A high resolution genetic mapping population

We generated an F₁ mapping population by crossing the C. deneoformans strains XL280a and XL280αSS [92, 137] with the environmental isolate, 431α [92, 139, 140] in α–α unisexual and a–α bisexual matings [92]. The haploid genomes of the parental strains and 101 segregants were sequenced at approximately 64× coverage. Following filtering, 92,103 sites were identified that differ between the parental strains, and genotypes at each of these variable sites were called for each segregant based on mapping to the XL280α reference genome [137]. Variable sites were collapsed into unique haploblocks based on genetic exchange events, resulting in 3,108 unique haploblocks. The average size of the haploblocks was 5.4 kb (approximately 1 cM; [141]) with a maximum and minimum size of 6.3 and 4.4 kb, respectively (S1 Fig). This set of 101 segregants, parental strains, and their genotypic states at each of the 3,108 haploblocks served as the mapping population for subsequent QTL analyses.

QTL for melanization

Melanization is an important phenotype related to virulence, and a previous study that utilized the same set of progeny used here observed significant variation in melanin production [92]. Melanization was quantified from scanned images of colonies grown on L-DOPA plates by calculating the mean grayscale intensity (the amount of light reflected off of a colony) of each segregant. The parental strains differ in their production of melanin—the XL280a parental strain has an opaque, beige appearance and the 431α parental strain grew as a dark brown colony (Fig 1A). There is significant variation in the production of melanin among the segregants, with most progeny exhibiting melanization intermediate between the two parental phenotypes (Fig 1A). Less than 8% of progeny exhibited transgressive melanin phenotypes that were more pigmented than the 431α parental strain or lighter than the XL280a parental strain. QTL mapping of the melanin phenotype identified a single large peak on chromosome 14 (Fig 1B). Segregants with the XL280a genotype at this locus had lighter colonies (higher mean intensity), while segregants with the 431α allele produced darker colonies (lower mean intensity, Fig 1C and 1D). Based on the regression model used for mapping, this QTL explains 39% of the variation in melanization in this cross.

Download:

• PPT
  PowerPoint slide
• PNG
  larger image
• TIFF
  original image

Fig 1. QTL analysis of variation in melanin production.

A) Melanization phenotypes of parental strains—XL280a and 431α– and examplar phenotypes of their segregants. B) Manhattan plot of the association between genotype and melanin production. The x-axis represents chromosomal locations of haploblocks and the y-axis represents the strength of association between genotype and variation in melanization. The significance threshold (dashed horizontal line) was determined via permutation. C) Mean grayscale intensity (y-axis; arbitrary units) of segregants (gray dots) grown on L-DOPA plates as a function of genotype (x-axis) at the QTL peak on chromosome 14. Blue and orange triangles mark the parental phenotypes while black horizontal lines denote the phenotypic means by allele. The red line represents a regression model relating phenotype to genotype; this regression model explains 39% of the variation in melanin production. D) QTL allele, mean intensity, and melanin production of example F₁ strains.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1009313.g001

QTL for variation in capsule diameter

The production of a polysaccharide capsule is another well-studied virulence trait in Cryptococcus. India ink stained cells from each segregant were imaged using brightfield microscopy, and cell body and capsule diameter were measured. There was a strong allometric relationship between capsule diameter and cell size (Fig 2A). To account for this “size effect” we regressed capsule diameter on the combined cell and capsule diameter, and used the residuals from this relationship as a measure of size-standardized capsule size (Fig 2B). A similar model, comparing cell diameter to the cell and capsule diameter was also calculated (S2 Fig).

Download:

• PPT
  PowerPoint slide
• PNG
  larger image
• TIFF
  original image

Fig 2. QTL analysis of variation in capsule diameter residuals.

A) Measurements of the average cell and capsule diameters (x-axis) and the calculated capsule diameter (y-axis) per segregant colored by the chromosome 14 QTL allele in C. B) Histogram of capsule diameter residuals calculated from the linear regression model in A, separated by chromosome 14 QTL allele. C) Manhattan plot of the association between genotype and capsule diameter residuals. The x-axis represents chromosomal locations of haploblocks and the y-axis represents the strength of association between genotype and variation in capsule diameter residuals.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1009313.g002

QTL mapping of the standardized capsule size identified a single significant peak on chromosome 14 (Fig 2C). Heritablity at this locus was estimated to be 17%. At the peak of this QTL, segregants with the XL280a genotype had larger (positive) capsule diameter residuals compared to sibling strains with the 431α allele (Fig 2B).

Negative transgressive segregation in temperature and amphotericin B tolerance

Microbial stress responses are dependent on both the intensity of exposure and time since exposure. In order to capture both aspects of such responses to thermal stress and antifungal drugs we employed an automated phenotyping framework to measure microbial growth over time across multiple environmental conditions. For each of the segregants and parental strains, growth in liquid media was measured on an absorbance microplate reader for a total of eleven experimental conditions consisting of combinations of temperature (30, 37, and 39°C) and amphotericin B (concentrations of 0, 0.075, 0.125, and 0.175 μg/ml). These conditions were chosen to maximize the phenotypic variation within the mapping population. In each experimental condition, the optical density (OD_595nm) was measured at 15-minute intervals for 72 hours. Each set of time series measurements was treated as a growth curve and four replicate growth curves were measured per segregant. After normalization and base-lining, total growth was estimated as the area under each growth curve. Fig 3 represents the median growth curve across replicates for each segregant at each combination of temperature and amphotericin B concentration.

Download:

• PPT
  PowerPoint slide
• PNG
  larger image
• TIFF
  original image

Fig 3. C. deneoformans growth curves.

Parental strains and progeny were assayed for growth across combinations of temperatures (rows) 30°, 37°, 39°C and concentrations of amphotericin B (columns) at 0.0, 0.075, 0.125, and 0.175 μg/ml. Optical density (OD_595nm, y-axis) was measured every 15 minutes for 72 hours (x-axis). The median optical density across replicates is shown for the parental strains, XL280a (blue curve) and 431α (orange curve), and the F₁ segregants (grey curves).

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1009313.g003

There was significant variation in the growth trajectories across the eleven temperature by amphotericin B conditions. At the permissive conditions of 30°C and no amphotericin B, most of the segregants growth curves fell near or between the parental growth curves. Conversely, at 37°C without amphotericin B, the parental strain 431α outgrew the other parental strain, XL280a, as well as all of the segregants. In this high temperature condition 35% of segregants outgrew the XL280a parental strain. In most other combinations of temperature and amphotericin B stress, F₁ progeny displayed negative transgressive segregation, with less total growth compared to the parental strains.

At 30°C, across amphotericin B concentrations of 0.075, 0.125 and 0.175 μg/ml, the 431α progenitor strain grew poorly and across these experimental conditions only 33, 24, and 19% of segregants (respectively) outgrew the XL280a parental strain. Surprisingly, 431α, when exposed to a combination of modest thermal stress (37°C) and moderate amphotericin B concentrations (0.075 and 0.125 μg/ml), grows better than when exposed to drug stress alone. At 37°C in conditions of 0.075, 0.125 and 0.175 μg/ml of amphotericin B, 44, 24, and 18% of segregants outgrow the XL280a progenitor strain, respectively. At 39°C the parental strains had similar total growth with the 431α displaying a greater final OD. Across amphotericin B conditions at 39°C, the XL280a parent outgrew the 431α strain, and only a modest number of offspring (∼7%) outgrew either parental strain. Taken as a whole, these data revealed a temporally dynamic and varying response to temperature and antifungal stress.

Dynamic QTL underlying temperature stress and resistance to amphotericin B

A common approach to identify QTL associated with variation in microbial growth is to map the maximum growth rate or the population density at a specific time point and regress this value across variable genetic loci. This approach however fails to capture genotype-phenotype associations that change across time. Time varying traits are often referred to as function-valued [120]. Here, a function-valued, marker-regression approach was employed to quantify the relationship between genotype and growth phenotypes at each variable haploblock across the 72-hour time courses of each temperature and amphotericin B combination.

Temporally dependent QTL underlying variation across each of the eleven experimental combinations of temperature and concentrations of amphotericin B were identified with a temporal regression model. Following model fitting, the −log₁₀ p-values (effect of a potential QTL) were calculated across time points (S3 Fig), and significance thresholds were estimated by permutation tests [142]. For nine of the eleven conditions, between one and three QTL (on different chromosomes) were identified across the time course (S4 Fig). Across the combinations of temperature and amphotericin B stress, taking the maximum association at each variable site across the 72-hour time course (Fig 4), a total of thirteen QTL above the thresholds of significance were identified across the eleven temperature and amphotericin B conditions (S5 Fig). Nearly all of the QTL identified showed temporally dependent behavior, with early time-series associations for some QTL and later associations for others (Fig 5A). Taking the maximum association across combinations of temperature and amphotericin B stress, and across time, four unique QTL on chromosomes 2, 11, 12, and 14 were identified (Fig 5B). Two of these QTL, on chromosomes 11 and 12 would not have been detected using the traditional marker-regression framework based on final growth (S6 Fig).

Download:

• PPT
  PowerPoint slide
• PNG
  larger image
• TIFF
  original image

Fig 4. Schematic of temporal QTL mapping.

Across experimental conditions, OD was sampled every 15 minutes for 72 hours. Across the 72-hour time course, the median (across replicates) area under the curve (AUC) is calculated per segregant and utilized for QTL mapping, regressing AUC across the 14 chromosomes represented by 3,108 haploblocks. This process is conducted per time point and examples of this analysis at 70, 48, and 28 hours from growth data collected at 37°C with 0.125 μg/ml of amphotericin B are depicted. The temporal trends in QTL may then be summarized by taking the maximum per haploblock across time.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1009313.g004

Download:

• PPT
  PowerPoint slide
• PNG
  larger image
• TIFF
  original image

Fig 5. Associations between genotype and phenotype.

Across the experimental combinations of temperature and amphotericin B concentrations in Fig 3, median growth AUCs were regressed onto haplotypes for each sample time point in 72-hour time courses. A) Temporal analysis of association between genotype and phenotype, collapsed across conditions. Across the experimental conditions, the maximum association across time (y-axis) per chromosome (x-axis) is shown. B) QTL collapsed across conditions and time. The x-axis represents chromosomal positions of haploblocks; the y-axis represents the maximum −log₁₀(p-value) for each haploblock across both time and conditions. The maximum significance thresholds (dotted and dashed horizontal lines) were determined via permutation. C) Normalized (max-min normalization) AUC of growth (y-axis) by parental allele (x-axis) at the QTL on chromosomes 2, 11, 12, and 14 (left to right, respectively). Blue and orange triangles represent the AUC values for parental strains, black horizontal lines denote phenotypic means by allele, and red lines indicate the best fit line from the regression used to detect QTL. The heritability of each QTL (annotated in black) is estimated by the coefficient of determination from the regression.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1009313.g005

Identifying candidate genes and nucleotide variants

For the four QTL detected in temperature and amphotericin B experiments, the regions containing candidate genes were determined by taking the maximum association for each haploblock across time, temperature, and amphotericin B concentration and calculating the left and right boundaries of haploblocks above the maximum significance threshold (across conditions). The open reading frames of genes within these regions were determined by realigning gene sequences from the JEC21α reference annotation to the XL280α reference. For all genes within the four candidate regions, we predicted potential changes in protein sequence due to the genetic variants between the XL280a and 431α parental strain (S9 Fig) and identified those with non-synonymous changes (S3 Table). Orthologous genes in the C. neoformans background were identified for genes with non-synonymous changes between the parental strains. Where available, gene deletion strains [21] were used in follow up temperature and amphotericin B growth assays (S10–S13 Figs). Candidate genes and causal genetic variants were further narrowed down by consulting the previous literature, considering the severity of the non-synonymous genetic changes on protein length and function, and comparing the growth curve profiles from temperature and amphotericin B experiments on C. neoformans deletion strains. Using this approach, we identified candidate quantitative trait genes (QTGs) and their associate quantitative trait nucleotides (QTNs) for three of the four QTL identified above (discussed below). For the chromosome 11 QTL we were unable to predict a candidate QTG as several significant non-synonmous changes are observed in genes with unknown function and none of the phenotypes of C. neoformans deletion mutants for this region were consistent with our QTL mapping results. Although our analyses focused on coding variants within each QTL region, a summary of non-coding and synonymous variants is included in S3 Table.

RIC8 is a candidate QTG for the pleiotropic QTL on chromosome 14.

The pleiotropic chromosome 14 QTL contributing to variation in melanization, capsule diameter, and high temperature growth spanned approximately 69 kb and was located between the coordinates 354,000 to 423,000 bp. There are 29 genes within this QTL region, 17 of which are estimated to have genetic variants that lead to non-synonymous changes between the parental backgrounds (S3 Table). A single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) identified in the second to last exon of the gene RIC8 (CNN01270) is predicted to cause a premature stop-gain in the XL280a background when compared to the JEC21α reference strain (Fig 6). Additional non-synonymous changes in the RIC8 gene were identified in the 431α strain compared to both the XL280a parental strain and the JEC21α reference strain and include an in-frame codon deletion and a predicted shift in the stop codon (S14 Fig).

Download:

• PPT
  PowerPoint slide
• PNG
  larger image
• TIFF
  original image

Fig 6. SSK1, SSK2, and RIC8 gene models.

Exons are shown as large grey rectangles, while the introns, 5’ UTR, and 3’ UTR are shown as grey, horizontal lines. The positions of the predicted start and stop codons are annotated along the bottom of the gene bodies and the positions of genetic differences between 431α and XL280a are marked by black, vertical lines. Within the second exon of SSK1, an insertion of a single nucleotide, present in the 431α parental strain is predicted to cause a frame shift that leads to a downstream early stop-gain. Within the second and third exons of SSK2, two SNPs are annotated that lead to non-synonymous changes previously identified by Bahn et al. [143]. Within the second-to-last exon of RIC8, a SNP is present in the XL280a parental strain that is predicted to cause a premature stop. The local, predicted translations of the regions near these non-synonymous, genetic variants and associated amino acids are annotated in colored rectangles.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1009313.g006

Ric8 is a guanine nucleotide exchange factor for Gpa1, the G_α activator of the cAMP-PKA pathway in Cryptococcus [144]. In C. neoformans, ric8Δ strains have been previously demonstrated to exhibit melanization and capsule defects [144]. We confirmed the melanization defect using a ric8Δ strain from the C. neoformans deletion collection (Fig 7A and S15 Fig). To test the effect of ric8 mutations on thermal tolerance, growth of the ric8Δ strain was profiled at 37° and 39°C. At these elevated temperatures, the ric8Δ strain exhibited a slower initial growth rate than the wild-type control strain, but then reached a higher maximum density, with the result being higher total growth (Fig 7B and S15 Fig).

Download:

• PPT
  PowerPoint slide
• PNG
  larger image
• TIFF
  original image

Fig 7. Melanin and high-temperature phenotypes of RIC8.

A) The C. neoformans strain, KN99α, the ric8Δ deletion strain, and C. deneoformans parental strains, 431α and XL280a were grown on plates with L-DOPA and L-DOPA + cAMP. Both the ric8Δ strain and XL280a demonstrated large increases in the production of melanin when grown in the presence of exogenous cAMP. B) Growth in liquid culture (OD₅₉₅, y-axis) of KN99α (black) and the corresponding ric8Δ strain (red) under conditions of heat stress (37°C and 39°C) across 72 hours (x-axis).

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1009313.g007

Ric8 loss-of-function mutants are predicted to have lower levels of cAMP signaling [144]. Consistent with the finding of Gong et al. [144], the addition of exogenous cAMP to L-DOPA plates restored melanization in the C. neoformans ric8Δ strain. The parental strain XL280a, bearing the predicted ric8 loss-of-function allele, also exhibited increased melanization when grown on plates with L-DOPA + cAMP (Fig 7A). The 431α parent exhibited only modest changes in melanization in the presence of cAMP, suggesting that cAMP-PKA signaling is already active in this background. Because the melanization and thermal tolerance phenotypes of the ric8Δ strain were consistent with the effects predicted from the QTL mapping, as were the predicted effects of chemical manipulation of the XL280a background, the RIC8 allele identified in the XL280a background (RIC8^XL280a) was labeled as a likely QTN for melanization, high temperature growth, and capsule size.

QTL mapping of HOG-related phenotypes

Our initial studies of amphotericin B susceptibility implicated two key genes—SSK1 and SSK2—in the HOG pathway, a signaling network that plays a central role in the regulation of cellular responses to osmostress in fungi. Consequently, we predicted that segregants in this study might show variation for additional HOG pathway related phenotypes attributable to one or both of these loci. Thus, we undertook additional analyses of HOG-related phenotypes including resistance to salt stress, resistance to the antifungal drug fludioxonil, and oxidative stress tolerance.

Fludioxonil resistance is governed by an epistatic interaction between SSK1 and SSK2.

Fludioxonil is an agricultural antifungal drug whose mode of action is thought to be hyperactivation of the HOG pathway, leading to physiological effects such as glycerol accumulation and increased turgor pressure [145]. Resistance to fludioxonil has been shown to occur primarily through mutations that ameliorate or decrease HOG signaling. While resistance to fludioxonil is rare in most fungal species due to the negative pleiotropic consequences of HOG pathway loss-of-function mutations [145], Cryptococcus is unusual in that many strains of both C. deneoformans and C. neoformans exhibit resistance to this drug. Bahn et al. [143] demonstrated that variation in sensitivity to fludioxonil among Cryptococcus lineages correlates with Hog1 phosphorylation levels which are in turn correlated with two different allelic states observed at SSK2. The allelic states identified by Bahn et al. are the same SSK2 alleles identified as segregating in the cross considered here, with the SSK2^XL280a allele predicted to correlate with resistance to fludioxonil and the SSK2^431α variant predicted to be sensitive.

Surprisingly, when exposed to fludioxonil (100 μg/ml) the two parental strains both exhibited resistance. We reasoned that the resistance seen in the 431α parental strain was due to an epistatic interaction involving the SSK1 loss-of-function allele identified in this background. Following this logic, we predicted that recombinant segregants with the SSK1^XL280a SSK2^431α genotype would exhibit sensitivity to fludioxonil. Consistent with this prediction, 14 of the 20 segregants with the SSK1^XL280a SSK2^431α genotype were fludioxonil sensitive. Segregants with any of the other of three possible allele combinations at these two loci were fludioxonil resistant (Fig 8).

Download:

• PPT
  PowerPoint slide
• PNG
  larger image
• TIFF
  original image

Fig 8. SSK1 and SSK2 govern fludioxonil sensitivity.

The relationship between SSK1 and SSK2 genotypes and fludioxonil sensitivity. Only progeny with the SSK1^XL280a SSK2^431α genotype are sensitive to fludioxonil. Resistant SSK1^XL280a SSK2^431α segregants suggest additional higher-order epistatic interaction involving SSK1 and SSK2.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1009313.g008

To provide further evidence for an epistatic interaction between SSK1 and SSK2 we assayed the additional set of fine-mapped offspring from a–α bisexual crosses between the XL280a strain and the three 431α strains (S1 Table) for fludioxonil resistance. In this larger set of progeny, only those segregants that were the genetic mosaics of the XL280a and 431α strains, possessing the SSK1^XL280a SSK2^431α genotype, displayed sensitivity to fludioxonil (S19 Fig). These data supported our hypothesis that the SSK1^431α allele observed in the 431α parental strain is indeed a naturally occurring loss-of-function mutation and in this isolate the SSK1^431α has an epistatic effect with SSK2^431α, rescuing an otherwise fludioxonil-sensitive SSK2 phenotype. Our findings also point to even higher order genetic interactions—a small number of segregants among those with the mosaic SSK1^XL280a SSK2^431α genotype were resistant, indicating the presence of additional loci that interact epistatically with SSK1 and SSK2 to mediate fludioxonil resistance.

Of the multiple traits examined in this study, fludioxonil sensitivity was the only phenotype to exhibit distinct distributions between segregants derived from α–α unisexual versus a–α bisexual matings. In the primary mapping population, the majority of fludioxonil sensitive progeny were derived from the unisexual cross. This is due to an allelic bias at the SSK2 locus, wherein bisexually derived segregants preferentially inherit the SSK2^XL280a allele. However, in the fine-mapped offspring, all of which are derived from a–α bisexual matings, there is a bias in favor of the SSK2^431α allele. Despite these opposing allelic biases, for both unisexually and bisexually derived offspring, the only segregants exhibiting fludioxonil sensitivity are those with the allelic combination SSK1^XL280a SSK2^431α.

SSK2 and RIC8 are QTGs underlying oxidative stress tolerance.

Resistance to oxidative stress is another virulence related trait in Cryptococcus, that is associated with HOG signaling [143]. Segregants were grown on media containing 5 mM of H₂O₂, and colony growth was quantified from high-resolution images by two independent observers using ordinal scoring (Fig 9A). There was significant variation in response to H₂O₂ across the segregants. The XL280a parental strain displayed higher tolerance of H₂O₂ (on average) than the 431α parental strain, and a portion of the progeny (less than 25%) displayed no growth and complete sensitivity to H₂O₂ (Fig 9B).

Download:

• PPT
  PowerPoint slide
• PNG
  larger image
• TIFF
  original image

Fig 9. Variation in hydrogen peroxide sensitivity.

QTL analysis of variation in response to hydrogen peroxide. A) Example growth phenotypes and scores of C. deneoformans segregants grown on media with hydrogen peroxide. B) Histogram of hydrogen peroxide growth scores. Growth scores of parental strains are marked by vertical lines. C) Manhattan plot of the association between genotype and growth in response to hydrogen peroxide. The x-axis represents chromosomal locations of haploblocks and the y-axis represents the strength in association between genotype and variation in growth score. D) Hydrogen peroxide growth scores (y-axis) as a function of allele at the peak of chromosome 12 (left) and chromosome 14 (right) QTL. Blue and orange triangles mark the parental phenotypes, black horizontal lines denote the average phenotypes of segregants by allele, and red lines are regression models relating the genotype to phenotype. The heritablity at each locus is estimated from these models and annotated in black.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1009313.g009

Two QTL associated with hydrogen peroxide growth were detected (Fig 9C), on chromosomes 12 and chromosome 14, each with modest heritablity (∼16% at each QTL); (Fig 9D). These two QTL overlapped with the previously identified QTL governing amphotericin B sensitivity on chromosome 12 and the pleiotropic QTL underlying variation in melanization, capsule size, and thermal tolerance on chromosome 14. Joint analysis of the H₂O₂ growth scores and growth at 37°C with 0.125 μg/ml of amphotericin B revealed a strong correlation between these phenotypes (Spearman ρ = 0.5, p-value < 7^-8). Segregants with the 431α allele at the chromosome 12 QTL peak display greater tolerance to H₂O₂ and resistance to amphotericin B (S20 Fig). Similarly, for the virulence-related phenotypes associated with the chromosome 14 QTL, the H₂O₂ phenotype was strongly correlated with thermal tolerance at 39°C (Spearman ρ = 0.53, p-value < 9^-9) and negatively correlated with melanization (Spearman ρ = -0.59, p-value < 5^-11). There was no significant correlation between H₂O₂ growth and the capsule phenotype (Spearman ρ = 0.15, p-value = 0.13). Given the location of H₂O₂ QTLs, and the general trends of phenotypic correlations observed, we predict that SSK2 (chromosome 12) and RIC8 (chromosome 14) are the underlying QTGs for this trait.

At the predicted QTN for SSK2 and RIC8 the marginal variance explained was approximately 13% and 14% (respectively). A linear model based solely on additive effects of these two loci explains approximately 21% of phenotypic variance, while models that include an interaction term between these loci explains 26.4% of the variance (ANOVA, p-value < 1.0⁻⁶). Segregants with the SSK2^XL280a RIC8^431α genotype displayed the greatest average sensitivity to H₂O₂ while other allelic combinations of SSK2 and RIC8 exhibited similar average H₂O₂ resistance (S21 Fig).

Re-examination of thermal tolerance phenotypes (Fig 3) with respect to two-locus SSK2 RIC8 genotypes, suggests that epistasis between these two loci may also influence this trait. Across the temperatures used in growth curve assays (30, 37, 39°C), segregants bearing the SSK2^XL280a RIC8^431αgenotype displayed the poorest overall growth (S21 Fig). This growth defect was most pronounced at 39°C (ANOVA, R² = 0.332, p-value < 9⁻⁹).

Three-way epistasis contributes to hydrogen peroxide resistance

Since SSK2 was found to interact epistatically with both SSK1 (fludioxonil resistance) and RIC8 (oxidative stress resistance and thermal tolerance), we hypothesized that higher-order interactions involving all three loci might contribute to phenotypic variation in one or more of these traits. To test for three-way epistasis, we employed an approach proposed by Hu et al. [146], which uses a statistic called “information gain” (IG), which is based on information-theoretic mutual information measures [147]. Hu et al.’s IG statistic provides a measure of synergistic interaction between three loci with respect to a phenotype of interest, after subtracting the information inherent in single locus effects and synergies between pairs of loci. Since the IG statistic requires discrete data, we limited our analysis of three-way epistasis to a transformed H₂O₂ resistance phenotype, classifying each segregant as either sensitive, intermediate, or resistant. Applying the IG method to H₂O₂ resistance, we find evidence for single locus effects (IG(SSK1) = 4.6%, p-value = 0.005; IG(SSK2) = 6.0%, p-value = 0.002; IG(RIC8) = 5.4%, p-value = 0.006) as well as a three-way synergy between SSK1, SSK2, and RIC8 (IG(SSK1, SSK2, RIC8) = 7.0%, p-value = 0.004), but no significant pairwise synergies.

Fig 10A illustrates the distributions of H₂O₂ growth scores for each of the eight possible genotypic combinations of SSK1, SSK2, and RIC8. The mapping between the three-locus genotypes and H₂O₂ resistance can be summarized as follows. Segregants with the two-locus genotypic combination SSK2^XL280a RIC8^431α exhibit the lowest average H₂O₂ resistance. Conversely, segregants with the opposite genotypic combination SSK2^431α RIC8^XL280a exhibit high average H₂O₂ resistance. The phenotype of segregants with the other two-locus combinations of SSK2 and RIC8 (i.e. SSK2^XL280a RIC8^XL280a and SSK2^431α RIC8^431α) depends on their genotypic state at SSK1—those with the SSK1^XL280a allele have high average resistance, while those with the SSK1^431α allele exhibit intermediate average resistance.

Download:

• PPT
  PowerPoint slide
• PNG
  larger image
• TIFF
  original image

Fig 10. Three-way epistasis underlies H₂O₂ resistance.

Three-way epistasis between SSK1, SSK2, and RIC8 governs resistance to H₂O₂ stress. A) Distributions of growth scores under H₂O₂ stress (y-axis) for segregants with different three locus genotypes at SSK1, SSK2, and RIC8 (x-axis and color). Triangles mark the median scores per genotype. B) Proposed models for HOG and cAMP-PKA signaling for each genotypic combination in A. The SSK1^431α and RIC8^XL280a alleles are predicted to be non-functional and associated with reduced signaling. The SSK2^431α allele has been previously associated with increased basal levels of Hog1 phosphorylation. Proposed levels of HOG and cAMP-PKA signaling are denoted by edge thickness of expression and repression arrows.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1009313.g010

Allelic variation in cAMP-PKA signaling has highly pleiotropic effects on virulence traits

QTL for melanization, thermal tolerance, capsule size, and growth under oxidative stress (H₂O₂) all mapped to the same approximate region on chromosome 14. We identified a likely QTN for this pleiotropic QTL—a SNP that leads to a premature stop-gain within the penultimate exon of the gene RIC8. This genetic variant is present in the XL280a parental strain. Ric8 is a guanine nucleotide exchange factor for the G_α protein Gpa1, which activates the cAMP-PKA signaling pathway in C. neoformans [144, 158]. Based on the location of this variant, we predict that the XL280a allele results in a loss-of-function, perhaps partial, of RIC8, and hence reduces signalling through the cAMP-PKA pathway.

In our mapping population the RIC8^XL280a allele was associated with decreased melanization but increased thermal tolerance, capsule size, and H₂O₂ resistance. The associations we observed between phenotypes and RIC8 genotypes in our C. deneoformans mapping population show a mixture of agreement and disagreement with prior studies of cAMP-PKA signaling in Cryptococcus, most of which have been conducted in C. neoformans. For example, Gong et al. [144] showed that in C. neoformans, ric8Δ mutants exhibit a loss of melanization and reduced capsule size, and that both of these phenotypes could be rescued by cAMP supplementation. We found that addition of exogenous cAMP to the growth medium increased melanization of the XL280a strain, consistent with the prediction that the RIC8^XL280a is associated with reduced cAMP signaling. However, contrary to that prior study, the predicted loss-of-function RIC8^XL280a allele was associated with increased relative capsule size.

Gong et al. [144] did not examine thermal tolerance in their study, but we assayed growth of a C. neoformans ric8Δ strain at high temperatures, and found that this strain exhibited slower initial growth rates relative to the wild-type background, but came to a higher overall population density. This parallels the thermal tolerance phenotype we observed for the XL280a background. A similar inverse relationship between thermal tolerance and cAMP-PKA signaling has been observed in S. cerevisiae; Li et al. [159] found that hyperactivation of cAMP-PKA signaling reduces resistance to acute heat stress while PKA inhibition increased resistance.

Considering the multivariate relationships among these four traits, we find that: a) melanization is negatively correlated with thermal tolerance and H₂O₂ resistance; b) capsule size is positively correlated with thermal tolerance but weakly correlated with melanization and H₂O₂ resistance; and c) H₂O₂ resistance is positively correlated with thermal tolerance. While melanization is thought to be protective against reactive oxygen species [160], Jacobson et al. [70] observed no significant protection against H₂O₂ in C. deneoformans strains; thus observing a negative relationship between these two phenotypes is not unexpected. However, the inverse relationship between melanization and thermal tolerance is somewhat surprising, as prior studies have demonstrated a positive relationship between the production of melanin and the ability to grow at high temperatures [68].

A likely explanation for the mix of similar and dissimilar correlates with RIC8 genotypes relative to earlier work, is divergence in cAMP-PKA signaling between C. neoformans and C. deneoformans strains. Hicks et al. and Hicks and Heitman [161, 162] showed that mutations of the PKA catalytic subunits, PKA1 and PKA2, have distinctly different effects on melanization, capsule formation, and mating in C. neoformans, C. deneoformans and the more distantly related species C. gattii. Genetic variation that affects cAMP-PKA signaling in particular is an increasingly common theme in studies of fungal quantitative genetics and experimental evolution [163–166]. A recent comparative study of cAMP-PKA signaling in S. cerevisiae and related yeasts hypothesized that this pathway is likely to be a hotspot for functional variation and evolutionary adaptation [167]. We predict that segregating genetic variation in cAMP-PKA signaling may be particularly relevant for natural variation in virulence-related traits not only in Cryptococcus but in other pathogenic fungi as well.

HOG pathway variants moderate resistance to the antifungal drug amphotericin B

Major QTL for amphotericin B sensitivity were found on chromosomes 2 and 12. We identified candidate QTG that underlie these loci—SSK1 on chromosome 2 and SSK2 on chromosome 12—both of which are components of the HOG signalling pathway. The HOG pathway is known to regulate the production of ergosterol, the target of amphotericin B [168].

At the chromosome 2 locus we discovered a single nucleotide insertion in the 431α parental strain background that leads to an early stop-gain in the gene SSK1, the response regulator of the HOG pathway. Given the location of the identified variant, it is likely that this results in a complete loss of function for the gene. C. neoformans ssk1Δ mutant strains exhibit increased sensitivity to amphotericin B compared to wild-type strains [148, 168], a pattern we observed in segregants with the SSK1^431α allele. Interestingly, the ssk1Δ strains in the XL280a background we generated did not display an amphotericin B sensitive phenotype. We hypothesize that this was due to additional genetic variants in this background that also contribute to amphotericin B resistance.

In C. neoformans, but not C. deneoformans strains, Ssk1 has also been shown to govern capsule elaboration and melanization [169]. Consistent with this earlier study, allelic variation at SSK1 is not associated with variation in either capsule or melanin phenotypes in our mapping population, suggesting that HOG signaling has diverged between Cryptococcus species.

The likely causal variants for amphotericin B sensitivity that mapped to chromosome 12 are alleles of the gene SSK2, the MAPKKK of the HOG pathway. The variant sites within SSK2 observed here have been previously described by Bahn et al. [143]. In their study, Bahn et al. [143] showed that the allele present in the 431α parental strain (SSK2^431α) is associated with increased basal levels of Hog1 phosphorylation and in a follow-up study, Ko et al. [168] demonstrated that C. deneoformans strains with this allele are more resistant to higher concentrations of amphotericin B. Across C. neoformans and C. deneoformans strains, the amount of pre-phosphorylated Hog1 is known to vary [169], and Bahn et al. [143] hypothesized that this allowed some strains to rapidly respond to extracellular stresses. Interestingly in our study, SSK2^431α was the only allele from the 431α parental strain associated with increased fitness.

Epistatic interactions within and between signaling pathways

Ssk1 and Ssk2 are both members of the HOG pathway, and Ssk1 physically interacts with and regulates Ssk2’s kinase activity [24, 153, 170]. This naturally led us to explore genetic interactions between the allelic states we observed for SSK1 and SSK2. Additionally, crosstalk between HOG and cAMP-PKA signaling pathways has been documented in both S. cerevisiae and C. neoformans [169, 171–174], thus motivating an exploration of genetic interactions between RIC8 and HOG-pathway alleles.

We found that an epistatic interaction between SSK1 and SSK2 affected sensitivity to fludioxonil, an agricultural antifungal drug. Fludioxonil’s mode of action is thought to be hyperactivation of the HOG pathway [175] and resistance to fludioxonil occurs primarily through HOG pathway loss-of-function mutations [145, 176]. Bahn et al. [143] showed that strains with the SSK2^431α genotype were sensitive to fludioxonil, presumably due to hyperactive HOG signaling associated with pre-phosphorylated Hog1. Surprisingly, the parental strain 431α, which bears the predicted sensitive SSK2 allele, was fludioxonil resistant. Analysis of offspring from our cross revealed that the unexpected resistance in 431α is mediated by allelic variation at SSK1—segregants with the sensitive SSK2^431α allele as well as the loss-of-function SSK1^431α allele exhibit fludioxonil resistance, while the pairing of the sensitive SSK2^431α allele with the functional SSK1^XL280a allele results in sensitivity to fludioxonil. All other allelic combinations at these two loci are fludioxonil resistant. This thus represents a compelling example of within-pathway epistasis.

Our analysis of hydrogen peroxide resistance suggests complex cross-pathway epistasis between the HOG and cAMP-PKA signaling networks. We propose that the three-way epistatic interaction between SSK1, SSK2, and RIC8 can be rationalized in terms of the relative balance between HOG signaling and cAMP-PKA signaling (Fig 10B). Segregants with the genotype SSK2^XL280a RIC8^431α exhibit the greatest average sensitivity to hydrogen peroxide stress. This genotypic combination is predicted to have weak or intermediate levels of HOG signaling but normal cAMP-PKA signaling. Conversely, segregants with the genotype SSK2^431α RIC8^XL280a are predicted to have intermediate or high HOG signaling activity (associated with pre-phosphorylation of Hog1), but weak cAMP-PKA signaling (due to Ric8 loss-of-function alleles), resulting in H₂O₂ resistance. The two genotype combinations are thus consistent with the observed marginal effects of SSK2 and RIC8. The phenotypes of the other genotypic combinations of SSK2 and RIC8 require consideration of SSK1 allelic state. For example, intermediate resistance phenotypes are associated with either intermediate HOG signaling (SSK1^431α SSK2^431α) combined with normal cAMP-signaling (RIC8^431α) or weak HOG signaling (SSK1^431α SSK2^XL280a) coupled with weak cAMP-signaling (RIC8^XL280a).

There is significant experimental evidence consistent with a model of opposing effects of HOG and cAMP-PKA signaling for a variety of stress responsive phenotypes in both Cryptococcus and other fungi. For example, Maeng et al. [177] report that C. neoformans ras1 mutants show increased resistance to H₂O₂ stress but decreased resistance to diamide, while hog1 mutants are H₂O₂ sensitive and diamide resistant. C. neoformans hog1 mutants exhibit an increase in capsule size [169], another stress responsive phenotype, while cAMP related mutations such as gpa1, pka1, cac1, and ric8 have reduced or absent capsule [144, 178–180]. Gutin et al. [173] report evidence of crosstalk between cAMP-PKA and HOG signaling with respect to the general stress response in yeast, with cAMP-PKA activity associated with the repression of key stress responsive genes while HOG activity is associated with their activation.

The importance of time for the study of microbial growth phenotypes

A critical feature of our study is the inclusion of temporal data and the application of function-valued analytical approaches for key growth traits. While there are both experimental [181] and statistical [134, 135] challenges associated with the collection of high-resolution time series growth phenotypes and functional valued QTL mapping, such data are much more information rich than conventional end-point growth or estimates of maximum growth rates. For example, several of the QTL associations we identified are temporally variable and would likely not have been detected without the inclusion of a time axis in our analyses.

The importance of temporal information for microbial growth phenotypes is not limited to QTL mapping, but is equally relevant to genetic approaches based on mutational analysis. For example, we found that when exposed to heat stress C. neoformans ric8Δ mutants exhibit slower maximum growth rates compared to an isogenic wild-type strain, but reach a higher final population density (Fig 7B). The determination of whether the mutant grows better or worse than wild-type thus depends critically on when during growth this question is posed and whether the investigator considers maximal growth rate or final population density to be a better reflection of thermal tolerance. Only by including the time axis and using a function valued approach can we appreciate the complexity of growth patterns inherent in this comparison.

While not explored in this report, we hypothesize that the relative timing of QTL or mutational associations with microbial growth phenotypes may reflect key transitions in physiological state within microbial populations. Temporal QTL/mutational information could thus be used to inform the construction of models relating the dynamical behavior of gene networks to distinct physiological states.

Comparison to previous QTL studies in Cryptococcus and other fungi

There are commonalities between the results presented here and a previous QTL mapping study of C. deneoformans. For example, Lin et al. [111] examined variation in thermal tolerance and melanization within C. deneoformans progeny and identified a pleiotropic QTL on chromosome 7 that contributes towards both of these aforementioned traits. This QTL was narrowed down to allelic differences in MAC1, a copper homeostasis transcription factor. Similar to this past study, we also identified pleiotropic QTGs contributing to more than one virulence-related trait examined here (including thermal tolerance and melanization), namely the genes RIC8 and SSK2. While our study did not share any of the previously implicated QTGs [79, 111], across several studies—not just those using QTL mapping strategies—observing pleiotropic effects of genes and pathways connected to virulence and virulence-associated traits seems to be a unifying phenomena [108, 182–187].

The genetic complexity of virulence phenotypes

While the effects of each of the QTL we identified are relatively large, explaining on average 24% of the phenotypic variance in amphotericin B susceptibility at SSK1 and SSK2, ∼33% in thermal tolerance between SSK2 and RIC8, 17% in capsule size, and 39% in melanization at RIC8, and 25% of variation in resistance to H₂O₂ between SSK2 and RIC8, there are still large portions of unexplained phenotypic variation. Coupled with the observation of transgressive phenotypes in several of our experiments, these data may suggest the presence of many unidentified QTL and undiscovered epistatic interactions. Our analysis also focused primarily on the analysis of non-synonymous coding variants, though non-coding variation (e.g. [188, 189]) and synonymous variation (e.g. [190]) have both been shown to be important for the genetic architecture of complex traits in fungi and as well as other eukaryotes. Additional functional analyses, larger mapping populations and higher order models that test for multiple [191] and interacting loci [192] may help to detect these elusive QTL in future studies.

Implications for the study of fungal virulence

Virulence is a complex outcome, an emergent property, that is determined by the combined effects of numerous morphological, physiological, metabolic, and molecular features of pathogens and their hosts [1]. The QTL and associated candidate genes and variants we have identified emphasize the genetic and functional complexity of virulence traits. For example, the RIC8^XL280a allele we identified is associated with decreased melanization but increased thermal tolerance, oxidative stress resistance, and capsule size. Despite low levels of melanin, and the loss of a key activator of the cAMP-PKA pathway, the strain XL280 is still virulent in an inhalation infection model of murine cryptococcosis [137, 193]. One must therefore exercise caution when trying to predict the likely effects of natural variation on virulence potential. This is likely to apply equally to engineered genetic manipulations or the effects of drugs that target particular pathways.

Our findings in the present study may also have implications for clinical treatment of cryptococcal disease. Outright resistance to antifungals such as amphotericin B is rare in Cryptococcus species [84, 194], but variance in the minimum inhibitory concentrations of antifungals, including amphotericin B, have been observed within species. Such variation could lead to recurring instances of disease within patients [49, 78, 195, 196]. A recent survey of antifungal susceptibility in clinical isolates of C. neoformans saw increases across a ten-year period in the minimum inhibitory concentration for both fluconazole and amphotericin B [85]. The QTN (at SSK1 and SSK2) identified in the environmental strain 431α are implicated in sensitivity and increased resistance (respectively) to amphotericin B and provide concrete examples of the types of natural genetic variants that are present within Cryptococcus that might underlie differences in response to clinical treatment, depending on the particular lineage(s) that a patient is infected with. Similarly, in the case of infections by multiple Cryptococcus strains [48], naturally occurring alleles that decrease sensitivity to antifungals are likely targets for selection.

Current global trends point to both a warming planet and an increase rate of resistance to antifungal drugs [1, 197]. Studies like the one presented here, that focus on standing genetic variation within species, may help to predict the complex and evolving landscape of fungal virulence, providing insights into both lineages and genetic variants that are likely to be favored or disfavored as environments and clinical treatment change.

Parental strains, laboratory crosses, and isolation of F₁ progeny

As described in Sun et al. [92] the parental strains 431α, XL280αSS, and XL280a were used inα–α unisexual and a–α bisexual crosses (S1 Table). The parental strain 431α is a natural C. deneoformans isolate with the MATα allele [92, 138]. The parental strain XL280αSS is an XL280 strain with an inserted NAT resistance marker in the URA5 gene [141] and is congenic to the parental strain XL280a with the exceptions of the URA5 gene, NAT resistance marker, the MAT locus, and a partial duplication of the left arm of chromosome 10 [92, 137, 141]. Due to the insertion of the NAT in the URA5 gene of the XL280αSS strain, a wild type XL280α strain was used in phenotyping experiments. Because the strains XL280α and XL280a are congenic with the exception of the MAT locus, throughout the manuscript only the XL280a strain is referred to when referencing the XL280 background.

As described in [92], both a–α bisexual (XL280a × 431α) and α–α unisexual (XL280αSS × 431α) matings were carried out and progeny were isolated, yielding 261 and 156 progeny respectively. Parental strains and segregants were maintained in 35% glycerol frozen stocks at -80°C and subcultured from freezer stock to YPD media for experimentation. Between segregants derived unisexually verses bisexual, no significant effect was observed in any of the phenotypes examined here—except for fludioxonil sensitivity (see Results)—and their phenotypic values were pooled into a single mapping population for use in QTL mapping.

Sequencing, aligning, and variant calling

In total, 127 segregants, which included 63 from the α–α unisexual, 61 from the a–α bisexual crosses, and the 3 parental strains, XL280a, XL280αSS, and 431α, were sequenced as previously described [92, 141]. Raw reads were aligned to an XL280 C. deneoformans reference genome [137] using BWA (v0.7.12-r1039, [198]). Variant calling was carried out using SAMtools (v0.1.19-96b5f2294a, [199]) and FreeBayes (v1.2.0, [200]) resulting in 449,197 bi-allelic single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and 1,500 bi-allelic insertions and deletions (INDELs) between the parental strains, segregating within the F₁ segregants.

Segregant filtering and marker creation

Each of the 127 segregants were filtered to remove those which exhibited aneuploidy, clonality, or lack of recombination as described in Roth et al. [141]. After applying these filtering criteria, 104 segregants—composed of 55 progeny from α–α unisexual crosses, 46 progeny from a–α bisexual crosses, and the three progenitor strains—were retained for further analysis.

The 449,197 bi-allelic variants sites were filtered on call rate, read depth, allelic read depth ratio, minor allele frequency, and quality scores. Across the 104 segregants, SNP and INDEL sites were required to have 100% call rate, greater than 10× coverage in read depth, an allelic read depth ratio of 80% (for example, if a SNP site has 10 reads mapping over it, 8 of the 10 reads must support the existence of the SNP), a minor allele frequency of 20%, and a log₁₀ quality score, normalized by read depth, of greater than or equal to 0.75. A maximum log₁₀ read depth of 4.1 was set to filter out SNPs in regions with repetitive elements. Finally, bi-allelic SNP and INDEL sites within 5 kb of centromeres and of the ends of the chromosomes were removed as these regions are difficult to sequence, resulting in 92,103 genetic variants. These 92,103 genetic variants were then grouped into haploblocks (“haplotype blocks”) based on variants in perfect linkage, in order to reduce the number of markers for analysis in genotype-phenotype association tests [201]. This was done for each chromosome such that every haploblock had at least one segregant with a genotype change between contiguous haploblocks, resulting in 3,108 sites across the segregants. The average size of haploblocks was 5.4 kb with a minimum size of 4.4 kb and maximum size of 6.3 kb.

Quantitative growth assays

Quantitative growth assays were measured using absorbance microplate readers (Tecan Sunrise). Initially, segregants were arrayed in U-bottom 96 well plates containing 100 μl of liquid YPD, incubated for two days at 30°C, and after the addition of glycerol, preserved as frozen stocks at -80°C. Plates were stored as frozen stocks and used to start each assay. After two days of growth on YPD solid agar plates, segregants were pinned into 150 μl liquid YPD and grown on a plate shaker for two days at 30°C. Subsequently for each segregant, 1 × 10⁵ cells were transferred into 150 μl BD Difco yeast nitrogen base (YNB) buffered to pH 7.0 with 0.165 M MOPS (morpholinepropanesulfonic acid) buffer (Sigma-Aldrich). For drug treatments, amphotericin B (Sigma-Aldrich) was added to YNB from a stock solution of 100 μg/ml for final drug concentrations of 0.075, 0.125, and 0.175 μg/ml. Cells were grown in microplate readers for three days at either 30°, 37°, or 39°C with no drug and assayed for all possible combinations of temperature by amphotericin B concentration except for 39°C and 0.175 μg/ml because no strains grew at this combination of temperature and drug stress. Assays were replicated four times. To monitor growth, optical density measurements were made at a wavelength of 595 nm (OD₅₉₅) every 15 minutes. To prevent fogging in the machines, plate lids were pre-treated with a solution of 0.05% Triton X-100 in 20% EtOH.

Plate based assays

For plate based assays using solid agar media, segregants were pinned from liquid YPD media to the appropriate, freshly prepared assay media. To minimize edge effects, no segregants were arrayed in the outer rows and columns of the plates. Instead, a control strain was grown in these positions, either H99α or JEC21α.

To assess melanin production, segregants were grown on chemically defined minimal medium containing L-DOPA (7.6 mM L-asparagine monohydrate, 5.6 mM glucose, 10 mM MgSO4, 0.5 mM 3,4-dihydroxy-L-phenylalanine, 0.3 mM thiamine–HCl, and 20 nM biotin) and incubated at 30°C for three days in the dark. After three days plates were scanned on an Epson Expression 10000 XL Flatbed Scanner in reflective mode (scanned from below) at 300 dpi. The grayscale intensity of each colony, as measured using ImageJ, was used as a proxy for melanization, and the mean across three replicates of these values was utilized in statistical association tests. The average Spearman rank correlation coefficient between replicates values was approximately 0.98.

To assay for hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂) sensitivity, segregants were pinned onto YPD plates supplemented with 5mM H₂O₂ and incubated at 30°C. After five days, plates were scanned in the same manner as above. Across four replicates, colony growth was scored manually by two individuals on a scale from 0 to 5. The median score per segregant was used for data analysis. Between replicates, the average Spearman rank correlation coefficient was 0.86.

To examine sensitivity to fludioxonil, segregants were similarly pinned onto YPD plates supplemented with 100 μg/ml fludioxonil and incubated at 30°C for five days. Scanned images of colonies were scored by two observers on a binary scale (growth or no growth) and this value was used in analysis. This assay was replicated in an additional, larger set of segregants generated using the same parental backgrounds (see below).

To assess the response to osmotic stress in this mapping population, colonies were pinned to YP medium containing 1.0 M NaCl, incubated for three days, and then scanned in transmissive mode. The average grayscale density across three replicates of each colony was used as the growth phenotype. Across replicates the average Spearman rank coefficient was 0.80.

Capsule induction and imaging

Overnight cell cultures were resuspended in 9.0 ml CO₂-independent medium (Gibco) and incubated for three days at 37°C with shaking at 150 rpm. After incubation, cells were washed and then stained with India ink [202]. Each strain was imaged at least three times on an EVOS M5000 Cell Imaging System using a 40X objective. Using ImageJ, total area of the capsule plus cell and cell body only were measured and used to quantify capsule size for approximately 30 cells per segregant. The mean of these values was used in QTL mapping.

Growth curve base-lining and parameter estimation

For each growth experiment, a blank optical density was calculated from the average optical density of wells containing no cells, and this value was subtracted from each well on a per plate basis. The first two time points, representing the first fifteen minutes of data collection, were dropped from analysis.The next five time points were used to baseline the data by calculating the average optical density of these points (the first 1.5 hours) and subtracting this from the remaining sampled time points. These five baseline points were then set to zero. After blank correction and baselining, individual growth curves were filtered using a median filter [203] with a moving, symmetric window of 25 time points, padding the beginning and end of the time courses with zeros or the final OD, respectively. After base-lining and median filtering, we estimated the area under the growth curve at each time point n as with Δt = .25 hours (or 15 minutes). For each segregant, the median of the AUC_n across replicates with respect to time was used in QTL mapping across the experimental conditions. One replicate at the condition of 30°C and 0 μg/ml of amphotericin B was dropped from analysis for 60 of the segregants due to poor initial growth seen in pre-culture plate. At 30°C, in the absence of drug, the average Spearman rank correlation coefficient between replicates was 0.82.

QTL mapping

For each plate based assay and the 3,108 haploblock test sites, a marker regression frame work was used to associate genotypes to phenotypes. The genotype of each haploblock was coded as zero if inherited from the XL280a (or XL280αSS) parental strain, and one if from the parental 431α strain. The model used in statistical association tests can be summarized as y = μ + βI_c + ϵ where ϵ is the error term, μ is the average phenotype (i.e. mean intensity, growth score, capsule or cell size), I_c is an indicator variable for genotype, and β is the coefficient depicting the effect of having the genotype of XL280a (or XL280αSS) or genotype of 431α at the given haploblock. An estimation of this effect, β, is given by [204]. The −log₁₀(p-value) for each unique haploblock, for a given experiment and phenotype was used as the measure of association. The 95% confidence intervals for melanization, capsule size, and thermal tolerance were calculated as described in Visscher et al. [205], sampling a 1,000 times with replacement and taking the mean location per maximum haploblock.

For experiments that generated colony growth curves, a function-valued, marker-regression approach was employed to quantify the relationship between genotype and growth phenotypes for each variable haploblock across the 72-hour time course. For these experiments, the area under the growth curve (AUC) was calculated at 15-minute intervals and used as the growth phenotype. As described above, the usual marker-regression model is y = μ + β I_c + ϵ, with y = AUC. Across time, the AUC_t can be calculated for a given time point within the 72-hour time course and treated as separate phenotypes (Fig 4). This marker-regression model may then be extended for the functional phenotype dependent on time, y(t), where, y(t) = μ(t)+ β(t)I_c+ ϵ(t). An estimate of the QTL effect across time is then given by where Y is a matrix of segregant phenotypes with columns that represent the multiple time points [134, 206].

Permutation tests

Permutation tests, as described in Churchill and Doerge [142], were conducted to establish significance thresholds for the −log₁₀(p-value) from QTL mapping. The number of permutations for all phenotypes analyzed here was 10,000. The same set of random reassignments of genotype to phenotype were used for the eleven temperature by amphotericin B experimental conditions to conserve correlation structure between the experimental conditions. Each growth curve was treated as a single phenotypic measure during permutations to preserve autocorrelation across time points, and the significance thresholds for the maximum and mean associations between genotype and phenotype (with respect to time) were calculated [134]. The 95^th and 99^th percentile of the permuted distribution of genotype-phenotype associations was used to estimate thresholds for significance.

Analyzing three-way epistasis

We used an information-theoretic approach proposed by Hu et al. [146] to evaluate models of three-way genetic epistasis for the association of hydrogen peroxide resistance with genotypic variation at SSK1, SSK2, and RIC8. Hu et al.’s method is based on a measure of the relative amount of “information gain” (IG) attributable to synergistic epistatic interactions, quantified in terms of standard information theoretic measures of mutual information. To apply this approach we discretized each segregant’s H₂O₂ response as sensitive, intermediate, or resistant based on the observed growth scores, and estimated Hu et al.’s IG statistic using mutual information functions implemented in the Python package scikit-learn [207]. We used permutation tests to simulate null distributions and estimate p-values for the IG statistic. For single locus effects, we used permutations which randomized the relationship between phenotype and genotype at each of the three loci, while maintaining the genotypic covariance between loci. For second- and third-order effects we permuted genotypes of samples within each phenotypic class, preserving the independent main effects while randomizing any non-linear interactions, as recommended in Hu et al. [146]. A thousand permutations were used to simulate the distributions of both main and higher order effects. We report normalized information gain, expressed as a percentage of the Shannon entropy of the phenotypic distribution.

Annotation realignment and genetic variant effect prediction

To predict the effects of genetic variants identified between the XL280a (or XL280αSS) and 431α parental strains, annotated gene features were derived from the C. deneoformans reference strain, JEC21α [208]. These sequences were then aligned via the blast-like alignment tool (BLAT, [209]) to the XL280α reference genome [137]. Per gene, alignments were filtered for sequence identity of 95% and at most two mismatches between the JEC21α and XL280α genomes. There are a total of 5,210 annotated features in the JEC21α genome annotation, of which 4,800 mapped perfectly and uniquely to the XL280α genome. After mapping orthologous genes, the effects of genetic differences between the XL280a (or XL280α) and the 431α backgrounds were imputed with respect to the predicted exonic and intronic regions.

Gene disruption

TRACE (Transient CRISPR-Cas9 Coupled with Electroporation [56]) was used to genetically disrupt SSK1 in the parental strains. Deletion constructs were assembled with two-step PCR using homologous arms one kb in length and a NAT marker, a dominant drug-resistance marker conferring resistance to nourseothricin. Single-guide RNAs were designed with Eukaryotic Pathogen CRISPR guide RNA/DNA Design Tool (http://grna.ctegd.uga.edu/) using default parameters, and the gRNA scaffold was amplified from pDD162. To generate complete gRNAs, a one-step overhang PCR was used to amplify the construct from sgRNA, the scaffold, and the U6 promoter (JEC21α), following TRACE protocols. Cas9 was amplified from pXL1-Cas9-HygB.

Parental strains were transformed with the amplified constructs following the protocol for electroporation in Fan and Lin [56], except competent yeast cells were washed and resuspended in 1M sorbitol before transformation. Electroporated cells recovered for two hours in YPD before being plated onto YPD supplemented with nourseothricin (YPD+NAT) selective media. After re-streaking, transformants were screened with internal SSK1 primers. Colonies that were capable of growing on YPD+NAT selective media were subsequently screened with external primers for product size, primers that spanned across the gene boundaries, and primers for detecting the presence of Cas9. One ssk1 transformant for 431α and three ssk1 transformants for XL280a were identified. The inserted deletion construct for each of these transformants was sequenced in full for confirmation. Primers are listed in S2 Table. To assess gene disruption effects, growth curves for the ssk1 strains were measured at 30°C in 0.125 μg/ml amphotericin B, the condition with the largest strength in association at the chromosome 2 QTL which contains the gene SSK1.

Additional fine-mapped crosses, segregant isolation, and sequencing

To further investigate the identified QTL on chromosome 2 (approximately 150-kb wide), fine-mapping techniques were applied to generate additional progeny. Parental strains were transformed as described previously [56] using the NAT and NEO selectable markers inserted at intergenic regions flanking the QTL. The chosen intergenic regions were between genes CNB02680 and CNB02690 at approximately 797,055—797,281 kb on the left and between genes CNB03490 and CNB03500 at approximately 1,047,138—1,047,346 kb on the right of the chromosome 2 QTL for the NAT and NEO markers respectively. Transformants were screened as described previously [56] and one strain transformed from the XL280 strain background, with NAT cassette and three strains transformed from the 431α strain background, each with the NEO cassette, were identified (S1 Table). Southern blot probing for the selectable markers was used to determine that only one copy was inserted in the genome for each transformant.

To generate recombinant progeny from the transformed parental strains, spores from mass matings were purified through Percoll gradient centrifugation [22, 210]. Purified, recombinant spores were selected for by growing progeny on YPD+NAT+NEO, and NAT^R NEO^R segregants were verified as recombinant by colony PCR. In total, 192 progeny were sequenced on a NovaSeq 6000 (SP) flow cell (150 bp PE). Sequencing data were analyzed in the same manner as described previously. Segregants were filtered to remove clones and progeny with diploid or aneuploid genomes and 173 segregants were retained for analysis.