https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6251-8890
Figures
Abstract
Plague is a flea-borne fatal disease caused by the bacterium Yersinia pestis, which persists in rural Madagascar. Although fleas parasitizing rats are considered the primary vectors of Y. pestis, the human flea, Pulex irritans, is abundant in human habitations in Madagascar, and has been found naturally infected by the plague bacterium during outbreaks. While P. irritans may therefore play a role in plague transmission if present in plague endemic areas, the factors associated with infestation and human exposure within such regions are little explored. To determine the socio-ecological risk factors associated with P. irritans infestation in rural households in plague-endemic areas of Madagascar, we used a mixed-methods approach, integrating results from P. irritans sampling, a household survey instrument, and an observational checklist. Using previously published vectorial capacity data, the minimal P. irritans index required for interhuman bubonic plague transmission was modeled to determine whether household infestations were enough to pose a plague transmission risk. Socio-ecological risk factors associated with a high P. irritans index were then identified for enrolled households using generalized linear models. Household flea abundance was also modeled using the same set of predictors. A high P. irritans index occurred in approximately one third of households and was primarily associated with having a traditional dirt floor covered with a plant fiber mat. Interventions targeting home improvement and livestock housing management may alleviate flea abundance and plague risk in rural villages experiencing high P. irritans infestation. As plague-control resources are limited in developing countries such as Madagascar, identifying the household parameters and human behaviors favoring flea abundance, such as those identified in this study, are key to developing preventive measures that can be implemented at the community level.
Author summary
Plague is a bacterial disease transmitted by flea bites, and the rat fleas are the main vectors of Yersinia pestis, the plague bacterium. Households in plague endemic-areas of Madagascar are frequently infested by Pulex irritans, the human flea, which does become naturally infected with the plague bacterium during epidemic. The intensity of flea infestation varies among households, but the reasons for such disparities are poorly understood. This study identifies factors associated with P. irritans infestation in rural households in plague-endemic areas of Madagascar. Infestation risk was more pronounced for poor households living in homes made with organic construction materials and flea density did not show a seasonal pattern. One third of the household experienced high flea infestation, putting inhabitants at risk of sustained interhuman plague transmission, should the fleas or a household member become infected. While P. irritans may be a secondary vector, this additional route of plague transmission deserves more attention from epidemiologists. The factors identified in this analysis suggest that improvement of housing and better management of livestock would alleviate flea burden and potential plague risk in rural plague-endemic villages experiencing high flea infestation.
Citation: Miarinjara A, Raveloson AO, Mugel SG, An N, Andriamiadanarivo A, Rajerison ME, et al. (2024) Socio-ecological risk factors associated with human flea infestations of rural household in plague-endemic areas of Madagascar. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 18(3): e0012036. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0012036
Editor: Benjamin L. Makepeace, University of Liverpool, UNITED KINGDOM
Received: July 31, 2023; Accepted: February 29, 2024; Published: March 7, 2024
Copyright: © 2024 Miarinjara et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All data generated or analyzed during this study are included in this published article and its supplementary information files, as well as at OSF, under a public repository link (https://osf.io/6mqux/?view_only=70d21dff44ce42bc8fc9bc45d8a9bf8c) in the manuscript main text.
Funding: AM received funding from The Branco Weiss Fellowship Society in Science, (https://brancoweissfellowship.org) and The American Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, through the Centennial Travel Award (https://www.astmh.org/awards-fellowships-medals/awards-and-honors/centennial-travel-award). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Background
Fleas (Order Siphonaptera) are bloodsucking, wingless insects with laterally- compressed bodies and hind legs specialized for jumping [1]. Flea species from Pulicidae and Tungidae families are important pests for humans and domestic animals and include species such as Xenopsylla cheopis (the Oriental rat flea), Pulex irritans (the human flea), Ctenocephalides canis and Ctenocephalides felis (dog and cat fleas, respectively), Echidnophaga gallinacea (the sticktight flea), and Tunga penetrans (jigger flea), which are commonly found in the human environment [2]. In many cases, flea infestations are concurrent among livestock and companion animals, which act as reservoir and/or principal hosts [3–5]. Flea infestations have not received much attention despite their detrimental impacts on community morbidity, wellbeing, and productivity in low-income countries [6–8].
Fleas undergo full metamorphosis and the immature flea life-stages live among the dust and crevices of floors within homes or in animal host burrows. The photophobic worm-like larvae require high humidity to survive and feed on various organic debris in the environment. Flea life cycle from egg to adult is influenced by factors related to the immediate environment, such as temperature, humidity, and host presence [2,9,10]. Adult fleas of both sexes feed exclusively on blood. Some flea species live in animal nests and burrows as adults, while others live on host fur, leaving only if the host dies. Host blood source has a decisive impact on flea population maintenance since blood components determine flea fitness and survival [11]. Flea host specificity (i.e., number of host species exploited) depends on factors that affect both adult and immature stage survival; and host availability and preferences determine flea distributions and their role in the transmission of pathogenic parasites and bacteria [9]. Cat and dog fleas serve as intermediate hosts for various tapeworms (Order Cyclophyllidea), contributing to the spread of the parasite among companion animals and potential zoonotic exposure [9]. Murine typhus is a flea-borne rickettsial disease caused by infection with Rickettsia typhi that has been detected in flea species including C. felis, E. gallinacea, P. irritans, and X. cheopis [12,13]. Fleas may also play a limited role in the transmission of tularemia, a bacterial disease caused by Francisella tularensis [9]. Bartonella sp., responsible for bartonellosis, has been detected in various flea species parasitizing commensal and wild hosts [2].
Among flea-borne diseases, plague is arguably the most infamous [2]. Yersinia pestis, the etiologic agent of plague, is a highly virulent bacterium that has killed millions during three historic human pandemics and continues to re-emerge [14]. The transmission cycle of Y. pestis is complex, involving multiple vertebrate hosts. Plague is principally a flea-borne rodent disease, characterized by circulation within resistant rodent populations, inducing low or no mortality but allowing persistence of the pathogen in the environment (enzootic plague), and transmission between susceptible rodent populations inducing high mortality (epizootic) [15]. Humans are most likely to become infected when flea numbers are high and epizootic plague is decimating a susceptible rodent population, as infected fleas from dead rodents are seeking new hosts [16].
In countries such as Uganda, Madagascar, and Tanzania, where bubonic plague is prevalent, C. felis and P. irritans are among the most abundant fleas in homes and are categorized as house-dwelling, free, host-seeking or house fleas, as opposed to on-host fleas [17–19]. Interestingly, C. felis, and the human flea, P. irritans, are considered of low concern for public health despite a presumable role in plague transmission [17,20–22]. In Madagascar, rat fleas are the only target of vector control efforts, and solely within the framework of plague epidemic mitigation [19,23,24]. Troublingly the insecticide powder used for flea control during plague outbreaks, spread on the household floor or contained in bait stations, has little effect on P. irritans [23,24]. Furthermore, households in plague-endemic areas of Madagascar were frequently infested by a large number of human fleas at magnitudes rarely found in other countries reporting human plague outbreaks [18,25]. Although the intensity of flea infestation varies greatly among households, the reasons for such disparities are poorly understood [19,23]. Research regarding P. irritans biology, ecology, and the conditions under which this species may play a role in plague transmission are scarce in Madagascar, though this knowledge would be valuable to develop science-based plague control strategies.
The aim of the present study was to determine the socio-ecological risk factors associated with P. irritans infestations that may increase plague transmission risk in rural Madagascar households where plague is known to circulate, or recent outbreaks have occurred. Our primary hypothesis was that P. irritans density is driven by seasonal patterns and influenced by household characteristics. As ectoparasite control resources are limited in developing countries, identifying household parameters and human behaviors favoring flea abundance and plague risk are key to developing preventive measures that can be implemented by community engagement. Our specific aims were: 1. to identify household-level characteristics that correspond to high-risk P. irritans abundance and 2. to assess seasonal variation in P. irritans abundance in homes in plague-endemic region of Madagascar.
Methods
Ethic statement
Participants in this study were adults (> 18 years old) that provided oral informed consent for interview and flea sampling in their homes. The project was reviewed and approved by the Emory University Institutional Review Board (STUDY00004288), the Institut Pasteur de Madagascar scientific committee, and the biomedical research ethics committee of the Malagasy Ministry of Public Health (Comité d’Ethique de la Recherche Biomédicale, case number 82-MSANP/SG/AMM/CERBM).
Study area
Repeated cross-sectional surveys and household flea sampling were conducted in four rural villages within the plague-endemic Southeastern part of the Central Highlands of Madagascar [19,26] (Fig 1). Two villages, Nanda and Alakamisy Ambohimaha, belong to the Lalangina district, within the Matsiatra Ambony Region where multiple suspected or confirmed plague outbreaks have been reported in the past decade. The other two villages, Soafandry and Ambohipanalinana, belong to the district of Ambositra (Amoron’i Mania region), which has several active plague foci [27,28].
The map was generated with QGIS software (https://qgis.org/en/site/about/index.html). Administrative boundaries were downloaded from GADM: https://gadm.org/index.html.
Survey instrument
Interviews were conducted during the dry season (June—July 2022) when workload in rice paddies was lowest and heads of households were expected to be available for interviews. The survey instrument was developed in English, translated to Malagasy, and validated via back-translation [29] before being administered orally to each head of household in Malagasy. Village leaders and investigators called open community gatherings where attendees were informed of the purpose, scope, methods, and plans for information sharing of the study, and an investigator disclosed that participation in the study was voluntary and prospective participants were asked for their informed consent. Households were selected randomly, starting from the village gathering place to the periphery and included when an adult (>18 years old) was present and orally consented to participate to the study. The survey instrument focused on socio-ecological variables that may influence abundance of P. irritans in households including demographics, sleeping arrangement, presence of animals, behavioral practices related to home hygiene, and attitudes towards rodents and fleas (S1 File). Observational data related to household characteristics such as building materials and presence/absence of animal housing were also collected.
Flea sampling
Fleas were sampled twice in the four villages, once during the dry season (June–July 2022) and once during the rainy season (November 2021 in Nanda and October 2022 for the three other villages). Fleas were sampled via candle trap method [30]. Briefly, a candle (21.5 cm in height and 1.5 cm in diameter) was lit in the middle of a pale-colored enamel plate (diameter = 22.5 cm) containing water mixed with a pinch of laundry powder. Fleas attracted by the candlelight fell into soapy water and died. Each household received one candle trap per night for three consecutive nights. Candle traps were placed in a room chosen by each head of the household (typically the bedroom) and lit before bedtime, burning until the wick reached the water level (about eight hours). Fleas were collected the following morning one by one, placed on blotting paper to remove excess water, and stored in separate 1.5 ml vials containing 70% ethanol using fine-tip entomological forceps. Flea species were later identified based on morphology using an identification key [31] and individuals of each species were counted at 25X magnification.
Data analysis
The factors associated with P. irritans abundance in households were analyzed using two approaches where the outcome variable was characterized as raw flea count per household (Model 1) or a binomial categorization of P. irritans index per household based on simulated plague transmission risk (Model 2). Variables were selected a priori according to relevant scientific literature [3–8] and the research team members’ own experiences (see Table 1). Variables were excluded if there was too much homogeneity (<20% in a level) in the dataset and were included in the model if there was low collinearity (assessed using “VIF”, variance inflation factor function from the R package “car” [32]). Both Models 1 and 2 were conducted on flea data from the dry season only (when interviews were conducted).
Model 1 focused on risk factors for flea abundance as measured by P. irritans count per household (totaled across three consecutive sampling nights) using a generalized linear mixed model, which included a random effect for village and utilized a negative binomial distribution to account for overdispersion in flea counts.
Model 2 explored the potential for flea abundance sufficient for plague transmission [17,33,34] by modeling the risk factors associated with a household exhibiting a density of P. irritans per person greater than or equal to that estimated to sustain person-to-person transmission of Y. pestis as has been done previously [17], based on P. irritans vector competence during early phase transmission [21]. Model assumptions accounting vector competence included that: infectious fleas could locate human hosts, early phase transmission was the primary mode of vector transmission, all hosts were equally sought and bitten by fleas [17,33] and parameters were similar for fleas from different populations. The average number of fleas per person required to sustain transmission (m) was modeled as follows:
Eq 1
In the equation, R0 represented the average number of secondary infections and was set at R0 = 1 to model minimum sustained transmission at a population level [34]. The daily biting rate of P. irritans, a, was described using a beta distribution based on a recent laboratory study in which 230 of 280 P. irritans fed daily on human blood [21]. The probability of acquiring and transmitting Y. pestis during early phase transmission (within 24-hours of infectious blood meal), b, was described using a beta distribution based on the same study, which found that 15 of 181 P. irritans transmitted Y. pestis. The probability of P. irritans surviving the extrinsic incubation period (here, the 24-hours of early phase transmission), pn, was estimated to be one, because nearly all fleas survived this short period [17,21]. The average life expectancy of the human host following the threshold septicemia, 1/r, was estimated as two days based on previous reports [27,35]. Then, using 10,000 simulated random draws from beta distributions for a and b, a distribution for m was generated using R Studio software [32].
Households were categorized as at “higher infestation risk” when Pii (P. irritans index, the total number of P. irritans collected in a household across three nights divided by the household size) ≥ mean (m) or households were categorized at “lower infestation risk” when Pii < mean (m), referring to household plague transmission via P. irritans if a single person were infected.
A binomial generalized linear model was used to identify risk factors for a household being at “higher infestation risk” based on this Pii categorization from the dry season. Village was treated as a fixed effect because the model failed to converge with random effects. A sensitivity analysis was performed with lower and upper 95% confidence intervals of m. Seasonality of P. irritans was assessed by comparing total flea number per village between seasons using an ANOVA test. All analyses were conducted using R Studio software [32]. R codes and data are available at OSF.
Results
A total of 126 households were visited in the four villages. Of the households visited, 82.54% participated in all components of the study during both wet and dry seasons. Five heads of household declined to participate in the interview but participated in the flea sampling component. In addition, 12 households only participated in one season of flea sampling, and an additional five households ended involvement prematurely. Only households that gave interview consent and where flea sampling was conducted during both seasons were included in analyses (n = 104).
Mean household size was four and ranged from one to 14. Most respondents were women (83.16%), but men (i.e., husband, father, son, or older brother) were usually identified as head of household (81.73%). Among household heads, 24.04% were identified as single (female = 18.27%, male = 5.77%), 58.76% had not finished primary school, 41.35% reported having at least one household member sleeping on the floor (without an elevated bedframe), and 69.23% reported at least one household member using a mosquito net at night on a regular basis.
Most enrolled households resided in houses constructed in traditional fashion (S2 File) for the southern part of the Central Highlands of Madagascar with three-stories (ground floor, first floor and attic) and at least two rooms per level (S3 File). Residents usually slept on the first floor and the kitchen was usually in the attic. Most families kept livestock on the ground floor at night (78.85%), and animal enclosures and pens were observed in proximity to many homes (57.28%). Most households (85.58%) owned livestock, with an average of nine animals per household. A summary of household characteristics is presented in Table 1.
Most floors were either dirt covered with a woven plant fiber mat (66.35%), wooden boards (23.08%), or concrete (5.77%). Other material types such as vinyl sheets and tarps were infrequently observed. House floor cleaning was done daily for 83.65% of respondents. Walls were generally constructed of sun-dried or baked clay bricks, or of mud blocks. In some homes, interior and exterior walls were plastered with a mixture of sand, mud, and/or cement. Roofs were either baked clay tiles (34.62%), thatched (33.65%), or corrugated iron sheet (31.73%).
Rodents were reported in 75.96% of homes, dominated by the house mouse (Mus musculus) (69.23%) and the black rat (Rattus rattus) (25.96%). Flea nuisance was a common problem in the communities (Table 2), with 50.98% of heads of households reporting that they or family members experienced severe flea nuisance (bites, scratches or the sensation of fleas crawling on body) in the last two months. Flea nuisance was mostly experienced at night (80.77%) and in bed and/or in the bedroom (79.49%). In addition, 73.03% of heads of households reported experiencing more intense flea nuisance with warmer temperatures (wet season). Domestic insecticide use was a common practice (Table 2), with 58.81% of households having used insecticide in the last two months and 80.77% having used chemical insecticide to control household pests at some point. Most participants bought insecticide from the local market and only 52.22% could give the name (brand or commercial name) of insecticide used, 79.01% of which were bought in liquid form and 8.64% as powder. The primary target of domestic insecticide treatments were fleas (67.80%), followed by cockroaches (27.97%), and mosquitoes (7.63%).
Candle traps were set in rooms according to head of household directive, with 65.38% placed on the 1st floor, 24.04% in the attic, and 10.58% on the ground floor. The head of household usually chooses the bedroom (74.36%). In some instances, the room in which the trap was set served as a bedroom and kitchen (20.51%), as a spare room where nobody was sleeping (4.27%) or kitchen (1.70%).
A total of 9,352 fleas were collected from 126 houses investigated, with 98.18% (n = 9,182) being P. irritans and the remainder identified as C. felis (n = 154), E. gallinacea (n = 11), and T. penetrans (n = 5). Flea species distribution per village and per season is summarized in Table 3. Household flea prevalence was 99.03% during the dry season and 98.08% during the rainy season. The number of fleas collected did not differ per village when compared between seasons (Fig 2).
ALA: Alakamisy Ambohimaha (p-value = 0.461), AMB: Ambohipanalinana (p-value = 0.435), NAN: Nanda (p-value = 0.530), SOA: Soafandry (p-value = 0.904). Black diamond-shaped points inside the boxes are mean values. Horizontal bars in boxes are the 50th percentiles (medians), and the bottom and the top of the box represent the 25th and the 75th percentiles, respectively. The two limits of vertical lines above and at the bottom of the box are the whiskers and represent the maximum and the minimum values of the data. Points outside the limit of vertical line are “outlier,” which are values outside 95% of the confidence interval.
Since P. irritans represented >98% of fleas recovered, only number of P. irritans was considered as outcome variable in both models. The mixed model of flea abundance (P. irritans count; Model 1, Table 4) demonstrated a strong association with household size, where households with more than four members had 1.92 times increased flea counts compared to households with fewer than four members, (p = 0.03, 95%CI: 1.08–3.41; Table 4). Households keeping chickens indoors at night had 1.75 times higher P. irritans count compared to those not keeping chickens indoors (p = 0.03, 95% CI: 1.07–2.28; Table 4). Households with rodent activity and keeping cows indoors at night (Table 4) also had increased flea counts though these estimates were marginally non-significant, indicating that increased precision through larger sample sizes may improve our estimate.
To emphasize the potential epidemiologic significance of observed P. irritans infestation, the model dichotomizing households into high and low interhuman Y. pestis transmission risk utilized a threshold for Pii = 7.43 (CI 95%: 7.31–7.55; Table 4) as simulated by vector competence modeling. Thirty-four out of 104 (32.70%) households exhibited a Pii over 7.43, suggesting increased risk for sustained interhuman Y. pestis transmission based on vector competence modeling. Households which never used insecticides for pest control had increased odds of higher infestation risk compared to those which had used insecticides (aOR = 7.39, p = 0.02, 95% CI: 1.53 -– 47.33; Table 4). Households with floors made of concrete or board, as opposed to traditional fiber mats had lower odds of being in high-risk infestation households (aOR = 0.085, p = 0.04, 95% CI: 0.01–0.70; Table 4). Surprisingly, households with heads who had not finished primary school had lower odds of high infestation risk (aOR = 0.19, p = 0.05, 95% CI: 0.03–0.92; Table 4). A large aOR was found for primitive roof types (i.e., thatch), indicating increased odds higher Y. pestis transmission risk, though the effect was non-significant with wide confidence intervals (aOR = 3.86, p = 0.18, 95% CI: 0.59–34.78; Table 4). Households keeping chickens indoors at night and reporting rodent activity also had increased odds of high infestation risk, though these estimates were marginally non-significant (aOR = 4.20, p = 0.08, 95% CI: 0.01–24.0 for indoor chickens; aOR = 6.64, p = 0.02, 95% CI: 1.53–47.33 for rodent activity; Table 4), suggesting that improved precision is necessary to better estimate this association. These results were robust to the m simulation for Pii thresholds (S4 File).
Discussion
Our observations of high household flea infestation rates dominated by the human flea P. irritans reinforce the findings of previous studies in rural Madagascar [19,22,23,36]. Furthermore, flea number captured per household in our study were high compared to adjusted averages reported in other countries using comparable sampling techniques [18,37–39]. Consistent with other studies, the number of fleas was found to be highly variable among households within the same village emphasizing the likely role of household characteristics [19,23].
Madagascar is one of the countries where plague remains a public health concern. During the last two decades, there have been more than 13,000 human plague cases in Madagascar with a fatality rate of ~27% [27]. Our findings suggest that households in plague-endemic areas of Madagascar are frequently but heterogeneously infested by P. irritans, a flea species that has been found infected by the plague bacterium during previous epidemics in Madagascar and elsewhere [20,22,40]. Although the vector capacity of P. irritans is unknown, in Tanzania, the density and distribution of P. irritans was associated with plague frequency and plague incidence [18]. Laboratory transmission tests showed that P. irritans was a less potent vector than rodent fleas [20,21] but high household flea burden may facilitate an interhuman transmission event [20].
Based on laboratory data [21] and flea transmission modeling using the vectorial capacity equation for early-phase Y. pestis transmission following published procedures [17], a household infestation of more than seven P. irritans per person per household (Pii>7.43) was estimated to potentially sustain interhuman transmission of Y. pestis should the pathogen be present in this vector-host ecosystem. A third of surveyed households were in the higher risk category of high Pii, presenting a considerable threat of sustained Y. pestis transmission vectored solely by P. irritans. It is unlikely that a plague outbreak would be sustained solely by P. irritans, however, while the proportion of transmission events attributed to P. irritans may be low in the presence of more competent vectors, this additional route deserves more attention from epidemiologists. Since P. irritans was the most abundant species found in human domiciles, modeling based on this assumption was a first step toward exploring the role which P. irritans may play in local outbreaks. [20]
This study identifies factors associated with increased flea abundance that also place households in this plague-endemic area at increased risk of sustained transmission if flea were exposed to circulating Y. pestis. The results suggest several modifiable environmental features, including household construction materials associated with high flea infestation.
Certain floor types (i.e., concrete and board) were negatively associated with flea abundance, providing a protective effect. Previous studies reported that thorough and frequent floor cleaning could remove fleas of all developmental stages, as well as organic particles on which larvae feed, and thus could reduce flea infestations [4,41]. Most households reported daily floor sweeping (Table 1), although the dirt floor under the mat covering would be left undisturbed. The use of smoother flooring materials, such as board or concrete, may allow more thorough cleaning and may explain the protective effect demonstrated in our model. Indeed, studies involving other flea species mentioned earthen floor as one of the risk factors for the prevalence of flea infestations or flea-induced skin disorders [25,42–44]. Flea immature stages are very susceptible to desiccation [2,45], and earthen floor covered with plant fiber mats may offer immature fleas the best conditions for survival.
Although the results did not achieve statistical significance and lack precision, the substantial effect size observed for primitive roof types (e.g., thatch) being linked to an increased likelihood of falling into the higher Y. pestis transmission risk category implies a potentially noteworthy role for this construction material. However, it is essential to note the need for further investigation to validate these preliminary findings. Organic material such as thatch may offer a more stable environment for insect development, as reported for other vectors [46]. Interestingly, another study that examined plague epidemiological data and household characteristics also associated thatched roof with human plague risk [26]. Although flea abundance was not among factors studied, thatched roofs favored human contact with the black rat and their fleas.
House construction materials may also reflect household income. In this study, individual household gross income was not assessed directly, but the national census reported that a mat floor and thatch roof are among the housing material characteristics of the poorest households in Madagascar [47]. With 88% of the rural population living under the International Poverty Line, house building materials choice would be biased toward locally sourced and thus, more affordable materials. Therefore, any action to alleviate flea burden should prioritize the most vulnerable households in the community. On a national scale, 77.8% of the Malagasy rural population live in houses constructed of non-durable materials, including 41.8% woven plant fiber mats, and 66.5% plant-derived roof materials [47]. Since insecticide treatment has little effect on P irritans infestation [23], improved house construction programs offer the most promise for mitigating infestations. This study identified strategic home modifications against P. irritans infestation that also align with non-profit and government goals. Increasing the number of households with more durable and easier to clean floor types would likely benefit the entire community by reducing flea infestation prevalence at village level. As reported for programs targeting other vectors, house improvement generated other health benefits and increased inhabitant life quality [48].
Keeping any livestock indoors at night was among the risk factors identified. Although the odds ratios of keeping pigs and chicken indoors at night were non-significant with plague risk analysis (Model 2), the analysis of factors affecting flea abundance (Model 1) showed that keeping chickens indoors at night increases the odds of having P. irritans infestation (Table 4). Raising chicken was among the risk factor for house flea infestation in a study conducted in China [25] and chicken DNA was among the host genetic material detected in wild-caught P. irritans in DR Congo [49]. In this study, 66.35% of the households raised chicken and more than 60% kept them indoors at night. Therefore, keeping those animals in separate structures may alleviate flea burden. In Madagascar livestock housing choice may vary according to region, climate, and farming practices [50]. Unfortunately, in the study area, livestock were usually kept on the ground floor at night, due to concern of theft, which may promote flea infestation and increase the disease transmission risk. These animals are among potential hosts for adult P. irritans in Madagascar since this species has been collected in pig pens [30] and on chickens [51]. In other countries, this flea species has also been found infesting various livestock including chickens and pigs, [3,5,52]. However, without host blood source identification from field-caught fleas, it is difficult to establish a clear link between flea abundance and any animal presence. In addition, animal waste was pointed out as a potential source of flea reinfestation in cattle since manure accumulation is a source of heat, humidity, and organic material favorable for flea larvae development [3,52].
Domestic insecticide use was highlighted as a common practice for flea control in our study. The model suggested that insecticide use against any household pest might be a factor that influenced flea infestation. The elevated prevalence of P. irritans infestation may elucidate the necessity for employing domestic insecticides to mitigate the perceived nuisance as reflected in Table 2. Nonetheless, our analysis revealed an elevated adjusted odds ratio with wide confidence interval (Table 4), emphasizing the need for caution in interpreting the possible effect due to the considerable uncertainty. Although our model showed that chemical insecticides may have a protective function against high flea abundance, there are concerns for the long-term efficacy of this method due to insecticide resistance. Previous studies in Madagascar suggested that insecticide treatment deployed during plague outbreaks were inefficient for the P. irritans [23,24]. However, insecticide resistance in P. irritans has never been investigated in Madagascar. This is especially concerning as most of study participants could not recall the name of insecticides used. This lack of household knowledge surrounding insecticide use could lead to mismanagement of chemicals that may induce insecticide resistance in P. irritans and other flea species over time.
Seasonal abundance among rodent flea has been correlated with climatic factors in the Central Highlands of Madagascar [45,53], with higher flea indices observed in the beginning of the rainy season, which coincides with the onset of bubonic plague transmission [54]. In this study a seasonal pattern for P. irritans abundance was not established despite interview respondents reporting more intense flea nuisance during the rainy season (Table 2). Since rodent flea abundance depends also on rodent host physiology and reproduction [36], P. irritans appear to benefit from a more stable home environment. However, our findings are limited by small sample size and the fact that our study represents only a snapshot in time for both seasons.
Rodent presence was examined in this study, since rodents are the host of many flea species, including P. irritans [55]. Interestingly, P. irritans has rarely been found infesting rodents in Madagascar and thus, might not be the primary host for this flea species [22,53]. Analysis of homeowner responses concerning perceptions of flea nuisance (Table 2) suggests a potential scenario where this species is feeding on humans. Interestingly, we found a positive association between household size and P. irritans abundance. Households with more than four members have, on average, 1.92 times higher odds of experiencing P. irritans infestation (Table 4). Consequently, the larger family size may offer an increased opportunity for fleas to access blood meals and sustain a larger flea population. Moreover, in larger households, diverse activities may increase flea exposure. Similar trends were observed in Ethiopia regarding tungiasis [43,44], and in Bogota regarding flea-induced skin disorder [42], indicating higher risks for children going to school, from larger families, and those using public transportation. Research in China suggests that floor fleas can transfer between houses, especially in larger villages [25]. Sampling fleas in shared spaces like schools, churches, and public transportation could be valuable for future investigations.
Our results demonstrated that the odds of a high flea infestation index varied by village. This effect could be due to the proportion of households per village presenting one or several risk factors. Although no village level factors were included in the present model, it has been demonstrated elsewhere that village size, distance between homes, proportion of households raising chickens, and presence of a central waste disposal area can influence the prevalence of off-host fleas [25]. These village-level factors may influence P. irritans ecology and deserve to be investigated further in the future.
One of the main plague risk indicators is the flea index, which is obtained by dividing number of fleas by number of hosts sampled [56]. The same method was applied to obtain a house or nest index for off-host fleas [16]. The P. irritans index calculated in this study estimated human exposure to flea bites capable of sustaining plague transmission for each household. This index was obtained by dividing the total number of P. irritans collected during three successive nights by household size. A limitation of our study was that the sampling method underestimates the number of fleas collected in the household, since only a single room per household was sampled. Furthermore, our model assumed that members of the same household were equally exposed to flea bite risk, whereas the odds of being bitten by fleas may vary even between individuals within a household [5]. More extensive sampling, including more household rooms, would give a better estimate of a household’s flea population. Another limitation of our study was the scarcity of P. irritans vector competence studies [21]. Our model was based on poor vector competence of P. irritans collected from owls and foxes, which may under-estimate vector competence of human-adapted strains that may bite more frequently [21]. Therefore, the strength of the model could be improved by incorporating more in vivo values of vector competence on the human-adapted strains from plague-endemic areas of Madagascar. Entomological parameters such as biting rates, host preferences, and daily survivorship of infected P. irritans, must also be further explored to quantify the role of P. irritans in plague epidemics in Madagascar.
Conclusions
The present study confirms that P. irritans infestation is a neglected nuisance in rural households in Madagascar. Since this flea species does become naturally infected with the plague bacterium, further studies concerning its biology, ecology, and vector competence are wanted. Our results demonstrate that one third of investigated households in plague endemic areas of Madagascar were exposed to a high P. irritans index, putting them at risk of sustained interhuman plague transmission, should the fleas or a household member become infected. Furthermore, infestation risk was more pronounced for poor households living in homes made with organic materials, and in close contact with livestock. The factors identified in this analysis suggest that improvement of housing and better management of livestock would alleviate flea burden and potential plague risk in rural plague-endemic villages experiencing high flea infestation.
Supporting information
S2 File. Photos of the traditional three-story house in the central highland of Madagascar with various roof type.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0012036.s002
(PDF)
S3 File. Diagram of three-story traditional house in the central highland of Madagascar, with common use of each level.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0012036.s003
(PDF)
S4 File. Sensitivity analysis of the infestation at high risk for interhuman Y. pestis transmission using m upper and lower cut-off values.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0012036.s004
(PDF)
Acknowledgments
We thank Centre Valbio Ranomafana for logistical support; Andrianirina O. Rafanambinantsoa, Paul JN. Niaina, Jean-Francois A. Randrianasolo, Farida Juliette and Mandimby A, Rajaonarimanana, for assistance with flea collection and interview. We are also grateful to Belen Santana-Godinez for her contribution to the early conception of the project, to Pr. Josef Zeyer for his critical review and insightful comments which improved the manuscript, and to Dr. Mireille Harimalala for hosting the students working on this project in her research group at Institut Pasteur de Madagascar. We also want to extend our gratitude to the study participants and the authorities in the villages visited.
References
- 1.
Durden LA, Traub R. Fleas (Siphonaptera). In: Mullen R G, Durden LA, editors. Medical and Veterinary Entomology. Academic Press; 2002.
- 2. Bitam I, Dittmar K, Parola P, Whiting MMF, Raoult D. Fleas and flea-borne diseases. International Journal of Infectious Diseases [Internet]. 2010;14(8):e667–76. Available from: pmid:20189862
- 3. Christodoulopoulos G, Theodoropoulos G, Kominakis A, Theis JH. Biological, seasonal and environmental factors associated with Pulex irritans infestation of dairy goats in Greece. Vet Parasitol. 2006 Apr 15;137(1–2):137–43. pmid:16414195
- 4. Dahm JR, Bailey JB, Kelly RF, Chikungwa P, Chulu J, Junior LC, et al. Risk factors associated with Ctenocephalides felis flea infestation of peri-urban goats: a neglected parasite in an under-appreciated host. Trop Anim Health Prod. 2021 Dec;53(1):1–11.
- 5. Rahbari S, Nabian S, Nourolahi F, Arabkhazaeli F, Ebrahimzadeh E. Flea infestation in farm animals and its health implication. Iran J Parasitol [Internet]. 2008 [cited 2019 Apr 24];3(2):43–7. Available from: http://ijpa.tums.ac.ir/index.php/ijpa/article/view/61
- 6. Gizaw Z, Engdaw GT, Nigusie A, Gebrehiwot M, Destaw B. Human Ectoparasites Are Highly Prevalent in the Rural Communities of Northwest Ethiopia: A Community-Based Cross-Sectional Study. Environ Health Insights [Internet]. 2021;15. Available from: pmid:34366670
- 7. McNair CM. Ectoparasites of medical and veterinary importance: Drug resistance and the need for alternative control methods [Internet]. Vol. 67, Journal of Pharmacy and Pharmacology. Blackwell Publishing Ltd; 2015 [cited 2023 Mar 13]. p. 351–63. Available from: https://academic.oup.com/jpp/article-abstract/67/3/351/6128192
- 8. Wafula ST, Ssemugabo C, Namuhani N, Musoke D, Ssempebwa J, Halage AA. Prevalence and risk factors associated with Tungiasis in Mayuge district, Eastern Uganda. Pan African Medical Journal [Internet]. 2016 [cited 2022 Jul 9];24. Available from: /pmc/articles/PMC5012786/ pmid:27642416
- 9. Gage KL. Fleas, the Siphonaptera. In: Marquardt WC, editor. Biology of Diseases Vectors. Second edi. Dana Dreibelbis; 2004. p. 77.
- 10.
Mullen GR, Durden LA. Medical and veterinary entomology. Academic press; 2002.
- 11. Prasad R. Host dependency among haematophagous insects: a case study on flea-host association. Proc Indian Acad Sci (Anim Sci) [Internet]. 1987 [cited 2022 Nov 25];96(4):349–60. Available from: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF03179588
- 12. Rakotonanahary RJL, Harrison A, Maina AN, Jiang J, Richards AL, Rajerison M, et al. Molecular and serological evidence of flea-associated typhus group and spotted fever group rickettsial infections in Madagascar. Parasit Vectors. 2017 Mar 4;10(1). pmid:28259176
- 13. Ehlers J, Krüger A, Rakotondranary SJ, Ratovonamana RY, Poppert S, Ganzhorn JU, et al. Molecular detection of Rickettsia spp., Borrelia spp., Bartonella spp. and Yersinia pestis in ectoparasites of endemic and domestic animals in southwest Madagascar. Acta Trop [Internet]. 2020 Jan 11 [cited 2020 Jan 15];205:105339. Available from: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0001706X19315700#! pmid:31935354
- 14. Vallès X, Stenseth NChr, Demeure C, Horby P, Mead PS, Cabanillas O, et al. Human plague: An old scourge that needs new answers. PLoS Negl Trop Dis [Internet]. 2020 Aug 27;14(8):e0008251. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0008251
- 15. Gage KL, Kosoy MY. Natural history of plague: perspectives from more than a century of research. Annu Rev Entomol. 2005;50(50):505–28. pmid:15471529
- 16.
Gratz N. Rodent Reservoirs & Flea Vectors of Natural Foci of Plague. In: Plague Manual Epidemiology, Distribution, Surveillance and Control—World Health Organization. 1999. p. 63–96.
- 17. Eisen RJ, Borchert JN, Holmes JL, Amatre G, Van Wyk K, Enscore RE, et al. Early-phase transmission of Yersinia pestis by cat fleas (Ctenocephalides felis) and their potential role as vectors in a plague-endemic region of Uganda. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene. 2008;78(6):949–56. pmid:18541775
- 18. Laudisoit A, Leirs H, Makundi RH, Van Dongen S, Davis S, Neerinckx S, et al. Plague and the human flea, Tanzania. Emerg Infect Dis. 2007;13(5):687–93. pmid:17553245
- 19. Rahelinirina S, Harimalala M, Rakotoniaina J, Randriamanantsoa MG, Dentinger C, Zohdy S, et al. Tracking of Mammals and Their Fleas for Plague Surveillance in Madagascar, 2018–2019. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene. 2022;106(6):1601–9. pmid:35436762
- 20. Blanc G, Baltazard M. Recherches sur le mode de transmission naturelle de la peste bubonique et septicemique. Vol. Tome 3, Archives de l’Institut Pasteur du Maroc. 1945. 173–354 p.
- 21. Miarinjara A, Bland DM, Belthoff JR, Hinnebusch BJ. Poor vector competence of the human flea, Pulex irritans, to transmit Yersinia pestis. Parasit Vectors [Internet]. 2021 Dec 10 [cited 2021 Jun 10];14(1):317. Available from: https://parasitesandvectors.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s13071-021-04805-3 pmid:34112224
- 22. Ratovonjato J, Rajerison M, Rahelinirina S, Boyer S. Yersinia pestis in Pulex irritans fleas during plague outbreak, Madagascar. Emerg Infect Dis [Internet]. 2014 [cited 2016 Feb 23];20(8):1414–5. Available from: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4111190/ pmid:25061697
- 23. Miarinjara A, Rahelinirina S, Razafimahatratra LN, Girod R, Boyer S, Razafimahatratra NL, et al. Field assessment of insecticide dusting and bait station treatment impact against rodent flea and house flea species in the Madagascar plague context. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2019;13(8):e0007604. pmid:31386661
- 24. Rakotoarisoa A, Ramihangihajason T, Ramarokoto C, Rahelinirina S, Halm A, Piola P, et al. Bubonic Plague Outbreak Investigation in the Endemic District of Tsiroanomandidy—Madagascar, October 2014. Journal of Cases Report and Studies. 2016;5(1):1–6.
- 25. Yin JX, Geater A, Chongsuvivatwong V, Dong XQ, Du CH, Zhong YH. Predictors for abundance of host flea and floor flea in households of villages with endemic commensal rodent plague, Yunnan Province, China. PLoS Negl Trop Dis [Internet]. 2011 Jan 29 [cited 2015 May 9];5(3):e997. Available from: http://journals.plos.org/plosntds/article?id=10.1371/journal.pntd.0000997 pmid:21468306
- 26. Rakotosamimanana S, Taglioni F, Ravaoarimanga M, Rajerison ME, Rakotomanana F. Socioenvironmental determinants as indicators of plague risk in the central highlands of Madagascar: Experience of Ambositra and Tsiroanomandidy districts. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2023;17(9):e0011538. pmid:37672517
- 27. Andrianaivoarimanana V, Piola P, Wagner DM, Rakotomanana F, Maheriniaina V, Andrianalimanana S, et al. Trends of Human Plague, Madagascar, 1998–2016. Emerg Infect Dis [Internet]. 2019 Feb [cited 2019 Jan 29];25(2):220–8. Available from: http://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/25/2/17-1974_article.htm pmid:30666930
- 28. Rakotosamimanana S, Kassie D, Taglioni F, Ramamonjisoa J, Rakotomanana F, Rajerison M. A decade of plague in Madagascar: a description of two hotspot districts. BMC Public Health. 2021;21(1):1–9.
- 29. Brislin RW. Back-translation for cross-cultural research. J Cross Cult Psychol. 1970;1(3):185–216.
- 30. Brygoo E, Rajenison S. Puces et rats d’un village de l’itasy, en zone d’endémie pesteuse. Archives de l’ Institut Pasteur de Madagascar Inst Pasteur Madagascar. 1960;28:109–24.
- 31. Harimalala M, Ramihangihajason TR, Rakotobe Harimanana R, Girod R, Duchemin JB. Illustrated Morphological Keys for Fleas (Siphonaptera) in Madagascar. J Med Entomol. 2021;58(4):1701–16. pmid:33822101
- 32.
R Core Team. R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing [Internet]. R Foundation for Statistical Computing Vienna Austria. Vienna, Austria: R Foundation for Statistical Computing; 2022. Available from: http://www.r-project.org/
- 33. Eisen RJ, Bearden SW, Wilder AP, Montenieri JA, Antolin MF, Gage KL. Early-phase transmission of Yersinia pestis by unblocked fleas as a mechanism explaining rapidly spreading plague epizootics. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A [Internet]. 2006;103(42):15380–5. Available from: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17032761\nhttp://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=PMC1592641 pmid:17032761
- 34. Lorange EA, Race B, Sebbane F, Hinnebusch BJ. Poor Vector Competence of Fleas and the Evolution of Hypervirulence in Yersinia pestis. J Infect Dis [Internet]. 2005 Jun 1 [cited 2015 Nov 11];191(11):1907–12. Available from: http://jid.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/content/long/191/11/1907 pmid:15871125
- 35. Teh WL, Chun JWH, Pollitzer R. Clinical observations upon the manchurian plague epidemic, 1920–21. Journal of Hygiene. 1923;21(3):298–306. pmid:20474781
- 36. Rahelinirina S, Scobie K, Ramasindrazana B, Andrianaivoarimanana V, Rasoamalala F, Randriantseheno LN, et al. Rodent control to fight plague: field assessment of methods based on rat density reduction. Integr Zool [Internet]. 2021 Mar 30 [cited 2021 Apr 21];16(6):868–85. Available from: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/1749-4877.12529 pmid:33694282
- 37. Haule M, Lyamuya EE, Hang’ombe BM, Kilonzo BS, Matee MI. Investigation of fleas as vectors in the transmission of plague during a quiescent period in North-Eastern, Tanzania. J Entomol Nematol. 2013;5(7):88–93.
- 38. Kilonzo BS, Makundi RH, Mbise TJ. A decade of plague epidemiology and control in the Western Usambara mountains, north-east Tanzania. Acta Trop [Internet]. 1992 Apr [cited 2018 May 7];50(4):323–9. Available from: http://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/0001706X92900678 pmid:1356303
- 39. Mwalimu CD, Mgode G, Sabuni C, Msigwa F, Mghamba J, Nyanga A, et al. Preliminary investigation and intervention of the suspected plague outbreak in Madunga, Babati District-Tanzania. Acta Trop. 2022 Sep 1;233:106566. pmid:35724712
- 40. Karimi Y, Eftekhari M, Almeida CR. Sur L’écologie des puces impliquées dans L’épidemiologie de la peste et le rôle éventuel de certains insectes hématophages dans son processus au nord-est du Brésil. Vol. 67, Bulletin de la Société de Pathologie Exotique. 1974. p. 583–91.
- 41. Dryden M, Neal J, Bennett G. Concepts of flea control. Companion animal practice. 1989;19(4–5):11–20.
- 42. Halpert E, Borrero E, Ibañez-Pinilla M, Chaparro P, Molina J, Torres M, et al. Prevalence of papular urticaria caused by flea bites and associated factors in children 1–6 years of age in Bogotá, D.C. World Allergy Organization Journal. 2017 Nov 7;10(1):36.
- 43. Hyuga A, Larson PS, Ndemwa M, Muuo SW, Changoma M, Karama M, et al. Environmental and household-based spatial risks for tungiasis in an endemic area of coastal Kenya. Trop Med Infect Dis [Internet]. 2022 Dec 23 [cited 2023 Feb 9];7(1):2. Available from: https://www.mdpi.com/2414-6366/7/1/2
- 44. Jorga SD, Dessie YL, Kedir MR, Donacho DO. Prevalence of Tungiasis and its risk factors of among children of Mettu woreda, southwest Ethiopia, 2020. PLoS One. 2022 Jan 1;17(1 January). pmid:34986188
- 45. Kreppel KS, Telfer S, Rajerison M, Morse A, Baylis M. Effect of temperature and relative humidity on the development times and survival of Synopsyllus fonquerniei and Xenopsylla cheopis, the flea vectors of plague in Madagascar. Parasit Vectors. 2016;9(1). pmid:26864070
- 46. Lindsay SW, Jawara M, Mwesigwa J, Achan J, Bayoh N, Bradley J, et al. Reduced mosquito survival in metal-roof houses may contribute to a decline in malaria transmission in sub-Saharan Africa. Sci Rep. 2019;9(1):1–10.
- 47. Institut national de statistique de Madagascar (INSTAT). Rapport thématique sur les résultats du RGPH-3 thème 5: Habitation et Cadre de Vie de la Population. 2021.
- 48. Castro-Arroyave D, Monroy MC, Irurita MI. Integrated vector control of Chagas disease in Guatemala: a case of social innovation in health. Infect Dis Poverty [Internet]. 2020 Apr 14 [cited 2023 Nov 6];9(1):1–9. Available from: https://idpjournal.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s40249-020-00639-w
- 49. Woods ME, Montenieri JA, Eisen RJ, Zeidner NS, Borchert JN, Laudisoit A, et al. Identification of flea blood meals using multiplexed real-time polymerase chain reaction targeting mitochondrial gene fragments. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene. 2009;80(6):998–1003. pmid:19478265
- 50. Costard S, Porphyre V, Messad S, Rakotondrahanta S, Vidon H, Roger F, et al. Multivariate analysis of management and biosecurity practices in smallholder pig farms in Madagascar. Prev Vet Med. 2009;92(3):199–209. pmid:19781801
- 51. Ehlers J, Poppert S, Ratovonamana RY, Ganzhorn JU, Tappe D, Krüger A. Ectoparasites of endemic and domestic animals in southwest Madagascar. Acta Trop [Internet]. 2019;196:83–92. Available from: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0001706X19301731 pmid:31082365
- 52. Moemenbellah-Fard MD, Shahriari B, Azizi K, Fakoorziba MR, Mohammadi J, Amin M. Faunal distribution of fleas and their blood-feeding preferences using enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays from farm animals and human shelters in a new rural region of southern Iran. Journal of Parasitic Diseases [Internet]. 2016 Mar [cited 2019 Apr 24];40(1):169–75. Available from: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27065620 pmid:27065620
- 53. Rasoamalala F, Gostic K, Parany MJ, Rahelinirina S, Rahajandraibe S, Gorgé O, et al. Population dynamics of plague vector fleas in an endemic focus: implications for plague surveillance. J Med Entomol. 2023;61(1):201–11.
- 54. Andrianaivoarimanana V, Kreppel K, Elissa N, Duplantier JMM, Carniel E, Rajerison M, et al. Understanding the persistence of plague foci in Madagascar. PLoS Negl Trop Dis [Internet]. 2013 [cited 2015 Aug 17];7(11):e2382. Available from: http://dx.plos.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0002382 pmid:24244760
- 55. Buckland PC, Sadler JP. A Biogeography of the Human Flea, Pulex irritans L. (Siphonaptera: Pulicidae). J Biogeogr [Internet]. 1989 Mar [cited 2018 May 7];16(2):115. Available from: https://www.jstor.org/stable/2845085?origin=crossref
- 56.
Pollitzer R. Plague. Vol. 229, World Health Organization Monograph Series. No 22. Geneva Switzerland; 1954.