ (2007) Tracer v1.4, Available from http://beast.bio.ed.ac.uk/Tracer.
- 41. Katoh K, Asimenos G, Toh H (2009) Multiple alignment of DNA sequences with MAFFT. Meth. Mol. Biol. 537: 39–64.
- 42. Sanderson MJ (2003) r8s: inferring absolute rates of molecular evolution and divergence times in the absence of a molecular clock. Bioinformatics 19: 301.
- 43. Clement M, Posada D, Crandall KA (2000) TCS: a computer program to estimate gene genealogies. Mol. Ecol. 9: 1657–1659.
- 44. Katz RW (2002) Techniques for estimating uncertainty in climate change scenarios and impact studies. Clim. Res. 20: 167–185.
- 45. Murphy J (1999) An Evaluation of Statistical and Dynamical Techniques for Downscaling Local Climate. J. Climate 12: 2256–2284 .
- 46.
Ramirez J, Jarvis A (2010) Downscaling Global Circulation Model Outputs: The Delta Method Decision and Policy Analysis Working Paper No. 1. International Center for Tropical Agriculture. Available at: http://ccafs-climate.org/download_sres. html.
- 47. Tabor K, Burgess ND, Mbilinyi BP, Kashaigili JJ, Steininger MK (2010) Forest and woodland cover and change in coastal Tanzania and Kenya, 1990 to 2000. J. E. Afr. Nat. Hist. 99: 19–45.
- 48. Phillips SJ, Dudik M (2008) Modeling of species distributions with Maxent: new extensions and a comprehensive evaluation. Ecography 31: 161–175.
- 49. Phillips SJ, Anderson RP, Schapire RE (2006) Maximum entropy modeling of species geographic distributions. Ecol. Model. 190: 231–259.
- 50. Pearson RG, Raxworthy CJ, Nakamura M, Peterson AT (2007) Predicting species distributions from small numbers of occurrence records: a test case using cryptic geckos in Madagascar. J. Biogeogr. 34: 102–117.
- 51. Araújo MB, Rahbek C (2006) How does climate change affect biodiversity? Science 313: 1396.
- 52.
Nix HA (1986) A biogeographic analysis of Australian elapid snakes. In: Longmore R, editor. Atlas of elapid snakes of Australia. Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service. 4–15.
- 53. Anderson RP, Lew D, Peterson AT (2003) Evaluating predictive models of species’ distributions: criteria for selecting optimal models. Ecol. Model. 162: 211–232.
- 54. Souza Muñoz ME, Giovanni R, Siqueira MF, Sutton T, Brewer P, et al. (2009) openModeller: a generic approach to species’ potential distribution modelling. GeoInformatica 15: 111–135 .
- 55.
Bertrand R, Lenoir J, Piedallu C, Riofrío-Dillon G, de Ruffray P, et al.. (2011) Changes in plant community composition lag behind climate warming in lowland forests. Nature. doi:10.1038/nature10548
- 56. Ruiz-Labourdette D, Nogués-Bravo D, Ollero HS, Schmitz MF, Pineda FD (2011) Forest composition in Mediterranean mountains is projected to shift along the entire elevational gradient under climate change. J. Biogeogr. 39: 162–176 .
- 57. Zachos J, Pagani M, Sloan L, Thomas E, Billups K (2001) Trends, rhythms, and aberrations in global climate 65 Ma to present. Science 292: 686–693 .
- 58.
Griffiths CJ (1993) The geological evolution of East Africa. In: Lovett JC, Wasser SK, editors. Biogeography and ecology of the rain forests of eastern Africa. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. 9–21.
- 59. Jacobs BF, Kingston JD, Jacobs LL (1999) The origin of grass-dominated ecosystems. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 86: 590–643.
- 60. Loader SP, Pisani D, Cotton JA, Gower DJ, Day JJ, et al. (2007) Relative time scales reveal multiple origins of parallel disjunct distributions of African caecilian amphibians. Biol. Lett. 3: 505–508 .
- 61.
Harvey PH, Pagel MD (1991) The comparative method in evolutionary biology. Oxford university press Oxford.
- 62. Peterson AT, Soberón J, Sánchez-Cordero V (1999) Conservatism of ecological niches in evolutionary time. Science 285: 1265.
- 63. Wiens JJ, Graham CH (2005) Niche conservatism: integrating evolution, ecology, and conservation biology. Annu. Rev. Ecol. Evol. Syst. 36: 519–539.
- 64. Losos JB (2008) Phylogenetic niche conservatism, phylogenetic signal and the relationship between phylogenetic relatedness and ecological similarity among species. Ecol. Lett. 11: 995–1003.
- 65. Crisp MD, Arroyo MTK, Cook LG, Gandolfo MA, Jordan GJ, et al. (2009) Phylogenetic biome conservatism on a global scale. Nature 458: 754–756 .
- 66.
Axelrod DI, Raven PH (1978) Late Cretaceous and Tertiary vegetation history of Africa. In: Werger MJA, editor. Biogeography and ecology of southern Africa. The Hague: W Junk bv Publishers. 77–130.
- 67. Jacobs BF (2004) Palaeobotanical studies from tropical Africa: relevance to the evolution of forest, woodland and savannah biomes. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. B 359: 1573–1583 .
- 68. Burgess N, Doggart N, Lovett JC (2002) The Uluguru Mountains of eastern Tanzania: the effect of forest loss on biodiversity. Oryx 36: 140–152 .
- 69.
Burgess ND, Clarke GP (2000) Coastal forests of eastern Africa. World Conservation Union.
- 70. Haywood AM, Ridgwell A, Lunt DJ, Hill DJ, Pound MJ, et al. (2011) Are There Pre-Quaternary Geological Analogues for a Future Greenhouse Warming? Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A 369: 933–956 .
- 71. Hulme M, Doherty R, Ngara T, New M, Lister D (2001) African climate change: 1900–2100. Clim. Res. 17: 145–168.
- 72. Nogués-Bravo D, Araújo MB, Errea MP, Martinez-Rica JP (2007) Exposure of global mountain systems to climate warming during the 21st Century. Global Environ. Change 17: 420–428.
- 73. Kamino LHY, Stehmann JR, Amaral S, De Marco P, Rangel TF, et al. (2012) Challenges and perspectives for species distribution modelling in the neotropics. Biol. Lett. 8: 324–326 .