Figures
Abstract
Curcumin has been widely investigated for its myriad cellular effects resulting in reduced proliferation of various eukaryotic cells including cancer cells and the human malaria parasite Plasmodium falciparum. Studies with human cancer cell lines HT-29, Caco-2, and MCF-7 suggest that curcumin can bind to tubulin and induce alterations in microtubule structure. Based on this finding, we investigated whether curcumin has any effect on P. falciparum microtubules, considering that mammalian and parasite tubulin are 83% identical. IC50 of curcumin was found to be 5 µM as compared to 20 µM reported before. Immunofluorescence images of parasites treated with 5 or 20 µM curcumin showed a concentration-dependent effect on parasite microtubules resulting in diffuse staining contrasting with the discrete hemispindles and subpellicular microtubules observed in untreated parasites. The effect on P. falciparum microtubules was evident only in the second cycle for both concentrations tested. This diffuse pattern of tubulin fluorescence in curcumin treated parasites was similar to the effect of a microtubule destabilizing drug vinblastine on P. falciparum. Molecular docking predicted the binding site of curcumin at the interface of alpha and beta tubulin, similar to another destabilizing drug colchicine. Data from predicted drug binding is supported by results from drug combination assays showing antagonistic interactions between curcumin and colchicine, sharing a similar binding site, and additive/synergistic interactions of curcumin with paclitaxel and vinblastine, having different binding sites. This evidence suggests that cellular effects of curcumin are at least, in part, due to its perturbing effect on P. falciparum microtubules. The action of curcumin, both direct and indirect, on P. falciparum microtubules is discussed.
Citation: Chakrabarti R, Rawat PS, Cooke BM, Coppel RL, Patankar S (2013) Cellular Effects of Curcumin on Plasmodium falciparum Include Disruption of Microtubules. PLoS ONE 8(3): e57302. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0057302
Editor: Philip Bejon, Kenya Medical Research Institute (KEMRI), Kenya
Received: August 1, 2012; Accepted: January 21, 2013; Published: March 7, 2013
Copyright: © 2013 Chakrabarti et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work has been supported in part by an Australian National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC) project grant to RLC, an IITB-Monash Research Academy project grant to RC and IIT Bombay intramural funding to SP. BMC is supported by a Senior Research Fellowship from the Australian National Health and Medical Research Council(NHMRC). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Introduction
Curcumin or diferuloylmethane (from the root of Curcuma longa) is a naturally occurring phenolic derivative, experimentally proven to possess anti-malaria activity against various Plasmodium species [1]–[3]. Its anti-malaria activities have been partially attributed to pro-oxidant properties and the ability to inhibit histone acetyltransferases [1]. The pro-oxidant activity of curcumin is also believed to be responsible for its role in immunomodulation [4]. Another study noted that curcumin interacts with the sarcoplasmic Ca+ ATPase (SERCA) of P. falciparum and suggested that this may account for its anti-malaria mechanism [5]. Finally, recombinant P. falciparum glyoxalase (GloI) has been found to be inhibited by curcumin in vitro [6]. Thus curcumin appears to have several targets in the parasite that singly or collectively may be responsible for its observed antiparasitic action.
Curcumin is also known to have multiple targets in mammalian cells, showing a variety of effects including anti-inflammatory activity [7], anticarcinogenic activity [8] and modulation of angiogenesis [9]. These physiological and therapeutic effects are attributed primarily to its antioxidant activity [10], [11]. In addition to this activity, curcumin is known to target transcription factors c-jun and c-fos [12], NF-κB [13], cytokines and growth factors IL-1, IL-8 [14], FGF-2 [15], receptors and enzymes COX-2 [16], EGFR [17], iNOS [18] and others.
Another target of curcumin in mammalian cells is tubulin, a protein that is essential for cell division and cellular trafficking. Curcumin has been demonstrated to down-regulate the expression of tubulin genes in HT-29 and Caco-2 colon-cancer cells [19]. Curcumin treatment also leads to the formation of mono-polar mitotic spindles in MCF-7 cancer cell lines which were incapable of chromosomal segregation [20]. In another study it was found that curcumin can bind strongly to tubulin in vitro, inhibiting polymer assembly, reducing GTPase activity and inducing tubulin dimer aggregation. Additionally, in cells treated with curcumin, depolymerization of mitotic microtubules during cell division was also seen [21].
Although curcumin has not been analyzed for its anti- microtubule activity in P. falciparum, various known microtubule inhibitors have been tested in this parasite for their antiproliferative effects. These include microtubule stabilizing agents - taxoids [22], [23] and various destabilizing agents - colchicum alkaloids [24], [25], vinca alkaloids [26], dinitroanilines [27] and tubulozoles [28], [29]. The effects of microtubule inhibition by these compounds on the erythrocytic cycle of P. falciparum have been suggested due to defects in cellular processes that are thought to be dependent on microtubule function: merozoite formation [23], inhibition of invasion of erythrocytes by daughter merozoites [25] and blocking of nuclear division [22]. Inhibition of protein synthesis is also an effect of these compounds [29].
As curcumin is known to have inhibitory effects on both mammalian tubulin and P. falciparum growth in culture, we hypothesized that P. falciparum growth inhibition induced by curcumin might be attributed in part to its anti-microtubule activity in the parasite. Here we have investigated the effect of different concentrations of curcumin on the organization of P. falciparum microtubules in cultured parasites. Results are reported through immunofluorescence studies and predicted binding of curcumin to the parasite α, β -tubulin heterodimer by molecular docking. Different mechanisms including direct and indirect effects on tubulin have been discussed to ascertain probable causes for the observed anti-microtubule effects.
Materials and Methods
Parasite culture
The chloroquine sensitive strain of P. falciparum, 3D7, was grown in human B+ erythrocytes at 5% hematocrit in complete medium containing RPMI 1640 supplemented with 25 mM HEPES, pH 7.5, 25 mM sodium bicarbonate, 50 mg/liter hypoxanthine, 10% Albumax II and 40 µg/ml gentamicin sulphate as previously described [30]. Cultures were maintained at 37°C in a gas mixture of 5% CO2,1% O2 and 94% N2. Synchronization was performed using 5% D-sorbitol [31].
Ethics statement
Ethics approval was obtained from the Monash University Human Ethics Committee for using human erythrocytes for culturing malaria parasites. Blood was provided by the Australian Red Cross Blood Bank, Melbourne.
In vitro drug susceptibility assays
100 mM stock solution of curcumin was prepared in 100% dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), filter sterilized and stored in aliquots at −20°C. The effect of curcumin on parasite in vitro growth was tested using a standard Giemsa staining method with serial dilutions of the drug to final concentrations of 0.5 to 50 µM. Synchronized ring stage parasites (0.5%) with 3% hematocrit were seeded in a 24 well plate and curcumin at various concentrations was added along with media up to 96 hours. DMSO (0.1%) was used as solvent control. In all the test cultures DMSO concentration was kept at 0.1% v/v. Parasitemia was determined up to 96 hours. Slides were also photographed at different time points.
For combination assays, combinations of curcumin with colchicine, paclitaxel and vinblastine were set up in 24 well plates following the Fixed Ratio method [32]. In addition, all the four drugs were individually tested. Negative controls had no drug and solvent controls were set up with 0.1% DMSO (v/v). The plates were incubated at 37°C for 96 hours with periodic change of media (containing appropriate drug concentration) every 24 hours. Parasitemia was determined by light microscopy using Giemsa stained smears. Combination Index [CIAB (ΣFICx)] was calculated as:
Hemocompatibility assay for curcumin
Hemolysis was measured as previously described [33] with slight modifications. Blood in 10% CPDA buffer was washed with an equal volume of phosphate buffered saline (PBS) three times. A suspension of erythrocytes (50% hematocrit) was prepared by adding an equal volume of PBS to the washed, packed erythrocytes. To 1.5 ml PBS, 50 µl of cell suspension was added. This sample served as the negative control for hemolysis. 50 µl of cell suspension was also added to 1.5 ml deionized water (hypotonic for erythrocytes), which worked as the positive control for hemolysis. In test samples, 1.5 ml PBS, 50 µl cell suspension and various curcumin concentrations (5 to 100 µM) were added. Spectrophotometer blanks for each test sample were prepared by adding 1.5 ml PBS and various curcumin concentrations (5 to 100 µM) respectively. The experiment was done in duplicates. All the samples were incubated at 37°C for an hour and the reaction was stopped by adding 50 µl of 2.5% glutaraldehyde. The samples were then centrifuged at 1000× g at 4°C for 5 minutes and absorbance of the supernatant was measured at 540 nm. Percent hemolysis was calculated as
Pre-treatment assay
Uninfected B+ erythrocytes at 3% hematocrit were incubated in complete medium along with 5 µM curcumin and maintained for 48 hours as described. These samples represent the curcumin pre-treated erythrocytes which were subsequently infected with parasite-infected erythrocytes to a final parasitemia of 0.5% (ring-stage) and final hematocrit of 3%. The starting ratio of pre-treated to non pre-treated erythrocytes (uninfected) in the pre-treatment assay samples was 9: 1. These samples were maintained and treated with curcumin, 5 µM for 96 hours. During the same experiment, 0.5% ring-stage parasites were also seeded in erythrocytes (not treated with curcumin) to a final hematocrit of 3% simultaneously. These previously untreated cultures were then treated with curcumin, 5 µM for 96 hours. At each 24 hour time interval parasitemia in various cultures were assessed. All samples were tested in duplicate.
Curcumin uptake assay
Curcumin uptake assay was performed to assess the concentration of curcumin inside erythrocytes. Experiments were performed with 3 flasks each for first and second cycle of parasite growth. These 3 flasks were - a. Control with no drug b. Treated: with 5 µM curcumin and c. Uninfected erythrocytes: with 5 µM curcumin. Parasitemia in control and treated flasks were kept same at the start of the experiment whereas hematocrit in all the flasks (control, treated and uninfected erythrocytes) was kept at 3%. Uptake assay by fluorimetry was performed as previously described [34]. Fluorescence readings from control flasks (without curcumin) were considered as background and readings from treated and uninfected erythrocytes flasks were normalized with respect to this background reading. A standard curve for curcumin fluorescence was plotted with different concentrations of the drug to correlate fluorescence intensity with curcumin concentration.
Immunofluorescence
Microtubules in P. falciparum in untreated and treated cultures were monitored at various time points and concentrations by confocal microscopy. The primary antibody used for tubulin immunofluorescence (a kind gift from Dr. Angus Bell, Trinity College, Dublin) was raised in rabbit against a P. falciparum specific beta tubulin peptide [35]. Acyl Carrier Protein (ACP) antibody specific for P. falciparum (a kind gift from Prof. Geoff McFadden, The University of Melbourne) was used for apicoplast immunofluorescence. The immunofluorescence protocol was similar to that reported [36] with a few minor changes. A solution of 4% paraformaldehyde and 0.1% Triton X-100 was used for fixation and permeabilisation. MOWIOL® 4-88 (Calbiochem®) was used as an antifade agent. Images were taken using a Nikon Eclipse 90i microscope.
Molecular docking
The crystal structure of P. falciparum tubulin has not yet been determined, so individual monomers of alpha and beta-tubulin were modeled based on the principle of homology modeling by SWISS-MODEL server [37]. Structures of both the monomers were validated using ANOLEA program in the COLORADO 3D server [38]. The dimeric form of parasite tubulin was constructed by assembling these two monomers using the protein-protein docking server HEX [39].
The crystal structure of curcumin has been published [40]. It has been reported that curcumin, in its solid state, exists as a mixture of its keto and enol tautomeric forms. 3D structures of the diketo (CID969516) and enol (CID11947775) form were downloaded from PUBCHEM. The PUBCHEM structures were in SDF format which were converted to PDB using the NCI Online SMILES Translator (http://cactus.nci.nih.gov/translate/).
Molecular docking of the protein dimer with curcumin and colchicine was performed using AUTODOCK v4.0 [41]. Clusters were generated with an RMS tolerance of 2 angstrom. The Lamarckian Genetic Algorithm (LGA) was used and 250 GA runs were performed for each docking with 1500000 energy evaluations per run. Docked poses were rendered with PyMOL (The PyMOL Molecular Graphics System, Version 1.2r3pre, Schrödinger, LLC).
Results
Curcumin inhibits growth of P. falciparum cultures in vitro
Previous reports have demonstrated the anti-malaria potential of curcumin with IC50 values ranging from 5 to 30 µM [1], [2], [42]. In order to determine the working concentration for 3D7 parasites, an in vitro susceptibility assay against P. falciparum was performed. Figure 1 shows the anti-malaria activity of curcumin. Treatment of P. falciparum cultures with curcumin demonstrated a dose dependent antiparasitic effect. The solvent control (0.1% v/v DMSO) showed no adverse effect on parasite viability.
Control = no drug administered. Solvent control, DMSO = 0.1% (v/v) DMSO. Parasitemia was determined by light microscopy of Giemsa stained blood smears. Error bars represent standard error of the mean (n = 4).
At curcumin concentrations of 35 µM and 50 µM, rapid parasiticidal effect was observed, clearing 70–90% of the cultures within 48 hours (corresponding to one P. falciparum life cycle). At 20 µM curcumin concentration, the parasite growth was reduced by 63% compared to control in the first cycle. After the first cycle, the cultures treated with 20 µM curcumin also showed minimal parasitemia (15%). The percent parasitemia in cultures containing 5 µM curcumin showed ∼50% reduced growth in the first cycle. However, unlike results with higher concentrations of curcumin, at this concentration the parasitemia remained almost constant after the first parasite life-cycle; at the 96 hour time point a 10 fold increase in parasitemia (compared to 0 hours) was observed at 5 µM curcumin in contrast to 37 fold increase in controls. Together with compromised growth, cultures treated with 5 µM curcumin also showed loss of synchrony after 48 hours. At 0.5 µM curcumin, parasite growth was indistinguishable from that of the controls (no curcumin/solvent).
We noted a degree of parasiticidal activity at curcumin concentrations of 5 µM. This is of interest since Cui et. al. have previously demonstrated that after 5 µM curcumin treatment for 4 hours, levels of reactive oxygen species (ROS) were similar to controls [1]. Thus this concentration offers an opportunity to examine curcumin effects that may be independent of generation of ROS, in particular the effects on microtubule structure.
Curcumin leads to morphological alterations in the parasite
Previously, treatment with microtubule inhibitors has been shown to lead to abnormal morphology of the parasites in vitro [22], [23]. To analyze the gross effects of curcumin on parasite morphology, 5 µM curcumin treated cultures were compared with untreated cultures. Figure 2 shows the morphological alterations in P. falciparum cultures treated for 96 hours with 5 µM curcumin. In contrast to untreated cultures, nuclear material of the parasites (at schizont stage), in 5 µM curcumin treated cultures, appeared to be shrunken and aggregated concentrating towards one end of the erythrocyte. In addition to the parasites, the morphology of the uninfected erythrocytes in the curcumin treated cultures also appeared distorted (Figure 2, Panels C and D). This led to two hypotheses; first, that curcumin may be hemolytic or second, that curcumin may be affecting the properties of the erythrocytes required for intracellular parasite growth. We examined each of these possibilities.
Panel A and B represent the morphology of schizonts and late trophozoites in untreated cultures. Panel C and D represent the morphological changes in schizonts and late trophozoites in cultures treated for 96 hours with 5 µM curcumin.
Curcumin is not hemolytic
The hemolytic potential of curcumin was determined by incubating isolated erythrocytes with different concentrations of curcumin (0.5–100 µM). Compared to the positive control (deionized water, hypotonic), all curcumin concentrations showed negligible hemolytic activity (Figure 3), and all were within the permissible limit of 5% for hemolysis [43]. This suggests that the anti-plasmodial activity of curcumin is not a result of a significant hemolytic effect of the compound.
Erythrocytes were resuspended in isotonic PBS (137 mMNaCl, 2.7 mMKCl, 10 m Na2HPO4, 1.76 mM KH2PO4, pH 7.0) (positive control), deionised water (negative control), and different concentrations of curcumin. * Hemolysis was measured as a % of positive control. Error bars represent standard error of the mean (n = 6).
Curcumin does not modify erythrocyte properties required for growth of P. falciparum
To address the hypothesis that curcumin alters the properties of host erythrocytes required for adequate growth of the parasites, we pre-incubated erythrocytes with 5 µM curcumin for 48 hours before infecting with P. falciparum. If this hypothesis were true, parasite growth should be lower in cultures with pre-treated erythrocytes than in cultures containing non pre-treated erythrocytes. Figure 4 shows the comparative parasite growth patterns in cultures containing 5 µM curcumin pre-treated and untreated erythrocytes. Up to 96 hours, i.e. two parasite life cycles, the parasitemia in both pre-treated and non pre-treated cultures are similar. This suggests that curcumin at 5 µM does not affect properties of the host erythrocytes required for survival and growth of P. falciparum. We conclude that the inhibitory effect of curcumin on P. falciparum is due to action on parasites leading to reduced parasite growth.
For pre-treatment, erythrocytes were incubated with 5 µM curcumin for 48 h and then mixed with parasite-infected untreated erythrocytes to a final parasitemia of 0.5% and final hematocrit of 3%. In no pre-treatment cultures, erythrocytes were not given any pre-treatment with curcumin. No drug control parasite culture with no drug. Error bars represent standard error of the mean (n = 4).
Effects of curcumin on P. falciparum microtubule structures
Curcumin has potent anti-microtubule activity in mammalian systems [20], [21] and parasite tubulin shares 83% identity with its mammalian counterpart. This led us to hypothesize that curcumin can also perturb parasite microtubules. To investigate this, immunofluorescence studies were performed using a beta-tubulin antibody specific for P. falciparum tubulin. Parasites were treated with 5 and 20 µM curcumin for 96 hours and compared to untreated parasites at similar stages. Figure 5 shows immunofluorescence images of untreated (5A) and curcumin-treated (5 and 20 µM) P. falciparum cultures (5B, C).
Microtubular structures of P. falciparum as observed in different timelines of progression through the mature blood stages. Parasite tubulin is stained with an anti β tubulin antibody and Alexa Fluor 488 and is shown in green. Blue represents nuclear material stained with DAPI. Panel A: Normal parasite microtubules without any drug treatment. Spindle structures were observed in the mid to late trophozoite stages (A1) and distinct MTOCs in the schizonts (A2). The typical subpellicular microtubules were seen in the merozoites (A3 and A4). Panel B: Parasites treated with 5 µM curcumin daily over the course of 96 hours, B1 – 24 hours, B2 – 48 hours, B3- 72 hours, B4 – 96 hours. Panel C: Parasites treated with 20 µM curcumin daily over the course of 96 hours, C1 – 24 hours, C2 – 48 hours, C3- 72 hours, C4 – 96 hours. Spindle structures are conspicuous in their absence in the trophozoites. Towards the later stages tubulin fluorescence pattern becomes diffused compared to the distinct MTOCs and subpellicular microtubules observed in the untreated parasites.
In untreated cultures, parasite microtubules and the structures formed by them were observed to follow a particular pattern as P. falciparum progressed through its different blood stages of rings, trophozoites and schizonts. In the trophozoite stage, at the onset of nuclear division, hemi-spindle structures were seen always associated with the nucleus. In schizonts, subpellicular microtubules were clearly visible. When treated with 5 µM and 20 µM curcumin, changes were observed in microtubular structures, as compared to untreated cultures and no significant effect on parasite microtubule morphology was observed in the first 48 hours (corresponding to the first cycle).The number of trophozoites and schizonts imaged with spindle and subpellicular microtubules in treated cultures were less than controls, but still comparable (Table 1). Major effects were evident after approximately 48 hours when the parasites progressed to the next growth cycle. No definite hemispindle structures could be found throughout the trophozoite stages or any subpellicular microtubules in schizonts (Table 1). Instead, the tubulin immunofluorescence patterns appeared micro-punctate and diffuse in both these stages. Of note here is that although progression through the growth cycle was delayed, there was nuclear division towards the end of the first cycle as well as the second one in the curcumin treated population. No apparent differences were noted from the untreated schizonts in terms of number of nuclei per infected host cell. This late action of curcumin on P. falciparum microtubules, occurring in the second cycle, was noted and subsequent experiments were performed to explore potential factors leading to this effect.
The micro-punctate staining and diffuse localization of tubulin with an apparent loss of hemi-spindles suggested that curcumin destabilizes microtubules. To compare these results with those seen for known microtubule destabilizing and stabilizing drugs, we treated cultures with paclitaxel and vinblastine (Figure 6 B, C). Paclitaxel treatment (1 µM for 6 hours) has been shown to result in the appearance of thick rod-like microtubules whereas vinblastine treatment (20 µM for 6 hours) has the converse effect and results in diffuse tubulin staining [35], [44] in P. falciparum. We treated cultures for 24 hours with lower concentrations of paclitaxel and vinblastine (500 nM and 100 nM respectively). As expected, paclitaxel-treated parasites exhibited thick rod-like microtubule structures (Figure 6B) and vinblastine treated parasites showed diffuse, micro-punctate staining of tubulin (Figure 6C) resembling the appearance of curcumin treatment cultures. This suggests that cellular effect of curcumin in P. falciparum is similar to known destabilizing drugs.
Microtubule stabilizing and destabilizing compounds exert contrasting effects on their target. Panel A shows P. falciparum without any drug treatment after 24 hours. Panel B shows parasites 24 hours after treated with 500 nM paclitaxel. Images in panel C represents parasites treated with 100 nM vinblastine, after 24 hours. Molar concentration of the drugs was chosen on the basis of published IC50.
Intracellular concentration of curcumin is much less than 5 µM
Immunofluorescence studies showed that the effect of curcumin on P.falciparum microtubules was more prominent in second cycle rather in the first cycle. This could be due to several reasons, including low permeability of the compound into the erythrocytes, resulting in lower intracellular drug concentration. To test this possibility, the concentration of curcumin within erythrocytes after the first and second cycle was measured. On average (n = 3), 267 nM of curcumin was found inside the cells of the treated cultures compared to 208 nM curcumin in uninfected erythrocytes, in the first cycle of growth. In the second cycle 217 nM of intracellular curcumin was found in treated cultures compared to 58 nM in uninfected erythrocytes (Figure 7). Note here that 5 µM curcumin was added to the culture for these experiments. Hence, fluorimetric estimation of uptake revealed that a very small fraction (217–267 nM) of this 5 µM curcumin was taken up by the infected erythrocytes. Additionally, no significant differences in intracellular curcumin were observed in the first and second cycles of parasite growth.
Error bars represent standard error of the mean (n = 3).
Effects of curcumin on P. falciparum apicoplasts
Late action of curcumin on parasite microtubules, in the second cycle, is concurrent with a large body of evidence reporting apicoplast targeting drugs showing prominent effects in the second cycle after treatment begins [45]–[47]. In eukaryotes, including Apicomplexans, microtubules are known to provide the tracks for segregation of organelles [48]. To address whether apicoplast structure and segregation are affected in curcumin-treated parasites, we visualised apicoplast by immunofluorescence. Apicoplasts in curcumin treated parasites were morphologically different from the untreated controls. Distinct spherical apicoplasts, associated with subpellicular microtubules (Figure 8 A1, A3) and spindle microtubules (Figure 8 A2), were observed in controls and also in the first cycle of 5 µM curcumin treated parasites (Figure 8B1). Parasites treated with 5 µM curcumin at later stage (93 hours) (Figure 8 B3) as well as parasites treated with 20 µM curcumin (Figure 8C1, C2 and C3) showed a diffuse pattern of apicoplast fluorescence, different from the apicoplasts observed in untreated parasites.
Panel A: Untreated parasites at (1) 45 hours (2) 69 hours and (3) 73 hours. Panel B and Panel C represent parasites treated with 5 µM and 20 µM curcumin respectively, at same time points. Tubulin fluorescence is depicted in green, apicoplast fluorescence in red and nucleus in blue.
Autodock predicts curcumin binding at the interface of P. falciparum tubulin dimer
To provide supporting evidence that curcumin can affect microtubules by destabilizing tubulin polymers, we hypothesised that in silico docking of the compound to the α-β heterodimer of tubulin should reveal a binding site close to those of destabilizing drugs. The binding sites of paclitaxel - a stabilizing drug and two destabilizing drugs - vinblastine and colchicine, to mammalian tubulin have been studied in great detail. Paclitaxel and vinblastine has been shown to be bind at the taxol and vinca domain respectively, present in β-tubulin [49] and colchicine to the interface of the tubulin dimer [50].
Docking studies of curcumin with Autodock resulted in 250 binding poses each for the diketo and enol form of curcumin. The binding of the diketo form is highly site specific. Most of the 250 bound poses are clustered at the interface of the alpha and beta subunits (Figure 9A). The most suitable binding pose as predicted by Autodock, is also at the interface (Figure 9B). This pose was used to compare the interacting residues with those of colchicine.
Figures showing bound poses of curcumin diketo form at the interface of tubulin dimer. P. falciparum tubulin is represented as dimer of alpha (yellow) and beta (green) subunit. Panel A shows all the predicted bound poses, mostly at the interface of the dimer. Panel B shows the most probable binding pose according to Autodock (Rank 1) with the curcumin diketo form at the interface of alpha and beta tubulin monomers. Panel C shows binding sites of colchicine (purple), paclitaxel (red) and vinblastine (brown) on parasite tubulin dimer.
To this end, colchicine, paclitaxel and vinblastine were also docked with the parasite tubulin dimer to find its binding site. Analysis of interacting amino acid residues revealed the predicted binding site of the diketo form of curcumin to tubulin overlapping the colchicine binding site (Table 2 and Figure 9C). On the other hand, the binding site of the enol form seems to be spread out throughout the dimer (data not shown). Paclitaxel and vinblastine binding sites on P. falciparum beta tubulin (Figure 9C) was found to be similar to their binding sites in mammalian tubulin.
Curcumin and colchicine show antagonistic interactions whereas combinations of curcumin-paclitaxel and curcumin-vinblastine have additive and synergistic interactions respectively
Molecular modeling of the predicted binding of curcumin to the tubulin heterodimer indicated that colchicine and curcumin have overlapping binding sites while paclitaxel and vinblastine have binding sites distinct from that of curcumin. This prompted us to test the effect of combinations of these anti-microtubule drugs with curcumin, on parasite viability. The growth pattern observed for all the combinations tested, when compared with the growth curves for the effect of individual drugs, showed that when curcumin and colchicine were tested in combination, neither of the two drugs could function at their full potential (Figure 10 A, B). Combination Indices (CI) calculated at two different time points, 6.75 at 48 hours and 2.51 at 96 hours denote antagonistic interaction between curcumin and colchicine. Conversely, curcumin showed an additive interaction in combination with paclitaxel and a synergistic interaction with vinblastine (Table 3).
Panels A and B represent growth patterns of parasites subjected to curcumin and colchine individually and in combination, for 48 hours and for 96 hours respectively. Panels C and D represent same scenario for curcumin and paclitaxel treated parasites while panels E and F represent curcumin and vinblastine treated parasites. Concentrations of individual drugs used in the combinations are included for each data point. Error bars represent standard error of the mean (n = 4).
Discussion
It has been reported that curcumin has multiple targets in P. falciparum, similar to mammalian cells. With a compound like curcumin that acts on many pathways and proteins in a cell, it could be possible that different targets are affected at different concentrations. The 5 µM curcumin concentration was interesting to us for two reasons. First, Cui et. al. showed that at 5 µM curcumin levels of ROS, which have been proposed to be responsible for the antiparasitic action of curcumin, were similar to controls [1]. Second, since a fraction of parasites escape the first cycle, the microtubule structures of these parasites can be studied even at 96 hours. So, 5 µM may represent a concentration of curcumin where effects on microtubules and cell numbers are seen with minimal contribution from global effects such as generation of ROS. Our immunofluorescence data suggest that the microtubule-affecting properties of curcumin are evident even at 5 µM.
Apart from elevated ROS levels there was also a chance that curcumin could alter erythrocyte properties that are necessary for parasite survival. After all curcumin is known to affect mature erythrocytes by inducing their suicidal death with involvement of Ca2+ influx and formation of ceramide [51]. So when the morphology of erythrocytes seemed to be perturbed at 5 µM, it was possible that the decrease in parasite growth could be due to alteration of erythrocyte properties required for parasite survival. To asses this possibility 5 µM curcumin pre-treated (for 48 h) erythrocytes were inoculated with parasites. Patterns of parasite growth in cultures containing pre-treated erythrocytes and those containing erythrocytes which did not undergo this pre-treatment were similar. This suggests that at a 5 µM curcumin concentration, reduction in parasitemia is unlikely to be a result of alteration of erythrocyte properties required for intracellular growth of P. falciparum.
Despite this evidence, unless binding of curcumin to P. falciparum microtubules is demonstrated, it is difficult to ascribe the effects of curcumin to a direct interaction with microtubules. Nevertheless, immunofluorescence data shown in this report indicates that curcumin certainly disrupts parasite microtubules. This could also be through secondary routes such as elevated ROS leading to global effects on microtubule stability. However the latter seems unlikely in light of our immunofluorescence assay results with 20 µM curcumin. A previously published report suggested that ROS levels were considerably higher than normal after 4 hours of treatment with 20 µM curcumin [1]. Increased ROS levels are known to lead to increased cytotoxicity. In this context, we note that microtubules of 20 µM curcumin treated parasites looked unperturbed and similar to controls even after 24 hours (Figure 5 panel C1). In the following sections we discuss aspects of curcumin action on P. falciparum growth, invoking models of direct action on microtubules as well as indirect effects.
Predicted binding site of curcumin to tubulin overlaps that of colchicine – a destabilizing drug
The major line of evidence in favor of a direct interaction between curcumin and tubulin is provided by docking studies with the diketo form of curcumin that is predicted to bind to the interface of the tubulin dimer. This binding pattern of the ligand is indicative of its effect on P. falciparum microtubules resembling destabilizing drugs, considering that the binding site overlaps with the colchicine domain [50]. Colchicine binds predominantly to beta tubulin at the interface of the dimer. It has been shown to bind tubulin in a biphasic manner and is believed to induce a conformational change on binding [52]. Interestingly, experiments in HeLa and MCF-7 cells have indicated a similar binding site and same mode of action for curcumin [21]. P. falciparum tubulin is yet to be purified in sufficient quantity to conduct similar experiments in the parasites. However based on this correlation it seems probable that, like colchicine, curcumin molecules bind to a fraction of the free tubulin, induce a conformational change, thus forming an altered tubulin-curcumin complex. When these defective dimers along with normal dimers are polymerised to the plus end, the microtubules can still grow, but their dynamic properties are compromised.
Drug interaction data from the combination assays supports this line of evidence. Antagonistic interaction between curcumin and colchicine could be due to a) the drugs competing for the same binding site or b) having contradictory effects on the same target. Immunofluorescence assays show curcumin to have a destabilizing effect like colchicine so the competing binding site hypothesis seems most plausible. Of note here is the apparent poor effectiveness of the curcumin-colchicine combinations even after 96 hours (Figure 10B). Had the antiproliferative action of curcumin been due to off target or global effects (e.g. increase in ROS levels), and not due to targeting tubulin, the combination growth curves at 96 hours should have been similar to the individual drugs in case of curcumin-colchicine combinations.
This hypothesis can also be complemented with the results from the controls – the curcumin-vinblastine and curcumin-paclitaxel combination experiments. Vinblastine and paclitaxel are known to bind at the top and one side of beta tubulin respectively (Figure 9C and extensive data from mammalian tubulin structures). These binding sites, distinct from the colchicine as well as curcumin binding site at the interface of the tubulin dimer (Figure 9A–C), could explain the effect of curcumin-paclitaxel and curcumin-vinblastine combinations. In the latter case curcumin and vinblastine, both destabilizing drugs, bind to two separate sites on the beta tubulin and bring about a synergistic effect in reducing the parasitemia. When combined with paclitaxel, curcumin shows an additive effect. This could be partly because paclitaxel and curcumin have two opposing modes of action on tubulin. However, the growth curves for combinations of these two drugs (Figure 10C, D) suggest that paclitaxel is the more potent partner in this combination and seems to be mostly responsible for the observed additive effect.
Effect of curcumin on microtubules is more pronounced in the second cycle and associated with an altered apicoplast morphology
The microtubule disrupting action of curcumin becomes prominent in the second cycle. This delayed aspect of its action may be attributed to several possible factors. If curcumin acts stage specifically in the mature parasites and considering a tight 100% synchrony is hard to achieve, it might be possible for some parasites to escape the drug action in the first cycle as has been observed previously with vinblastine [26]. Alternatively, it might be due to the fact that rings are less permeable in their uptake of external compounds [35]. However, neither reason explains why some parasites escape the action of the drug even after the second cycle, at lower concentrations.
An alternative explanation could be that curcumin, like the antibacterial agents tetracycline [47], azithromycin, ciprofloxaxin, doxycycline and clindamycin [53], exhibit its effect more prominently in the second cycle. A widely accepted model of the tetracycline mechanism of action in P. falciparum is based on loss of apicoplast function [54]. Presently, no evidence has been cited in favor of an interaction between the apicoplast and microtubules in P. falciparum. However, in a related apicomplexan parasite, T. gondii, division and segregation of apicoplast into daughter cells have been observed to be linked with centrosomes/microtubules [55]. It is possible that the disruption of microtubules seen after curcumin treatment causes a cascading effect which, in addition to disrupting schizogony, also disrupts apicoplast segregation and function.
When treated with curcumin (both 5 µM and 20 µM), parasites showed apicoplast morphology different from the untreated controls at same time points (Figure 8). Based on observations in T. gondii [55], tubular, undivided apicoplasts might have been expected in the mature stages resulting from a segregation defect. Instead diffuse apicoplast fluorescence is observed in the mature stages of treated parasites (Figures 8B3 and 8C3) compared to discrete spherical apicoplasts found in daughter merozoites in untreated controls (Figures 8A1 and 8A3). This pattern of diffuse apicoplast fluorescence could also be a result of defective import of apicoplast proteins as has been reported previously with delayed death drugs [47].
It is also possible that curcumin does not enter the host erythrocyte at high concentrations. Hence, maximal exposure to the drug occurs in the very small time frame between the egress of merozoites from infected erythrocytes and invasion of new erythrocytes. It is only at this brief window of time that the extracellular merozoites are in contact with the drug present in the media. This is supported by the data showing nanomolar concentrations of curcumin in the intracellular compartment during the first and second cycles of parasites in culture, while extracellular concentrations of curcumin are approximately 1000 fold higher. If schizonts are shielded from curcumin in their intracellular niche and only exposed to the drug prior to the start of the second cycle when they egress, a delayed effect of curcumin would be expected. This is also consistent with the data showing that pre-treatment of erythrocytes with curcumin and presumably loading them with the drug does not affect parasite growth.
The points discussed above explore the possibility of curcumin having a pronounced effect on microtubule structures in the second cycle due to mechanisms unrelated to curcumin directly binding microtubules. Instead, if curcumin acts directly on tubulin, yet another explanation lies in the way antimitotic drugs exert their effect on microtubules. It has been noticed that at high concentrations of destabilizing drugs like vinblastine, there is inhibition of GTPase activity, preventing polymerization. However at much lower but pharmacologically significant concentrations, they affect the dynamic instability of the microtubules [56], [57]. Considering that P. falciparum tubulins have not been fluorescently tagged in vivo as yet, it is not possible to perform live cell microscopy to assess the effect of the drug on the dynamic properties of parasite microtubules. Nevertheless diffused micro-punctate structures observed in curcumin treated fixed parasites (Figure 6 B, C) might represent accumulated unpolymerized tubulin. This would be similar to observations with other microtubule disrupting drugs tested in P. falciparum [27], [35], [58] illustrated in Figure 7A, and different from the thick rods of microtubules observed after paclitaxel treatment, a tubulin stabilizing agent [22], [23], [59], [60] and Figure 7B. Interestingly, the figures are suggestive of the fact that although spindle structures are affected, there seems to be no difference in the outcome as far as the division of the nucleus is concerned. Neatly segmented nuclei appeared in the schizont stages of curcumin-treated cultures. These observations suggest that curcumin might exert its inhibitory effect by promoting aberrant mitosis, like other microtubule disrupting drugs, and not a complete mitotic block promoted by stabilizing drugs like paclitaxel.
Conclusion
Considering curcumin is known to have multiple targets in P. falciparum, it would be interesting to understand their individual roles and which are necessary for their antiparasitic effect. We have tried to explore the effect of curcumin on P. falciparum microtubules and plausible mechanisms leading to this effect. Our molecular docking data suggests that curcumin might bind at the interface of alpha-beta tubulin heterodimer leading to altered microtubule morphology, as shown by our immunofluorescence studies. This is supported by results from drug combination assays with an antagonistic interaction between curcumin and colchicine suggesting competition for the same binding site. Alternatively, it might still be possible that curcumin does not bind directly to tubulin. The microtubule destabilizing effect could also be a part of global cell damage or due to off target effects of curcumin. Curcumin is known to affect a significant number of kinases in mammalian cells. Similar studies have not been done in P. falciparum, but a similar action in the parasites might have an indirect effect on the polymerization of microtubules. Irrespective of the cause, the damaged microtubules hinder cellular functions including apicoplast morphology. These lead to reduced parasite viability and are, at least partially, responsible for the antiparasitic action of curcumin.
Acknowledgments
We would like to thank Dr. Angus Bell, Trinity College, Dublin for providing us with the P. falciparum beta tubulin antibody and Prof. Geoff McFadden, The University of Melbourne, for the ACP antibody used in our immunofluorescence studies. We also thank Prof. P.V. Balaji, IIT Bombay for his guidance and suggestions in the molecular docking section. We gratefully acknowledge the Micro Imaging platform at Monash University for their assistance with fluorescence microscopy and imaging.
Author Contributions
Conceived and designed the experiments: SP RLC BMC. Performed the experiments: RC PSR. Analyzed the data: RC PSR BMC RLC SP. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: BMC RLC SP. Wrote the paper: RC PSR BMC RLC SP.
References
- 1. Cui L, Miao J (2007) Cytotoxic effect of curcumin on malaria parasite Plasmodium falciparum: inhibition of histone acetylation and generation of reactive oxygen species. Antimicrob Agents Chemother 51: 488–494.
- 2. Nandakumar DN, Nagaraj VA, Vathsala PG, Rangarajan P, Padmanaban G (2006) Curcumin-artemisinin combination therapy for malaria. Antimicrob Agents Chemother 50: 1859–1860.
- 3. Reddy RC, Vatsala PG, Keshamouni VG, Padmanaban G, Rangarajan PN (2005) Curcumin for malaria therapy. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 326: 472–474.
- 4. Mimche PN, Taramelli D, Vivas L (2011) The plant-based immunomodulator curcumin as a potential candidate for the development of an adjunctive therapy for cerebral malaria. Malaria Journal 10 Suppl 1: S10.
- 5. Ji HF, Shen L (2009) Interactions of curcumin with the PfATP6 model and the implications for its antimalarial mechanism. Bioorg Med Chem Lett 19: 2453–2455.
- 6. Urscher M, Przyborski JM, Imoto M, Deponte M (2010) Distinct subcellular localization in the cytosol and apicoplast, unexpected dimerization and inhibition of Plasmodium falciparum glyoxalases. Molecular Microbiology 76: 92–103.
- 7. Sandur SK, Pandey MK, Sung B, Ahn KS, Murakami A, et al. (2007) Curcumin, demethoxycurcumin, bisdemethoxycurcumin, tetrahydrocurcumin and turmerones differentially regulate anti-inflammatory and anti-proliferative responses through a ROS-independent mechanism. Carcinogenesis 28: 1765–1773.
- 8. Agrawal DK, Mishra PK (2010) Curcumin and its analogues: Potential anticancer agents. Med Res Rev 30 (5) 818–860.
- 9. Thaloor D, Singh AK, Sidhu GS, Prasad PV, Kleinman HK, et al. (1998) Inhibition of angiogenic differentiation of human umbilical vein endothelial cells by curcumin. Cell Growth and Differentiation 9: 305–312.
- 10. Motterlini R, Foresti R, Bassi R, Green CJ (2000) Curcumin, an antioxidant and anti-inflammatory agent, induces heme oxygenase-1 and protects endothelial cells against oxidative stress. Free Radical Biology and Medicine 28: 1303–1312.
- 11. Kunchandy E, Rao MNA (1990) Oxygen radical scavenging activity of curcumin. International Journal of Pharmaceutics 58: 237–240.
- 12. Lu Y-P, Chang RL, Lou Y-R, Huang M-T, Newmark HL, et al. (1994) Effect of curcumin on 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol-13-acetate- and ultraviolet B light-induced expression of c-Jun and c-Fos in JB6 cells and in mouse epidermis. Carcinogenesis 15: 2363–2370.
- 13. Singh S, Aggarwal BB (1995) Activation of transcription factor NF-κB is suppressed by curcumin (diferulolylmethane). Journal of Biological Chemistry 270: 24995–25000.
- 14. Jobin C, Bradham CA, Russo MP, Juma B, Narula AS, et al. (1999) Curcumin Blocks Cytokine-Mediated NF-{kappa}B Activation and Proinflammatory Gene Expression by Inhibiting Inhibitory Factor I-{kappa}B Kinase Activity. J Immunol 163: 3474–3483.
- 15. Mohan R, Sivak J, Ashton P, Russo LA, Pham BQ, et al. (2000) Curcuminoids inhibit the angiogenic response stimulated by fibroblast growth factor-2, including expression of matrix metalloproteinase gelatinase B. Journal of Biological Chemistry 275: 10405–10412.
- 16. Goel A, Boland CR, Chauhan DP (2001) Specific inhibition of cyclooxygenase-2 (COX-2) expression by dietary curcumin in HT-29 human colon cancer cells. Cancer Letters 172: 111–118.
- 17. Korutla L, Cheung JY, Medelsohn J, Kumar R (1995) Inhibition of ligand-induced activation of epidermal growth factor receptor tyrosine phosphorylation by curcumin. Carcinogenesis 16: 1741–1745.
- 18. Jung KK, Lee HS, Cho JY, Shin WC, Rhee MH, et al. (2006) Inhibitory effect of curcumin on nitric oxide production from lipopolysaccharide-activated primary microglia. Life Sciences 79: 2022–2031.
- 19. Van Erk M, Teuling E, Staal Y, Huybers S, Van Bladeren P, et al. (2004) Time- and dose-dependent effects of curcumin on gene expression in human colon cancer cells. J Carcinog 3 (1) 8.
- 20. Holy JM (2002) Curcumin disrupts mitotic spindle structure and induces micronucleation in MCF-7 breast cancer cells. Mutation Research/Genetic Toxicology and Environmental Mutagenesis 518: 71–84.
- 21. Gupta KK, Bharne SS, Rathinasamy K, Naik NR, Panda D (2006) Dietary antioxidant curcumin inhibits microtubule assembly through tubulin binding. The FEBS journal 273: 5320–5332.
- 22. Schrevel J, Sinou V, Grellier P, Frappier F, Guenard D, et al. (1994) Interactions between docetaxel (Taxotere) and Plasmodium falciparum-infected erythrocytes. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 91: 8472–8476.
- 23. Pouvelle B, Farley PJ, Long CA, Taraschi TF (1994) Taxol arrests the development of blood-stage Plasmodium falciparum in vitro and Plasmodium chabaudi adami in malaria-infected mice. J Clin Invest 94: 413–417.
- 24. Sinden RE, Smalley ME (1979) Gametocytogenesis of Plasmodium falciparum in vitro: the cell-cycle. Parasitology 79: 277–296.
- 25. Bejon PA, Bannister LH, Fowler RE, Fookes RE, Webb SE, et al. (1997) A role for microtubules in Plasmodium falciparum merozoite invasion. Parasitology 114: 1–6.
- 26. Usanga EA, O'Brien E, Luzzato L (1986) Mitotic inhibitors arrest the growth of Plasmodium falciparum. FEBS Lett 209: 23–27.
- 27. Fennell BJ, Naughton JA, Dempsey E, Bell A (2006) Cellular and molecular actions of dinitroaniline and phosphorothioamidate herbicides on Plasmodium falciparum: tubulin as a specific antimalarial target. Mol Biochem Parasitol 145: 226–238.
- 28. Dieckmann-Schuppert A, Franklin RM (1989) Compounds binding to cytoskeletal proteins are active against Plasmodium falciparum in vitro. Cell Biol Int Rep 13: 411–418.
- 29. Bell A, Wernli B, Franklin RM (1993) Effects of microtubule inhibitors on protein synthesis in Plasmodium falciparum. Parasitol Res 79: 146–152.
- 30. Cranmer SL, Magowan C, Liang J, Coppel RL, Cooke BM (1997) An alternative to serum for cultivation of Plasmodium falciparum in vitro. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 91: 363–365.
- 31. Lambros C, Vanderberg JP (1979) Synchronization of Plasmodium falciparum erythrocytic stages in culture. The Journal of parasitology 65: 418–420.
- 32. Fivelman QL, Adagu IS, Warhurst DC (2004) Modified fixed-ratio isobologram method for studying in vitro interactions between atovaquone and proguanil or dihydroartemisinin against drug-resistant strains of Plasmodium falciparum. Antimicrob Agents Chemother 48: 4097–4102.
- 33. Aditya NP, Patankar S, Madhusudhan B, Murthy RS, Souto EB (2010) Arthemeter-loaded lipid nanoparticles produced by modified thin-film hydration: Pharmacokinetics, toxicological and in vivo anti-malarial activity. European journal of pharmaceutical sciences : official journal of the European Federation for Pharmaceutical Sciences 40: 448–455.
- 34. Tønnesen HH, Kristensen S, Grinberg LN (1994) Studies on curcumin and curcuminoids: XXV. Inhibition of primaquine-induced lysis of human red blood cells by curcumin. International Journal of Pharmaceutics 110: 161–167.
- 35. Fennell BJ, Carolan S, Pettit GR, Bell A (2003) Effects of the antimitotic natural product dolastatin 10, and related peptides, on the human malarial parasite Plasmodium falciparum. J Antimicrob Chemother 51: 833–841.
- 36. Richard D, Kats LM, Langer C, Black CG, Mitri K, et al. (2009) Identification of rhoptry trafficking determinants and evidence for a novel sorting mechanism in the malaria parasite plasmodium falciparum. PLoS Pathogens 5.
- 37. Schwede T, Kopp J, Guex N, Peitsch MC (2003) SWISS-MODEL: An automated protein homology-modeling server. Nucleic Acids Res 31: 3381–3385.
- 38. Sasin JM, Bujnicki JM (2004) COLORADO3D, a web server for the visual analysis of protein structures. Nucleic Acids Res 32: W586–589.
- 39. Macindoe G, Mavridis L, Venkatraman V, Devignes MD, Ritchie DW (2010) HexServer: an FFT-based protein docking server powered by graphics processors. Nucleic Acids Res 38: W445–449.
- 40. Payton F, Sandusky P, Alworth WL (2007) NMR study of the solution structure of curcumin. J Nat Prod 70: 143–146.
- 41. Morris GM, Huey R, Olson AJ (2008) Using AutoDock for ligand-receptor docking. Curr Protoc Bioinformatics Chapter 8: Unit 8 14.
- 42. Reddy RC, Vatsala PG, Keshamouni VG, Padmanaban G, Rangarajan PN (2005) Curcumin for malaria therapy. Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communications 326: 472–474.
- 43. Autian J (1975) Biological Model Systems for the Testing of the Toxicity of Biomaterials. 181–203.
- 44. Bell A (1998) Microtubule inhibitors as potential antimalarial agents. Parasitol Today 14: 234–240.
- 45. Dahl EL, Rosenthal PJ (2007) Multiple antibiotics exert delayed effects against the Plasmodium falciparum apicoplast. Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy 51: 3485–3490.
- 46. Dahl EL, Shock JL, Shenai BR, Gut J, DeRisi JL, et al. (2006) Tetracyclines specifically target the apicoplast of the malaria parasite Plasmodium falciparum. Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy 50: 3124–3131.
- 47. Goodman CD, Su V, McFadden GI (2007) The effects of anti-bacterials on the malaria parasite Plasmodium falciparum. Mol Biochem Parasitol 152: 181–191.
- 48. Striepen B, Crawford MJ, Shaw MK, Tilney LG, Seeber F, et al. (2000) The plastid of Toxoplasma gondii is divided by association with the centrosomes. Journal of Cell Biology 151: 1423–1434.
- 49. Rai SS, Wolff J (1996) Localization of the vinblastine-binding site on β-tubulin. Journal of Biological Chemistry 271: 14707–14711.
- 50. Uppuluri S, Knipling L, Sackett DL, Wolff J (1993) Localization of the colchicine-binding site of tubulin. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 90: 11598–11602.
- 51. Bentzen PJ, Lang E, Lang F (2007) Curcumin induced suicidal erythrocyte death. Cellular Physiology and Biochemistry 19: 153–164.
- 52. Garland DL (1978) Kinetics and mechanism of colchicine binding to Tubulin: Evidence for ligand-induced conformational change. Biochemistry 17: 4266–4272.
- 53. Dahl EL, Rosenthal PJ (2007) Multiple antibiotics exert delayed effects against the Plasmodium falciparum apicoplast. Antimicrob Agents Chemother 51: 3485–3490.
- 54. Dahl EL, Shock JL, Shenai BR, Gut J, DeRisi JL, et al. (2006) Tetracyclines specifically target the apicoplast of the malaria parasite Plasmodium falciparum. Antimicrob Agents Chemother 50: 3124–3131.
- 55. Striepen B, Crawford MJ, Shaw MK, Tilney LG, Seeber F, et al. (2000) The plastid of Toxoplasma gondii is divided by association with the centrosomes. J Cell Biol 151: 1423–1434.
- 56. Dhamodharan R, Jordan MA, Thrower D, Wilson L, Wadsworth P (1995) Vinblastine suppresses dynamics of individual microtubules in living interphase cells. Molecular Biology of the Cell 6: 1215–1229.
- 57. Jordan MA, Wilson L (1990) Kinetic analysis of tubulin exchange at microtubule ends at low vinblastine concentrations. Biochemistry® 29: 2730–2739.
- 58. Kappes B, Rohrbach P (2007) Microtubule inhibitors as a potential treatment for malaria. Future Microbiol 2: 409–423.
- 59. Sinou V, Boulard Y, Grellier P, Schrevel J (1998) Host cell and malarial targets for docetaxel (Taxotere) during the erythrocytic development of Plasmodium falciparum. J Eukaryot Microbiol 45: 171–183.
- 60. Sinou V, Grellier P, Schrevel J (1996) In vitro and in vivo inhibition of erythrocytic development of malarial parasites by docetaxel. Antimicrob Agents Chemother 40: 358–361.