Figures
Abstract
The Pleistocene vertebrate assemblage of Aldabra Atoll has been comparatively well studied. Three Upper Pleistocene fossil localities have been described yielding birds, reptiles and terrestrial molluscs. Those of Bassin Cabri and Bassin Lebine on Ile Picard are undated but must be in excess of 136,000 YBP, whereas Point Hodoul on Malabar Island is circa 100,000 YBP. Aldabra was seemingly completely submerged between deposition of the Ile Picard and Point Hodoul deposits, resulting in local faunal extinctions. Here we present the results of an ongoing study of fossil material collected on Ile Picard in 1987, which reveals a more diverse assemblage than previously realised. Notable discoveries are an Ardeola heron, three Procellariformes, tropic-bird Phaethon, gull Larus, rail Dryolimnas, harrier Circus and owl Tyto, plus evidence of recolonisation of the atoll by some seabirds, rail, harrier, owl, giant tortoises and lizards after the Ile Picard/Point Hodoul submergence event.
Citation: Hume JP, Martill D, Hing R (2018) A terrestrial vertebrate palaeontological review of Aldabra Atoll, Aldabra Group, Seychelles. PLoS ONE 13(3): e0192675. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0192675
Editor: William Oki Wong, Indiana University Bloomington, UNITED STATES
Received: July 29, 2017; Accepted: January 29, 2018; Published: March 28, 2018
Copyright: © 2018 Hume et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All accession files are available from the United States National Museum database (accession numbers) USNM 381095 (bulk number for collection of 573 fossil bones), USNM UJP79, USNM 96A, USNM UPJ15. All other relevant data are within the paper.
Funding: JPH received funding for fossil preparation from the Percy Sladen Centenary Fund. https://www.linnean.org/the-society/medals-awards-prizes-grants/percy-sladen-memorial-fund-grants. The other authors received no specific funding for this work.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Introduction
Aldabra Atoll in the southwestern Indian Ocean is an isolated, raised atoll, the second largest in the world after Kiribati in the central Pacific Ocean (Figs 1 and 2). Aldabra Atoll is famous for harbouring the densest population of giant tortoises anywhere (>100,000), and is also home to the last surviving flightless bird in the Indian Ocean, the endemic subspecies of the White-throated Rail Dryolimnas cuvieri aldabranus [1–3]. Because of its unique fauna and flora, including over 400 endemic species, Aldabra was designated the first UNESCO World Heritage Site in 1982 [4]. However, the previous introduction of domestic goats Capra aegagrus, domestic cats Felis catus and the Black Rat Rattus rattus resulted in the decline and probable extinction of some terrestrial gastropods and extinction of the endemic Aldabra Brush Warbler Nesillas aldabrana, last recorded in 1983 [5–6].
The atoll includes a number of Pleistocene fossil localities that contain terrestrial gastropod assemblages [7], but only three vertebrate fossil localities are known. These are Bassin Cabri and Bassin Lebine on Ile Picard (West Island) (Fig 2), with deposits older than 136,000 YBP, based on 230Th/234U dating of the Aldabra Limestone [8–9], and Point Hodoul on Malabar (South Island), the youngest of the three at 100,000 YBP [10]. Limited numbers of fossil reptile remains have been described from Bassin Cabri [11], and Harrison & Walker [9] described an endemic gadfly petrel Pterodroma kurodai (Fig 3) and a terrestrial duck Aldabranus cabri from the same locality. Conversely, large numbers of reptile bones, including six species of lizard, giant tortoises and a horned crocodilian, Aldabrachampsus dilophus, were found at Point Hodoul, but a single bone of Dryolimnas cuvieri was the only avian element recovered [9, 11–12]. The material described in this analysis comes from the Bassin Cabri and Bassin Lebine localities.
Specimen number USNM 78. Scale bar = 10mm.
From March 26 –April 15, 1987, John Becker, formerly of the Smithsonian Institution, collected a large series of fossils encased in matrix from Bassin Cabri and Bassin Lebine, of which many were never fully prepared and none described. Here we present the results of a long-term project to acid-prepare the remaining material collected by Becker, and provide hitherto unrecorded information about the original avian diversity of Aldabra Atoll during the Upper Pleistocene. Furthermore, we examined the holotype and paratype Pterodroma kurodai material as well as the Dryolimas cuvieri material examined by Harrison & Walker [9], which provide additional details about the faunal diversity of the Atoll.
Geography
Aldabra Atoll (9°24′S, 46°22′E) is part of the Aldabra Group, comprising Aldabra Atoll, Assumption Island and the atolls of Astove and Cosmeledo. It is situated 425 km to the northwest of Madagascar and belongs to the outer islands of the Seychelles, situated 1,138 km from the granitic islands to the northeast (Fig 1). Aldabra is the second largest raised coral reef in the world with an elevation of 8 m at its highest point [13]. The atoll is surrounded by a coral reef and is 34 km long and 13 km wide with a surface area of 380 km2, of which 196 km2 comprises a large shallow internal lagoon [13–15]. The lagoon has a very high tidal range for an oceanic atoll, with a mean spring-tide range of 2.74 m [16], with four main tidal passages that connect the lagoon to the surrounding ocean; the largest, Grande Passe (Main Channel), is a 65 m wide and around 20 m deep channel on the north west coast [15–16]. These tidal channels divide Aldabra into four main islands: Grande Terre (South Island), Malabar (Middle Island), Polymnie Island and Ile Picard (West Island) (Fig 2).
Aldabra is subject to the northwest monsoon from circa November to March (Austral summer) and south-easterly trade winds which are drier, for the remainder of the year, [17–18]. Aldabra is rarely affected by cyclones, unlike other southwestern Indian Ocean islands (e.g. Mascarene Islands), and receives an average of 960 millimetres (38 in) rainfall per year [18–19]. The highest monthly mean maximum temperature is recorded in December at 31°C (88°F), whereas the lowest mean minimum temperature is recorded in August at 22°C (72°F) [17,18–21].
Geology and geological history
The surface geology of Aldabra Atoll is represented entirely by Pleistocene and Holocene strata; no data are available for earlier geological events. It is complex, reflecting numerous periods of uplift and submergence, summarised in detail in references [8, 10, 13–14]. There are at least three major marine transgressive events represented entirely by carbonate and phosphate deposition. As there is only one dated sequence (Aldabra Limestone), the age of the others is based on their depositional sequence, and are here presented oldest first.
The Esprit limestone and phosphorites
The earliest deposits on Aldabra are the Esprit limestone (quiet-water calcarenites) and the Esprit phosphorites of the lagoonal Esprit Island and adjacent area (Fig 2). These were deposited in calm water conditions in a shallow lagoon, at which time the atoll was completely submerged. These deposits contain abundant marine molluscs but very few corals [10] and are older than 136,000 YBP [14]. Lower sea levels saw the exposure of the sediments in sub-aerial conditions, resulting in the cementation and dissolution of the limestone to form a dissected karst topography, at which time phosphates, probably derived from sea bird guano, accumulated in open cavities. At this time Aldabra may have been as large as 365 km2, the total area of the bank exposed during the lowest sea levels [10, 14].
Picard calcarenites
Subsequently, rising waters resulted in the deposition of the still undated Picard Calcarenites that gave rise to an island, which may have been 20 km2 in area [10], and was colonised by giant Fs, birds, crocodiles and terrestrial snails (Bassin Cabri and Bassin Lebine fossil deposits). There is also evidence of seasonal bodies of fresh water [10]. During this time extensive sub-aerial disolution and local deposition of terrestrial soils occurred [8].
Takamaka limestone
The second major marine incursion is represented by the Takamaka Limestone, consisting largely of a fine calcarenite deposited in quiet-water conditions, and characterized by abundant calcareous, benthic red algae, with few corals or molluscs [10, 13]; exposures of this limestone rise to approximately 2 m above present sea level (PSL). The geology suggests that the atoll was possibly totally submerged during deposition of this unit, but the rise of only 2 m above PSL, compared with 8 m during deposition of the Aldabra Limestone (see below), leaves room for doubt; smaller refugia islands may have remained above-sea level.
Aldabra limestone
A third major marine incursion is represented by the Aldabra Limestone, and all available geological and palaeontological evidence supports a complete inundation event during this time. Deposited between 118,000 and 136,000 YBP ± 9,000, it covers most of the outer rim of the atoll and rises to around 8 m above PSL, forming some low cliffs [13]; the sea level had risen to ~10 m above PSL. It consists of coarse calcarenites and calcirudites with abundant well preserved corals and marine molluscs [8, 14]. A subsequent interrupted fall in sea level, eventually to ~120 m at the last glacial maximum, cut two distinct terraces of 8 m and 4–6 m above PSL along the coast line [13–14]. This event corresponds with geological evidence on Bermuda, South Atlantic, when the onset of the last interglacial (Marine Isotope Stage 5 (MIS 5)) completely inundated the island [22]. Due to falling sea levels, Aldabra now comprised a ring of narrow, low rocky islets surrounding a wide shallow lagoon [10]. Terrestrial deposits (soils) accumulated in the irregular cavities and in pools, and it is these that contain high densities of vertebrate remains [13]; the undated reptile-rich Point Hodoul, a cavity fill deposit, accumulated at some time during this period [10].
Post 118,000 YBP
Aldabra became a steep-sided, large rocky island, possibly up to 100 m high relative to sea level and perhaps of around 400 km2, for an unknown duration during the Würm Glaciation beginning 115,000 YBP, and to the Late Wisconsin (85,000–11,000 YBP) in which the last glacial maximum occurred approximately 25,000–21,000 YBP [10, 13, 23]. The subsequent ocean rise to its PSL, and heavy erosion due to high rainfall, saw the breaching of the land rim by sea water, resulting in a reduction of land surface area by nearly 60% [7, 10]. This event may have occurred as recently as 5,000–7,000 YBP [24–25]. All limestone on Aldabra is heavily eroded by intense dissolution and probable bioerosion, with a karstic topography of jagged pinnacles (champignon), flat areas of a probable old lagoon floor (platin), and relatively smooth areas broken by deep pot holes and pits (pavé) [26]. Eroded reef-platforms have produced fine carbonate sands on the lagoon floor and formed pocket beaches and sand dunes, especially on the windward south coast.
Petrography and mineralogy of the fossiliferous limestone
A number of studies provided a petrographic study of the carbonates of Aldabra have concluded that the petrology was generally heterogeneous with considerable lateral and vertical facies diversity; mineralogy and porosity were also extremely diverse [26–28]. The limestone has been subject to much reworking, so that large volumes consist of phosphatic cement sequences with infilled cavities or are internal sediments [26]. The analysed samples were simple bioclastic deposits, cemented by high magnesium calcite or aragonite, with the presence of small amounts of phosphates. The petrology of the Picard calcarenites (calcarenite and calcilutite) contained a mineralogy of aragonite, calcite, low and high magnesium calcite and iron oxides [27]. No information is available for Point Hodoul.
Upper Pleistocene vegetation
The Bassin Cabri and Bassin Lebine area on Ile Picard at the time of the deposition of the Picard calcarenites was probably well vegetated, but with a moist, low, grassy habitat and an absence of true soil development [7]; a terrestrial gastropod fauna was abundant. Fossil pollen and spores reveal a vegetational change occurred at the time of the Takamaka deposits, showing that the atoll had an irregular rocky surface with true soil accumulation in pockets. The abundant and diverse gastropod assemblage suggests open, low vegetation habitats subject to periodic flooding, open wood and scrub with leaf litter development, to drier habitats with open scrub [7]. The diversity of vertebrates and terrestrial gastropods of Point Hodoul’s pipe-fill deposits indicate that the atoll was probably well vegetated, with a complex open or dense scrub and scrub forest, generally xerophytic, and broken by open grass areas, perhaps similar to the present-day vegetation, but with a higher rainfall [7, 29].
Present-day vegetation
Around 273 species of plants, 19 of which are endemic, have been recorded on Aldabra [29–30]. The vegetation has been divided into zones, with the most important being: Pemphis scrub (Pemphis acidula), which forms almost pure stands up to 6 m tall at lower levels and mixes with Sideroxylon and other scrub species at higher levels; Mixed scrub and scrub woodland which consists of a large diversity of evergreen species, especially Pandanus; and Mangroves that occur within the lagoon and occupy a total area of around 800 ha [30–32]. However, due to absence of terrestrial sediment and considerable flushing due to high tidal ranges, the tallest mangrove trees attain a height of only 10 m, and are generally much shorter [32]. Other vegetation components are: Broadleaf forest comprising Pisonia, Thespesia and Calophyllum (Takamaka); Scaevola coastal scrub of coastal and inland areas; and Sporobolus grassland, Sclerodactylon tussock grassland and Tortoise turf which are heavily grazed by giant tortoises. Tortoise turf is a distinct association of grasses, sedges and herbs [2, 30]. Because they occur in the areas of the highest tortoise concentration and are subject to intense tortoise grazing, more than half of these Tortoise turf species are genetically dwarfed and consequently has evolved highly specialised growth strategies, e.g. flowers and fruits produced at the base of the plants [31].
Present day vertebrate fauna
The avian vertebrate fauna comprises 12 endemic terrestrial birds and 14 breeding natives [3, 33–34] (Table 1), and numerous migrant and vagrant species, notably waders, occur, as comprehensively listed by Safford & Hawkins [3] and SRBC [34]. No native terrestrial mammals occur, but five bats (three endemic) are present [35–37]. Reptiles make up the remaining vertebrate fauna, which consists of the largest and densest population of giant tortoises, Aldabrachelys gigantea anywhere [2], but unlike in the Pleistocene assemblage, when Aldabran lizard diversity was high, only three species (one endemic) now inhabit the atoll [38–39] (Table 2).
Introduced fauna
A number of alien species have been introduced to Aldabra Atoll since its settlement by humans in 1880, which include the accidental introduction of black rat Rattus rattus (circa 1890) and some lizards, and the intentional introduction of goat Capra aegagrus (circa 1878) and cat Felis catus (circa 1892) [40]. The mammalian introductions have been particularly detrimental to the endemic fauna of Aldabra.
Materials and methods
All fossil material mentioned is accessioned to the collection of the United States National Museum (USNM) except where stated otherwise. A large amount of fossil material had been prepared prior to this study, with the remaining fossil samples still in matrix. These were submerged in 10% acetic acid to free the fossiliferous material, and once this was completed the acetic acid was neutralised in water. No additional preparation was undertaken on the majority of the specimens, but the more delicate specimens were coated with Paraloid B-72 to consolidate them and prevent damage. Fossil material was compared with Aldabra fossil specimens, held at the Palaeontology division of the Department of Earth Sciences, Natural History Museum, London (NHMUK), which were collected in 1969 by Dr. J. D. Taylor. All measurements were made using a dial calipers and rounded to the nearest 0.1 mm. Much of the fossil material used in this analysis is fragmentary, so obtaining measurements was sometimes problematic. Osteological abbreviations used in the text are R (right), L (left), p (proximal) and d (distal). Bird nomenclature follows Safford & Hawkins [3]. Unless otherwise stated, all fossil material is bulk numbered USNM 381095.
Results
Systematic Palaeontology.
Aves.
Procellariformes Fürbringer, 1888 [41].
Procellariidae Leach, 1820 [42].
Pterodroma Bonaparte, 1856 [43].
Pterodroma kurodai Harrison & Walker, 1978 [9].
Material: 380+ bones representing nearly all parts of the cranial and post cranial skeleton.
Fossil locality: Bassin Cabri and Bassin Lebine.
Status: Extinct, endemic, known only from fossils.
Remarks: From the material collected by Becker, including specimens already prepared by him, we have 416 identifiable avian bones, of which 362 are specifically assigned to Pterodroma kurodai, i.e. 87%. The deposit includes articulated specimens and juveniles, which confirms that a breeding population was present at Bassin Cabri and Bassin Lebine. P. kurodai is slightly larger in post-cranial elements than the otherwise similar-sized P. leucoptera (Fig 4), but smaller than any extant Pterodroma petrels from the south-western Indian Ocean, and Mascarene Petrel Pseudobulweria aterrima from Réunion Island, Mascarenes.
Scale bar = 10mm.
Pterodroma sp. (large).
Material: Ld, Rd and Rp humerus; R humerus shaft fragment; Ld and Rd ulna; Ld carpometacarpus; R femur; Lp, Ld tibiotarsus.
Fossil locality: Bassin Lebine.
Status: Extant?
Remarks: Unassociated premaxilla and post-cranial bones belonging to a large Pterodroma species much larger than P. kurodai show that a second species was present on Aldabra in the Upper Pleistocene. Given the scarcity of remains, this taxon may not have been a resident breeder.It could represent one of the extant larger Pterodroma species present today elsewhere in the Indian Ocean, but more material is needed to confirm this. Species that fall within the size range and inhabiting the Indian Ocean are Trindade Petrel P. arminjoniana and Kermadec Petrel P. neglecta.
Puffinus Brisson, 1760 [44].
Puffinus sp.
Material: Associated and partially articulated post-cranial skeleton, plus premaxilla; R humerus shaft; Rd femur; Ld tibiotarsus; R, L, Lp, Ld, Rd, Rp tarsometatarsus.
Fossil locality: Bassin Cabri and Bassin Lebine.
Status: Extinct/extirpated?
Remarks: The Tropical Shearwater Puffinus bailloni is the only resident breeding species of procellarid on Aldabra, whereas the osteologically similar Wedge-tailed Shearwater Puffinus pacifica and Flesh-footed Shearwater P. carneipes are occasional vagrants to Aldabra. The procellarid fossils are too small to belong to P. carneipes, are too large to belong to P. bailloni, but are within the smaller size range of P. pacificus, which is common throughout the Indian Ocean and breeds on many islands [3]; the fossils are approximately the same size as Manx Shearwater P. puffinus, although the latter does not occur in the Indian Ocean region. The small size range of the fossil material suggests that a different species of Puffinus may once have occurred on Aldabra, but is no longer present.
Hydrobatidae Mathews, 1912 [45].
Oceanodroma monorhis? (Swinhoe, 1867) [46].
Material: Rp ulna.
Fossil locality: Bassin Lebine.
Status: Extant?
Remarks: This ulna fragment is the only evidence that a probable Oceanodroma storm petrel occurred on Aldabra during the Upper Pleistocene. Swinhoe’s Storm-petrel Oceanodroma monorhis is a rare straggler to the atoll [3], and the specimen is within its size range, but too fragmentary to identify to species.
Phaethontiformes Sharpe, 1891 [47].
Phaethontidae Brandt, 1840 [48].
Phaethon Linnaeus, 1758 [49].
Phaethon rubricauda Boddaert, 1783 [50].
Material: Rd coracoid; L humerus; x2 Ld humerus; Rd humerus; L ulna; Rd carpometacarpus.
Fossil locality: Bassin Cabri and Bassin Lebine.
Status: Extant.
Remarks: The Red-tailed Tropicbird is a common breeding resident on Aldabra today, and is widespread throughout the Indian and Pacific oceans. Although scarce, the fossil remains comprise two individuals which suggests that it was also a resident species in the Upper Pleistocene of Aldabra.
Pelecaniformes Sharpe, 1891 [47].
Ardeidae Leach, 1820 [42].
?Ardeola sp. F. Boie, 1822 [51].
Material: Ld femur.
Fossil locality: Bassin Lebine.
Status: Extant/extirpated.
Remarks: This femur, although fragmentary, is almost certainly referable to an Ardeola pond heron. The Madagascar Pond Heron Ardeola idae breeds in small numbers on Aldabra today, which confirms that it or a similar species was present on Aldabra in the Upper Pleistocene.
Accipitriformes Vieillot, 1816 [52].
Accipitridae Vieillot, 1816 [52].
Circinae Sundevall, 1836 [53].
Circus Lacépède 1799 [54].
Circus sp.
Material: Associated, but crushed Lp coracoid; L radius shaft fragment; Lp tibiotarsus fragment; L carpometacarpus; Rd femur. Also Rp ulna; L tibiotarsus; Rd tarsometatarsus; ungual (Bassin Lebine).
Fossil locality: Bassin Cabri and Bassin Lebine.
Status: Extant?
Remarks: A least three individuals of a Circus sp. are represented in the fossil deposits, which strongly suggests that a local breeding population was present. The fossils are in the size range of the endemic Indian Ocean island species, Réunion Harrier C. maillardi, which today is known only from Réunion (extant) and Mauritius (extirpated) [55], but is smaller than Madagascar Marsh Harrier C. macrosceles, which occurs on Madagascar and the Comoros [3]. Two species of Circus, Pallid Harrier C. macrourus, which is of similar size, and Western Marsh Harrier C. aeruginosus, which is much larger, are rare vagrants to the Seychelles [34], but neither have been recorded on Aldabra.
Gruiformes Bonaparte, 1854 [55].
Rallidae Rafinesque, 1815 [56].
Dryolimnas Sharpe, 1893 [57].
Dryolimnas cuvieri Pucheran, 1845 [58].
Dryolimnas cuvieri cf. aldabranus Günther, 1879 [59].
Material: L humerus; Rd humerus (USNM UJP79).
Fossil locality: Bassin Cabri.
Status: Extant.
Remarks: A complete left and distal right humerus of White-throated Rail Dryolimnas cuvieri falls within the size range of the present flightless population of D. c. aldabranus, suggesting that the taxon was similarly flightless during the Upper Pleistocene (Fig 5). A distal tarsometatarsus collected from Point Hodoul is more robust than volant D. c. cuvieri and D. c. aldabranus, being more similar in size and morphology to the recently extinct, flightless subspecies, D. c. abbotti from Assumption Island [9].
From left to right, D. cuvieri aldabranus NHMUK S/1989.38.7 ♂; D. cuvieri (Upper Pleistocene) USNM UJP79 unsexed; D. c. abbotti NHMUK 1910.4.8.1 unsexed; D. c. cuvieri NHMUK 1897.5.10.47 unsexed. Scale bar = 10mm.
Charadriiformes Huxley, 1867 [60].
Laridae Rafinesque, 1815 [56].
Larus Linnaeus, 1758 [49].
Larus sp.
Material: Rd humerus.
Fossil locality: Bassin Lebine.
Status: Extant?
Remarks: A distal end of a humerus confirms the presence of Larus on Aldabra during the Upper Pleistocene. The only Larus species recorded from Aldabra is Lesser Black-backed Gull Larus fuscus, which is a rare vagrant [3], but this species is inseparable osteologically from Yellow-legged Gull L. micahellis, which may have occurred further south in the past. Two other gull genera, Chroicocephalus sp. and Sooty Gull Icthyaetus hemprichii are vagrant to the main Seychelles islands, but are too small to be referable. This individual fossil specimen is similar in morphology and size to L. fuscus, but with only a single bone available, we suggest a similarity to a Larus species, rather than assigning it specifically to L. fuscus.
Strigiformes Wagler, 1830 [61].
Tytonidae Ridgway, 1914 [62].
Tyto Billberg, 1828 [63].
Tyto sp.
Material: distal ulna.
Fossil locality: Bassin Cabri.
Status: Extinct/extirpated.
Remarks: This specimen NHMUK A4379 was mis-identified by Harrison & Walker [9] as a paratype of Pterodroma kurodai (Fig 6). It was not described or listed in their description of that species, so a zoological nomenclature resolution is not necessary here. The specimen is similar in size and morphology to Barn Owl Tyto alba, and within the individual size variation exhibited in this species. Because of the fragmentary nature of the specimen, little more can be said about it.
Testudines Batsch, 1788 [64].
Cryptodira Cope, 1868 [65].
Testudinoidea Fitzinger, 1826 [66].
Testunidae Batsch, 1788 [64].
Aldabrachelys Loveridge & Williams, 1957 [67].
Aldabrachelys gigantea Loveridge & Williams, 1957 [67].
Material: vertebra; scapula-coracoid fragment (USNM 96A); phalanx ungual.
Fossil locality: Bassin Cabri.
Status: Extant.
Remarks: Giant tortoises were present and presumably common on Aldabra during the Upper Pleistocene and remain common today. They appear to be of Madagascan origin, therefore as Aldabra was presumably colonised by the Madagascar Giant Tortoise Aldabrachelys abrupta, it has been suggested that it recolonised on at least three occasions after the submergence of the atoll during high sea stands [7]. However, it is equally likely that small areas of land allowed survival of giant tortoises during some of the marine incursions.
Squamata Oppel, 1811 [68].
Lacertilia Günther, 1867 [69].
Scincomorpha Camp, 1923 [70].
Scincidae Gray, 1825 [71].
Trachylepis Fitzinger, 1843 [72].
?Trachylepis sp.
Material: dentary; vertebrae.
Fossil locality: Bassin Cabri.
Status: Extinct/extirpated, known from fossils only.
Remarks: Arnold [11] described Mabuya (now Trachylepis) skinks from Point Hodoul, and these larger fossil elements confirm that a Trachlepis skink, most similar in size to T. comorensis, also occurred in the older deposits at Bassin Cabri.
Iguania Gray, 1827 [73].
Opluridae Titus & Frost, 1996 [74].
Oplurus cf. cuvieri Gray, 1831 [75].
Material: R dentary fragment (USNM UPJ15); L dentary fragment; R humerus; x3 vertebrae.
Fossil Locality: Bassin Cabri.
Status: Extinct/extirpated.
Remarks: Arnold [11] described an Oplurus iguana from Point Hodoul, but was unable to confirm if it was conspecific with the Madagascar species, Oplurus cuvieri, or represented a distinct taxon. The discovery of Oplurus fossil material from Bassin Cabri, the first recorded from the older deposit, confirms that iguanas were present before and after the Ile Picard/Point Hodoul submergence event.
Discussion
Analysis of the Bassin Cabri and Bassin Lebine fossil localities reveals a more diverse faunal composition in the Upper Pleistocene than previously documented, especially among sea birds. During deposition of the Picard calcarenites, as evidenced at Bassin Cabri, Aldabra at 136,000+ YBP, Aldabra was an extensive, prograding carbonate sand cay that developed behind an active reef, rose to a probable maximum of 2 m above sea level, and was heavily vegetated but lacked true soil development [7, 13]. A probable shallow dune field occurred at the western end, in which standing bodies of fresh water occurred between the dunes [13]. The island was colonised by terrestrial snails, including Tropidophora, which is an inhabitant of drier, more open areas, an Oplurus iguanid lizard, giant tortoises, an endemic population of gadfly petrels Pterodroma kurodai, and a terrestrial duck Aldabranus cabri [7, 9, 11–12]. This duck is known from just two fragmentary bones collected at Bassin Cabri, with no new material recovered in this study. Alongside the above-named fauna was alarge Pterodroma, a Puffinus shearwater, an Oceanodroma storm petrel, a flightless White-throated Rail D. cuvieri and possibly resident/endemic populations of a Circus harrier and a Tyto barn owl. Sea and shore birds included Red-tailed Tropicbird P. rubricauda, a Larus gull and a possible Ardeola pond heron. Giant tortoise A. gigantea and at least two terrestrial lizards, Trachylepis and Oplurus, were also present, the last-named were previously only known from Point Hodoul. Crocodilian teeth have been reported from this deposit, and used to be thought to represent Nile Crocodile Crocodylus niloticus [11, 39], but all have now been referred to the endemic horned crocodile Aldabrachampsus dilophus [12].
The younger deposit of Point Hodoul, at 100,000 YBP as inferred by [14], is separated from the Bassin Cabri deposits by the Aldabra limestone [11]. The Point Hodoul deposit indicates higher precipitation, with resulting denser scrub and leaf litter development [7]. A much greater diversity of fossil reptiles is reported from this deposit (Table 2), including A. dilophus, Trachylepis and Scelotes skinks, Geckolepis, Paroedura and Phelsuma gecko species and numerous giant tortoise bones. The only bird is represented by a single distal tarsometatarsus of White-throated Rail Dryolimnas cuvieri [9]. The high density of lizards, particularly as they include nocturnal species [11], suggests predation by owls, and although from the older Bassin Cabri deposits, the discovery of a Tyto element confirms its presence during the Upper Pleistocene. Furthermore, a Barn Owl Tyto alba occurred on Aldabra in recent times until 1906 [33], but it was not formally described and no museum specimen exists.
The complete submergence of the Aldabra platform, evidenced by the Aldabra Limestone unit separating the younger Point Hodoul deposit from that of Bassin Cabri and Bassin Lebine, saw the complete extinction, in the case of the Aldabra Petrel and Aldabra Duck, or extirpation of much of the Upper Pleistocene fauna 136,000 YBP. The last interglacial (MIS 5) on Bermuda also resulted in the extinction of all endemic birds, including a crane, a duck, and a flightless rail [22]. Therefore the presence of a reptile-rich deposit at Point Hodoul suggests that the atoll was subsequently recolonised by the above-named lizards, and some bird taxa, most notably a Dryolimnas rail. Giant tortoises appear to have recolonised Aldabra from Madagascar at least three times after these submergence events, presumably due to their ability to cover large expanses of open ocean by floating [1, 76]. If land refugia occurred elsewhere, e.g. Assumption Island, it could have required a shorter recolonisation distance than from Madagascar or the Comoros. It is not known for certain when the lizard fauna disappeared, because no Holocene fossil deposits exist, but the breaching of the Aldabra land rim and flooding of the lagoon around 5,000–7,000 YBP, which resulted in the loss of 60% of the land surface area, may have been the cause [1, 10].
Another interesting discovery is the presence of an unidentified Circus harrier in both of the Ile Picard deposits, representing at least three individuals, of which one is a skeletally associated individual. This suggests that a resident population was present on Aldabra in the Upper Pleistocene, especially during sea level low stands when the land surface area was greater. Furthermore, confirmation that a Tyto owl was also present in the older deposit of Bassin Cabri has added another predatory bird to the atoll’s faunal list. As the atoll was submerged between the Bassin Cabri and Point Hodoul deposits, owls must have colonised the atoll on at least two occasions during the Upper Pleistocene, as the rich owl-deposited lizard accumulations at Point Hodoul suggests that an owl was resident [1]; it is very likely that Tyto alba was involved on both occasions.
A recently reported fossil locality on Grand Terre contained giant tortoise and crocodile remains, all found loose on the surface in an area surrounding a pond [77]. The crocodile elements appear to belong to Nile Crocodile Crocodylus niloticus, and not to the endemic Aldabrachampsus dilophus, which suggests that Nile crocodile colonised Aldabra after the extinction of the latter. The authors state that the fossil material is Upper Pleistocene, but this is based on the Upper Pleistocene date for the Aldabra Limestone [8]. We suggest that as it was surface material, and not in matrix as was all other Upper Pleistocene material described here, it is very likely to be much younger, probably Holocene in age. Therefore, our conclusions are not affected by this discovery.
The fossiliferous deposits of Bassin Cabri and Bassin Lebine represent a small but significant window into the original faunal diversity of Aldabra during the Upper Pleistocene. The deposits are dominated by seabirds, with few terrestrial bird species, but an abundant terrestrial reptile fauna. Furthermore, the majority of species are derived from the Malagasy region, including the Comoros, and not from SE Asia as in the case of the Mascarenes [78]. Our present understanding of the geological and palaeontological history of Aldabra is not sufficient to determine the number of times the atoll was completely submerged during the Upper Pleistocene, but the Aldabra Limestone depositional event shows that at least one complete inundation event occurred. Therefore, it is likely, based on the fossil evidence presented here, that an almost complete faunal turnover occurred between the Bassin Cabri/Bassin Lebine and the Point Hodoul fossil deposits during the Upper Pleistocene, and again between the Upper Pleistocene and Holocene due to fluctuating sea levels.
Supporting information
S1 File. Data deposition.
All fossil material in the text is deposited and accessioned in an appropriate public repository, the United States National Museum (USNM). All fossil material was loaned by the USNM for study and will be returned for permanent depository and public availability.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0192675.s001
(DOCX)
Acknowledgments
We thank Robert Prŷs-Jones (NHMUK), Anthony Cheke, Steve Goodman and an anonymous reviewer for comments that helped improve this paper. We thank Storrs Olson, Helen James, Jennifer Strotman and Mark Florence (USNM) for the long term loan of the J. Becker Aldabra material. We thank Sandra Chapman and Lorna Steel (NHMUK) for access to material in their care; Harry Taylor (NHMUK) for photography, and Robert Loveridge for some fossil preparation. We especially thank the Percy Sladen Centenary Fund whose financial support made this research possible.
References
- 1. Arnold EN. Indian Ocean giant tortoises: their systematics and island adaptations. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B. 1979;286:127–145.
- 2.
Cheke AS, Bour R. Unequal struggle—how humans displaced the tortoise's dominant place in island ecosystems. In: Gerlach J, editor, editor. Western Indian Ocean Tortoises: biodiversity, palaeontology, evolution and conservation. Manchester: Siri Scientific Press; 2014.p. 31–120.
- 3.
Safford R, Hawkins F. Birds of Africa, vol. VIII: the Malagasy region. London: Christopher Helm; 2013.
- 4. Stoddart DR, Ferrari JDM. Aldabra Atoll: a stunning success story in nature conservation. Nat. Resour. 1983;19:20–28.
- 5.
Gerlach J. Terrestrial and Freshwater Mollusca of the Seychelles. Leiden: Backhuys; 2006.
- 6.
Hume JP. Extinct Birds 2nd ed. London: Christopher Helm; 2017.
- 7. Taylor JD, Braithwaite CJR, Peake JF, Arnold EN. Terrestrial faunas and habitats of Aldabra during the late Pleistocene. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B. 1979:286:47–66.
- 8. Thomson J, Walton A. Redetermination of Chronology of Aldabra Atoll by 230Th/234U Dating. Nature 1972;240:145–146.
- 9. Harrison CJO, Walker CA. Pleistocene bird remains from Aldabra Atoll, Indian Ocean. J. Nat. Hist. 1978;12(1):7–14.
- 10. Braithwaite CJR, Taylor JD, Kennedy WJ. The evolution of an atoll: the depositional and erosional history of Aldabra. Phi. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B. 1973; 266:307–340.
- 11. Arnold EN. Fossil reptiles from Aldabra Atoll, Indian Ocean. Bull. British Mus. (Nat. Hist.) Zool. 1976;29(2):83–116.
- 12. Brochu CA. A new miniature horned crocodile from the Quaternary of Aldabra Atoll, western Indian Ocean. Copeia 2006;2:149–158.
- 13.
Plummer P. 1995. Planet Aldabra. In: Amin M, Willetts D, Skerrett A, editors. Aldabra—World Heritage Site. Nairobi: Camerapix International & Seychelles Islands Foundation: 1995. p. 49–70.
- 14.
Braithwaite CJR. Geology of the Seychelles. In: Stoddart DR, editor. Biogeography and ecology of the Seychelles Islands. The Hague, Netherlands: Dr W. Junk Publishers; 1984. p. 17–38.
- 15. Stoddart DR, Wright CA. Geography and geology of Aldabra Atoll. In: Stoddart DR, editor. Ecology of Aldabra Atoll. Atoll Res. Bull. 1967;118: p. 11–52.
- 16. Farrow GE, Brander KM. Tidal studies on Aldabra. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B. 1971;260:93–121.
- 17. Stoddart DR, Taylor JD, Fosberg FR, Farrow GE. Geomorphology of Aldabra Atoll Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B. 1971;260:31–66.
- 18. Hnatiuk RJ. Temporal and spatial variations in precipitation on Aldabra. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B. 1979;286:25–34.
- 19.
Walsh RPD. Climate of the Seychelles. In: Stoddart DR, editor. Biogeography and ecology of the Seychelles Islands. The Hague, Netherlands: Dr W. Junk Publishers; 1984. p. 39–62.
- 20. Stoddart DR, Walsh RPD. Long-term climatic change in the western Indian Ocean. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B. 1979;286:11–23.
- 21. Farrow GE. 1971. The climate of Aldabra Atoll. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B. 1971;260:67–91.
- 22. Olson SL, Hearty PJ, Pregill GK. Geological constraints on evolution and survival in endemic reptiles on Bermuda. J. Herpetolo. 2006:40:394–398.
- 23. Blaise B, Clague J, Mathewes R. Time of Maximum Late Wisconsin Glaciation, West Coast of Canada. Quat. Res. 1990;34(3):282–295.
- 24.
Bloom AL. Glacial-eustatic and isostatic controls of sea level since the last glaciation. In: Turekian KK, editor. Late Cenozoic ice ages. New Haven: Yale University Press; 1971. p. 355–379.
- 25. Camoin GF, Montaggioni LF, Braithwaite CJR. Late glacial to post glacial sea-levels in the western Indian Ocean. Marine Geol. 2004;206:119–146.
- 26. Braithwaite CJR. Petrology of palaeosols and other terrestrial sediments on Aldabra, Western Indian Ocean. Phi. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B 1975; 273:1–32.
- 27. Braithwaite CJR. The Petrology of Oolitic Phosphorites from Esprit (Aldabra), Western Indian Ocean. Phi. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B. 1980; 288:511–540.
- 28. Trudgill ST. Geochemistry and mineralogy of carbonate rock samples from Aldabra Atoll, Indian Ocean. Atoll Res. Bull. 1981;255:11–22.
- 29. Fosberg FR. Preliminary survey of Aldabra vegetation. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B. 1971;260:215–225.
- 30.
Fosberg FR, Renvoize S A. The flora of Aldabra and neighbouring islands. London: HMSO; 1980.
- 31.
Stoddart DR, Fosberg FR. Vegetation and floristics of western Indian Ocean coral islands. In: Stoddart DR, editor. Biogeography and ecology of the Seychelles Islands. The Hague, Netherlands: Dr W. Junk Publishers; 1984. p. 220–238.
- 32. Macnae W. Mangroves on Aldabra. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B. 1971; 260:237–247.
- 33. Benson CW, Penny MJ. The land birds of Aldabra. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B. 1971;260:417–527.
- 34.
SBRC (Seychelles Bird Records Committee). http://www.seychellesbirdrecordscommittee.com/ Accessed 01/09/2017.
- 35. Benda P, Vallo P. Taxonomic revision of the genus Triaenops (Chiroptera: Hipposideridae) with description of a new species from southern Arabia and definitions of a new genus and tribe. Folia Zool. 2009:58(Monograph 1):1–45.
- 36. Hutson AM. The bats of Aldabra atoll, Seychelles. Phelsuma 2004;12:126–132.
- 37. Goodman SM, Ranivo J. A new species of Triaenops (Mammalia, Chiroptera, Hipposideridae) from Aldabra Atoll, Picard Island (Seychelles). Zoosystema 2008;30(3): 681–693.
- 38.
Cheke AS. Lizards of the Seychelles. In: Stoddart DR, editor. Biogeography and ecology of the Seychelles Islands. The Hague, Netherlands: Dr W. Junk Publishers; 1984. p. 331–360.
- 39. Rocha S, Harris DJ, Perera A, Silva A, Vasconcelos R, Carretero A. Recent data on the distribution of lizards and snakes of the Seychelles. Herpetol. Bull. 2009;110:20–32.
- 40. Cheke A[S]. The timing of humans and their commensal animals on Western Indian Ocean oceanic islands. Phelsuma 2010;18:38–69.
- 41.
Fürbringer M. Untersuchungen zur morphologie und systematik der voögel, zugleich ein beitrag zur anatomie der stuötz- und bewegungsorgane. Amsterdam: T. van Holkema; 1888.
- 42.
Leach WE. Eleventh room, upper floor. In: Anon , editor. Synopsis of the contents of the British Museum 17th Edition. London: British Museum; 1820. p. 65–70.
- 43. Bonaparte CL. Espèces nouvelles d’Oiseaux d’ asie et d’Amérique, et tableaux paralléliques des Pélagians ou Gaviae. Compt. Rend. Acad. Sci. Paris 1856;42:764–776.
- 44.
Brisson MJ. Ornithologia–Ornithologie, 3 volumes. Paris: Joannus-Baptist Bauche; 1760.
- 45.
Mathews GM. The birds of Australia. Volume 2, Part 2. London: Witherby & Co; 1912.
- 46. Swinhoe R. Jottings on birds from my Amoy journal/Ornithological notes from Amoy. Ibis 1867–1868;(2)3:226–237, 385–413: (2)4: 52–65.
- 47.
Sharpe RB. A review of recent attempts to classify birds. Proc. 2nd Int. Orn. Congress, Budapest; 1891.
- 48. Brandt JF. Tentamen monographie zoologicae generis Phaëthon. Mem. l'Acad. Imp. Sci., St Petersburg 1840;(S6),5(2):239–275.
- 49.
Linnaeus C. Systema naturæ per regna tria naturæ, secundum classes, ordines, genera, species, cum characteribus, differentiis, synonymis, locis, edition 12, volume 1. Holmiæ: Laurentii Salvii; 1758.
- 50.
Boddaert P. Table des planchées enluminéez d’histoire naturelle. Utrecht; 1783.
- 51. Boie F. Ueber Classication, infonderheit der europäischen Vögel. Isis von Oken 1822.
- 52.
Vieillot LJP. Nouveau dictionnaire d’histoire naturelle. Volume 5. Paris: Déterville; 1816.
- 53. Sundeval CE. Ornithologiskt System. Kongl. Vetenskops Acad. Handl. 1836:43–130.
- 54.
Lacépède BGde. Tableau des sous-classes, divisions, sous-division, ordres et genres des oiseux. Discours d'ouverture et de clôture du cours d'histoire naturelle. Paris: Plassan; 1799.
- 55.
Bonaparte CL. Conspectus generum avium, volume 2. Lugduni Batavorum: E.J. Brill; 1854.
- 56.
Rafinesque CS. Analyse de la nature ou tableau de l'universe et des corps organisées. Palermo: L'Imprimerie de Jean Barravecchia; 1815.
- 57. Sharp RB. Classification of the Rallidae. BBOC 1893;5:26–29.
- 58. Pucheran MLD. Notes sur quelques espèces Madécasses de l’ordre des Échassiers. Rev. Zool. 1845:277–280.
- 59. Günther A. On the occurrence of a land-rail (Rallus) in the Island of Aldabra. Ann. Mag. Nat. Hist. 1879;(5)3:164–168.
- 60. Huxley TH. On the classification of birds; and on the taxonomic value of the modifications of certain of the cranial bones observable in that class. Proc. Zool. Soc. Lond. 1867:415–472.
- 61.
Wagler JG. Natürliches system der amphibian mit vorangehender classification der Säugthiere und Vögel. Ein beitrage zur verleichhenden Zoologie. Munich, Stuttgart and Tübingen; 1830.
- 62. Ridgway R. The Birds of North and Middle America, part 6. Bull. US Nat. Mus. 1914;50:1–882.
- 63.
Billberg GJ. Synopsis faunæ Scandinaviæ. Volume 1(2). Stockholm: Published by the author; 1828.
- 64.
Batsch GC. Versuch einer Unleitung, zur Kenntnis und Geschichte der Thiere und mineralien. Jena: Akademische Buchhandlung; 1788.
- 65. Cope ED. On the origin of genera. Proc. Acad. Nat. Sci. Philadelphia 1868:242–300.
- 66.
Fitzinger L. Neue Classification der Reptilien nach ihren naturlichen Verwandtschaften. Verlag J. G. Heubner, Wien; 1826.
- 67. Loveridge A, Williams EE. Revision of the African tortoises and turtles of the Suborder Cryptodira. Bull. Mus. Comparative Zoology, Harvard, 1957; 115(6):161–557.
- 68.
Oppel M. Die Ordnungen, Familien unda Gattungen der Reptilien als Prodrom einer Naturgeschichte derselben. München: Lindauer; 1811.
- 69. Günther A. Additions to the knowledge of Australian reptiles and fishes. Ann. Mag. Nat. Hist. 1867;(3)20:45–68.
- 70. Camp CL. Classification of the lizards. Bull. Am. Mus. Nat. Hist. 1923;48:289–481.
- 71. Gray JE. A Synopsis of the Genera of Reptiles and Amphibia, with a Description of some new Species. Ann. Phil. Lond. 1825; ser.2,10:193–217.
- 72.
Fitzinger L. Systema Reptilium, Fasciculus Primus, Amblyglossae. Vienna: Braumüller & Seidel. 1843.
- 73. Gray JE. A synopsis of the genera of saurian reptiles, in which some new genera are indicated, and the others reviewed by actual examination. Phil. Mag. 1827;S2(2):54–58.
- 74. Titus TA, Frost DR. Molecular homology assessment and phylogeny in the lizard family Opluridae (Squamata: Iguania). Mol. Phylogenet. Evol. 1996;6:49–62. pmid:8812305
- 75.
Gray JE. A Synopsis of the Species of the Class Reptilia. In: Griffith E, editor. The Animal Kingdom Arranged in Conformity with its Organization, by the Baron Cuvier, with Additional Descriptions of All the Species hitherto Named, and of Many not before Noticed. Volume the Ninth. London: Whittaker, Treacher, and Co. 1831. p. 448 + 110.
- 76. Gerlach J, Muir C, Richmond MD. The first substantiated case of trans-oceanic tortoise dispersal. J. Nat. Hist. 2006;40(41–43):2403–2408.
- 77. Scheyer TM, Delfino M, Klein N, Bunbury N, Fleischer-Dogley F, Hansen DM. Trophic interactions between larger crocodylians and giant tortoises on Aldabra Atoll, Western Indian Ocean, during the Late Pleistocene. R. Soc. open sci. 2018:5: 171800. pmid:29410873
- 78.
Cheke AS, Hume JP. Lost land of the Dodo: the ecological history of the Mascarene Islands. London: A. & C. Black publishers (Poyser imprint). 2008.