Advertisement
Browse Subject Areas
?

Click through the PLOS taxonomy to find articles in your field.

For more information about PLOS Subject Areas, click here.

  • Loading metrics

Open Access

Peer-reviewed

Research Article

Differential Responses of Calcifying and Non-Calcifying Epibionts of a Brown Macroalga to Present-Day and Future Upwelling pCO2

Abstract

Seaweeds are key species of the Baltic Sea benthic ecosystems. They are the substratum of numerous fouling epibionts like bryozoans and tubeworms. Several of these epibionts bear calcified structures and could be impacted by the high pCO2 events of the late summer upwellings in the Baltic nearshores. Those events are expected to increase in strength and duration with global change and ocean acidification. If calcifying epibionts are impacted by transient acidification as driven by upwelling events, their increasing prevalence could cause a shift of the fouling communities toward fleshy species. The aim of the present study was to test the sensitivity of selected seaweed macrofoulers to transient elevation of pCO2 in their natural microenvironment, i.e. the boundary layer covering the thallus surface of brown seaweeds. Fragments of the macroalga Fucus serratus bearing an epibiotic community composed of the calcifiers Spirorbis spirorbis (Annelida) and Electra pilosa (Bryozoa) and the non-calcifier Alcyonidium hirsutum (Bryozoa) were maintained for 30 days under three pCO2 conditions: natural 460±59 µatm, present-day upwelling1193±166 µatm and future upwelling 3150±446 µatm. Only the highest pCO2 caused a significant reduction of growth rates and settlement of S. spirorbis individuals. Additionally, S. spirorbis settled juveniles exhibited enhanced calcification of 40% during daylight hours compared to dark hours, possibly reflecting a day-night alternation of an acidification-modulating effect by algal photosynthesis as opposed to an acidification-enhancing effect of algal respiration. E. pilosa colonies showed significantly increased growth rates at intermediate pCO2 (1193 µatm) but no response to higher pCO2. No effect of acidification on A. hirsutum colonies growth rates was observed. The results suggest a remarkable resistance of the algal macro-epibionts to levels of acidification occurring at present day upwellings in the Baltic. Only extreme future upwelling conditions impacted the tubeworm S. spirorbis, but not the bryozoans.

Citation: Saderne V, Wahl M (2013) Differential Responses of Calcifying and Non-Calcifying Epibionts of a Brown Macroalga to Present-Day and Future Upwelling pCO2. PLoS ONE 8(7): e70455. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0070455

Editor: Jack Anthony Gilbert, Argonne National Laboratory, United States of America

Received: October 24, 2012; Accepted: June 24, 2013; Published: July 23, 2013

Copyright: © 2013 Saderne, Wahl. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

Funding: This work was funded by the European community, Marie Curie ITN CALMARO (PITN-GA-2008-215157). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.

Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.

Introduction

Since the pre-industrial time, human activities led to an increase of the atmospheric pCO2 from 280 to 399 µatm [1]. CO2 is an acid gas and when dissolving in seawater, leads to the reduction of seawater pH. This phenomenon of ocean acidification has already caused a pH drop by 0.1 units since the year 1800. The most severe scenarios predict atmospheric pCO2 of up to of 1000 µatm to occur by the end of the 21th century, decreasing the oceanic pH by a further 0.4 units [2]. This shift will increase the corrosiveness of seawater to calcium carbonate, a major component of most shells and skeletons of marine species. Consequently, in the course of ocean acidification, non-calcified organisms may outcompete calcifying organisms [3] as already observed between corals and seaweeds [4] or among seagrasses epiphytes in the Mediterranean Sea [5], [6].

The Baltic Sea is particularly prone to acidification due to its low salinity, alkalinity and temperature [7], [8]. This large scale/long term global signal may be overlain by a biological signal at a shorter and smaller scale, but of higher intensity. Indeed, in the nearshore macrophyte meadows of the Western Baltic, diurnal photosynthesis/respiration cycles of phytoplankton and benthic macrophytes drives day/night oscillations of pCO2 by 200 to 400 µatm, causing fluctuations by 1.5 to 2.5 of the saturation state for aragonite and calcite (Ωarag, Ωcalc), the two isoforms of calcium carbonate [7], [9]. At the end of summer, the intensification of westerly winds together with the collapse of the thermocline leads to upwelling events of hypercapnic deep water masses to the nearshore habitats [10]. During such events, the mean pCO2 may reach 1600 µatm in the macrophyte stands, with an amplitude of diel variation up to 2180 µatm [9]. Under such circumstances, the nearshore habitats may remain undersaturated for calcite and aragonite for periods of days to weeks.

As for the open ocean, the pCO2 in the Baltic Sea is predicted to increase during the 21st century, but the value of that increase is unknown [11]. This uncertainty for the Baltic sea is caused by the concomitant shift of several other parameters: increase of mean sea surface temperature by 2 to 3.5°C, increase of the riverine input of dissolved organic carbon, strengthening of westerly wind (affecting upwelling and exchanges with the North Sea) and decrease of sea surface salinity [12], [13]. This multi-factorial change is expected to increase the duration, frequency and intensity of the upwellings events [14]. Melzner et al. (2012) [14] have shown a relationship between hypoxia and elevated pCO2 in the upwelling deep water of the Baltic. According to their model, the pCO2 recorded in 2011 by Saderne et al. (2013) [9] in Baltic macrophyte meadows would correspond to concentrations of O2 in deep water of approx. 100 µM (instead of a theoretical saturated O2 concentration of approx. 290 µM at salinity 20 and temperature 13°C [9], [15]). For this level of hypoxia and considering a doubling of atmospheric pCO2 during the 21st century [2], the model of Melzner et al. (2012) [14] predicts the pCO2 to reach 3000 µatm in the macrophyte meadows during the end of summer upwelling in 2100.

The brown alga Fucus serratus is a common and, locally, dominant species in the shallow (<3 m) macrophyte meadows in the Western Baltic, providing valuable ecosystem services such as primary production, the provision of spawning and nursery areas, food for herbivores and substratum for micro- and macrofoulers [16], [17]. In total, 164 macro- and micro-faunal species have been inventoried as associated with F. serratus in the Baltic [18]. Most prevalent sessile epibiotic species inventoried are the calcifying tubeworm Spirorbis spirorbis, the calcifying bryozoan Electra pilosa and the non-calcifying bryozoan Alcyonidium hirsutum [18]. As most epibionts, these species play an important role in the ecology of their host. S. spirorbis can overgrow fucoid blades, presumably causing shading and an increase in weight and brittleness [19]. Similarly, shading by E. pilosa and A. hirsutum can reduce the photosynthetic activity of F. serratus by up to 85% [20] and their physical presence could contribute to the degeneration of the underlying thallus as demonstrated on kelps [21], [22]. In kelp forests, the overgrowth by bryozoans can lead to extensive defoliation affecting the entire ecosystem [23], [24]. On the other hand, bryozoans are directly supplying the host algae with ammonium [25] and dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC) [26] and are a food source for grazers such as nudibranchs and urchins [27]–[29].

The epibiotic species spend at least the initial part of their life cycle within the diffusive boundary layer (DBL) surrounding the algal thallus. This layer typically is 50 µm to 2 mm thick depending on ambient flow velocity [30], [31]. It is characterized by the slow diffusion of molecules, creating steep concentration gradients of compounds produced or consumed by the alga and its micro- and macro-epibionts [30]–[33]. Due to the net uptake of CO2 at daytime and the net release of CO2 at night, pH within the DBL of Fucus vesiculosus can vary between 8 in the dark and 9.2 at 785 µE light [34]. The biotic signal is apparently skewed towards lower pH i.e. algal photosynthesis increases pH more than algal respiration decreases it (e.g. [34]). Consequently, we would expect the microhabitat on the macroalga thallus to shelter sessile calcifiers from seawater corrosiveness, especially during daytime [31].

In the present study, we tested the hypothesis whether present-day and future upwelling pCO2 (“transient acidification”) (i) impacts epibiotic species and (ii) disadvantages the calcifying sessile fauna of F. serratus over the non-calcifying one. The calcifying tubeworm S. spirorbis and two bryozoan species, the calcifying cheilostome E. pilosa and the keratinous ctenostome A. hirsutum were investigated regarding their growth and settlement (S. spirorbis only) under three pCO2 conditions during a 30 day incubation. The two higher pCO2 treatments were meant to simulate a prolonged upwelling event of variable intensity. Treatments were unmodified pCO2 (460 µatm), typical present-day upwelling pCO2 (1200 µatm) and upwelling pCO2 expected by 2100 (3150 µatm). We also tested at the same pCO2 light versus dark growth of epibiotic S. spirorbis settled juveniles as a first indicator of a potential protection of calcification in the DBL by the host algae metabolism.

Materials and Methods

Collection of Macroalgae and Epibionts

Fucus serratus individuals bearing epibiotic communities composed of S. spirorbis, E. pilosa and A. hirsutum were collected in less than 2 m depth in Eckernförde Bay (Western Baltic Sea, Germany, 54°27′ N, 9°53′ E) on the 1st of February 2011, carried in coolers to the lab and stored in one aquarium (100 L) for two days under the conditions of pCO2 (460 µatm), light (300 µE), salinity (17) and temperature (16°C) of the control treatment of the future incubation. No specific permits were required for the study, the location is not privately-owned or protected in any way and the study did not involve endangered or protected species.

Bryozoans are colonial filter feeders (as e.g. corals), composed of modules called zooids expending by asexual budding. Bryozoans are protected by box-like exoskeletons of structure differing among taxa. In ctenostome bryozoans such as A. hirsutum, the skeleton is a periostracum composed of a thin membrane covering a main periostracal layer, both made of keratin and muco-polysaccharides [35]. In cheilostomes such as E. pilosa, the above described periostracum is reinforced on the inside by a layer of calcium carbonate [35]. The biomineralization pathway is still unexplored [36].

Each zooid is connected to its neighbors by channels through the skeleton, allowing the allocation of resources to the budding edge of the colony. Within a colony, zooids are deciduous units. Each filter-feeding zooid can only ingest a determined amount of food before the accumulation of waste within the stomach epithelium leads to the zooid degeneration [37], [38]. The zooid is therefore replaced by a new one within the same skeletal box.

S. spirorbis is a filter feeding tubeworm of maximum 5 mm length protected by a spiral calcified tube. The tube is secreted by glands located under a collar between the head and the thorax [39]. According to Nott and Parkes (1975) [39] the crystals of calcium carbonates are formed in the lumen of the gland from a calcium rich mucous secretion and carbonate and bicarbonate ions originating from seawater. Embryos are brooded within the calcareous tube in an egg bag attached to the parental body [40]. The release of swimming non-feeding larvae is triggered by favourable environmental factors (rising tide, especially of spring type) [41]. The settlement and metamorphosis into juveniles occurs within 1 to 3 hours [41].

Preparation of the Material

Two days after sampling, equivalently fouled thallus sections of F. serratus were cut to an average (± SD) weight and area of 1±0.02 g and 24±5 cm2, reciprocally. Sections were taken at the center of the thallus (Fig. 1). We took care not to hurt the epibionts in the process. Each thallus section carried on average (± SD) 26.8±5.3 S. spirorbis individuals, 6.2±1.9 colonies of E. pilosa and 1.9±0.6 colonies of A. hirsutum, distributed on both sides of the thallus. The mean (± SD) colonies area was 2.3±3.6 cm2 for E. pilosa and 3.5±3.8 cm2 for A. hirsutum. The fluorescent dye calcein was added for five days at 50 mg L−1 to the aquarium (in the conditions of incubation stated in the previous sub-section).

thumbnail
Download:
Figure 1. Experimental design.

(A) Schematic representation of the incubation system. (B) Schematic representation of one experimental F. serratus section bearing the three epibionts, both sides of the thallus were bearing epibionts.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0070455.g001

The incorporation of the dye into the newly grown tubes and bryozoan skeletons marked the starting point for calcification under the experimental treatment levels [42]–[44]. Calcein is a very low toxicity dye often used in biomineralization studies, as on the bryozoan Adeonellopsis sp [45]. The innocuty of calcein at concentrations inferior to 100 mg L−1 has been demonstrated on bivalves [46] and juvenile fish [47].

During the 5 day staining period, the animals were fed ad libitum with the microalgae Rhodomonas sp. to ensure good growth rates [48], [49] and intense incorporation of the stain. The expansion of the tubes and colonies during the calcein staining attested for the absence of stress in the animals linked to the staining or, generally, to the maintenance conditions.

Experimental Design

A schematic representation of the experimental design is given in Fig. 1. Each F. serratus section bearing the three epibiont species was individually incubated in a 600 mL culture flask (11 cm×3.5 cm×14.5 cm; Sarstedt, Germany). Ten replicate flasks were assigned to each pCO2 treatment. Flasks were constantly aerated with modified ambient air containing either 460 µatm pCO2 (ambient), 1200 µatm pCO2 or 3000 µatm pCO2 (Linde gas and HTK Hamburg, Germany) (see [50] for details). The vigorous gas bubbling assured a continuous convective movement of water and a homogeneous repartition of microalgae in the flasks as in Riisgård and Goldson (1997) [51]. The algae sections and the epibionts were neither in contact with the bubbling stone nor with the bubbles but were confined to the opposite side of the experimental flasks by the convective flow.

Temperature was maintained at 16°C and light was provided by three Biolux neon tubes (Osram, Germany), delivering a total of 300 µE under a 12/12 h day/night cycle. The seawater of the flasks was replaced every third day with water pre-adjusted to the same pCO2 and enriched with Rhodomonas sp. to a final concentration of 10,000 cells mL−1, corresponding to the phytoplankton concentrations observed in August – September in the inner bays of the Western Baltic [52].

Natural Baltic seawater from the Kiel Bight (Western Baltic Sea, Germany, 54° 19′ N, 10° 08′ E) was used in the experiment after storage in a 300 L tank aerated with ambient air and sterilized by a Microfloat 1 floating UV lamp (Aqua Concept Karlsruhe, Germany). 24 h before use, the seawater was equilibrated with the three experimental pCO2 in three separate tanks.

The duration of the incubation was 30 days, simulating the duration of an extended present-day upwelling period and of a possibly average duration of future upwelling events. At the end of the incubation period, the algal fragments were conserved in borax-formaldehyde-seawater solutions suitable for preservation of calcareous structures (see [53] for the detailed recipe) prior to the measurement of growth rates.

Measurement of Relative Growth Rates (RGR) of Bryozoans

We used relative growth rates to compare the growth rates of colonies of different starting sizes. Colonies were photographed by overlapping fields of vision under an epifluorescence microscope (Axio Scope A1, Carl Zeiss, Germany) at the end of the experiment. The partial pictures were reassembled into complete colony pictures. The initial colony surface (SI) (pre-staining) and the final total colony surface (SF) (after 30 days incubation) were measured by image analysis (ImageJ, U. S. National Institutes of Health). In each replicate flask, SI and SF of all the colonies were summed for each species so that in each flask (replicate) the relative growth rate in percent (RGR) was:

With n the number of colonies in one flask. The logarithmic growth pattern of bryozoan colonies has been assessed by [48]. A. hirsutum colonies (non-stainable), were photographed prior and after incubation. The areas were measured and the RGR calculated as for E. pilosa.

Measurement of Growth and Settlement of S. spirorbis

For S. spirorbis, the absolute tube growth in mm was estimated as the length of the external arc of the coil comprised between the staining front and the terminal tube edge around the opening (see Fig. 2 A). In each flask, the new tube length increment of all worms was averaged as the flask represents one replicate within a treatment level. S. spirorbis settlement was quantified for each flask as the number of juveniles found on algae sections (their favorite substratum) at the end of the experiment divided by the number of adults. No juveniles were present on the thallus at the onset of the experiment.

thumbnail
Download:
Figure 2. Illustrative examples.

(A, C) Adult S. spirorbis tubes after 30 days of incubation at 460 µatm and 3150 µatm pCO2 respectively. (B, D) Juveniles S. spirorbis tubes after 30 days of incubation at 460 µatm and 3150 µatm pCO2. Note the conspicuous dissolution of the shell in (C) and the disappearance of part of the tube in (D). All photos were taken under epifluorescence microscope, yellow/green: calcein staining. The white lines show the considered distances for the growth measurements of S. spirorbis tubes.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0070455.g002

Growth of S. spirorbis Juveniles under Light and Dark Conditions

To test the effect of photosynthetic activity and pCO2 on the growth of juvenile worms, calcein was added to all the flasks (final concentration: 20 mg L−1) during the last 24 hours of the experiment. Subsequently, half of the flasks were kept in light (with host algal photosynthesis), the other half was darkened by wrapping in aluminum foil (without host algal photosynthesis). Growth was measured as the length of the stained newly formed tube (see Fig. 2 B).

Seawater Chemistry

Seawater processing for carbonate system measurements was made according to the standard operating procedure (SOP) 1 of Dickson and Sabine (2007) [54]. Three random flasks in each treatment and the three mixing tanks were sampled prior to each water exchange. The temperature of the flasks and the tanks were measured with 0.01°C precision for future in-situ pH recalculation (see below). Samples were analyzed in the laboratory for DIC and pHT. DIC was measured with an AIRICA (Marianda, Germany), the measurement principle is based on the infrared measurement of CO2(g) purged out of an acidified sample. The system was calibrated on every measurement day with Certified Reference Material (CRM) (Andrew Dickson, Scripps Institution of Oceanography). The pH on total scale (pHT) was measured as follows. Seawater TRIS pH buffers at salinity 15 were made according to the SOP 6a [54]. A combined reference/measurement electrode Metrohm Ecotrode (Metrohm, Switzerland) was used together with a pH-meter/conductimeter Mettler-Toledo SG 7/8 (Mettler-Toledo, Switzerland). For calibration, the TRIS buffer was immersed in a thermostatic bath and the voltage (±0.1 mV) of the pH electrode was measured. The temperature of the buffer was modulated on a range of 1.5°C. The temperature corresponding to every mV change was recorded with >0.01°C accuracy with a Fluke 5658 reference thermometer equipped with a 5608 platinum resistance sensor (Fluke, USA). The procedure was repeated by increasing and decreasing the temperature to get an average voltage (mV) versus T (°C) reference curve for the electrode in the buffer. The fitting of the electrode voltage to the curve was assessed on every measurement day to check for the natural depolarization of the electrode. This calibration protocol was repeated at least once a week. The voltage and temperature of the sample was measured at the temperature corresponding to the calibration range. The sample voltage, sample temperature and the theoretical TRIS buffer voltage (corresponding through the calibration curve to the sample temperature) were computed through the equation of the SOP 6a to obtain the laboratory pH on total scale of the sample. The temperature of the sample measured the climate room at the time of sampling was used to recalculate the in-situ pH. Preparative work conducted on CRM together with buffers at salinity 35 demonstrated an accuracy of this method of 0.003 to 0.005 pH units. Salinity of the samples was measured to an accuracy of 0.01 with a Mettler Toledo Inlab 738 conductivity probe after calibration at 25°C with KCl 0.1 mol L−1 (Fischer Scientific, USA). The overall in situ-pH and carbonate system was recalculated with the R package Seacarb [55] using first and second carbonate system dissociation constants for estuarine systems from Millero (2010) [56] and the dissociations constants of HF and HSO4− of Perez and Fraga (1987) [57] and Dickson (1990) [58].

Statistical Analysis

Statistical analyses were conducted with Statistica 7 (Statsoft, USA.). Treatments were compared using one way ANOVAs and Tukey’s HSD tests. Assumptions of normality and homoscedasticity were tested with Shapiro-Wilk’s and Levene’s tests. To achieve normality, data for growth rates of E. pilosa and A. hirsutum were transformed by the natural logarithm.

Results

Chemistry

A summary of the variables of the carbonate system measured in the flasks during the 30 days duration of the experiment derived from pHT and DIC is presented in Table 1. Average (± SD) pCO2 treatment levels were 460±59 µatm, 1193±166 µatm and 3150±445 µatm. Saturation states (mean ± SD) below one were found for aragonite only (0.82±0.14) in the bulk water of the 1200 µatm treatment and for both isomorphs (Ωcalc 0.66±0.14, Ωarag 0.40±0.09), was found in the 3150 µatm pCO2.

thumbnail
Download:
Table 1. Seawater carbonate system in the experimental flasks.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0070455.t001

Spirorbis spirorbis

The growth of S. spirorbis tubes was significantly affected by pCO2 (one way ANOVA, Df = 2, F = 5.84, p 0.008, Fig. 3 A). Compared to the 460 µatm, reductions of growth rates by approx. 40% were found at 3150 µatm (Tukey’s HSD, p = 0.007) and by approx. 25% at 1200 µatm (marginally significant, Tukey’s HSD, p = 0.075). While no signs of shell injuries were visible at 460 µatm and 1200 µatm, all S. spirorbis tubes exhibited substantial shell dissolution marks at 3150 µatm (see Fig. 2 C). This loss of integrity of the outer spiral of the tube exposed the worm bodies and the embryo bags to the external seawater. Settlement of S. spirorbis was significantly affected by pCO2 (one way ANOVA, Df = 2, F = 12.98, p<0.001, Fig. 3 B). The number of settled juveniles per adult was significantly reduced by approx. 75% at 3150 compared to 1200 µatm (Tukey’s HSD, p = 0,003) and by approx. 85% compared to the control (Tukey’s HSD, p<0.001). Juvenile tube growth was significantly higher by about 40% in light as compared to dark incubation (factorial ANOVA, Df = 1, F = 17.6, p<0.001; Fig. 4). The pCO2 did not significantly influenced the juvenile growth rates (factorial ANOVA, Df = 2, F = 0.44, p = 0.64) but important damages on the early tubes were observed in the 3150 µatm treatment (see Fig. 2 D).

thumbnail
Download:
Figure 3. Growth and reproduction of S. spirorbis.

(A) Growth of the tubes of S. spirorbis during the 30 days of incubations at 460 µatm, 1200 µatm and 3150 µatm pCO2, data are the mean ± SE of newly formed tubes sections in mm per worm per flask. (B) Settlement of S. spirorbis during the 30 days of incubations at 460 µatm, 1200 µatm and 3150 µatm pCO2, data are the mean ± SE of the number of juveniles settled per adult between flasks. One-way ANOVAs, n = 10, statistical significance: ***: p≤0.001, **: p≤0.01, *: p≤0.05, •: p<0.1.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0070455.g003

thumbnail
Download:
Figure 4. Growth of the juveniles of S. spirorbis.

Growth in µm of the tubes of the juveniles of S. spirorbis during 24 h in light and dark condition exposed to pCO2 of 460 µatm, 1200 µatm and 3150 µatm. Data are the mean ± SE newly formed tubes sections in µm per worm per flask Two-way ANOVA, n = 5, statistical significance: ***: p≤0.001.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0070455.g004

Bryozoans

The growth rate of E. pilosa was significantly affected by pCO2 (one way ANOVA, Df = 2, F = 5.04, p = 0.014). Growth rates were enhanced at 1200 µatm by approx. 35% compared to 3150 µatm and by approx. 45% compared to the control. However, only the difference between the 3150 µatm treatment and the 1200 µatm was significant (Tukey’s HSD, p = 0.01) (Fig. 5 A). In the highest pCO2 treatment the skeleton of uninhabited zooids, but not of live zooids, dissolved completely resulting in a “ghost” organic matrix of the exact same shape. The growth rates of A. hirsutum were similar under all pCO2 levels (ANOVA, Df = 2, F = 0.4, p = 0.64; Fig. 5 B).

thumbnail
Download:
Figure 5. Growth of the bryozoan.

Relative growth rate (RGR) of (A) E. pilosa, (B) A. hirsutum colonies during the 30 days of incubations at 460 µatm, 1200 µatm and 3150 µatm pCO2. Data are the mean ± SE of the growth rates in % in n = 10 flasks. One-way ANOVAs, statistical significance: **: p≤0.01.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0070455.g005

Discussion

None of our experimental species was negatively impacted in growth rates or settlement (investigated only for the polychaete) under present-day upwelling pCO2 conditions (1200 µatm treatment). Instead, bryozoans tended to grow better at this pCO2. At the pCO2 level expected in 2100 upwelling events (3150 µatm treatment), S. spirobis showed a severe reduction of growth and settlement together with important tube dissolution while both bryozoans, calcifying and non-, were unaffected. Therefore, we cannot validate the hypothesis of a general competitive advantage of non-calcifying epibionts over calcifying ones at elevated pCO2.

We observed as a trend a quadratic relation between bryozoans growth and increasing pCO2 with best growth at intermediate levels of pCO2. Similar response patterns were described by Ries et al., 2009 [59] for several calcifiers exposed to lowered pCO2. In contrast, a tendency toward a more linear reduction of growth rates with increasing pCO2 was found in the calcifying bryozoan Celleporella hyalina (max. pCO2 tested: 4400 µatm, [60]) and Celleporaria nodulosa (max. pCO2 tested: 1200 µatm, [61]) albeit with remarkable intraspecific variability. This (presumably) genetic variability of sensitivity hints at a substantial potential of adaptation of these bryozoan species to elevated pCO2 [60], [61].

The difference in sensitivity to acidification between the two calcifiers S. spirorbis and E. pilosa and the lack of difference between the two bryozoans, calcifying or not, could be due to differences in physiology, crystallization pathways, shell mineralogy and/or structuration. Most of these are unknown for the three species investigated, however Bornhold and Milliman (1973) [62], in what remains the only study documenting the mineralogy of S. spirorbis (as S. borealis), reported that their tubes are calcitic with 10 to 14% of aragonite and include 0 to 10% of MgCO3 depending on location and possibly on environmental factors such as temperature. The skeleton of E. pilosa is exclusively calcitic, including 4 to 8% MgCO3 [63]–[65] and may, therefore, be less prone to dissolution than the worm tubes. This could explain some of the observed sensitivity differences between the two calcifiers. Furthermore, Nott and Parkes (1975) [39] suggested for S. spirorbis that the crystallization process directly depends on the uptake of DIC from seawater. Therefore, the reduction of the worm growth observed at elevated pCO2 could also be explained by the reduction of the carbonate ion fraction of the DIC.

To our knowledge, the crystallization pathway in the biomineralization of cheilostome bryozoans has not yet been described [36]. According to Weiner and Addadi (2011) [66], the fact that their skeleton can be labeled by calcein, a molecule that cannot pass through membranes, suggests that the deposited calcium originates from direct endocytosis of seawater. We cannot deduce anything concerning the origin of the carbonate involved (external or metabolic). For E. pilosa, the calcium carbonate is deposited beneath an organic periostracum made of muco-polysaccharides, proteins and chitin [35], protecting the carbonated skeleton from corrosive seawater. In contrast, the calcium carbonate of the spirorbid tube is in direct contact with seawater [67]. The protection or not of calcified structures by external organic layers and periostracum is recognized as a major feature explaining the differences of sensitivity to corrosive water between calcifier taxa [59], [68]. The organisms with protected shells or skeleton (e.g. corals and mussels) are more resilient to seawater corrosiveness than organisms with bare calcified structures (e.g. limpets) [59]–[68]. That feature could partially explain why we observed for S. spirorbis a reduction of growth for adults and important shell damages for adults and juveniles at 3150 µatm, when Ωcalc <1, but no effects for E. pilosa. For this latter specie, only the dead central parts of the colonies were decalcify, similarly to what was observed for the bryozoan Myriapora truncata at the CO2 vents of Ischia (Italy) [69]. This suggests the importance of living processes in bryozoans for the maintenance of the calcified structure. Our results for S. Spirorbis and E. pilosa are coherent with the observations made in Ischia for Electridae and Spirorbidae epibionts on the seagrass Posidonia oceanica. Cigliano et al. (2010) [70] found Spirorbis marioni only at stations of normal atmospheric pCO2 and Ωcalc >5.5. In our study, S. spirorbis was impacted for growth and settlement only at the highest pCO2 treatment with Ωcalc <1. As in the present study, Martin et al. (2008) [6] did not find any correlation between lowered pH and Ωs and the abundance of bryozoans, including Electra posidoniae.

In bryozoans, the fact that the calcified structure is just one element of a composite skeletal assemblage could explain the similarity of results between E. pilosa and A. hirsutum. To our knowledge, the skeleton of the genus Alcyonidium is mostly composed of chitin but its structure (architecture) has never been described in detail [71]. Instead, Tavener-Smith and Williams (1972) [35] described the composition and structure of Bowerbankia sp., another ctenostome bryozoan. Compared to cheilostomes, ctenostome bryozoans have a thicker periostracum reinforced in chitin and lack any calcium carbonate layer. Cheilostomes evolved calcification from a soft-bodied ctenostome-type ancestor (of which Alcyonidiidae is the closest living related taxa [72]). Both clades share similar skeleton, differing only by the presence of the calcium carbonate layer [35], [36], [72]. The similarity of response of E. pilosa and A. hirsutum observed in the present study suggests that acidification impacts other physiological pathways than calcification common to both species with, as result, an increase of growth rates in the intermediate CO2 treatment. Such enhancement have been observed in some echinoderms [73], [74], but could be at the cost of energetic tradeoffs detrimental to other key functions like reproduction.

To our knowledge, the present article is the first presenting measures of the growth rates of S. spirorbis, adults and juveniles, and of A. hirsutum. In contrast, growth rates for E. pilosa have been assessed in several articles, under different food and flow regimes (reviewed by [48]–[75]). The growth rates in our experiment for E. pilosa are approximately ten times lower than observed in other laboratory experiments conducted with comparable concentrations of food. However, those studies have been conducted on isolated colonies in absence of competitors for food. In our study, each E. pilosa colony is in competition with conspecific colonies, with colonies of A. hirsutum and with S. spirorbis individuals. Consequently, the available food quantity for each colony might have been reduced close to the minimum threshold for growth of 500 cell mL−1 identified for E. pilosa [75].

The imposed water motion in our experimental flasks could have impaired the food uptake by the bryozoans, contributing to the reduced growth rates observed for E. pilosa [76]. The question of the influence of current velocity on bryozoans food uptake and growth is controversial [48], [76]. Hermansen et al. (2001) [48] stated that while very slow flow could impair supply to the polyps, high current velocities do not limit E. pilosa growth rates. In contrast, earlier studies by Okamura (1988, 1992) [77], [78] shown that strong current reduces feeding rates of isolated E. pilosa colonies but enhances feeding rates of both A. hirsutum and E. pilosa colonies when they occur contiguously on the same algal thallus. This facilitation between the two bryozoans would be due to micro-turbulences created by A. hirsutum colonies, slowing and diverting the flow at the vicinity of E. pilosa colonies [77].

Finally, we cannot exclude the slow growth rates to be the consequence of stresses relative to the shortness of the acclimation period (two days) and/or to the conditions of incubation (e.g. temperature, light). Regarding vigorous bubbling and short acclimation time, our study conditions resemble those of Okamura (1988) [77], Okamura (1992) [78], Mercado et al. (1998) [79] and Riisgård and Goldson (1997) [51] on similar or the same organisms. The absence of acclimation to elevated pCO2 through a stepwise acidification was deliberate and aimed at mimicking the sudden occurrence of an upwelling event [9].

Growth rates in E. pilosa were approx. 50% higher than in A. hirsutum. To our knowledge, no studies investigated the growth rates of both species in competition on a same algal thallus. Nonetheless, our results are in accordance with the known strategy for substrate occupation of both species. On F. serratus, Alcyonidiidae are end-of-succession species, slowly overgrowing all other epibionts until dominating the entire algal fronds [80]–[83]. In contrast, E. pilosa is a smaller, early-succession specie, mostly relying on elevated growth rates to escape overgrowth by superior bryozoan competitors [80]–[83].

A reduction of S. spirorbis settlement of about 85% relative to the control was found at the highest pCO2. In this species, the embryos are bred within the parental tube for a period of 10 to 25 days until the emission of a fully formed larvae settling within few hours [41], [84]. The reduction in settlement could be the result of adverse conditions during fertilization, cleavage (embryogenesis), planktonic larva, settlement or metamorphosis [85]. Exchange of sperm might or might not have occurred during the experiment. Some sperm stored over winter in a specific organ of the head could have been used to fertilize the eggs [86], [87]. Likewise, some embryos in dormancy at the beginning of the experiment could have reactivated their development. A more probable explanation for our results would be a delaying or interruption of the embryogenesis due to the exposure of the embryo bags to external acidified seawater after dissolution of the parental tubes. Such impacts during embryogenesis have been observed for gastropods, bivalves and echinoderms [88]–[90]. While the planktonic phase is considered a sensitive life stage (e.g. [85], [91]), the short duration of the pelagic phase in S. spirorbis (a few minutes to 3 h) and the non-calcifying nature of the larvae should reduce the likeliness of impact of acidified seawater. Spirorbis spirorbis specifically settles on brown algae and this preference is most likely chemically mediated [92]–[94]. The sensitivity to cues could be affected by seawater pH, making the larvae incapable of recognizing their hosts as found in clown fish larvae (Amphiprion percula), becoming “blind” to their host anemones cues under high pCO2 [95].

Our study did not considered species in isolation, but in close association with their host alga, reflecting the intention to assess the response of an ecologically relevant association to upwelling-like acidification events. Our results suggest that the host algae photosynthesis could modulate the calcification of the smallest encrusting organisms inhabiting the algal DBL. The thickness of the DBL is mostly depending on the flow velocity, ranging from almost 2 mm in stagnant water and exponentially decreasing to a threshold of 50 to 150 µm at flow velocity above 10 cm s−1 [30]–[32]. In the experimental flasks a vigorous and convective water motion was ensured by the continuous gas bubbling which, however, was not measured. The water movement served to ensure homogeneous conditions throughout the water column and to warrant exchanges of nutrients and gases at the thallus surface. While water movement per se was strong the shear velocity at the thallus surface was presumably moderate. We could expect therefore the thickness of the DBL to be of some intermediate size, maybe between 100 and 500 µm, such as S. spirorbis juveniles only might fully experience its effects. The conditions within algal boundary layer is strongly influenced by the physiological activity of the host algae and the micro- and macro-epibiont species living in it (e.g. [33] and references therein). For instance, during alternating cycles of algal respiration (“night”) and photosynthesis (“day”), oxygen concentration and pH at 100 µm above the thallus surface can vary between 200 and 750 µmol O2 L−1 and between 8.0 and 9.2 pH units, respectively (data extracted from plots in [34]). Thus, although this has never been investigated to date, one would expect that ocean acidification effects would be dampened in the DBL during daytime at least. Supporting this, we found a 40% enhancement of growth rates of juveniles under light compared to dark. In contrast, we did not find an antagonistic interaction of darkness (algal respiration) and elevated pCO2 on the juvenile growth rates. Therefore, we cannot exclude that the day/night rhythm of calcification observed could be due to inherent activity patterns of the worm or to stresses engendered by e.g. the variations of O2 more than by daily variations of Ω in the DBL.

In our experiment we found that the epibionts of F. serratus tolerate a transient rise of pCO2 similar to present-day upwelling events of the Western Baltic. We hypothesize that this tolerance consists of a periodic relaxation of the acidification stress by the algal host in the thallus-associated boundary layer due to photosynthesis in daytime. Despite the (presumed) biotic modulation by the host alga, we observed very severe effects on growth and settlement of the tubeworm S. spirorbis under the conditions of upwelling of year 2100. The calcifying and non-calcifying bryozoans E. pilosa and A. hirsutum were not affected by elevated pCO2 but rather favored under present-day upwelling conditions. This study shows for epibionts that (i) calcifiers may not all be “losers” in a high pCO2 ocean and (ii) small scale processes at the habitat or microhabitat scale could mitigate the impact of acidification on species and communities.

Acknowledgments

We wish to thank M. Fischer for his field assistance, J-P. Gattuso for providing access to the AIRICA DIC analyzer and the two anonymous reviewers for their great contribution to the improvement of the manuscript.

Author Contributions

Conceived and designed the experiments: VS. Performed the experiments: VS. Analyzed the data: VS. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: VS. Wrote the paper: VS MW.

References

  1. 1. NOAA – ESRL website. Available: http://www.esrl.noaa.gov/gmd/ccgg/trends. Accessed 2013 Jun 27.
    • 2. Caldeira K, Wickett ME (2005) Ocean model predictions of chemistry changes from carbon dioxide emissions to the atmosphere and ocean. J Geophys Res 110: 1–12.
    • 3. Fabry VJ, Seibel BA, Feely RA, Orr JC (2008) Impacts of ocean acidification on marine fauna and ecosystem processes. ICES J Mar Sci 65: 414–432.
    • 4. Diaz-Pulido G, Gouezo M, Tilbrook B, Dove S, Anthony KRNN (2011) High CO2 enhances the competitive strength of seaweeds over corals. Ecol Lett 14: 156–162.
    • 5. Kuffner IB, Andersson AJ, Jokiel PL, Rodgers KS, Mackenzie FT (2007) Decreased abundance of crustose coralline algae due to ocean acidification. Nature Geoscience 1: 114–117.
    • 6. Martin S, Rodolfo-Metalpa R, Ransome E, Rowley SJ, Buia M-C, et al. (2008) Effects of naturally acidified seawater on seagrass calcareous epibionts. Biology Letters 4: 689–692.
    • 7. Thomas H, Schneider B (1999) The seasonal cycle of carbon dioxide in Baltic Sea surface waters. J Mar Sys 22: 53–67.
    • 8. Tyrrell T, Schneider B, Charalampopoulou A, Riebesell U (2008) Coccolithophores and calcite saturation state in the Baltic and Black Seas. Biogeosciences 5: 485–494.
    • 9. Saderne V, Fietzek P, Herman PMJ (2013) Extreme variations of pCO2 and pH in a macrophyte meadow of the Baltic Sea in summer: evidence of the effect of photosynthesis and local upwelling. PloS ONE 8: e62689.
    • 10. Thomsen J, Gutowska MA, Saphörster J, Heinemann A, Trübenbach K, et al. (2010) Calcifying invertebrates succeed in a naturally CO2-rich coastal habitat but are threatened by high levels of future acidification. Biogeosciences 7: 3879–3891.
    • 11. Schneider B (2011) The CO2 System of the Baltic Sea: Biogeochemical Control and Impact of Anthropogenic CO2. In: Schernewski G, Hofstede J, Neumann T, editors. Global Change and Baltic Coastal Zones. Dordrecht: Springer Netherlands, Vol. 1: 33–49.
    • 12. Schrum C (2001) Regionalization of climate change for the North Sea and Baltic Sea. Clim Res 18: 31–37.
    • 13. Gräwe U, Burchard H (2011) Global Change and Baltic Coastal Zones. In: Schernewski G, Hofstede J, Neumann T, editors. Global Change and Baltic Coastal Zones. Dordrecht: Springer Netherlands, Vol. 1: 3–22.
    • 14. Melzner F, Thomsen J, Koeve W, Oschlies A, Gutowska MA, et al. (2012) Future ocean acidification will be amplified by hypoxia in coastal habitats. Mar Biol 1–15.
      • 15. Soetaert K, Petzoldt T, Meysman F (2010) MARELAC: tools for aquatic science. R package version 2.1.2 Software.
        • 16. Boaden PJS, O’Connor R J, Seed R (1975) The composition and zonation of a Fucus serratus community in Strangford Lough, Co. Down. J Exp Mar Biol Ecol 17: 111–136.
        • 17. Kautsky H, Kautsky L, Kautsky N, Kautsky U, Lindblad C (1992) Studies on the Fucus vesiculosus community in the Baltic Sea. Acta Phytogeographica Suecica 78: 33–48.
        • 18. Hagerman L (1966) The macro-and microfauna associated with Fucus serratus L., with some ecological remarks. Ophelia 3: 1–43.
        • 19. O’Connor RJ, Lamont P (1978) The spatial organization of an intertidal Spirorbis community. J Exp Mar Biol Ecol 32: 143–169.
        • 20. Oswald R, Telford N, Seed R, Happey-Wood C (1984) The effect of encrusting bryozoans on the photosynthetic activity of Fucus serratus L. Estuar Coast Shelf Sci. 19: 697–702.
        • 21. Dixon J, Schroeter SC, Kastendiek J (1981) Effects of the encrusting bryozoan, Membranipora membranacea, on the loss of blades and fronds by the giant kelp, Macrocystis pyrifera (Laminariales). J Phycol 17: 341–345.
        • 22. Krumhansl K, Scheibling RE (2011) Detrital production in Nova Scotian kelp beds: patterns and processes. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 421: 67–82.
        • 23. Saier B, Chapman AS (2004) Crusts of the alien bryozoan Membranipora membranacea can negatively impact spore output from native kelps (Laminaria longicruris). Botanica Marina 47: 265–271.
        • 24. Scheibling RE, Hennigar AW, Balch T (1999) Destructive grazing, epiphytism, and disease: the dynamics of sea urchin - kelp interactions in Nova Scotia. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 56: 2300–2314.
        • 25. Hurd CL, Durante KM, Chia F-S, Harrison PJ (1994) Effect of bryozoan colonization on inorganic nitrogen acquisition by the kelps Agarum fimbriatum and Macrocystis integrifolia. Mar Biol 121: 167–173.
        • 26. Munoz J, Cancino JM, Molina MX (1991) Effects on encrusting bryozoans on the physiology of their algal substratum. J Mar Biol Assoc U K 71: 877–882.
        • 27. Seed R (1976) Observations on the ecology of Membranipora (bryozoa) and a major predator Doridella stelnbergae (nudibranchiata) along the fronds of Laminaria saccharina at Friday harbor, Washington. J Exp Mar Biol Ecol 24: 1–17.
        • 28. Harvell D (1984) Why nudibranchs are partial predators: intracolonial variation in bryozoan palatability. Ecology 65: 716–724.
        • 29. Nestler E, Harris L (1994) The importance of omnivory in Strongylocentrotus droebachiensis (Müller) in the Gulf of Maine. In: David B, Guille A, Féral J-P, Roux M, editors. Echinoderms Through Time. Rotterdam: CRC press. 813–818.
          • 30. Wheeler WN (1980) Effect of boundary layer transport on the fixation of carbon by the giant kelp Macrocystis pyrifera. Mar Biol 56: 103–110.
          • 31. Hurd CL, Cornwall CE, Currie KI, Hepburn CD, McGraw CM, et al. (2011) Metabolically induced pH fluctuations by some coastal calcifiers exceed projected 22nd century ocean acidification: a mechanism for differential susceptibility? Glob Change Biol 17: 3254–3262.
          • 32. Stevens C, Hurd CL (1997) Boundary-layers around bladed aquatic macrophytes. Hydrobiologia 346: 119–128.
          • 33. Hurd CL (2000) Water motion, marine macroalgal physiology, and production. J Phycol 36: 453–472.
          • 34. Spilling K, Titelman J, Greve TM, Kühl M (2010) Microsensor measurements of the external and internal microenvironment of Fucus vesiculosus (Phaeophyceae). J Phycol 46: 1350–1355.
          • 35. Tavener-Smith R, Williams A (1972) The secretion and structure of the skeleton of living and fossil Bryozoa. Philos T R Soc Lon B 264: 97–160.
          • 36. Taylor P, Vinn O, Wilson M (2010) Evolution of biomineralisation in “lophophorates”. Spec Pap Palaeontol 84: 317–333.
          • 37. Bayer MM, Todd CD (1997) Evidence for zooid senescence in the marine bryozoan Electra pilosa. Invertebr Biol 116: 331–340.
          • 38. Bayer MM, Cormack RM, Todd CD (1994) Influence of food concentration on polypide regression in the marine bryozoan Electra pilosa (L.) (Bryozoa: Cheilostomata). J Exp Mar Biol Ecol 178: 35–50.
          • 39. Nott JA, Parkes KR (1975) Calcium accumulation and secretion in the serpulid polychaete Spirorbis spirorbis L. at settlement. J Mar Biol Assoc U K 55: 911–923.
          • 40. Knight-Jones EW, Knight-Jones P, Vine PJ (1972) Anchorage of embryos in Spirorbinae (Polychaeta). Mar Biol 12: 289–294.
          • 41. Knight-Jones EW (1951) Gregariousness and some other aspects of the setting behaviour of Spirorbis. J Mar Biol Assoc U K 30: 201–222.
          • 42. Comeau S, Gorsky G, Jeffree R, Teyssie J, Gattuso J-P (2009) Impact of ocean acidification on a key Arctic pelagic mollusk (Limacina helicina). Biogeosciences 6: 1877–1882.
          • 43. Dissard D, Nehrke G, Reichart GJ, Nouet J, Bijma J (2009) Effect of the fluorescent indicator calcein on Mg and Sr incorporation into foraminiferal calcite. Geochem Geophys Geosys 10: 1–13.
          • 44. Smith AM, Stewart B, Key M, Jamet CM (2001) Growth and carbonate production by Adeonellopsis (Bryozoa: Cheilostomata) in Doubtful Sound, New Zealand. Palaeogeogr Palaeoclim 175: 201–210.
          • 45. Kaehler S, McQuaid C (1999) Use of the fluorochrome calcein as an in situ growth marker in the brown mussel Perna perna. Mar Biol 133: 455–460.
          • 46. Bumguardner BW, King TL (1996) Toxicity of oxytetracycline and calcein to juvenile striped bass. T Am Fish Soc 125: 143–145.
          • 47. Hermansen P, Larsen SP, Riisgård HU (2001) Colony growth rate of encrusting marine bryozoans (Electra pilosa and Celleporella hyalina). J Exp Mar Biol Ecol 263: 1–23.
          • 48. Lisbjerg D, Petersen J (2001) Feeding activity, retention efficiency, and effects of temperature and particle concentration on clearance rate in the marine bryozoan Electra crustulenta. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 215: 133–141.
          • 49. Thomsen J, Melzner F (2010) Moderate seawater acidification does not elicit long-term metabolic depression in the blue mussel Mytilus edulis. Mar Biol 157: 2667–2676.
          • 50. Riisgård HU, Goldson A (1997) Minimal scaling of the lophophore filter-pump in ectoprocts (Bryozoa) excludes physiological regulation of filtration rate to nutritional needs. Test of hypothesis. Mar Ecol-Prog Ser 156: 109–120.
          • 51. Javidpour J, Molinero JC, Peschutter J, Sommer U (2009) Seasonal changes and population dynamics of the ctenophore Mnemiopsis leidyi after its first year of invasion in the Kiel Fjord, Western Baltic Sea. Biol Invasions 11: 873–882.
          • 52. Maybury CA, Gwynn IA (1993) Wet processing of recent calcareous foraminifera: methods for preventing dissolution. J Micropalaeontol 12: 67–69.
          • 53. Dickson AG, Sabine CL, Christian JR (2007) Guide to Best Practices for Ocean CO2 Measurements. PICES spec. Dickson AG, Sabine CL, Christian JR, editors. 191 p.
            • 54. Lavigne H, Gattuso J-P (2010) seacarb: seawater carbonate chemistry with R. R package version 2.3.3. Software.
              • 55. Millero FJ (2010) Carbonate constants for estuarine waters. Mar Freshwater Res 61: 139–142.
              • 56. Perez FF, Fraga F (1987) The pH measurements in seawater on the NBS scale. Mar Chem 21: 315–327.
              • 57. Dickson AG (1990) Standard potential of the reaction: AgCl(s)+½H2(g) = Ag(s)+HCl(aq), and the standard acidity constant of the ion HSO4− in synthetic sea water from 273.15 to 318.15 K. Chem Thermodyn. 22: 113–127.
              • 58. Ries JB, Cohen AL, McCorkle DC (2009) Marine calcifiers exhibit mixed responses to CO2-induced ocean acidification. Geology 37: 1131–1134.
              • 59. Pistevos J, Calosi P, Widdicombe S, Bishop JD (2011) Will variation among genetic individuals influence species responses to global climate change? Oikos 120: 675–689.
              • 60. Durrant HM, Clark GF, Dworjanyn SA, Byrne M, Johnston EL (2012) Seasonal variation in the effects of ocean warming and acidification on a native bryozoan, Celleporaria nodulosa. Mar Biol 1–9.
                • 61. Bornhold BD, Milliman JD (1973) Generic and environmental control of carbonate mineralogy in serpulid (polychaete) tubes. J Geol 81: 363–373.
                • 62. Rucker JB, Carver RE (1969) A survey of the carbonate mineralogy of cheilostome Bryozoa. J Paleontol 43: 791–799.
                • 63. Smith AM, Keyjr M, Gordon D (2006) Skeletal mineralogy of bryozoans: Taxonomic and temporal patterns. Earth Sci Rev 78: 287–306.
                • 64. Taylor PD, James NP, Bone Y, Kuklinski P, Kyser TK (2009) Evolving mineralogy of cheilostome bryozoans. Palaios 24: 440–452.
                • 65. Weiner S, Addadi L (2011) Crystallization pathways in biomineralization. Ann Rev of Mater Res 41: 21–40.
                • 66. Ippolitov AP, Rzhavsky AV (2008) On the tube microstructure of recent spirorbids (Annelida, Polychaeta). Dokl Biol Sci 418: 20–22.
                • 67. Rodolfo-Metalpa R, Houlbrèque F, Tambutté É, Boisson F, Baggini C, et al. (2011) Coral and mollusc resistance to ocean acidification adversely affected by warming. Nature Climate Change 1: 308–312.
                • 68. Rodolfo-Metalpa R, Lombardi C, Cocito S, Hall-Spencer JM, Gambi MC (2010) Effects of ocean acidification and high temperatures on the bryozoan Myriapora truncata at natural CO2 vents. Mar Ecol 31: 447–456.
                • 69. Cigliano M, Gambi MC, Rodolfo-Metalpa R, Patti FP, Hall-Spencer JM (2010) Effects of ocean acidification on invertebrate settlement at volcanic CO2 vents. Mar Biol 157: 2489–2502.
                • 70. Hyman L (1958) The occurrence of chitin in the lophophorate phyla. Biol Bull 114: 106–112.
                • 71. Waeschenbach A, Taylor PD, Littlewood DTJ (2012) A molecular phylogeny of bryozoans. Mol Phylogenet Evol 62: 718–735.
                • 72. Dupont S, Lundve B, Thorndyke M (2010) Near future ocean acidification increases growth rate of the lecithotrophic larvae and juveniles of the sea star Crossaster papposus. J. Exp. Zool. (Mol. Dev. Evol.) 314B: 382–389.
                • 73. Wood H, Spicer J, Widdicombe S (2008) Ocean acidification may increase calcification rates, but at a cost. P Roy Soc B-Biol Sci 275: 1767–1773.
                • 74. Hageman S, Needham L, Todd C (2009) Threshold effects of food concentration on the skeletal morphology of the bryozoan Electra pilosa (Linnaeus, 1767). Lethaia 42: 438–451.
                • 75. Pratt MC (2008) Living where the flow is right: How flow affects feeding in bryozoans. Integr Comp Biol 48: 808–822.
                • 76. Okamura B (1988) The influence of neighbors on the feeding of an epifaunal bryozoan. J Exp Mar Biol Ecol 120: 105–123.
                • 77. Okamura B (1992) Microhabitat variation and patterns of colony growth and feeding in a marine bryozoan. Ecology 73: 1502–1513.
                • 78. Mercado JM, Carmona R, Niell FX (1998) Bryozoans increase available CO2 for photosynthesis in Gelidium sesquipedale (Rhodophyceae). J Phycol 34: 925–927.
                • 79. Bishop JDD (1989) Colony form and the exploitation of spatial refuges by encrusting Bryozoa. Biol Rev 64: 197–218.
                • 80. Stebbing AR (1973) Competition for space between the epiphytes of Fucus serratus L. J Mar Biol Assoc U K. 53: 247–261.
                • 81. O’Connor R, Seed R, Boaden PJS (1980) Resource space partitioning by the Bryozoa of a Fucus serratus L. Community. J Exp Mar Biol Ecol 45: 117–137.
                • 82. Best MA, Thorpe JP (1986) Feeding-current interactions and competition for food among the bryozoan epiphytes of Fucus serratus. Mar Biol 93: 371–375.
                • 83. Daly JM (1978) The annual cycle and the short term periodicity of breeding in a Northumberland population of Spirorbis spirorbis (Polychaeta: Serpulidae). J Mar Biol Assoc U K 58: 161–176.
                • 84. Kurihara H (2008) Effects of CO2-driven ocean acidification on the early developmental stages of invertebrates. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 373: 275–284.
                • 85. Potswald HE (1967) Observations on the genital segments of Spirorbis (polychaeta). Bio Bull 132: 91–107.
                • 86. Daly JM, Golding DW (1977) A description of the spermatheca of Spirorbis spirorbis (L.) (Polychaeta: Serpulidae) and evidence for a novel mode of sperm transmission. J Mar Biol Assoc U K 57: 219–227.
                • 87. Desrosiers RR, Désilets J, Dubé F (1996) Early developmental events following fertilization in the giant scallop Placopecten magellanicus. Can J Fish Aqua Sci 53: 1382–1392.
                • 88. Kurihara H, Shirayama Y (2004) Effects of increased atmospheric CO2 on sea urchin early development. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 274: 161–169.
                • 89. Ellis RP, Bersey J, Rundle SD, Hall-Spencer JM, Spicer JI (2009) Subtle but significant effects of CO2 acidified seawater on embryos of the intertidal snail, Littorina obtusata. Aquat Biol 5: 41–48.
                • 90. Dupont ST, Havenhand J, Thorndyke W, Peck L, Thorndyke MC (2008) Near-future level of CO2-driven ocean acidification radically affects larval survival and development in the brittlestar Ophiothrix fragilis. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 373: 285–294.
                • 91. De Silva PHDH (1962) Experiments on choice of substrata by spirorbis larvae (serpulidae). J Exp Biol 39: 483–490.
                • 92. Al-Ogily SM (1985) Further experiments on larval behaviour of the tubicolous polychaete Spirorbis inornatus L’Hardy & Quiévreux. J Exp Mar Biol Ecol 86: 285–298.
                • 93. Qian P-Y (1999) Larval settlement of polychaetes. Hydrobiologia 402: 239–253.
                • 94. Munday PL, Dixson DL, Donelson JM, Jones GP, Pratchett MS, et al. (2009) Ocean acidification impairs olfactory discrimination and homing ability of a marine fish. P Natl Acad Sci U S A 106: 1848–1852.