Figures
Abstract
Background
Different locations and study periods were used in the assessment of the relationships between heatwaves and mortality. However, little is known about the comparability and consistency of the previous effect estimates in the literature. This study assessed the heatwave—mortality relationship using different study periods in the three largest Australian cities (Brisbane, Melbourne and Sydney).
Methods
Daily data on climatic variables and mortality for the three cities were obtained from relevant government agencies between 1988 and 2011. A consistent definition of heatwaves was used for these cities. Poisson generalised additive model was fitted to assess the impact of heatwaves on mortality.
Results
Non-accidental and circulatory mortality significantly increased during heatwaves across the three cities even with different heatwave definitions and study periods. Using the summer data resulted in the largest increase in effect estimates compared to those using the warm season or the whole year data.
Citation: Wang XY, Guo Y, FitzGerald G, Aitken P, Tippett V, Chen D, et al. (2015) The Impacts of Heatwaves on Mortality Differ with Different Study Periods: A Multi-City Time Series Investigation. PLoS ONE 10(7): e0134233. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0134233
Editor: Jeffrey Shaman, Columbia University, UNITED STATES
Received: March 23, 2015; Accepted: July 6, 2015; Published: July 28, 2015
Copyright: © 2015 Wang et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited
Data Availability: Data cannot be made publicly available due to ethical restrictions. Meteorological data were acquired from the Australian Bureau of Meteorology http://www.bom.gov.au/climate/data/. Mortality data were obtained from the Australian Bureau of Statistics http://www.abs.gov.au/.
Funding: This study was partly funded by the Australian Research Council (LP882699), Horticulture Australia Limited using the Nursery Industry Levy (Project # NY 11013) and CSIRO Climate Adaptation Flagship, the Queensland Department of Environment and Resources Management, Department of Community Safety, Queensland Health and the Environmental Protection Agency. ST was supported by a NHMRC research fellowship (#553043). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have read the journal's policy and the authors of this manuscript have the following competing interests: This study was partly funded by Horticulture Australia Limited using the Nursery Industry Levy (Project # NY 11013). There are no patents, products in development or marketed products to declare. This does not alter the authors' adherence to all the PLOS ONE policies on sharing data and materials.
Introduction
Heatwaves can cause a remarkable increase in mortality and morbidity, which is observed by a number of studies in different countries of the world [1–9]. It is projected that the frequency, intensity, duration and geographic extent of heatwaves will increase as climate change proceeds [10]. Thus, it is imperative to quantify the health impact of heatwaves and assess the disease burden attributable to climate change.
A heatwave is usually defined as two or more consecutive days with temperature above a certain temperature cut-off (e.g., 95th centile) for a specific study period [2–5,11]. In previous studies, different study periods were used in the assessment of the relationship between heatwaves and mortality [3,4,12–16]. For example, some studies chose five months (i.e., May—September) to represent the warm season in Northern Hemisphere as the study period [3,4], while others used three months (June—August) [12,13]. Other different periods (e.g., 6 months and/or a whole year) were also used [14–16]. However, little is known about the comparability of the previous effect estimates identified in the literature.
This study compared the heatwave—mortality relationship using different study periods, and explored the similarities and differences in the assessment of the health impacts of heatwaves by using summer, warm season and the whole year data across different cities in Australia.
Materials and Methods
This study included the three largest metropolitan cities in Australia—Brisbane, Melbourne and Sydney, which are the capital cities of Queensland, Victoria and New South Wales, respectively. Approximately half Australian population live in these cities [17]. In this study, we focused on three different study periods of data: summer (Dec–Feb), warm season (Nov–Mar) and the whole year during 1988–2011.
Data collection
Daily climatic data on maximum temperature (MaxT) (°C) and minimum temperature (MinT) (°C) for these three cities during the period 1988–2011, relative humidity (%) for Brisbane (1988–2011), Melbourne and Sydney (Jan. 1988 to May 2009) were acquired from the Australian Bureau of Meteorology. We selected all available meteorological stations located within ≤30 km of each city’s Central Business District (CBD) (7 stations in Brisbane, 7 stations in Melbourne and 11 stations in Sydney) and the same sets of meteorological data were used in our previous study [11].
Daily data on non-accidental and circulatory mortality in these cities for the same period were obtained from the Australian Bureau of Statistics. These data were aggregated and no individual information was provided due to the reasons of privacy protection.
Data analysis
Daily mean temperatures (MeanT) (°C) which averaged the values of daily maximum and minimum temperatures were used to investigate the effect of heatwaves on mortality in these cities, because our previous research shows that mean temperature was a slightly better predictor of mortality than other temperature indices [11,18]. A heatwave was defined as the mean temperature above a certain percentile (e.g., 90th, 95th, 98th and 99th centiles of mean temperature) for two or more consecutive days in the summer, the warm season and the whole year according to each city climatic conditions during 1988–2011. The heatwaves were coded as a binary variable of 1 or 0 on each day (i.e., 1 for the heatwave days while 0 for non-heatwave days). Poisson generalised additive model (GAM) was used to examine the heatwave effects on mortality for each city. Cumulative lagged effects of 0–3 days were assessed, as our previous work showed that the effects of heatwaves were acute and were unlikely to last for over 3 days [11]. We adjusted for an array of confounders in the model, including humidity, population size, day of week, trend and seasonality. We used natural cubic spline for humidity (df = 3) and day of the year or seasons (df = 4). Relative risks (RRs) and 95% confidence intervals (CIs) were calculated using the GAM model. For fitting the time series GAM, we used the ‘mgcv’ package in R software (V.2.14.1).
Results
Table 1 shows the summary statistics on the climatic variables for the three cities. The highest and lowest temperatures (MaxT and MinT) were all observed in Melbourne for three study periods. However, the means of these temperature measures were the highest in Brisbane and the lowest in Melbourne. The means of humidity in Brisbane and Sydney were slightly higher in summer than other two periods while Melbourne was opposite.
Table 2 indicates the number of heatwave days for each city. A consistent definition of heatwaves was used in this study (i.e., two or more consecutive days with mean temperature above 90th, 95th, 98th and 99th centile). Brisbane had more heatwave days than Melbourne and Sydney across all heatwave definitions during three study periods.
Table 3 shows the daily number of non-accidental and circulatory deaths in the three cities during the different study periods. Overall, the daily maximum number of deaths (including both non-accidental and circulatory diseases) was all recorded in the summer across these three cities. About half non-accidental deaths were caused by circulatory diseases. The elderly (aged 75 and over) deaths accounted for about 60%–63% and 67%–74% of all non-accidental and circulatory deaths, respectively, for the three cities. The ratio of male to female deaths was the same (i.e., 1:1) across these cities.
Table 4 depicts the relative risk (RR) of the non-accidental mortality in the three cities after adjustment for confounding factors in the model. Regardless of which heatwave definition was used, there was a statistically significant increase in mortality for almost all subgroups across three cities during heatwaves, particularly when the summer was used as the study period. In general, women were affected more by heat effects than men while the elderly (i.e., 75 years old or over) seemed more vulnerable to heatwaves than others, although not all RRs were statistically significant. Generally, the more intense the heatwave, the higher the RRs for non-accidental deaths.
The RRs for daily circulatory mortality during heatwaves using the different heatwave definitions and different study periods in the three cities before and after adjusting for confounders were shown in S1 Table. In general, heatwaves appeared to have greater impacts on circulatory mortality than non-accidental mortality in these cities (Table 4 and S1 Table). The patterns of susceptibility is similar to that observed in non-accidental deaths–viz., in most cases, females and the elderly aged 75 years or over appeared to be more vulnerable to heatwaves than males and the non-elderly, regardless of which definition was used.
Table 5 shows the relative risk of mortality in single lag (lag 1 to lag 3) and cumulative lag (Cum lag 0–3) effects during heatwaves defined as two or more consecutive days above a certain percentile of daily mean temperature using either the summer or whole year data. There was a consistent, immediate increase in mortality during heatwaves for almost all heatwave definitions across the three cities.
Discussion
In this study, we analysed the associations between heatwaves and mortality using the data for different study periods in the three largest Australian cities (Brisbane, Melbourne and Sydney). The results show that, regardless of which heatwave definition was used, there were consistent, statistically significant, increased risks of mortality during heatwaves even using different study periods. It is more sensitive to use the summer data than the warm season or the whole year data in assessing heatwaves-related health risks but the magnitude of risks varied with city. Finally, we found a stronger effect of heatwaves on circulatory mortality than overall non-accidental mortality across all three cities.
Several multi-city studies have reported the mortality impacts of heatwaves [3–5,16,19]. However, in previous studies different study periods were used to assess the heatwave-mortality relationship. The findings of this study show that the effect estimates using the summer data were greater than those estimated by using either the warm season or the whole year data. It is due largely to the different intensity of heat categorized by different study periods even though the same percentiles of temperature were applied in the definition of a heatwave.
There were different climatic patterns across Brisbane, Melbourne and Sydney. Brisbane is close to the northern east coast and has a humid subtropical climate with warm to hot and humid summers, and dry and moderately warm winters [20]. Melbourne has a moderate oceanic climate and changeable weather conditions [21,22]. Sydney’s weather is between Brisbane and Melbourne which has a temperate climate with warm summers and mild winters, with rainfall spread throughout the year [23]. Even though these cities have different climatic conditions, consistent, statistically significant, increased risks of mortality were observed during heatwaves across all these cities. It suggests that residents living in different climates were all susceptible to extreme heat effects and up to now, the role of adaptation was limited when a heatwave occurred.
Clearly, most heatwave events occurred in summer. For example, when two or more consecutive days above the 95th percentile of mean temperature were used to define a heatwave using the whole year data, there were 358 heatwave days in total and 330 (92%) days occurred in summer in Brisbane; similarly 81% and 86% heatwave days occurred in summer in Melbourne and Sydney, respectively. When the summer data were used, heatwaves appeared to have a greater impact on non-accidental mortality, elderly aged 75 years or over and females (Table 4 and S1 Table), which is consistent with previous studies [4,9,13,24,25]. Similar but less significant results were observed when the warm season and the whole year data were used.
We also investigated the lag effects of heatwaves in the summer and whole year, and found that the higher risk estimates for mortality were on the current day (lag 0) and lag of 1 day. Our results support the findings that the impact of heatwaves on mortality is usually acute and does not last long [15].
This study has three key strengths. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study to compare the effect estimates using different study periods in examining the health impacts of heatwaves across different cities. Comprehensive datasets (e.g., 24 years) on population, meteorological conditions and mortality for these cities were used, and key confounding factors were adjusted for in the model. Finally, a consistent definition was applied to define a heatwave based on local climatic conditions with different study periods.
This study also has some limitations. The aggregated data on non-accidental and circulatory deaths were used while individual information on exposure, outcomes and confounders was unavailable. Different cutoffs (i.e., 90th, 95th 98th and 99th percentile) of mean temperature were used to define a heatwave, and multiple significant tests were conducted. Potential confounding effects of air pollution (e.g., ozone) were not controlled for, as these data were not complete for the whole study period in all three cities. However, there is evidence that the association between heat and mortality is likely to be independent of air pollution [15]. It is also debated whether air pollution should be adjusted for in the studies of temperature effects [26].
Conclusions
It appears to be more sensitive to use the summer data rather than the warm season or the whole year data in assessing the heatwaves-mortality relationship. Regardless of which study period was used, a consistent and significant increase in mortality was observed during heatwaves across the three major Australian cities. The findings may have significant implications for developing standard approaches to evaluating the heatwave-mortality relationship and advancing heat health warning systems. It also provides an impetus to methodological advancement for assessing climate change-related health consequences.
Supporting Information
S1 Table. Relative risk (RR) of circulatory mortality during heatwaves in the three Australian cities (1988–2011).
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0134233.s001
(DOCX)
Acknowledgments
The authors thank the Queensland Health, Australian Bureau of Statistics and Australia Bureau of Meteorology for providing the relevant data.
Author Contributions
Conceived and designed the experiments: ST XYW. Performed the experiments: XYW YG. Analyzed the data: XYW YG. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: XYW YG. Wrote the paper: ST XYW. Contributed to the manuscript revision: YG GF PA VT DC XW.
References
- 1. Hajat S, Kosatky T (2010) Heat-related mortality: a review and exploration of heterogeneity. J Epidemiol Community Health 64: 753–760. pmid:19692725
- 2. Tong S, Ren C, Becker N (2010) Excess deaths during the 2004 heatwave in Brisbane, Australia. Int J Biometeorol 54: 393–400. pmid:20049484
- 3. Anderson GB, Bell ML (2011) Heat Waves in the United States: Mortality Risk during Heat Waves and Effect Modification by Heat Wave Characteristics in 43 U.S. Communities. Environ Health Perspect 119: 210–218. pmid:21084239
- 4. Son JY, Lee JT, Anderson GB, Bell ML (2012) The impact of heat waves on mortality in seven major cities in Korea. Environmental Health Perspectives 120: 566–571. pmid:22266672
- 5. Baccini M, Kosatsky T, Analitis A, Anderson HR, D'Ovidio M, Menne B, et al. (2011) Impact of heat on mortality in 15 European cities: attributable deaths under different weather scenarios. J Epidemiol Community Health 65: 64–70. pmid:19858539
- 6. Metzger KB, Ito K, Matte TD (2010) Summer heat and mortality in New York City: how hot is too hot? Environ Health Perspect 118: 80–86. pmid:20056571
- 7. Basu R, Ostro BD (2008) A multicounty analysis identifying the populations vulnerable to mortality associated with high ambient temperature in California. Am J Epidemiol 168: 632–637. pmid:18663214
- 8. O'Neill MS, Zanobetti A, Schwartz J (2003) Modifiers of the temperature and mortality association in seven US cities. Am J Epidemiol 157: 1074–1082. pmid:12796043
- 9. Yu W, Guo Y, Ye X, Wang X, Huang C, Pan X, et al. (2011) The effect of various temperature indicators on different mortality categories in a subtropical city of Brisbane, Australia. Science of the Total Environment 409: 3431–3437. pmid:21665244
- 10.
IPCC Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Climate Change 2013: The Physical Science Basis.
- 11. Tong S, Wang XY, Yu W, Chen D, Wang X (2014b) The impact of heatwaves on mortality in Australia: a multicity study. BMJ Open. 2014/02/20 ed. pp. e003579. pmid:24549159
- 12. Pascal M, Wagner V, Le Tertre A, Laaidi K, Honore C, Benichou F, et al. (2013) Definition of temperature thresholds: the example of the French heat wave warning system. International Journal of Biometeorology 57: 21–29. pmid:22361805
- 13. D'Ippoliti D, Michelozzi P, Marino C, de'Donato F, Menne B, Katsouyanni K, et al. (2010) The impact of heat waves on mortality in 9 European cities: results from the EuroHEAT project. Environ Health. 2010/07/20 ed. pp. 37. pmid:20637065
- 14. Peng RD, Bobb JF, Tebaldi C, McDaniel L, Bell ML, Dominici F (2011) Toward a quantitative estimate of future heat wave mortality under global climate change. Environ Health Perspect 119: 701–706. pmid:21193384
- 15. Anderson BG, Bell ML (2009) Weather-related mortality: how heat, cold, and heat waves affect mortality in the United States. Epidemiology 20: 205–213. pmid:19194300
- 16. Barnett AG, Hajat S, Gasparrini A, Rocklov J (2012) Cold and heat waves in the United States. Environmental Research 112: 218–224. pmid:22226140
- 17.
ABS (2012) (Australian Burean of Statistics). 2012. Australian Burean of Statistics: Regional Population Growth, Australia.
- 18. Vaneckova P, Neville G, Tippett V, Aitken P, FitzGerald G, Tong S (2011) Do Biometeorological Indices Improve Modeling Outcomes of Heat-Related Mortality? Journal of Applied Meteorology and Climatology 50: 1165–1176.
- 19. Stafoggia M, Forastiere F, Agostini D, Biggeri A, Bisanti L, Cadum E, et al. (2006) Vulnerability to Heat-Related Mortality: A Multicity, Population-Based, Case-Crossover Analysis. Epidemiology 17: 315–323 pmid:16570026
- 20.
Sturman AP, Tapper NJ (2006) The weather and climate of Australia and New Zealand (Second ed.): Melbourne, Australia: Oxford University Press.
- 21.
AGBM Climate statistics for Australian locations. MELBOURNE REGIONAL OFFICE: Bureau of Meteorology.
- 22.
Linacre E, Geerts B (1997) Climates and Weather Explained.: London: Routledge.
- 23.
ABS (2007) CLIMATE AND THE SYDNEY 2000 OLYMPIC GAMES. Australian Bureau of Statistics.
- 24. Fouillet A, Rey G, Wagner V, Laaidi K, Empereur-Bissonnet P, Le Tertre A, et al. (2008) Has the impact of heat waves on mortality changed in France since the European heat wave of summer 2003? A study of the 2006 heat wave. Int J Epidemiol 37: 309–317. pmid:18194962
- 25. Schifano P, Cappai G, De Sario M, Michelozzi P, Marino C, Bargagli A, et al. (2009) Susceptibility to heat wave-related mortality: a follow-up study of a cohort of elderly in Rome. Environmental Health. pp. 50. pmid:19909505
- 26. Buckley JP, Samet JM, Richardson DB (2014) Does air pollution confound studies of temperature? Epidemiology 25: 242–245. pmid:24487206