https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3136-5999
Figures
Abstract
Different factitious hosts were used to mass rear Trichogramma japonicum Ashmead in different parts of the globe because thorough details were lacking in both the laboratory and the field. The objective of this study was to compare, parasitoid, T. japonicum reared in different factitious hosts. Three commonly used factitious host eggs, Corcyra cephalonica (Stainton), Ephestia kuehniella Zeller and Sitotroga cerealella Olivier were tested under laboratory conditions and then in the field over a yellow stem borer, Scirpophaga incertulus (Walker) of rice. The highest parasitism by T. japonicum was observed on E. kuehniella eggs. The parasitoid’s highest emergence (88.99%) was observed on S. cerealella eggs at 24 h exposure, whereas at 48 h it was on E. kuehniella eggs (94.66%). Trichogramma japonicum females that emerged from E. kuehniella eggs were significantly long-lived. The days of oviposition by hosts and the host species were significant individually, but not their interaction. Higher proportions of flying T. japonicum were observed when reared on E. kuehniella and C. cephalonica eggs. Field results showed that T. japonicum mass-reared on E. kuehniella showed higher parasitism of its natural host, S. incertulus eggs. Hence, by considering these biological characteristics and field results, E. kuehniella could be leveraged for the mass rearing of quality parasitoids of T. japonicum in India, the Asian continent and beyond.
Citation: G. BG, Pandi G. GP, Ullah F, Patil NB, Sahu M, Adak T, et al. (2021) Performance of Trichogramma japonicum under field conditions as a function of the factitious host species used for mass rearing. PLoS ONE 16(8): e0256246. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0256246
Editor: Khalid Ali Khan, King Khalid University, SAUDI ARABIA
Received: June 5, 2021; Accepted: August 2, 2021; Published: August 19, 2021
This is an open access article, free of all copyright, and may be freely reproduced, distributed, transmitted, modified, built upon, or otherwise used by anyone for any lawful purpose. The work is made available under the Creative Commons CC0 public domain dedication.
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the manuscript.
Funding: BGG has received funding (EAP-274) from Rashtriya Krishi Vikas Yojana (RKVY), Government of Odisha, India.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
1. Introduction
Insect pests continue to influence agricultural production and human health significantly [1]. Chemical control of pests is a common practice to minimize crop losses [2–4]; still, their impacts on the soil, environment, non-target organisms, and the presence of residues in food products are matters of global concern [5–7]. Furthermore, insecticide-induced resistance and hormesis are thought to be significant factors in the failure of chemical-based insect pest control [8–12]. Alternatively, biological control agents have the potential to reduce crop losses and the use of insecticides [13–16]. Of the various bioagents, the family Trichogrammatidae (Order: Hymenoptera) has few successful biological control agents for agricultural and forest pests [17,18], the most important genus under the family being Trichogramma [19]. Several Trichogramma species are widely used commercially to control lepidopteran pests on economically important crops [20]. Globally, Trichogramma spp. is a mainstay of augmentative biological control and is annually applied to 15 million hectares across 40 countries [19]. Trichogramma is widely released in India to suppress different caterpillar pests attacking rice, maize, sugarcane, cotton, vegetables, and fruits. The short generation time and mass rearing on factitious hosts allow Trichogramma to be produced quickly and affordably compared to other parasitoids [19,21].
Rice (Oryza sativa L.) is the staple food for 2.5 billion people worldwide [22]. The rice crop is prone to biotic stress throughout the crop growth period. Among various insect pests that infest rice, yellow stem borer (YSB), Scirpophaga incertulas (Walker) (Lepidoptera: Crambidae) is a major pest and has the potential to cause loss up to 87.66% [23]. Apart from insecticides, T. japonicum Ashmead has been used extensively to manage YSB [19,24]. Trichogramma japonicum release can increase grain yields by 25.79%−45.13% over insecticide application [25]. However, despite the considerable release of T. japonicum in the field, consistent results are often not obtained due to parasitoid quality variability [26]. The field success of Trichogramma spp. species depends on selecting suitable host species, their maintenance, etc. Many good quality parasitoids (~300,000 parasitized eggs/ha) are needed to manage YSB in the field [26].
A better understanding of the development and behaviors of parasitoids on various factitious hosts is essential to explore their potential as biological control agents of crop pests [27,28]. Several studies reported sub-optimum parasitoid quality in India due to several factors during their mass rearing [29]. Mass rearing of T. japonicum in the laboratory on a suitable factitious host is the critical factor determining the quality of the parasitoids. Different factitious hosts are used to mass rear T. japonicum in different parts of the globe, typically based on the convenience and local availability of hosts and their diets. Therefore, the selection of suitable factitious hosts based on the quality of reared parasitoids has remained vital. Keeping this in mind, the objective of the present study was to investigate the productivity and efficiency of T. japonicum reared on eggs of three factitious hosts, Corcyra cephalonica (Stainton) (Lepidoptera: Pyralidae), Ephestia kuehniella Zeller (Lepidoptera: Pyralidae), and Sitotroga cerealella Olivier (Lepidoptera: Gelechidae). The performance of parasitoids was assessed using various methods such as parasitism rate, fecundity, offspring sex ratio, longevity, etc. in the laboratory and correlated with the efficiency of parasitizing a target host under field conditions. The present study evaluated the biological parameters of T. japonicum reared in three different hosts and their field efficiency to control YSB.
2. Materials and methods
2.1 Study environment
Study was carried out under controlled conditions (Temperature: 25 ± 1°C, relative humidity: 70 ± 10%, and 12 h photophase). Parameters were measured with an indoor thermometer/hygrometer (Model: HTC-1; Zhejiang Junkaishun Industrial & Trade Co Ltd., Zhejiang, China).
2.2 Insects
Host insects, C. cephalonica, E. kuehniella, S. cerealella and the parasitoid, T. japonicum were maintained in insect growth chambers (Daihan Labtech India Pvt. Ltd; LGC 5201 model). The C. cephalonica eggs and T. japonicum pupae were collected from ICAR-National Bureau of Agricultural Insect Resources, Bengaluru, India. Initial colony of the other two host species was obtained from the Grain Entomology laboratory, ICAR-NRRI, Cuttack, India. Corcyra cephalonica was reared using a maize diet [30]. The larvae of E. kuehniella were reared as per Lima et al. [31], and S. cerealella was reared on a susceptible rice variety, TN-1 [32]. To rear T. japonicum, factitious host eggs were UV-irradiated (30 W UV tube for 45 min at a distance of 45 cm) in a sterilization chamber using UV-C lamp (HNS 15W G13; Osram Puritec, Russia). Host eggs were glued on paper cards (15 × 10 cm). These eggs were exposed to the female wasp in the ratio of 40:1 until adult mortality. The population was maintained in tubes kept in insect growth chambers set at a temperature: 25 ± 1°C, relative humidity: 65 ± 10% RH with 14-h photophase and were used in the different experiments. For all the insect samples used in the study, no permission was required for the insect sampling and collection. Permission was not required because the insects used for the study are common insect pests. The insects used for this study are not endangered species.
2.3 Parasitism
Freshly collected eggs of C. cephalonica, E. kuehniella, and S. cerealella (0 to 4 h old) were UV irradiated as described above to arrest their development. Thirty eggs were pasted on a thick yellow paper card (2×2 cm) with gum Arabic (50%) diluted in distilled water. Twenty biological replicates were maintained with 30 eggs per host, and each replicate corresponded to an acrylic tube (6 cm height × 3.5 cm diameter) covered with a sterilized cotton plug. Cards of different host eggs were exposed to a mated adult female of T. japonicum (less than 24 h of age) individualized in an acrylic tube which had a drop of pure honey on the inner wall as a food source. A similar experiment was conducted for unmated females as well. Two sets of exposure durations of parasitoid to host eggs were maintained. Female T. japonicum was allowed to parasitize for 24 h, while in another, it was allowed for 48 h. All replicates were placed in an insect growth chamber as described in the previous section. Eggs were observed daily using a microscope (Nikon SMZ-745T, Japan). After the exposure period, the parasitoid was removed and discarded. The rate of parasitism of host eggs was assessed by recording the number of eggs turning black (> 5 days after development), indicating parasitism. Further, percent parasitism was calculated based on the number of blackened eggs among the total number of exposed eggs (30 eggs). The emergence rate was determined by recording the number of emergence holes from the black eggs using a microscope at 40X magnification.
2.4 Longevity
Longevity experiments consisted of two treatments based on the presence and absence of honey as food to parasitoids. Once the parasitoids emerged from the tested factitious host eggs, 20 females were randomly selected from each treatment for the experiment, corresponding to twenty biological replicates. Parasitoids were kept individually in a clean glass test tube (7.5 cm height × 1 cm diameter) containing a droplet of honey and covered with parafilm. Similar set up devoid of honey comprised ‘without food’ treatment. The entire setup was kept in a growth chamber as per the conditions described before. Observations were recorded at 24 h intervals from the day of emergence until parasitoids died. Further, the survival rate of parasitoids was calculated, and comparisons were made among different host eggs used.
2.5 Parasitism vs. days of oviposition by moths
To assess whether egg quality varies with the day of oviposition, eggs of each of the factitious hosts were collected daily from the first day till the 6th day of oviposition for each host separately. Egg cards having 30 eggs were prepared for each day from each host. Ten replicates were maintained. Cards were exposed to parasitism by a freshly emerged parasitoid (<24 h old) described in section 2.3. Eggs selected were of similar age (<12 h post-oviposition). All replicates were placed in a growth chamber. The data on parasitism and parasitoid emergence was recorded.
2.6 Flight test
Flight capacity of the adult parasitoids reared on the different host eggs was conducted as per the methodology of Dutton and Bigler [33] with slight modification. In brief, a testing unit (S1 Fig) was comprised of a glass jar (20.5 cm height × 15 cm diameter) lined with a black colored sheet on its inner wall. On the inner side of this sheet, 0.5 cm thick ring of glue (metroark; Wacker Metropark Chemicals Pvt. Ltd., India) was applied, which was 3.5 cm from the bottom of the jar to trap the parasitoids walking upward (walkers). Similarly, the flying parasitoids (flyers) were trapped by covering the top of the jar covered with a Petri dish (15 cm diameter), with glue on their inner surface. A card containing approximately 180 parasitized eggs with a pure drop of honey was placed at the bottom of a glass vial (7.5 cm height × 2.5 cm diameter) in the center of the jar from where wasps emerged. Five replications were maintained for each host. The entire setup was placed in growth chamber conditions, as mentioned earlier. Wasps caught in the glue in the Petri dish designated as ‘flyers’; wasps caught in the lower glue of band (3.5 cm from the bottom) designated as ‘walkers’ and wasps found below lower glue of band designated as ‘non-flyers’. Numbers in each of these locations within the test unit were expressed in percentage.
2.7 Field studies
The field performance of T. japonicum reared on different factitious host eggs was tested by releasing the wasps in the paddy field. Multi-location field studies were conducted at the research farm, ICAR-National Rice Research Institute (NRRI), Cuttack during monsoon (fall harvest) 2019, and at a farmer’s field, Mahanga, during monsoon (fall harvest) 2020 with the rice variety, Pooja. Regarding field site access, NRRI, Cuttack field was our institute experimental farm, hence no permission was required. Whereas, other site was a farmer field, access was obtained with mutual understanding. Four treatments (T. japonicum reared on three different factitious host eggs and untreated control), and five replications were maintained. All recommended cultural practices were applied until harvest (excluding pesticide applications). ‘Trichocards’ containing T. japonicum parasitized eggs were placed, corresponding to release densities of 50,000 male and female wasps/ha. Trichocards were prepared using three different factitious host eggs. Each release point was separated by 10 m within the plot. Each plot covered 400 m2 and was at least 15 m (edge to edge) away from the neighboring treatment plots [34]. Tricho cards were placed in an inverted, transparent plastic cup fixed to a wooden pole to avoid direct rainfall. When the eggs were blackened (ready-to-emerge), tricho-cards were released, and sentinel YSB egg masses less than 24 h old were placed in the plots. The sentinel egg masses were obtained from the glasshouse cage rearing. For each plot, 10 YSB egg masses with a rice leaf segment was randomly fixed on leaf by a stapler. YSB egg masses were retrieved from the fields after 48 hours and taken back to the laboratory individually on a moistened filter paper in a plastic vial (8.0 cm high × 2.0 cm in diameter) and observed periodically for the emergence of adult parasitoids. From each egg mass, number of hatched YSB larvae, emerged wasps, and dead eggs were recorded. Egg parasitism was calculated by dividing the number of parasitized eggs with total eggs and expressed in percentage.
2.8 Data analyses
The student’s t-test was for comparing two treatments and the one-way ANOVA was used (P < 0.05) when there were more than two treatments. Two-way ANOVA was performed to analyze the interaction of the day of oviposition by the host and different species of host. Treatment means were compared based on Tukey’s honest significant difference test (HSD) at 0.05-probability level. Analyses were performed using SAS software (Version 9.4). Data are shown as means ± SD based on data from replicate experiments.
3. Results
3.1 Parasitism
Parasitisation percentage of mated T. japonicum varied among the duration parasitisation time (for C. cephalonica: t = -10.271, df = 19, P<0.001; for E. kuehniella t = -6.343, df = 19, P<0.001; for S. cerealella: t = -11.653 and df = 19) and also the factitious host eggs used (24 h exposure: F2,57 = 14.23, P<0.0001; 48 h exposure: F2,57 = 6.94, df = 38, P<0.0001). When suitability of factitious hosts for parasitization was compared, E. kuehniella recorded an increased 23.74% and 32% parasitization at 24 h exposure and 12.33% and 22.17% at 48 h exposure over C. cephalonica and S. cerealella, respectively. Similarly, when exposure duration was increased from 24 h to 48 h, an additional 24.91%, 13.50%, and 23.33% parasitization was observed in C. cephalonica, E. kuehniella, and S. cerealella eggs, respectively (Table 1).
Correspondingly for unmated T. japonicum, similar results were noticed across the host species eggs (24 h exposure: F = 70.41 df = 19, P<0.0001; 48 h exposure: F = 347.54, df = 19, P<0.0001) as well as the duration exposed (C. cephalonica: t = -16.65, df = 19, P<0.001; E. kuehniella: t = -13.28, df = 19, P<0.001; S. cerealella: t = -7.8, df = 19, P<0.001) (Table 1). There was a considerable reduction in parasitism by unmated T. japonicum compared to mated at both the exposure duration except C. cephalonica exposed for 48 h duration.
Differences were observed among the different hosts and exposure duration of the parasitoid in the emergence rates of T. japonicum. Under mated category, higher percentage T. japonicum emergence (88.99%) was recorded on S. cerealella eggs at 24 h exposure, which differed significantly from other hosts (F2,57 = 50.25; P = 0.0001) and had increased emergence of 30.69% and 23.15% over C. cephalonica and E. kuehniella, respectively. Whereas at 48 h, E. kuehniella recorded the highest emergence of 94.66%, which differed significantly from other host’s eggs (F2,57 = 29.37; P = 0.0001) and had an increase of 8.66% and 12.27% over C. cephalonica and S. cerealella, respectively. The emergence of parasitoids differed significantly with the duration of exposure among all the host eggs used in the experiment. Both C. cephalonica (t = -1.77; df = 19; P = 0.001) and E. kuehniella (t = -3.164; df = 19; P = 0.001) had higher percentage of emergence at 48 h exposure duration, but S. cerealella (t = -0.988; df = 19; P = 0.01) had at 24 h. Whereas, under unmated category, the emergence rates of T. japonicum also differed significantly among hosts (F2,57 = 18.37; P = 0.0001). Highest emergence rate was recorded on E. kuehniella host eggs at both exposure durations (Table 1).
3.2 Longevity
There was an increased longevity of T. japonicum female descendants emerged from different host eggs parasitized by unmated T. japonicum females when food (honey) was provided at both the duration of exposures i.e. 24 h (C. cephalonica: t = -9.895, df = 19, P = 0.001; E. kuehniella: t = -7.909 df = 19; P = 0.001; S. cerealella: t = -10.847; df = 19; P = 0.001) and 48 h (C. cephalonica: t = -9.891, df = 19, P = 0.001; E. kuehniella: t = -7.690 df = 19; P = 0.001; S. cerealella: t = -9.723; df = 19; P = 0.001). Trichogramma japonicum emerged from E. kuehniella eggs had significantly highest female longevity when the wasps were provided honey (with food) at 24 h (F2,57 = 29.28, P<0.0001) and 48 h (F2,57 = 34.38, P<0.0001) exposure periods. A similar trend was also observed in “without food” at 24 h (F2,57 = 21.36, P<0.0001) and 48 h (F2,57 = 11.60, P<0.0001) exposure periods. Similar results were also obtained in mated T. japonicum female emergence except in the 24 h exposure ‘without food’ treatment where C. cephalonica and E. kuehniella were found on par (Table 2).
Honey was used as a food source for adult parasitoids.
3.3 Parasitism vs. days of oviposition by moths
Different host eggs collected from each oviposition day exposed to T. japonicum for parasitization yielded significant differences. On all days of oviposition, E. kuehniella eggs has recorded higher percentage of parasitism and differed significantly from other two host eggs (F5,54 = 61.26, P<0.001; F5,54 = 49.93, P<0.001; F5,54 = 139.56, P<0.001; F5,54 = 68.87, P<0.001; F5,54 = 67.70, P<0.001; F5,54 = 103.69, P = 0.001 on 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th and 6th day of oviposition, respectively). For C. cephalonica (χ2 = 40.51, df = 5, P<0.001), E. kuehniella (χ2 = 43.39, df = 5, P<0.001) and S. cerealella (χ2 = 39.57, df = 5, P<0.001) eggs, highest parasitisation was recorded on 2nd day of oviposition. Overall, the highest parasitism of T. japonicum was observed on eggs of E. kuehniella on its 2nd day of oviposition (79%) (Table 3). Different day of oviposition and the host species were found to be significant individually, but not their interaction by two-way ANOVA (Day of oviposition: F5,174 = 87.62, P < .0001; Host species: F2,177 = 756.76, P < .0001; Day of oviposition *Host species: F10,170 = 0.39, P = 1.06).
3.4 Flight test
Among host species used, the proportion of T. japonicum emerged from only E. kuehniella eggs had significantly more ‘flyers’ compared to ‘non-flyers’ and ‘walkers’. A higher proportion of flying T. japonicum was noticed when they were reared on E. kuehniella eggs (49.90%) and C. cephalonica eggs (47.33%) compared to S. cerealella eggs (39.50%) (F2,18 = 5.27, P = 0.0347). However, non-significant differences were noticed in flight capacity of the parasitoid in terms of ‘walkers’ (F2,18 = 2.68, P = 0.129) and ‘non-flyers’ (F2,18 = 3.42, P = 0.08) across different hosts (Fig 1).
Three flight activities were measured, flyers, walkers and non-flyers. The values are presented as the mean ± standard errors. Treatments were compared using one-way ANOVA (Tukey’s HSD test, P < 0.01). The same letter above error bars (capital letters across host species, lowercase letters across flight activities) did not differ significantly (P ≤ 0.01).
3.5. Field studies
A total of 160 egg masses were recollected from both treatment and control plots from both the fields. Data were pooled for further analysis. Results showed significant differences among the treatments in terms of parasitization rates by T. japonicum at research farm, NRRI, Cuttack (F3,16 = 160.50; P<0.0001). The higher parasitism (37.41±4.47%) of YSB eggs was observed in the treatment where T. japonicum reared on E. kuehniella was released (Fig 2). Similar trend was observed in the results of field experiment conducted at Mahanga, Cuttack, wherein T. japonicum reared on E. kuehniella eggs had highest parasitization of YSB eggs (46.71±6.27%) (F3,16 = 221.34; P<0.0001). Field experiments conducted in the present study suggested that T. japonicum reared on E. kuehniella provided more significant field parasitism of a different host (i.e., YSB eggs) in the field.
Multi-location field studies were conducted at NRRI, Cuttack and Mahanga, Cuttack. The values are presented as the mean ± standard errors. Treatments were compared using one-way ANOVA (Tukey’s HSD test, P < 0.01). The same letter above error bars (capital letters for NRRI, Cuttack location, lowercase letters for Mahanga, Cuttack location) did not differ significantly (P ≤ 0.01).
4. Discussion
Host (species, size, age) can impact parasitoids preference and offspring fitness [35]. The laboratory performance of the Trichogramma will predict their performance in the field (in suppressing the target pest) [36]. Hence, our study analyzed host dependant changes in the productivity of T. japonicum, a potential biological control agent released inundatively in India to manage YSB. One of the cornerstone strategies in choosing the most suitable parasitoid for field release is parasitization efficiency. In our study, the parasitism tests revealed a variation in the characteristics of T. japonicum and all these variations could affect the successful use of Trichogramma spp. [36]. Parasitization is one of the crucial characteristics representing the productivity of biological control agents, and it could vary due to differences in the hosts used for rearing. Overall, E. kuhniella eggs were parasitized the highest compared to others, both at 24 h and 48 h exposure duration.
The mating status would affect the oviposition of parasitoids]. In the current study, we also noticed a lower parasitism rate in the unmated females than mated. Similar results were also obtained by Pratissoli et al [37] in a different species, T. acacioi. Our results showed poor parasitism of S. cerealella eggs; similar observations were also reported by Parra et al [38]. Bai et al [39] compared the quality of T. pretiosum adults reared from different hosts and concluded that it depends on the host’s size from which it emerged. They measured the host egg volume and it was observed to be 0.028±0.003 mm3 for E. kuhniella and 0.022±0.005 mm3 for S. cerealella, but they have not considered C. cephalonica for the study. However, Consoli et al [40] measured the egg size of C. cephalonica and found it to be approximately 0.036 mm3. Apart from egg size, surfaces of host eggs, chorion structures, layers, etc., govern parasitoid development. The chorion surface of C. cephalonica has a rugged texture but not as evident as in E. kuehniella [40]; hence, higher parasitization of T. japonicum on E. kuehniella eggs was recorded in the present study.
Among different hosts tested, S. cerealella eggs are the smallest, and there would be depletion of nutrients for embryonic development of parasitoid and subsequently its biology and performance. Host features were previously pointed out as an essential factor for T. remus parasitism and development by Bueno et al [41]. Few studies have already pointed out the differential effects of the age of the host egg [42] on their parasitization, which was also evinced in the current study. Apart from the host egg age, parasitoid age can also influence the rate of parasitization [43].
In the current study, we recorded the highest parasitization on E. kuehniella eggs. However, the highest parasitoid emergence was recorded on S. cerealella eggs. The variation in emergence, as well as the varying parasitism rate of T. japonicum, could be related to the specific morphological characteristics host eggs used, the size and age of the host eggs, and the quality of the eggs for parasitoid development [44]. The emergence of T. japonicum varied across the host as well as exposure duration. Except for the unmated category in S. cerealella, emergence decreased when exposure duration was increased. It could be due to continuous and extended contact of parasitoids with host eggs; here, parasitoid may deposit their eggs on to a host that is already parasitized. Further, it results in superparasitism, where some or all of the immature parasitoids are insufficiently nourished and thus fail to develop fully and finally died. This differential emergence could also be due to the different sizes and quality of the hosts. Similar differences in host eggs which, act as an important parameter in Trichogramma development and survival, have been reported [40]. Our result about differences in emergence across exposure duration supports the need for inundative release of the parasitoids. Parasitoids will not maintain the sufficient population required to control the pest once emergence has declined in the field.
Trichogramma japonicum parasitized the eggs of all host species irrespective of egg’s age, indicating the acceptance of the egg of this species by the parasitoid, however, the level of parasitism varied. Similar findings were also noted by Chen et al [45]. In the current study, parasitism increased on the second day of oviposition by host species tested compared to other days. Similar to our results, increased parasitization of 2nd day oviposited C. cephalonica eggs by T. chilonis was recorded by Tiwari and Khan [46]. In our study, parasitization abated as the egg-laying (or day of oviposition) advanced. As moth age advances, this could be because they start losing vigor, vitality, and lay fewer eggs. This phenomenon was observed unfavorable for the parasitoid T. chilonis from the fitness point of view. A parsimonious explanation for the negative relationship between the day of oviposition and parasitoid development could be due to differences in egg nutrients. Parasitoids will not get sufficient nutrients from older eggs. Also eggs may undergo morphological and physiological changes that interfere with their acceptance by the parasitoid [47]. Parasitoids prefer freshly laid eggs to ensure that they get sufficient maximal fecundity [48]. Two hypotheses could explain the interaction between the host egg and parasitoid. Firstly, female parasitoids might have laid eggs similarly irrespective of the host egg laid, but parasitoid larvae could not have developed well in older eggs due to competition with developing native embryos [28,41,49]. Secondly, female parasitoids might sting the host eggs equally regardless of eggs oviposited, but parasitoids would be produced mostly in hosts showing optimal physiology for progeny development [50–52]. Hence, older eggs are considered as a low-quality host food for mass rearing protocols of egg parasitoids [43,49].
Longevity is one of the important quality parameters of a parasitoid. In our study, longevity of adult T. japonicum has improved with honey, and we anticipate a similar effect in the field when parasitoid feeds on plant nectar. Food for parasitoids is an important factor, and deprived parasitoids will first search for food resources before they search for hosts. In the present study, we have used honey as a food source, and it is expected to have proteins, enzymes, fructose, glucose, and amino acids. Honey deprived T. cacoeciae only attacked one host patch, whereas fed females were more likely to move to a second host egg patch. Females without supplemental food sources never lived more than 5 d while fed females lived an average of 11 d on honey [53]. Authors further found that longer-lived parasitoids may have greater efficiency in the field and parasitize pest eggs for a more extended period. This feature is essential in biological control programs. In our study, longevity among the descendants was influenced by the mating status of the parasitoid. Pratissoli et al [37] also showed the interference of mating on the longevity descendants in T. pretiosum. Like ours, descendants from unmated parasitoids have recorded 14.27 days’ longevity, whereas 11.33 days for mated parasitoids. Mating is also known to reduce the female lifespan in many insects.
The flight test is a pivotal component to monitor the quality of Trichogramma [33,54]. Overall, our study showed that the host insect could affect the flight capacity of T. japonicum to some extent. Similarly, high flight capacity was observed for T. annulata and T. atopovirilia on C. cephalonica, and A. kuehniella, respectively [55]. In the present study, E. kuehniella eggs were much better hosts for T. japonicum in terms of flight capacity than S. cerealella. Kolliker-Ott et al [56] assessed that the fitness of Trichogramma is strongly related to wing shape and size, and they influence dispersal and host location of the parasitoid in the field. Parasitoid wing size is known to be influenced by the host on which they are reared and influences the flight capacity. From our enclosure studies on flight capacity, we cannot exactly mimic the dispersal capacity of the parasitoid in the field condition; however, it has been shown that short-range flight capacity could be an indicator of field dispersal.
In the current study, we have field-tested T. japonicum reared on different factitious host against its natural host YSB. Achieving higher parasitization of YSB eggs is often tricky due to its very nature of egg mass, consisting of multiple layers of eggs and covered with hairs by the YSB female moth. In our study, T. japonicum reared from E. kuehniella eggs had parasitized the highest YSB eggs (37.41±4.47%). On the other hand, meager percent parasitism rates (0.35% ± 0.36%) of YSB eggs were found in the study carried out by Tang et al [26]. Further, the authors were also linked poor parasitism to sub-optimum quality of T. japonicum used. For the first time, the present study reports a comprehensive proof of quality variation based on the hosts used for rearing and their subsequent performance in the field. Mass production systems are crucial for cost efficiency and it depends on the possibility of exploring factitious hosts, which have a low cost of production [57]. We have mass-reared all three host eggs (C. cephalonica, E. kuehniella and S. cerealella) on the natural and locally available diet. In the present study, the total cost production of each factitious host was calculated considering various components of the production cycle. Among the three factitious hosts, cost of production (of one cc) 299 was lowest for E. kuehniella eggs, i.e. (28.32 INR), followed by C. cephalonica (29.38 INR) and it was highest S. cerealella (39.54 INR) [Gowda BG, unpublished observations]. Although the kilogram cost of the natural diet for S. cerealella (TN-1 paddy grains) was cheaper, producing one cc of eggs requires a higher quantity of diet. Factitious hosts are usually chosen even if they are not the optimal hosts [19]. Hence, to utilize E. kuehniella as a new host for T. japonicum its trade-off benefit could be crucial.
One of the key reasons for the failure of biological control programs is the lack of quality parasitoids. The quality-assured parasitoids will have tremendous implications for pest suppression under field conditions than a mere high number of parasitoids. The promotion of biological pest control should be considered on priority due to the effects of pesticides viz., residue, resistance, and resurgence. Overall, based on the biological characteristics and field results, the present study comprehensively unveiled that E. kuehniella is a more suitable host for T. japonicum in terms of performance both in the laboratory and field. Cocyra cephalonica was used hitherto for commercial rearing of T. japonicum. Our study recommends using E. kuehniella eggs to mass rear T. japonicum for maximum benefit.
Supporting information
S1 Fig. Flight test unit to measure the flight activity of T. japonicum.
(a) Inner view of flight test unit (b) Outer view of the flight test unit.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0256246.s001
(TIF)
Acknowledgments
Authors gratefully acknowledge Director, ICAR-National Rice Research Institute, Cuttack, India for constant support and providing all the facilities. Senior author thanks Dr. Shashank P. R. Scientist, ICAR-IARI, New Delhi for confirming Ephestia kuehniella. We thank Mr. Sheikh Shadmanul, Mr. Narendra Biswal and Mr. Debadarshi Panda, project staff for helping in various phases of the study.
References
- 1.
Sharma HC. Climate Change Effects on Insects: Implications for Crop Protection and Food Security. In: Kang MS, Banga SS, editors. Combating Climate Change: An Agricultural Perspective, CRC Press, 2013. pp. 213–236.
- 2. Shah FM, Razaq M, Ali Q, Ali A, Shad SA, Aslam M, et al. Action threshold development in cabbage pest management using synthetic and botanical insecticides. Entomol Gen 2020; 40:157–172.
- 3. Desneux N, Han P, Mansour R, Arno J, Brevault T, et al. Integrated Pest Management of Tuta absoluta: practical implementations across different regions around the world. J Pest Sci. 2021: In press.
- 4. Gul H, Ullah F, Hafeez M, Tariq K, Desneux N, Gao X, et al. Sublethal concentrations of clothianidin affect fecundity and key demographic parameters of the chive maggot, Bradysia odoriphaga. Ecotoxicology. 2021; 30:1150–1160. pmid:34165677
- 5. Desneux N, Decourtye A, Delpuech JM. The sublethal effects of pesticides on beneficial arthropods. Annu Rev Entomol. 2007; 52:81–106. pmid:16842032
- 6. Taning CNT, Vanommeslaeghe A, Smagghe G. With or without foraging for food, field-realistic concentrations of sulfoxaflor are equally toxic to bumblebees (Bombus terrestris). Entomol Gen. 2019; 39:151–155.
- 7. Varikou K, Garantonakis N, Birouraki A. Exposure of Bombus terrestris L. to three different active ingredients and two application methods for olive pest control. Entomol Gen 2019; 39:53–60.
- 8. Ullah F, Gul H, Tariq K, Desneux N, Gao X, Song D. Acetamiprid resistance and fitness costs of melon aphid, Aphis gossypii: an age-stage, two-sex life table study. Pestic Biochem Physiol. 2021; 171:104729. pmid:33357551
- 9. Gul H, Ullah F, Biondi A, Desneux N, Qian D, Gao X, et al. Resistance against clothianidin and associated fitness costs in the chive maggot, Bradysia odoriphaga. Entomol Gen. 2019; 39: 81–92.
- 10. Ullah F, Gul H, Desneux N, Gao X, Song D. Imidacloprid-induced hormesis effects on demographic traits of the melon aphid, Aphis gossypii. Entomol Gen. 2019a; 39: 325–337.
- 11. Ullah F, Gul H, Desneux N, Tariq K, Ali A, Gao X, et al. Clothianidin-induced sublethal effects and expression changes of vitellogenin and ecdysone receptors genes in the melon aphid, Aphis gossypii. Entomol Gen. 2019b; 39: 137–149.
- 12. Ullah F, Gul H, Tariq K, Desneux N, Gao X, Song D. Functional analysis of cytochrome P450 genes linked with acetamiprid resistance in melon aphid, Aphis gossypii. Pestic Biochem Physiol. 2020; 175: 104687. pmid:32980055
- 13. Lu Y, Wu KM, Jiang Y, Guo Y, Desneux N. Widespread adoption of Bt cotton and insecticide decrease promotes biocontrol services. Nature. 2012; 487:362–365. pmid:22722864
- 14. Gowda GB, Sahu M, Ullah F, Patil NB, Pandi GP, Adak T, et al. Insecticide-induced hormesis in a factitious host, Corcyra cephalonica, stimulates the development of its gregarious ecto-parasitoid, Habrobracon hebetor. Biol Control. 2021; 160: 104680.
- 15. Biondi A, Guedes RNC, Wan F-H, Desneux N. Ecology, worldwide spread, and management of the invasive South American tomato pinworm, Tuta absoluta: past, present, and future. Annu Rev Entomol. 2018; 63:239–258. pmid:28977774
- 16. Huang NX, Jaworski CC, Desneux N, Zhang F, Yang PY, Wang S. Long-term and large-scale releases of Trichogramma promote pesticide decrease in maize in northeastern China. Entomol Gen. 2020; 40:331–335.
- 17. Guo XJ, Di N, Chen X, Zhu Z, Zhang F, Tang B, et al. Performance of Trichogramma pintoi when parasitizing eggs of the oriental fruit moth Grapholita molesta. Entomol Gen. 2019; 39:239–249.
- 18. Qu YY, Chen X, Monticelli LS, Zhang F, Desneux N, Dai HJ, et al. Parasitism performance of the parasitoid Trichogramma dendrolimi on the plum fruit moth Grapholitha funebrana. Entomol Gen. 2020; 40:385–395.
- 19. Zang L, Sheng L, Wang S, Zhang F, Desneux N. Biological Control with Trichogramma in China: History, Present Status and Perspectives. Annu Rev Entomol. 2021; 66:463–484. pmid:32976724
- 20. Parra JRP, Zucchi RA. Trichogramma in Brazil: feasibility of use after twenty years of research. Neotrop Entomol. 2004; 33: 271–281.
- 21. Wang Y, Zou ZP, Hou YY, Yang X, Wang S, Dai HJ, et al. Manually-extracted unfertilized eggs of Chinese oak silkworm, Antheraea pernyi, enhance mass production of Trichogramma parasitoids. Entomol Gen. 2020; 40:397–406.
- 22. Manzanilla DO, Paris TR, Vergara GV, Ismail AM, Pandey S, Labios RV, et al. Submergence risks and farmers’ preferences: Implications for breeding Sub1 rice in Southeast Asia. Agr Syst. 2011; 104:335–347.
- 23. Pallavi D, Sharanabasappa , Girijesh GK. Crop loss estimation of yellow stem borer Scirpophaga incertulas (Walker) damage on paddy. J Entomol and Zool Studies. 2017; 5: 635–638.
- 24. Sharma S, Agarwal N. Safety assessment of selected biopesticides and botanicals on Trichogramma spp. (Hymenoptera: Trichogrammatidae) in fields. Indian J Exp Biol. 2019; 57: 443–449.
- 25. Sangha KS, Shera PS, Sharma S, Kaur R. On-farm impact of egg parasitoid, Trichogramma spp. against lepidopteran pests in organic basmati rice. J Biol Control. 2018; 32: 116–120.
- 26. Tang R, Babendreier D, Zhang F, Kang M, Song K, Hou ML. Assessment of Trichogramma japonicum and T. chilonis as potential biological control agents of yellow stem borer in Rice. Insects 2017; 8: 19–31. https://doi.org/10.3390/insects8010019.
- 27. Chailleux A, Desneux N, Seguret J, Khanh HDT, Maignet P, Tabone E. Assessing European egg parasitoids as a mean of controlling the invasive South American tomato pinworm Tuta absoluta. PLoS ONE 2012; 7:e48068. pmid:23144727
- 28. Li XY, Lei Q, Hua HQ, Song HF, Wang Su, et al. Impact of host suitability on oviposition preference toward fertilized and unfertilized host eggs in two Trichogramma parasitoid species. Entomol Gen. 2019; 39:313–323.
- 29. Ballal CR, Srinivasan R, Chandrashekhar B. Evaluation of quality of Trichogramma chilonis Ishii from different production units in India. Biol Control. 2005;19:1–8.
- 30. Lalitha Y, Ballal CR. Influence of seasons and inoculum dosages on the production efficiency of Corcyra cephalonica Stainton. Biol Control. 2015; 29: 25–30.
- 31. Lima FM, Favero S, Lima JOG. Production of the Mediterranean flour moth, Anagasta kuehniella (Zeller) (Lepidoptera: Pyralidae), on an artificial diet containing corn meal. Neotrop Entomol. 2001; 30: 37–42.
- 32. Mathew SM, Nelson SJ, Soundararajan RP, Uma D, Jeyaprakash P. Screening of paddy varieties against angoumois grain moth, Sitotroga cerealella Oliv. Electron J Plant Breed. 2019; 10: 476–482.
- 33. Dutton A, Bigler F. Flight activity assessment of the egg parasitoid Trichogramma brassicae (Hymenoptera: Trichogrammatidae) in laboratory and field conditions. Entomophaga. 1995; 40: 223–233.
- 34. Murali-Baskaran RK, Sharma KC, Sridhar J, Jain L, Kumar J. Multiple releases of Trichogramma japonicum Ashmead for biocontrol of rice yellow stem borer, Scirpophaga incertulas (Walker), Crop Prot. 2021; 141: 105471.
- 35. Du W, Xu J, Hou Y, Lin Y, Zang L, Yang X, et al. Trichogramma parasitoids can distinguish between fertilized and unfertilized host eggs. J Pest Sci. 2018; 91:771–780. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10340-017-0919-z.
- 36. Coelho A Jr, Rugman-Jones PF, Reigada C, Stouthamer R, Parra JRP. Laboratory performance predicts the success of field releases in inbred lines of the egg parasitoid Trichogramma pretiosum (Hymenoptera: Trichogrammatidae). Plos One. 2016; 11: e0146153 256–257. pmid:26730735
- 37. Pratissoli D. et al. Adult Feeding and Mating Effects on the Biological Potential and Parasitism of Trichogramma pretiosum and T. acacioi (Hym.: Trichogrammatidae). Braz Arch Biol Technol. 2009; 52: 1057–1062.
- 38. Parra JRP, Zucchi RA, Silveira-Neto S, Haddad ML. Biology and thermal requirements of Trichogrammagalloi Zucchi and T. distinctum Zucchi, on two alternative hosts. Colloq I’NRA. 1990; 56: 81–84.
- 39. Bai B, Luck RF, Forster L, Stephens B, Janssen JAM. The effect of host size on quality attributes of the egg parasitoid, Trichogramma pretiosum. Entomol Exp Appl. 1992; 64: 37–48.
- 40. Cônsoli FL, Kitajima EW, Parra JRP. Ultrastructure of the natural and factitious host eggs of Trichogrammagalloi Zucchi and Trichogramma pretiosum Riley (Hymenoptera: Trichogrammatidae). Int J Insect Morphol Embryol. 1999; 28: 211–229.
- 41. Bueno R, Bueno AF, Xavier MFC, Carvalho MM. Telenomus remus (Hymenoptera: Platygasteridae) parasitism on eggs of Antocarsia gemmatalis (Lepidoptera: Eribidae) compared with its natural host Spodoptera frugiperda (Lepidoptera:Noctuidae). Ann Entomol Soc Am. 2014; 107:799–808.
- 42. Moreau J, Richard A, Benrey B, Thieiry D. The influence of plant cultivar of the grapevine moth Lobesia botrana on the life history traits of an egg parasitoid. Biol Control. 2009; 50:117–122.
- 43. Iqbal A., Hou Y., Chen Y, Ali A, Montielli LS, Desneux N, et al. Impact of Trichogramma parasitoid age on the outcome of multiparasitism in the factitious host eggs of Chinese oak silkworm, Antheraea pernyi. J Pest Sci. 2020; 93: 1347–1357. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10340-020-01239-1.
- 44. Dorn S, Beckage N. Superparasitism in gregarious hymenopteran parasitoids: ecological, behavioural and physiological perspectives. Physiol Entomol. 2007; 32: 199–211.
- 45. Chen Y, Qu X, Li T, Iqbal A, Wang X, Ren Z, et al. Performances of six eupelmid egg parasitoids from China on Japanese giant silkworm Caligula japonica with different host age regimes. J Pest Sci. 2020: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10340-020-01271-1.
- 46. Tiwari S, Khan MA. Growth and development of Corcyra cephalonica (Stainton) on natural and fortified diets and dietary effect of age-old eggs on parasitization by Trichogramma chilonis Ishii. J Bio Control. 2003; 17: 13–16.
- 47. Khan MA, Tiwari S. Effect of plant extracts on the parasitization efficiency of Trichogramma chilonis Ishii. J Biol Control. 2001; 15: 133–137.
- 48. Ayvaz A, Karasu E, Karaborklu J, Tuncbilek AS (2008) Effects of cold storage, rearing temperature, parasitoid age and irradiation on the performance of Trichogramma evanescens Westwood (Hymenoptera: Trichogrammatidae). J Stored Prod Res 44: 232–240.
- 49. Pizzol J, Desneux N, Wajnberg E, Thiery D. Parasitoid and host egg ages have independent impact on various biological traits in a Trichogramma species. J Pest Sci. 2012; 85: 489–496.
- 50. Desneux N, Barta RJ, Hoelmer KA, Hopper KR, Heimpel GE. Multifaceted determinants of host specificity in an aphid parasitoid. Oecologia. 2009a; 160:387–398. pmid:19219460
- 51. Desneux N, Starý P, Delebecque CJ, Gariepy TD, Barta RJ, Hoelmer KA, et al. Cryptic species of parasitoids attacking the soybean aphid (Hemiptera: Aphididae) in Asia: Binodoxys communis and Binodoxys koreanus (Hymenoptera: Braconidae: Aphidiinae). Ann Entomol Soc Am. 2009b; 102:925–936.
- 52. Desneux N, Blahnik R, Delebecque CJ, Heimpel GE. Host phylogeny and host specialization in parasitoids. Ecol Lett. 2012;15: 453–460. pmid:22404869
- 53. Hegazi EM, Khafagi WE, Hassan SA. Studies on three species of Trichogramma. I. Foraging behavior for food or hosts. J Appl Ent. 2000; 124:145–149.
- 54. Coelho A Jr, Stouthamer R, Parra JRP. Flight propensity of isofemale lines of Trichogramma pretiosum Riley in two relative humidity levels. Fla Entomol. 2019; 101:364–368.
- 55. Dias-Pini NS, DaSilva CSB, Penaflor MFGV, Parra JRP. Does host determine short-range flight capacity of trichogrammatids. J Appl Entomol. 2014; 138: 677–682.
- 56. Kölliker-Ott UM, Bigler F, Hoffmann AA. Does mass rearing of field collected Trichogramma brassicae wasps influence acceptance of european corn borer eggs? Entomol Exp Appl. 2003; 109: 197–203.
- 57. Zhang JJ, Ruan CC, Zang LS, Shao XW, Shi SS. Technological improvements for mass production of Trichogramma and current status of their applications for biological control on agricultural pests in China. China J Biol Control. 2015; 31:638–46.